88. Worchuila vs Aged About 40 Years, D/O Vs
2022 Latest Caselaw 301 Mani

                                                                                      Page |1



SHAMURAILATPA                         IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR

M SUSHIL
                                                AT IMPHAL


SHARMA                                         WP(C) No. 451 of 2022

Digitally signed by
                                         1.

Kshetrimayum Liklaisana Singh, aged about 35 SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL SHARMA years, S/o:Kshetrimayum Kunjabihari Singh of Date: 2022.07.18 16:48:09 Lamjao Mayai Leikai, P.S: Waikhong, P.O: +05'30' Kakching-795103.

2. Kangabam Herojit Singh, aged about 43 years, S/o: (L) K. Ibobi Singh of Langdum Mayai Leikai, P.S-Irilbung& P.O- Singjamei-795008 Imphal East District.

3. Tong TongSerto aged about 37 years, S/o: (L) Maipu Serto of Salem-inn, Happy Valley,Thangmeiband, PS & P.O- Lamphel- 795004.

4. Olive Jimp Zimik, aged about 32 years, S/o:

Mataimizimik of TanruiVillage, Ukhrul District P.S & P.O-Somdail- 795142.

5. Oliver ChinliankhupSimte aged about 33 years, S/o:Kamchinthang Simteof National Games Village , P.O. Lamphel-795004.

6. Ramkrishna Khoirom aged about 41 years, S/o:

Khoirom Ramkumar Singh of Uripok Tourangbam Leikai, P.S &PO: Imphal West- 795001.

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 Page |2

7. Gloria Kamei aged about 35 years, D/o: Thomas Kamei of Namgailong, New Keithelmabi, Imphal West District, P.S -Patsoi&P.O: Langjing-795113.

8. K.PhilangamZimikaged about 44 years, W/o:

Mamang Haokip of Kairang Maning Leikai, PS: Heingang &PO: Mantripukhari-795002

9. Olen Irom aged about 40 years, S/o: I. Heramani Singh of Kongpal Kongkham Leikai, P.S &P.O Porompat-795005

10. Thongam Bharati aged about 41 years, D/o:Radhagovind Thongam of Sagolband Meino Leirak, P.S &P.O - Imphal West - 795001.

11. Md Rafique Ahmed aged about 36 years, S/o:

- Md Abdul Rauf Shah of Lilong Bazar Thoubal District,P.S. & P.O. Lilong -795130

12. Paominlen Haokip age about 42 years, S/o:

Lunkhokhai Haokip of T.Champhai Village P.S & P.O: Churachandpur-795128

13. Letminlun Khongsai age about 38 years S/o:Paolet Khongsai of S. Mongbung Village PO: Motbung &PS: Saikul Kangpokpi District, Pin-795107

14. Nengpichong Kipgenaged about 35years S/o:

(L) Lamminthang Kipgen Kangpokpi of Ward No. 1 Kangpokpi District P.S & P.O - Kangpokpi - 795129.

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 Page |3

15. D. Tsiiny aged about 34 years, D/o: M. L. Dahrii of Purul Rosofii, P. S. - Tadubi&P. O. - Maram- 795015.

16. Loveleen Kayao aged about 36 years, W/o:Timothy Pou of Langol Housing Complex, Imphal-795004

17. Laishram Momota Devi aged about 34 years, D/o: Laishram Jetombi Singh ofThongju Part 2, Boroimakhong, Imphal East District, PS: Singjamei & PO: Canchipur-795003

18. Longjam Sangita Devi aged about 43 years D/o:

L. Chandrasekhar Singh of Utlou Makha Leikai P. S.& P.O- Nambol-795134.

19. Kamei Jianthuilu aged about 37years D/o: Kamei Namkaolung of NgarianVillage, P.S & P.O- Bishnupur-795126

20. ShumtingKoireng aged about 43 years, D/o:

ThangchongKoireng of Thangmeiband Hijam Leikai, Imphal West District, P.S & P.O- Lamphel-795004.

21. Robita Riamei aged about 34 years, D/o: Tarun Riamei of Guigailong Thangmeiband, Imphal West District, P.S &P.O: Lamphel-795004

22. Khwairakpam Nirupama aged about 37 years, D/o:(L) Khwairakpam Ibochou of Awang Sekmai Makha Leikai, Imphal West District, P.S &P.O: Sekmai-795136

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 Page |4

23. Nivedita Laishram aged about 32 years, D/o: L.

Modhumangol of Porompat Thawanthaba Leikai, Imphal East District . P.S &P.O: Porompat-795005.

24. Santosh Arambam aged about 30 years, S/o: A Iboton of ThongjuPart- 2, Imphal East District, PO: Canchipur-795003 PS: Singjamei

25. Linda Lalhoihnem aged about 30 years, D/o:NehzasoiSimte of Salemveng, Churachandpur- 795128, Churachandpur District.

26. KansouwaMotuishim aged about 35 years, S/o :

Kansouwa Joseph of Machi, Chandel District. P.O. Pallel-795135, P.S. Machi.

27. Kamei Meena Kabui aged about 49 years, D/o:

K.Agangna of Dimdailong New Checkon Imphal East District, P.S &P.O: Porompat- 795005

28. Gaiguimeilu Kamei aged about 32 years D/o:

Dr. Gaithaorung Kamei of Ragailong, Minuthong, P.S: Porompat &P.O- Imphal - 795001 Imphal East District.

29. Wungmathot Mahong aged about 34 years, S/o:

Wungkui Mahong ofLungphu village, P.S-

Phungyar&P.O- Litan-795145, Kamjong District

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 Page |5

30. MohdNoorul Amin aged about 34 years, S/o:

Md Ahamed Ali of Lilong Turel Ahanbi P.S& P.O-Lilong-795130.

31. Khoirom Santosh Singh aged about 37 years, S/o: (L) khoiromYaiskul Singh ofKyamgei Khoirom Leikai, P. S -Irilbung &P.O- Canchipur-795003.

32. Kamei Apuiru Rongmei aged about 48 years, D/o:(L) Kamei Keiton of Dimdailong, New Checkon, P.S &P.O:Porompat-795005.

33. NgullenChongloi aged about 43 years, S/o:(L) SeikholamChongloiof Haijang Village P.S & P.O- Kangpokpi-795129.

34. Ahsana Shah aged about 36 years, D/o:M.A.

Rahman Shah of Kshetrigao Makha Kshetri Chandam Leikai, Imphal East District, P. S- Singjamei&P. O. Porompat-795008.

35. Md Abdul Hasim, aged about 42 years. S/o:Md Abdul Helim. Address:Lilong Haoreibi Lou Manga. P.S /PO:Lilong.-795130 District: Thoubal. State: Manipur.

36. Vijayalaxmi Yumnam aged about 33 years, D/o: Y. Yaiskul Singh ofKakwaLamdaibung, Imphal East District, P.S &P. O: Singjamei- 795008

37. Olivia Dirinamai aged about 41 years,W/o:Doren Kesham, of Haorongbam

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 Page |6

Leikai, Uripok SorbonThingel, P.S. & P.O. Imphal West-795001

38. Md. Arshad Ahmed Chist aged about 34 years, S/o: Abdul Majid of Kshetri Mayai Leikai, Imphal East District, P.S.& P.O- Porompat- 795005

39. Kho Veinii Pao aged about 35 years, S/o: L kho of Saranamai village, P.S &P.O-Tadubi- 795104 Senapati District.

40. LaljasehKipgenaged about 34 years, S/o:

Henkhosei Kipgen of Phaijang village, PS- Sapermeina & P. O -Motbung- 795107,Kangpokpi District.

41. Lamjakim Khongsai aged about 30 years, D/o:Chungkhosat Khongsai of Saikho Village, P. S. & P.O- Saikul-795118.

42. GairanliuGonmei aged about 33 years, D/o :Liangsi Paul Gonmei of Neikanlong Thangmeiband , IMC ward No. 1 ,Imphal West district, Pin-795004.

43. S Boinu Vaiphei aged about 44 years, D/o: S Prim Vaiphei of New Lambulane, Imphal East , PO Imphal, PS Porompat. 795001.

44. Niengneikim aged about 30 years; W/o:

Thenkhogin Haokip of National Game village, Lamphelpat, Imphal - 795004.

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 Page |7

45. Krishna Kumari Tongbram aged about 38 years, D/o: Tongbram Bira Singh of Kongba Kshetri LeikaiP.S- Irilbung and P.O- Imphal-795001.

46. Ngahneikim, aged about 30 years, D/o:Lunzahaoof Molnom, Churachandpur District, P.S& P.O- Churachandpur-795128.

47. T.Nengneisang, aged about 33 years, D/o:

(L)ThangkhopaoTouthan Address- Vazing Village, Churachandpur District., P.S & P.O- Churachandpur -795128.

48. Adaphro A, aged about 32 years, D/o: Ashuli of Memuo Colony P.S & P.O- P.O: Senapati- 795106.

49. LeivonThangneilenkom, Age about 34 years, S/o:Leivon AhmunteKom of Lalumbung village, Churachandpur District , P.S -Kumbi & Moirang-795133.

50. D. AsakhoLenus Maoaged about 34 years, S/o K.Daiho of Makhrelui Village, P.S. & P.O- Senapati-795106.

51. J Justin Lunkimaged about 36 years, S/o (L) JamseiLunkim of KCC Melody House, Dewlahland , P.S- Porompat, P.O: Imphal- 795001.

52. Sumpi Edmund Anal aged about 40 years, S/o:

S. Jerol. IAS (Retd) of Sumpi Residence, 1st Street, NewLambulane, P.S & P.O- Porompat- 795001.

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 Page |8

53. KhalingMikawlrawng aged about 36 years, S/o:

(L) KhalingKoshang ofKhangshim village P.O/ P.S : Kakching-795103, Tengnoupal District

54. MatiaAthisii aged bout 33 years, D/o: H Athisii of Maopungdong Village, P.S - Maogate&P.O.- Tadubi-795104

55. LujikluPanmei aged about 34 years, D/o:

Rajkumar Panmei of Keishamthong Kabui Colony 2nd Lamana Street Imphal-795001

56. KoshuniHeni aged about 36 years, D/o:Heni of Kaibi Village,P.S.& P.O- Tadubi-795104

57. RozyKamei aged about 32 years, D/o:(L) Khamlungpu Kamei of Maipak Road, Ragailong, Imphal East, P.S &P.O. Porompat - 795005

58. Chunthuiliu Kamei aged about 36 years, D/o:Talibung Kamei of Khupilong Tamenglong, PS & P.O- Tamenglong-795141

59. Niangmuankim aged about 32 years, D/o:Guite Lianlam of Mualveng Hiangtam Lamka, P.S & P.O- Churachandpur-795128

60. Vivekananda Sen aged 33 years, S/o:Achintasen of Uttar Saptibari P.S- Maynaguri & District- Jalpaiguri Pin- 735224,West Bengal.

61. Sabanam aged about 30 years, D/o: Md Nasir Khan of Lilong Haoreibi Turel Ahanbi Ubakthong Makha P.S &P.O- Lilong-795130.

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 Page |9

62. Kachinganglu Remei aged about 39 years, D/o Lalkhollung Remei of Keishamthong Kabui Khul, Imphal West-795001.

63. Md. Muhibullah aged about 43 years, S/o: (L) Mv Hamid Ali of Sora Maning Leikai, P.O.& P.S: Kakching - 795103.

64. Kh. Solomon Pantijie aged about 43 years, S/o:

Kh. Chaluisiba John of Hougailuang ward No 4,P.S &P.O.-Tamenglong -795141

65. NemminchongMisao, aged about 34 years, D/O HenkholunMisao of Ward No 6, Kangpokpi, P.S & P.O-Kangpokpi-795129.

66. L. Esther Hoineithem, aged about 30 years, D/O L. Thongkhothang of H.No-232, Bijang, P.S & P.O-Churachandpur-795128

67. T. Jelena Kom aged about 35 years, D/O T.

MangneithangKom of Lower KomKeirap Loktak Project,P.S & P.O-Loktak Project- 785124

68. Leivon Else Rejoice Kom, aged about 35 years, D/O Leivon AshongKom P.S & P.O- Churachandpur-795128.

69. Angson Kophun Maring, aged about 34 years, S/O A. Angrung Maring of WaithouPhunal Maring, P.S-Irilbung and P.O- Lilong- 795130

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 10

70. M. Thongminthang Haokip, aged about 37 years, S/O (L) M. Jamson Haokip of Beijang Village, P.S & P.O- Churachandpur-795128

71. Ng. Amos aged about34 years, S/O A. Ngamba of Taphou Naga Village, P.S & P.O- Senapati-795106.

72. Ganthaolung Riamei aged about 34 years, S/O Machungpaungpou Riamei of Shangji Village, P.O- Bishnupur and P.S- Khoupum, Noney District, Pin-795126

73. Kamei Gaiganglu, aged about 33 years, D/O Namdai Kamei of Namdunlong, Stadium Road, P.S- Porompat and P.O-lamlong- 795010.

74. LeiyaphiTallanao, aged about 28 years, D/o T.

Karei of A-58, Hamleikhong, Hundung, P.S & P.O- Ukhrul-795142.

75. Pf. Manikho, aged about 32 years, S/O A.

Pfokrehrii of Phikomai, P.S & P.O-Mao Gate, Pin- 795150.

76. NinghmanWango Anal, aged about 30 years, D/O, HlungvolWango Anal of Japhou Bazar, P.S & P.O- Chandel-795127.

77. Zingran A. Shishak, aged about 30 years, D/O Chinaongam A. Shishak of Shangshak Khullen, P.S & P.O- Ukhrul-795142.

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 11

78. RS Philachon aged about 34 years, W/O Yurreingam Kasar of Ramva (Lambui) Village, P.S & P.O-Ukhrul -795142.

79. Rv. Lakleiphi aged about 40 years, D/O RvShangam of Somdal Village, P.S & P.O- Somdal-795142, Ukhrul District.

80. Mayori H, aged about 33 Years, D/O David H of Chahong Khullen Village, Kamjong District, P.S & P.O- Kamjong- 795145.

81. Maringmei Amumei, aged about 43 years, S/O MaringmeiLanbirung of Loktak Project, P.S & P.O- Loktak Project-795124, Churachandpur District

82. K. Rekha, aged about 37 years, D/O K. Dindai of New Canaan Village, P.S & P.O-Loktak Project-795124, Churachandpur District.

83. Karong Nelson Kom aged about 39 years, S/O K. Tokhuochung of Khoirentak Khuman Village, P.S & P.O- Moirang-795133 Churachandpur District.

84. VCC Ngamchiyo aged about 37 years, D/O Benjamin Ngamchiyo of HungpungDungrei, P.S & P.O-Ukhrul-795142.

85. WorngamlaMahongnao aged about 38 years, D/O RamnganamMahongnao of Sinakeithal Village, Ukhrul District, P.S & P.O- Litan- 795145

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 12

86. J Ngachonshem aged about 35 years, S/O J Vaomi of Phalee Village, P.S & P.O-Somdal- 795144, Ukhrul District.

87. Thang Johnson aged about 35 years, S/O Pausianthang of Ensuan Road Vengnuam, New Lamka, P.S & P.O- Churachandpur- 795006.

88. Worchuila VS aged about 40 years, D/O VS Reuben of Shangshak Village, P.S & P.O- Shangshak-795142, Ukhrul District.

89. Soling M aged about 31 years, D/O David M of Tashar Village, P.S & P.O-Ukhrul-795142.

90. Ramsen AS aged about 34 years, S/O Patrick AS of Khamasom Khullen, P.S & P.O- Ukhrul-795142.

91. ThemthinglaMungrei, aged about 32 years, D/O ChinaoshangMungrei of Thawai Village, P.S & P.O- Litan-795145

92. Wunganing AS, aged about 31 years, S/O Silas AS of Khamasom Village, P.S & P.O- Ukhrul-795142.

93. K. Wilringstone, aged about 43 years, S/O K.

Pamleyo of Lunghar Village, P.S & P.O- Litan-795142, Ukhrul District.

95. Pamshim Kazingmei, aged about 32 years, S/OPamreiKazingmei of Lunghar Village, P.S & P.O- Litan-795145, Ukhrul District.

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 13

96. Lunkim Lhingneihoi Khongsai, aged about 33 years, D/O L. ZamkhoginKhogsai of VIII MongotChepu (Litan), P.O & P.S- Litan- 795145, Ukhrul District.

... Petitioners

- Versus -

1. The State of Manipur through Commissioner/Secretary, (Education /S), Government of Manipur, Imphal Secretariat, P.O. Imphal-795001, Imphal West District.

2. The Director of Education(S), Government of Manipur, Lamphelpat, - 795004.

3. W. Sobita Devi

4. N. Achouba Singh

5. A. Joykumar

6. G. Thambalsana Kabui

7. M. Takheljao Singh

8. S.Bijaya Devi

9. M. Debendro Singh

10. N. Dijendra

11. H. Dhanajit Singh

12. R.K. Shyamchoron Singh

13. T. Indira Devi

14. Th. Subashchandra Singh

15. K. Sunanda Devi

16. L. Norendro Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 14

17. M. W. Tharawon

18. N. Pramodini Devi

19. Th. Rajendra Kumar singh

20. K. S. Yaruingam

21. M. Kalachand Singh

22. Khol khoikim Vaiphei

23. M. Muhindro Singh

24. Mohnn Kumar Ivlishra

25. H. Anandi Devi

26. L. Triveni Devi

27. O. Geetarani Devi

28. M. Kiranmala Devi

29. Kh. lbomcha Singh

30. Ch. Robindro Singh

31. W. Rameshwor Singh

32. L. Rajendra Singh

33. N. jibanlata Devi

34. Th. Ralendro Singh

35. Ch. Medha Devi

36. I. Lily Devi

37. Urmila Kshetrimayum

38. Anupama Nepram

39. N. Goutam Singh

40. N. Borchandra Singh

41. P. Nimai Singh

42. M. Saya Devi

43. Shachikurmari Huidrombi

44. S. Ibemnungshi Devi

45. H. Jeeten Singh

46. N. Premlata Devi

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 15

47. T. Khomdon Singh

48. Th. Helu Devi

49. R. K. Chaoba Singh

50. N. Sangita Devi

51. Th. Sachinanda Singh

52. Kh. Memtombi Devi

53. I. Usharani Devi

54. M. Kheroda Devi

55. Jeida Begum

56. Kh. Shangai Devi

57. N. Ratana Devi

58. P. Baroda Devi

59. R. K.Sanatombi

60. H. Padmini Devi

61. W. Mohindro Singh

62. Kh. Chandrakanta Singh

63. Kh. Kamalakanta Singh

64. Y. Radheshyam Singh.

65. Kh. Shyamkumar Singh

66. K. Rajani Devi

67. G. Geeta Devi

68. Sh. Jayanta Singh

69. Saroj Kumar Sinha

70. O. Somila Devi

71. Ng. Kiranmala Devi

72. H. Ripupyari Devi

73. Kh. Bikramchandra Singh

74. S. Jugindro Singh

75. M. Tikendrajit Singh

76. Heltinmang Misao

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 16

77. M. Nimaichand Singh

78. N. Sumila Chanu

79. Kh. Nandini Devi

80. Th. Pratima Devi

81. Nirmala Koijam

82. L. Bor Singh

83. S. Devikarani Devi

84. I. Sujata Devi

85. K. Shantibala Devi

86. L. Bharati Devi

87. K. Bijaya Devi

88. Ksh. Ratna Devi

89. K. Shangkham Monsang

90. P. Nilakumari Devi

91. L. Nandabir Singh

92. Ataullah Khan

93. Ng. Karmaljit Singh

94. Sunita Laisom

95. T. Pusparani Devi

96. L. Sangeeta Devi

97. O. Manmohini Devi

98. Th. Ranieeta Devi

99. Prem Prasad Shivakoti

100. Vidya Mairembam

101. Th. Irika Devi

102. H. Sureshkumar Singh

103. P. Omita Devi

104. Th. Lite Devi

105. Kh. Brajeswori Devi

106. Kshetrimayum Kunjabihari Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 17

107. Y. Premila Devi

108. Thounaojam Bilasini Devi

109. Y.lboyaima Singh

110. Chabungbam Ranjit Singh

111. E. Noren Singh

112. Khundombam Indikumar Singh

113. O.. Rajendro Singh

114. Angonjabam Nalini Devi

115. Shantikuman Prasad

116. Chongtham Noyin Singh

117. Lhingneilam Haokip

118. Khuraijam Sunanda Devi

119. Ph. Tampakleima Devi

120. Taorem Jiibanlata Devi

121. Y. Babu Singh

122. Waikhom Ibeyaima Devi

123. R.K. Sarda Devi

124. Shamurailatpam Devani Devi

125. Y. Kumar Singh

126. Angoljabam Premila Devi

127. Ng. Tamphatombi Devi

128. Gurumayum Satyabati Devi

129. M. Subashini Devi

130. Oinam Sorodhoni Devi

131. Y. Khomdon Singh

132. Raikumari Khambisana Devi

133. H. Rejubala Devi

134. Nongmaithern Rasmon Singh

135. I. Usharanj Devi

136. Heisnam Mangijao Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 18

137. K. Lucybala Devi

138. R.K. Sanatomba Singh

139. I. Bipin Meetei

140. Thokchom Indira Devi

141. R.K. Sharatkumar Singh

142. Khuraijam Binodini Devi

143. Kh. Romola Devi

144. Konthoujam Bimolini Devi

145. H. Binodini Devi

146. Nongmaithem Sunita Devi

147. S.B. Pathak

148. Pukhrambam Sarju Singh

149. L. Muhindro Singh

150. Elangbam Dipali Devi

151. Dal Bahadur Bhattarai Chhetry

152. Moirangthem Opendro Singh

153. M.Sakhitombi Devi

154. Amakcham Naba Siingh

155. Punita Das

156. Nongthombam Femina Devi

157. Promila Ahanthembi

158. Naorem Lokendro Singh

159. M. Bidyapati Devi

160. Oinam Noyon Singh

161. Th. Anibolin Devi

162. Thongbam Bhogendro Singh

163. W. lbeyaima Devi

164. Nongthombam Lala Singh

165. A. Shashilata Devi

166. Laishram Nandakumari Devi

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 19

167. 0. Sarjubala Devi

168. Loitongbam Dorendro Singh

169. Kh. Bimola Devi

170. Chandam Khomei Singh

171. A. Sarjubala Chanu

172. Khoisnam Sunita Devi

173. L. Jugelata Devi

174. Laishram Doren Singh

175. N. Amita Devi

176. Rajesh Kumar Kar

177. Parmanand Singh

178. Waikhom Sushilkumar Meitei

179. Irom Shyamkesho Singh

180. Irom Bedamani Devi

181. H. Meghachandra Singh

182. Md. Alauddin Shah

183. L. Jibanmala Devi

184. Yumnam Bihari Meetei

185. L. Ratnaprava Devi

186. Talkhellambam lbohal Singh

187. Th. Nandini Devi

188. Akham Domarendro Singh

189. L. Padmabati Devi

190. YunosKhan

191. O. Chanu Amita

192. Laishram Sanjtibkurmar Singh

193. R.K. Romoni Devi

194. Kangjam Jamuna Devi

195. W. Manojkumar

196. Mandingbam Roma Devi

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 20

197. K. Geetika Devi

198. Laishram Sarojini Devi

199. G. Bala Devi

200. Nadira Begun

201. Nonibala Longjam

202. Kh. Kamkhohao Lungdei

203. H. Bhobashis Luwang

204. Nongmaithem Udoya Devi

205. Konsam Surendra

206. Thiyam Brajakeshwor Singh

207. N. Dhana Singh

208. Gururnayum Radharnani Devi

209. L. Joychandra Sharma

210. Keisham Jugeshwar Singh

211. Y. Romashini Devi

212. Rajkumar Dalimkumar Singh

213. K. Rebati Chanu

214. Md. Hatim Ali

215. W. Jayantakumar Singh

216. Laishrarn Khamba Singh

217. N. Jogendro Singh

218. Takhellambam Subarta Singh

219. Kh. Bimola Devi

220. Monohormayum Bebi Devi

221. W. Johny

222. Elangbam Rajen Singh

223. P. Nilamani Singh

224. Sanasam Bita Devi

225. S. Prabhatchandra Singh

226. Maibam Surjabal Khuman

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 21

227. Ranjeeta Laishram

228. Tongbram Tomba Singh

229. Md.Mirja Khan

230. Kshetrimayum Chitralekha Devi

231. Y. Binati Devi

232. Burhanuddin

233. Masan Ahamnd

234. Ahanthem Meghachandra Singh

235. N.Nandan Devi

236. Changamayum Binarani Devi

237. Arambam Sujata Devi

238. Khuraijam Indiprabha Devi

239. W. Gunananda Singh

240. Bareda Begum

241. Nganbam Bhobanta Singh

242. Wairokpam Ojitkumar Singh

243. O. Kunjo Singh

244. Kakchingtabam Pramodini Devi

245. Jeshmi Thokchom

246. Sikander Ali

247. P. Babu Singh

248. Md Liyakat Ali

249. Wahidur Rahaman

250. Moirangthem Sunita Devi

251. L.Ibomcha Singh

252. Bisnulatpam Profullo Sharma

253. Y . Badal Singh

254. N. Sanjib Kumar Singha

255. W. Priyadarshni Devi

256. Naoroibam Sashikanta Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 22

257. Charu Chandra Haomon

258. Kshetrimayum Mema Devi

259. T. Ibetombi Devi

260. Rajkumar Milan Singh

261. Ngangom Dilipkumar Singh

262. Lisam Jiteshwari Devi

263. L. Kanta Meitei

264. Md. Afzal Ali

265. Kiyam Sharat Singh

266. Mujibur Rahman

267. Chongtham Romita Devi

268. Thangjam Biren Singh

269. Nirmala Achom

270. Rajkumari Premoda Devi

271. L. Premchandra Singh

272. Wahengbam Dineshkumar Singh

273. Y. Nandakumar Singh

274. Ngangbam Tombi

275. Chandam Yaima Devi

276. Naoshekpam Aruna Devi

277. Gurumayum Meenakshi Sharma

278. Kangjam Ratankumar Singh

279. Leimapokpam Khogen Singh

280. Okram Imo Singh

281. Yumnam Jayanta Singh

282. Thingujam Heramot Singh

283. M. Raju Singh

284. Abdul Kalam

285. Rosekumar Ningthoujam

286. Shanglakpam Dhaneshwori Devi

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 23

287. H. Dijen Singh

288. Nongthombam Jugeshwar Singh

289. Leimapokpam Jumen Singh

290. Thongam Sunita Devi

291. Nongmeikapam Nilakanta Singh

292. Huidrom Basantakumar Singh

293. K.Priyokumar Singh

294. Thokchom Janaranjan Singh

295. L. Premananda

296. Laishram Dhamendra Singh

297. Khangembam Romen Meetei

298. Leishangthem Kheroda Devi

299. T. Soniya

300. Longjam Roma Devi

301. Shahabuddin Khan

302. Mayengbam Bijoychandra

303. Ksh. Ibubgo Singh

304. Shandmbam Pishak Singh

305. Thokchom lmobi Singh

306. Konsham Mahila Devi

307. Huidrom Surchand Singh

308. Thoidingjam Sunil Khuman

309. Yumnam Tarunbala Devi

310. Ngashepam Shanti Singh

311. Yanglem Sanaton Singh

312. Kayarnuddin

313. L. Anilkumar

314. Yamkhopao Touthang

315. Salem Imocha Singh

316. Laishram Nando Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 24

317. S. Ratna Devi

318. Brahmacharimayum Gyaneshwari Devi

319. S. Holendro Singh

320. LairikyengbamToniya

321. A. Shyamchand Singh

322. Sultana Begum

323. Takhellambam Promosini Devi

324. Athokpam Umabati Devi

325. A. Jayadev Sharma

326. Soraisam Meghachandra Singh

327. S. Ripon Singh

328. Yengkhom Thoibi Devi

329. Salam Meghachandra Singh

330. Yumnam Vedajit Singh

331. W. Sobha Singh

332. Sanasam Premananda Singh

333. Basantarani Pukhrambam

334. Shyamashakhee Nongthombam

335. Rajita Thingbaijam

336. Thounaojam Chanu Romabala 33 337. R.K. Romila Devi

338. Samukcham Romola Devi

339. N. Biramani Singh

340. Yumnan Tampha Devi

341. O. Modhochandra Singh

342. Konsam Ibungo Singh

343. Soibam Pramochandra Singh

344. Potshangbam Sabitri Devi

345. Thounaojam Neetu Chanu

346. Loitongbam Dadu Chanu

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 25

347. Ayam Thoi Singh

348. Vijaya Kongbrailatpam

349. Ch. Bogeshor Singh

350. Konsam Sanajaoba Singh

351. K. Bijoy Singh

352. Ibomcha Irengbam

353. Wham Nodiyachand Singh

354. angita Soram

355. Ningthomam Lukhoi Memel

356. Ngangom Rejia Devi

357. L. Sanahal Devi

358. Y. Premananda Singh

359. Ahongshangbam Monita Devi

360. Gopimohon Khundrakpam

361. Th. Bharat Singh

362. Thoudam Premila Devi

363. Ngaineihkim Gangte

364. Moirangthem Jayantakumar Singh

365. Lungthailiu Panmei

366. G. Surajkumar Sharma

367. Esther

368. Oinam Nepoleon Singh

369. Mashangvaljek Tangkhul

370. Th. James Singh

371. S. Subon Singh

372. Md. lqbal Shah

373. Suchin Akoijam

374. Laishram Surjitkumar Singh

375. Gourika Devi Naosekpam

376. Yendrembam Nomita Devi

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 26

377. Ak. Santaraj Singh

378. Namminkparn Sunita Devi

379. N. Inungnganbi

380. Ranita Angom

381. N. Robindro Singh

382. Brahmacharimayum Ramananda Sharma

383. Gurumayum Surlekha Sharma

384. Ngangom Nilamani Singh

385. Kh. Herojit Singh

386. Md. Iahuruddin Shah

387. Oinam Shyamprakash Singh

388. Najib Ali

389. Khundrakpam Chanuleima Devi

390. Thokchom Tamphaibema Devi

391. S. Ibetombi Devi

392. Elangbam Jamuna Devi

393. Sunita Ngashepam

394. Naorem Nabachandra Singh

395. Ak.Nongmainingthou

396. Radha Naorem

397. Rupachandra Lourembam

398. Keisham Surjalata Devi

399. Kumam Devachandra Singh

400. Khaidem Ashokumar Singh

401. N. Sarat Singh

402. Ningombam Upendro Singh

403. Punshi Khuraijam

404. Lairikyengbam Vidya Roy

405. Hidam Ramananda Singh

406. Khumallambam Inakhunbi Devi

407. Leimapokpam Komol Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 27

408. Lourembam Bimorani Chanu

409. Ak. Brojendro Singh

410. Thingbaijam Chanu Merryland

411. M. Ratna Devi

412. Sagolsemcha Pathou Mangang

413. R.K. Jien Singh

414. Moirangthem Baleshwor Singh

415. M. Amrita Devi

416. Mohd. Anjar Khan

417. Laishram Sharmila Devi

418. Abdul Quadir

419. Yumnam Brojeshwori Devi

420. Ngangbam Bandana Devi

421. L. Bhanumati Devi

422. Elangbam Anita Devi

423. Leimapokoam Sunilkumar Singh

424. Ningombam Samananda Singh

425. Th. Surjiit Singh

426. Naorem Dharmendra

427. Goswami Kebi

428. Chongtham Bidyaleima Devi

429. S.Sunderjeet Singh

430. Konsam Sodeshini

431. Oinam Dhaneshwori Devi

432. Nongthombam Ravichandra Singh

433. Rajkumar Somorjit Singh

434. Sagolsem Roma Devi

435. L.Chitaranjan Singh

436. Nongmaithem Budhibala Devi

437. M. Pahari Singh

438. Laishram Tanita Devi

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 28

439. Sanasam Dorendra Singh

440. Khaidem Ratan Meitei

441. Takhellambam Jayanta Singh

442. Monoharmayum Tangkeswor Sharma

443. L. Roohan Singh

444. Yuhlung Budhichandra Chothe

445. A. Shyam Singh

446. Sanjrambam Sandhyarani Devi

447. Leimapokpam Pratap Singh

448. Thaja Irom

449. Soibam Umeshwari Devi

450. Thangjam Romita Devi

451. Akoijam Priyokumar Singh

452. Orlando Laishram

453. Kh. Lolindro Singh

454. Aongshangbam Ajitkumar Singh

455. Kh. Joykumar Singh

456. Takhenchangbam Sunderchand Sharma

457. R.K. Dhanabir Singh

458. Wahengbam Inaocha Singh

459. Laishram Jugindro Singh

460. Sanasam Deban Singh

461. Sophia Akoijam

462. Nongthombam Purnima Devi

463. Longjam Joychandra Singh

464. Khwairakpam Suleja Devi

465. H. Sangtesana Chanu

466. Naorem lbomcha Singh

467. Samom Johnkumar Singh

468. Ayekpam Nandarani Devi

469. Usham Ranita

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 29

470. Yendrembam Phalguni Devi

471. K. Gautam Singh

472. Heisnam NilakantaSingh

473. Flangbam Upendra Singh

474. Kshetrimayum Nirmala Devi

475. Karam Bimola Devi

476. Huirem Meghachandra Singh

477. A. Basanta Kumar Singh

478. Ningthoujam Kennedy Singh

479. Heisnam Sobita Devi

480. Leitanthem Raiesh Singh

481. Puyarn Robindro Singh

482. Oinam Sandhyarani Devi

483. Oinam Medha Devi

484. Wanglembam Mobi Singh

485. Kh. Kamala Devi

486. Ningthoujam lngotomba Singh

487. Surbala Abujam

489. Laishram Suchitra Devi

490. Elam Salini Devi

491. Okram Ranjana Devi

492. Puyam Raniit Singh

493. Md Shoukat Ali

494. Sanasam Ira Singh

495. Hemam Umabati Devi

496. Kh. Belinda Devi

497. Sharmila Wahengbam

498. Th.Geetarani Devi

499. Ningthoujam Deepashree Devi

500. M.Premkumar Siungh

501. Kangujam Shanta Devi

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 30

502. Niroda Kongbrailatpam

503. Rajkumar Naba Singh

504. Yumlembam Priobarta Singh

505. Aribam Chanchalkumari Devi

506. Taiyemjam Meghachandra Singh

507. Haobijam Lokendro Singh

508. S.Sanjeeb Sharma

509. S. Mala Devi

510. Ngangom Sharjubala Devi

511. Angom Robinson Singh

512. L. Kamala Devi

513. Lamabam Anjuna Devi

514. W. Amujao Meitei

515. Sagolsem Cha Binit

516. Brahmacharimayum Seityabrata Sharma

517. Loitongbam Ojen Singh

518. K. lndira Devi

519. Hemam Jiitcn Singh

520. Ch. Runchi Devi

521. Yumnam Sulochana Devi

522. W. Nungshitombi Devi

523. Laimayum Surjakumar Sharma

524. Khundongbam Ranjit Singh

525. Ningthouiam Rajendra Singh

526. Naorem Dhanajit Singh

527. Soubam Sunitibala Devi

528. Romeo

529. Khuraijam Roshan Kumar Singh

530. Ph.Gokulchandra Sharma

531. Angom Chanu Renubala

532. S.Imo Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 31

533. Sorokhaibam Gojen Singh

534. N. Mangal Sana

535. Koijam Premala

536. Oinam Broieshwar Singh

537. Sharungbam Nganthoi Chanu

538. Kshetrimayum Goiendro Singh

539. Kangjam Sobha Devi

540. Oinam Arunkumari Devi

541. Moirangthem Ajitkumar Singh

542. L.. Robert Singh

543. Indira Devi Sorokhaibam

544. Wahengbam Debola Devi

545. Nongthombam Nalini Devi

546. Khwairakpam Surjit Singh

547. Khwairakpm Wangkhei Singh

548. Thingbaijam Zenita

549. Huirem Rajen Kumar Singh

550. Ziaur Rahman

551. S. Chhayalaxmi Devi

552. Yumkhaibam Bimol Singh

553. Laishram Manoikumar

554. L. Dhramendra Meitei

555. Md. Nasir Hussain Shah

556. Laikangbam Shalini

557. A. Nonima Singha

558. Rajkuman Shivani

559. Kangjam Geetarani Devi

560. Y. Sanatombi Devi

561. R. K. Krishnakumari Devi

562. Oinam Doren Singh

563. Waikhom Bimota Devi

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 32

564. Th. Surpriya Devi

565. R.K. Haridutta Singh

566. H.Ranjan Meetei

567. Hidangmayum Bishwashanti Sharma

568. Maikam Sharat Singh

569. Elangbam Nonibala Devi

570. Memthoi Takhellambam

571. Konsam Nokul Singh

572. Thounaojam Kanta Singh

573. lrengbam Nandini Devi

574. Jina Thokchom

575. Nongthombam Brojen Mectei

576. Naorem lbomcha Singh

577. Thiyam Dwijenkumar Singh

578. Maibam Tilotama Devi

579. Naorem Jibol Singh

580. Maibam Surjen Singh

581. Yumnam Binasakhi Devi

582. K.Sureshkumar Singh

583. Anwar Hussain

584. M. Meghachandra

585. Thoudam Maichael Singh

586. H.Surjit Singh

587. Aheibam Radhetombi Devi

588. Ningthouiam Thoiba Singh

589. Sorokhaibam Dhanachandra Singh

590. A. Inaotombi Singh

591. Kongbrailatpam Romeo Sharma

592. Khilona Thokchom

593. Naorem Nimaichand Singh

594. Th. Bimola Devi

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 33

595. Hemam Jinibala Devi

596. Md .Rashid Ali

597. M. Romeo Singha

598. Firoz Khan

599. Kshetrimayum Vivekananda Singh

600. Ningombam Romita Devi

601. Thingbaijam Gagarin Singh

602. Oinam Hemanta Meetei

603. Huirem Rakesh Singh

604. L. Dhanajit

605. S. Madhumati Devi

606. Khuraijam Phalguni Devi

607. Thangjam lnaobi Devi

608. L. Homen Meetei

609. Sagolsem Saraju Devi

610. Th. Ranijta Devi

611. Keisam Zenithta Devi

612. Mohd Noor-Ul Hasan Shah

613. K. Bidita Devi

614. S. Gurucharan Singh

615. Yengkokpam Ajitkumar Singh

616. M. Luhen Singh

617. Keisham Jiban Singh

618. Thingbaijam Dharamendra Singh

619. Thounaojam Shyamo Singh

620. A. Anita Devi

621. Ningthoujam Ramdas Singh

622. N. Bilash Singh

623. Thokchom Shurjitkumar Singh

624. Keisam Chinglenkhomba

625. Thokchom Nimai Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 34

626. T. Babita Devi

627. Leishangthem Amba Chanu

628. N. Kirankumar Singh

629. Laishram Chaoba Singh

630. Ninthemcha Tomba Meetei

631. Ningthoujam Manglem Singh

632. Konsam Santoshkumar

633. Maimom lngo Singh

634. Laishram Jugeshwar Singh

635. Waikhom Jotindro Singh

636. Ningombam Meghachandra Singh

637. Tourangbam Toto Singh

638. Yumnam Sangjta Devi

639. Thongam Chanu Chingkheileima

640. Aribam Sanajaobi Devi

641. L. Neheru Singh

642. Yumnam Shanta Singh

643. Shreemayum Premkumar Sharma

644. L. Broien Singh

645. Maibam Dijen Singh

646. Thiyam Devkiran Singh

647. Chandam Heramani Singh

648. Linthoingambi Wairokpam

649. Laishram Joykumar Singh

650. Ningombam Sarjubala Devi

651. Jiten Sharma

652. N. Premkumar Singh

653. Tongbram Rebarani Devi

654. Sunil Ahanthem

655. Mutum Manbi Devi

656. Hemam Bheigyachandra Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 35

657. Khundrakpam Asharani Devi 658 Kh. Dharmendra Singh

659. Khundongbam Ashokumar Singh

660. W. Khadrakpa Singh

661. Rikhi Philemon

662. L.Okendro Singh

663. K. Sow Stephen

664. Anne Chandam

665. Yengkhom Binapati Devi

666. L. Ashokumar Singh

667. Asem Nongyai Singh

668. Thokchom Premchand Singh

669. Lalboi Telien

670. Khwairakpam Jibon Singh

671. Raomai Thomas

672. Puyam James Singh

673. Akoiiam Sobita Devi

674. Wangkheimayum Phulindro Singh

675. Soram Jati Devi

676. L. Ranjanakumari Devi

677. Kshetrimayum Shamananda Singh

678. Nongmaithem Ronel Singh

679. Hoikhochong Lhungdim

680. Mongjam Anila Devi

681. Meithuan Pamei

682. Taorem Jeeban Khuman

683. Sanasam Mohendra Singh

684. Khundrakpam Punyabati Devi

685. Kimjaneng Koroung

686. Renuka Huidrom

687. Ch. Deborah Gangte

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 36

688. Mili Karam

689. Ningombam Surjit Singh

690. Md. Tamijur Rahaman

691. Salam Bimolchand Singh

692. Ningthoujam Premlata Devi

693. Jasha Cecilia Anal

694. Md. Arzad Ali

695. Sangita Sorokhaibam

696. Haobam Beejen Meitei

697. Thingujam Irabot Singh

698. Salam Sundip Singh

699. Heisnam Linthoingambi Devi

700. Ksh. Bhopender Singh

701. Okram Rajendro Singh

702. Ningthoujam Shivamkumar Singh

703. Naorem Mani Singh

704. M. Christamani

705. Shagolsem Anand Singh

706. Thoudam Rebika Chanu

707. K. S. V. Raamses Kahorthing

708. Sila Sinam

709. Ruivahnao Apem Shimray

710. Oinam Gitchandra Singh

711. Ameeta Huidrom

712. Amom Ronesh Singh

713. Langkoklakpam Melina Chanu

714. Indrani Akoiiam

715. Laishram Binasakhi Devi

716. Kongkham Loidang Devi

717. Maharabam Leibaklei Devi

718. Jaichand Oinam

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 37

719. Irengbam Ruhinikumar Singh

720. Chongtham Gilbert Singh

721. Khaidem Sunanda Devi

722. Soyam Nungshithoibi Devi

723. Tongbram Priyokumar Singh

724. S. Jotish Singh

725. Oinam Shyam Singh

726. Oinam Shyamo Singh

727. Md. Nurul Hussain

728. Premabati Leishangthem

729. Shemreingam Mungrei

730. M. Renubala Devi

731. Thiyam Jairam Singh

732. Hanjabam Shanta Devi

733. Sr. Tohring

734. N. Ranjita Devi

735. Adani Lokho

736. Th. Subhaschandra Singh

737. Haile Peter

738. Th.Motilal Singh

740. Ngamkhohou Baite

741. E. Khogen Singh

742. Khumanthem lngocha

743. R.K Dhaneshwari

744. Maharabam Neshwari Devi

745. Athokpam Sunanda

746. Adhikarimayum Brojenkumar Shanna

747. Khumallambam Nirmala Devi

748. Salam Premlata Devi

749. L. Ishwarjit Sharma

750. TakhellambamRobindro Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 38

751. Salam Naran Singh

752. Singmipam Khamrang

753. I.Dhani Devi

754. Chirom Jadumani Singh

755. Maisnam Premchand Singh

756. S. P. Philamaya

757. K Dineshchandra Singh

758. Reisang Iloram

759. Mamata Tayenjam

760. Simon Pukeho

761. Pukhrambam Shantikumar Singh

762. Ingudam Sanjoy Singh

763. Th. Somorjit Singh

764. Moirangthem Jiten Sinsth

765. Chongtham Chittaranjan Singh

766. Soibam Joymilan Singh

767. Ch. Indira Devi

768. N. Nityai Singh

769. N. Bembem Devi

770. Thounaojam Shyamashakhi Chanu

771. Bachaspatimayum Winchester Sharma

772. Yumnam Hemapati Chanu

773. Senjam Manju Devi

774. Jangkhothang Hoakip

775. Kh. Dhananjoy Singh

776. Naorem Surjit Singh

777. L. Ritendro Singh

778. Chongkhoncnit Chongloi

779. U. Ibohal Singh

780. Silas M ram

781. Ningthoujam Milankrishna

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 39

782. P. M Joy Charles

783. Keithelakpam Nandini Devi

784. Wahengbam Tuleshwori Devi

785. P. Jagatmani Singh

786. Nongmeikapam Omika Devi

787. Th.Venuchandra Singh

788. Nongmaithem Bikramjit Singh

789. Taorem Bhavini Devi

790. Debory Fimsangpui

791. Kh. Sanayaima Singh

792. Salam Rajeshwar Singh

793. Khaidem Sharat Singh

794. Samuel Shelly

795. Laishram Romita Devi

796. Sagolsem Linthoingambi Devi

797. Moirangthem.9aniit Singh

798. Aribam Shyammuhini Devi

799. Mayengbam Bhorot Singh

800. Thaigongam Dangmei

801. Takhellambam lbocha Singh

802. Kangababam Premchandra Singh

803. Ng. sanajaobi Devi

804. Aheibam Sanatomba Singh

805. Salam Janori Devi

806. M. Doukllomang Haokip

807. Sapam Jotindra Singh

808. K.S. Jehu Tangkhul

809. Kh.Premchand Singh

810. Sarita Laithangbam

811. Yumnam Sunil Singh

812. Samson Soro

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 40

813. Akoiiam lbochouba Singh

814. Wungreisun R. S.

815. L. Santa Devi

816. Akhuwan Kamei

817. Gotimayum Kennedy Sharma

818. John Ragui

819. Yumnam Sarajlakshrni Devi

820. Lalthuoikim Pangamte

821. Tongbram Jugin Singh

822. Konjengbam Chungkhonleima Chanu

823. Dinbuiyang

824. Khampi Pamei

825. S. Khamminthang Ngaihei

826. Ragailung Gonmei

827. V.S. Mashunthing

828. H. Lalthamuan

829. Yuimi Varam

830. Pantina Panmei

831. Esau Shaiza

832. Zeanut

833. Greenmila Rungsung

834. Patricia Neaihlun Thawmte

835. Thothor Muinao

836. Lalhminghlu

837. Patrina Ngaihlun Thawmte

838. Z. Pamreishang Shimray

839. S. Ngulzaching Negaihte

840. Lalthalur Infimate

841. Lalnghaklien Khobung

842. Dangmei Gaingamlong R Naga

843. Lamkhohen

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 41

844. H. Thangtungnung

845. Gangmei Surjit Kabui

846. Zamkholen Haokip

847. R.Muinao Tangkhul

848. Sochipem Keishing

849. Lalhmunsiama

850. Maibam Edula Devi

851. Ruijom Ruisosame Aimol

852. Jonathan Th

853. Sharon Gangte

854. Ruwndar Lastny Anal

855. Thangminlien Kilong

856. Sosochon Jajo

857. Keinamgong A. Riamei

858. Shylas Paoruw

859. Leivon Soneglerchung Kom

860. William Chanisii

861. Kamlunmang Kit>!!.cn

862. Salam Santosh Singh

863. Th. Ngailian Vaiphei

864. Yengkhom Jaken Singh

865. K. Siamkhanmuan Shamte

866. Leishangthem Manju//////////

867. Phelim Keishing Tangkhul

868. Khuraijam Rameshowri Devi

869. Namthiuwangbow Newmai

870. T. Kaikhanmuan

871. S.N. Bongshel Lamkang

872. Roel Margaret Moyon

873. Gaichui Malangmei

874. Jankholal Mate

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 42

875. Seikhomang Guite

876. Felly Hatneiting

877. Julia Golmei

878. Shornalu Phaomei

879. Nemjalam Doungel

880. Minhlung Anal

881. Lunkhothang Haokip

882. Letkholal

883. Sonminlian S. Haokip

884. Thoveini Peter

885. S. Chinhoikim

886. Awungshi Shimray N.

887. Shukrengzam Chiru

888. Phangamsung Ronra Shimray

889. T. Thuamkhanvung

890. Thienkhohao Touthang

891. Lankhollung Dangmei

892. Tungnung George Ginsuanlian Zou

893. Cecilia Zemei

894. Khopuneme Easter Arila

895. KL Warson Anal

896. Suantak Mercy Vaiphei

897. Phakholom Haokip

898. Sonkhosei Kilong

899. Thanglienlal C. Thangzom

900. S.R. Berilus

901. Arfina Haokip

902. Siambiakkim

903. Mayanglambam Brajabinodo Singh

904. Usham Anuradha

905. Shamjetshabam Thambou Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 43

906. A. Mary

907. Mayanglambam Cheiteinya Singh

908. Thiyam Surajkumar

909. N. Sumita Devi

910. P. Manikho

911. Ksh. Meghachandra Singh

912. Boisy Thangneivah

913. M. Maipak Singh

914. Heikrujam Sachikumar Singh

915. Maharabam Jamuna Devi

916. Elangbam Sunibala Devi

917. Ksh. Amarjit Singh

918. Nongmaithem Surjit Singh

919. Naorem Sangita Devi

920. Mayanglambam lndubala Devi

921. Y. Amujao Singh

922. Mayanglambam Praphullo Singh

923. Dineshchandra Haobijam

924. Thoudam Santa Singh

925. T. Lamkhoneng Haokip

926. Mayanglambam Chandrasekhar Singh

927. S. Lunjacob Vaiphei

928. Koningam Bungdon

929. Leivon. Damrenghui Kom

930. Amom Dilip Singh

931. G. Akimpou Kabui

932. Yumnam Sanjit Singh

933. Wahengbam Radhetombi Devi

934. Amom Raju Singh

935. Khundrakpam Devachandra Singh

936. Ruwndnr Nunsthnnit Anal

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 44

937. Mayanglambam Robin Singh

938. Mayanglilinbam Sapna Devi

939. Thingnam Ronita Devi

940. Khumukcham Ranibala Devi

941. Kshetrimavum Tampha Devi

942. Kshetrimayum Rani Devi

943. Yengkhom Sumita Devi

944. Oinam Chandrakumar Singh

945. Yumkhaibam lbomcha Meetei

946. L.Bono Singh

947. Chingakham Sujita Devi

948. Pukhrambam Chinglen Singh

949. Angom Manoi Kumar Singh

950. Meera Pheiroijam

951. Maibam Biiendra Singh

952. Warepam Sajuk Singh

953. Pheiroijam Shyamsunnder Singh

954. Shambanduram Daneel Singh

955. Pukhrambam Justice Singh

956. Kangabam Sunderchand Singh

957. A. Ratankumar Sharma

958. Rajkumar Bhupendra Singh

959. Laiphrakpam Zinco Singh

960. Chabungbam Somorjit Singh

961. Ahongsangbam Jayanta Singh

962. Ningthojam Dharamendra Singh

963. Hemam Bembem Devi

964. Khadrakpa Moirangthem

965. Ningthoujam Mahabir

966. Yurembam Jogen Singh

967. Philem Radharani Devi

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 45

968. Thokchom Sunil Meeti

969. Kakchingtabam Budhadev Sharma

970. Laithangbam Pushparani Devi

971. Langpoklakpam Hectorkumar

972. Amita Gurumayum

973. Longjam Lilashwori Devi

974. Aribam Utam Sharma

975. Thokchom Keat Singh

976. Konjengbam Minashwori

977. Ishwari Thiyam

978. Monica Yengkhom

979. Anuradha Khaidem

980. Laishram Jaysandeep Singh

981. Mutum Gopeshwor Singh

982. Sanatombi Chabungbam

983. Khundrakoam Gautam Singh

984. Yumkham Sarita Devi

985. Lairenlakpam Mirabati

986. Candela Takhellambam

987. Chirom Jolin Singh

988. Heikrujam Nevarani Devi

989. Laishram Nomita

990. Govind Oinam

991. Khangembam Nanao Devi

992. Khunjamayum SunitaDevi

993. Asem Priyoshakhi Devi

994. Amarwaljit Thounaojam

995. Shanglakpam Lakshmi Devi

996. Shahnaz Beguim

997. MoiranRthem Nawalkishore Singh

999. Bindia Laipubam

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 46

1000. Huidrom Sally 1001. Yengkhom Panche Chanu 1002. Khundrakpam Raman Singh 1003 Kshetrimayum Ibotombi Singh 1004. Khuraijam Dhananjoy Singh 1005. Pebam Sobharani Devi 1006 Lairellakpam Rita Devi 1007. Romesh Rajkumar 1008. Ngangom Prem Kumar Singh 1009. Mayengbam Meenakshi Devi 1010. Rajkumari Sanjita Devi 1011. Sanasam Renuka Devi 1012. Waikhom Robindro Sangh 1013. Nameirakpam Anuradha Devi 1014. Thounaojam Thabaleima 1015. Ningthoujam lndrajit Singh 1016. Chabungbam Shomita Devi 1017. Shamurailatpam Shantanu Sharma 1018. Ayekpam Angamba Meitei 1019. Rajkwrori Uttam Devi 1020. Konika Lourembam 1021. Oinam Geeta Devi 1022. Laishram Bijen Singh 1023. Chongtham Chandrakala Devi 1024. Md. Abdul Hashim 1025. Senjam Omala Devi 1026. Suchitra Taorem 1027. Naorem Ranjan Singh 1028. Yumnam Romamanjuri Devi 1029. Sinam Sanjib Singh 1030. Shamurailatpam Doren Sharma

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 47

1031. Thingnganing Awungshang 1032. Apem K. H.

1033. Huidrom Surrmla Devi 1034. Zanyo Varam 1035. Khaidem Mandakini Devi 1036. Alamjan Bibi 1037. Chingangbam Sujata Devi 1038. Thiyam Dharmendra Singh 1039. Laishram Nirmala Devi 1040. Vungzamoi 1041. Nongthombam Nandita Devi 1042. Orient Thansing R.S 1043. Joshua Kazingmei 1044. Soram Inaobi Singh 1045. Yumnam Nandita Devi 1046. Mongjam Ranjan Singh 1047. Naorem Romio Singh 1048. Themreichan Sharon S. 1049. Sudip Dhar 1050. Irom Ichal Devi 1051. Mayengbam Surak Singh 1052. S. kaminlun Vaiphei 1053. Naorem Yani Devi 1054. Tongbram Dham Singh 1055. Miranda Luithui 1056. Zcnmuanching 1057. Sonia Sanienbam 1058. Duidang Wonshimla 1059. Sally Niangngaihching Guite 1060. Konsam Nishikanta Singh 1061. Chanambam Bisheswor Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 48

1062. Jacob Laldomsang 1063. Lourembam Yaioharembi Devi 1064. Thiekzakhuo Buhril 1065. Haobam Rajashree Devi 1066. Ngaranmi Asara 1067. Nianlhianslam 1068. Ginkaolian 1069. Ashangbam Samani Devi 1070. Chingtham Babykiran Devi 1071. Cherry Kasom 1072. Manoharmayum Pushpanjali 1073. Nongmaithem Tilotama Devi 1074. Rajkumar Sanachaoba Singh 1075. Thuamneihmawii 1076. Sorokhaibam Supriva 1077. Chiinthianhoih 1078. Wungnaolui Luikham 1079. Yaothingwon Phawung 1080. Ninothoujam Nebedita Devi 1081. Soreiya Khongreiwo 1082. L. Chuimila 1083. C. Kam Thian Mang 1084. Mayonao Lungleng 1085. Lourembam Leenabai Devi 1086. Sonia Kongsong 1087. Wairokpam Pusoarani Devi 1088. Laishram Somobala Devi 1089. Rinsophy Ragui 1090. Pau Sonal Singson 1091. Jyotsana Lourembam 1092. Jasmine Hajarimayurn

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 49

1093. Leiphrakpam Sarnalata Devi 1094. Sagolsem Reedy Devi 1095. Laishram Kapil 1096. Takhellambam Manichandra Meitei 1097. Haobijam Shyamananda Singh 1098. Chongtham Apurba Singh 1099. Phuritsabam Yudhistrytatha Singh 1100. A. Vivekananda Singha 1101. Auegustine Anal 1102. Keisham Suresh Singh 1103. Sanasam Dijeshori 1104. Mangvungjamkhoneng Haokip 1105. T. Doukhoshon Haokip 1106. Db. Shantina Lamkang 1107. Sumpi Peter Anal 1108. Ashem Jamuna Devi 1109. Thangjam Nandashyam Singh 1110. Khwairakpam Tomcha Singh 1111. Wungminao Vashumwo 1112. Ngangom Manichandra Singh 1113. Amom Pushband Singh 1114. Nongmaithem Jugindro Singh 1115. Konjengbam Noyon Singh 1116. A. S. Boniface Phungyo 1117. Salam Apabi Singh 1118. Namthuilung Kamei 1119. Khundrakparn Bimol Singh 1120. R. S. Lucas 1121. Khangembam Bimol Singh 1122. P. Rammung 1123. Naorem Juegeshwar Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 50

1124. Lunkim Kaikhomang Khongsai 1125. Md. Muhammad Khan 1126. Lairenlakpam Bimol Singh 1127. Chongnu Kilong 1128. Wahengbam Bira Singh 1129. L. Thanmila 1130. Khugai Kamei 1131. Shapam Maipak Meitei 1132. P.S. John 1133. Huidrom Brojen Singh 1134. Mutum Lalmani Singh 1135. Haobijam Oken Singh 1136. R. A. Willington 1137. Irengbam Gandhajit Singh 1138. Ahongshabam Rajen Singh 1139. Ningthoujam Deben Singh 1140. Tonton Pheiray 1141. Nandalal Baral 1142. Shangngam Mayirnao 1143. A. S. Josiah 1144. Lalkai Chongloi 1145. Makujinang Philip 1146. Sanasam Prasanta Singh 1147. Mangshatabam Iboyairna Singh 1148. Pukhrambam Dayabati Devi 1149. Chongtham Hemanta Raj 1150. Salomie Panmei 1151. Rajkumari Bhanisana Devi 1152. Waikhom Umakanta Singh 1153. Jims Shadang 1154. Urikhimbam Baleshwor Singh

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 51

1155. Guitiang Panmei 1156. Ningthoukhongjam Ranjita Devi 1157. A. S. Redeemson 1158. Anoubam Devadutta Sharma 1159. Elizabeth Gangmei 1160. Howrei Panmea 1161. Shimeichan Rongray Shimray 1162. Athuma Panmei 1163. Huidrom Menaka Devi 1164. Shamurailatpam Nimaichand Sharma 1165. Salam Robiya Meitei 1166. Ngangbam Premlata Devi 1167. Moirangthem Gandhamani Singh 1168. Chanabam Shyamjit Singh 1169. Nongmaithem Vikram Singh 1170. Heisnam Gojen Meetei 1171. Thanjluliu Colme1 1172. Moirangthem Roshan Singh 1173. Kangabam Robikumar Singh 1174. Irom Bimol Singh 1175. Aribam Gyaneshwor Sharma 1176. Ok Somendro Singh 1177. Elangbam Homeshwari Devi 1178. Konthoujam Ranjita Devi 1179. Devikarani Khundrakpam 1180. Kshetrimayurn Mirabai Devi 1181. Yumnam Laksikanta Singh 1182. Maibam Somen Singh 1183. Nongmaithem Sanjiv Singh 1184. Mayanglambam Bebarani Devi 1185. Mayengbam Diana Chanu

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 52

1186. Khumukchrun Bebeshwori Devi 1187. Yumnam Binita Chanu 1188. Lhunthang Lunkim 1189. Laishram Vivekananda Singh 1190. T. Tongkholun Haokip 1191. Khuraijam Leibakleima Chanu 1192. S. Debananda Singh 1193. Dhiraj Sharma Sanglakpam 1194. Khaidem Jayananda Singh 1195. Joykumar Wahengbam 1196. Longjam Wilburd Singh 1197. Kongkham Babyshila Devi 1198. Phianringamang Panmei 1199. Md. Wahajuddin 1200. Mani Ibema Ksh 1201. Pheiroijam Singhajit Singh 1202. B. Harichoron Sharma 1203. Singam Leimatombi 1204. Ningmareo Shimray 1205. Gou Biak Ching 1206. S.R.Thotchuila ... Respondents.

BEFORE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN

For the Petitioners :: Mr. HS Paonam, Senior Advocate

For the Respondents :: Mr. S. Nepolean, GA

Date of Hearing and reserving Judgment & Order :: 17.06.2022

Date of Judgment & Order :: 13.07.2022

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 53

JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)

Mr.S.Nepolean, learned Government Advocate, accepts

notice on behalf of the respondents 1 and 2.

2. Heard Mr.HS Paonam, learned senior counsel for the

petitioners and Mr.S.Nepolean, learned Advocate for the

respondents 1 and 2. This writ petition has been heard and reserved

at the admission stage itself.

3. This writ petition has been filed by the petitioners to

quash the notification dated 20.04.2022 thereby publishing the

tentative seniority list of Lecturers in Government Higher Secondary

School and to direct the respondents to fix the seniority of the

Lecturers in Government Higher Secondary School strictly in terms

of the relevant provision of seniority rules of Government of Manipur

and relevant rules and also settled principles of law.

4. Mr. H.S. Paonam, the learned senior counsel for the

petitioners submitted that the petitioners are the direct recruits

appointed in the year 2016 on the recommendation of the Manipur

Public Service Commission. He would submit that the petitioners

are aggrieved by the fixation of seniority among the direct recruits

and promotion on the basis of Recruitment Rules, 2021 and not in

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 54

accordance with Recruitment Rules, 1997 where under the

petitioners were appointed.

5. The learned senior counsel further submitted that the

petitioner are also aggrieved by the placement of the regularized

contract Lecturers above them since the direct recruits were

selected earlier than the regularization of the contract Lecturers.

Moreover, regularization is not a mode of appointment and the

regularization having been done de hors the rules, the employees

cannot be placed above the direct recruits appointed on the

recommendation of the MPSC.

6. The learned senior counsel urged that in the impugned

notification, it has been informed that any claims and objections to

the tentative seniority list may be submitted on or before 12.5.2022.

Aggrieved by the erroneous fixation of the seniority position of the

direct recruits of 2016, some of the petitioners have filed their

objections on 11.5.2022 claiming that the tentative seniority list is

erroneous since the same has been fixed on the basis of

Recruitment Rules of Lecturers of Government Higher Secondary

Schools published in 2021, wherein the method of recruitment is

50% by direct recruitment and 50% by promotion. Further, in the

said objection, it was also mentioned that the regularized contract

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 55

Lecturers of Government Higher Secondary Schools should be

placed enbloc below the direct recruits appointed on the

recommendation of the MPSC. However, till date the said objection

has not been considered by the competent authority. However, the

petitioners are reliably learnt that based on the impugned tentative

seniority list, process has been taken up for conferring the higher

charge of Vice-Principal of Higher Secondary School. Thus, the

learned senior counsel prayed for set aside the impugned tentative

seniority list.

7. Per contra, Mr. S. Nepolean, the learned Government

Advocate appearing for the official respondents submitted that there

is no error in publishing the impugned tentative seniority list and the

seniority list impugned has been prepared and published taking into

consideration all the relevant Recruitment Rules and, therefore,

there is no flaw in it. Apart from this, the official respodnents called

the claims and objections to the tentative seniority list may be

submitted on or before 12.05.2022 and accordingly, some of the

petitioners have filed their objections on 11.05.2022 and the same

is pending for consideration. If the petitioners are aggrieved on the

orders passed by the respondents on the objections dated

11.05.2022 the petitioners are very well to challenge the same in

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 56

accordance with law. Therefore, ths writ petition is premature.

Therefore, there is no ground to cause interference in the impugned

tentative seniority list. Thus, the learned Government Advocate

prayed for dismissal of the writ petition.

8. This Court considered the rival submissions and also

perused the materials on record.

9. The grievance of the petitioners is that in the tentative

seniority list, the seniority position of the petitioners has been fixed

on the basis of the Recruitment Rules of Lecturers of Government

Higher Secondary Schools published in 2021, wherein the method

of recruitment is 50% by direct recruitment and 50% by promotion

and promotees and direct recruits are placed one after another

according to the rotation of vacancies as prescribed in the

Recruitment Rules, 2021. Such fixation is erroneous because

seniority has to be fixed on the basis of the rules in existence when

one entered service and it cannot be fixed on the basis of

subsequently amended rules. Therefore, the seniority position of

the Lecturers of Government Higher Secondary Schools should be

fixed on the basis of 1997 Recruitment Rules, wherein 66 -2/3% is

provided for direct recruitment and 33 -1/3% is provided for

promotion. According to the petitioners, the placement of contract

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 57

Lecturers of the Government Higher Secondary Schools who were

regularized vide order dated 12.5.2016 is contrary to the rules and

also against the notification issued by the Government of Manipur

from time to time in regard to fixation of seniority.

10. The learned senior counsel for the petitioners urged

that the direct recruits who were appointed on the basis of the

recommendation of the Selection Committee after following due

process shall be placed enblock above those regularized back door

entrants who entered service without following the due selection

process.

11. As could be seen from the records that the petitioners

have applied to the post of Lecturers in the Government Higher

Secondary Schools pursuant to the advertisement dated 8.11.2014

issued by the MPSC and the written examination for selection

process was held on 22.2.2015 and the result of the same was

declared on 13.8.2015. The petitioners were found qualified for the

personality test for selection to the post of Lecturers and the

personality test was held between 13.9.2015 and 18.9.2015 and a

subject wise merit list was published on 18.9.2015.

12. According to the petitioners, even though the MPSC

had furnished a copy of the recommendation to the Government for

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 58

appointment to the post of Lecturers of Higher Secondary Schools

in School Education Department for taking necessary steps on

2.11.2015, the appointment order could not be issued in favour of

the selected candidates because of the interim orders of this Court

operating at the relevant time. Subsequently, those interim orders

stand vacated thereby granting liberty to the respondent authorities

to proceed with the recruitment process as far as the appointment

under direct recruitment to the post of Lecturers in Higher

Secondary Schools as per the recommendation of the MPSC is

concerned. Pursuant thereof, the State Government was pleased

to appoint 180 recommended candidates as Lecturers of

Government Higher Secondary Schools on 31.8.2016, including the

petitioners. Thereafter, by another order dated 18.11.2016, nine

candidates were given appointment from waiting list. Therefore, the

learned senior counsel for the petitioners contended that the

petitioners are seniors to the private respondents and accordingly,

they could be placed above the contract Lecturers.

13. There is no dispute that the appointment to the post of

Lecturer of Higher Secondary Schools is governed by a recruitment

called the Education (S) Department Manipur (Lecturer of Higher

Secondary Schools) Recruitment Rules, 1997. Under the said

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 59

rules, as stated supra, the method of recruitment is 63 - 2/3% is by

direct recruitment and 33 - 1/3% by promotion. The post of Lecturer

of Higher Secondary Schools is classified as Class-I Gazetted by

the said Recruitment Rules.

14. The Government of Manipur decided to regularize the

services of 707 contract Lecturers in Government Higher

Secondary Schools with immediate effect vide order dated

12.5.2016 and, accordingly, the services of the contract Lecturers

have been regularized on 12.05.2016. Since the regularization of

the contract Lecturers is prior to the appointment of the direct

recruits, how the direct recruits can be placed above the contract

Lecturers as sought for by them. Anyhow, the said aspect of the

matter cannot be gone into in this writ petition.

15. Nothing has been placed on record to show that the

private respondents are back door entrants and are entered into

service without following the due selection process. That apart, the

said factual aspects of the matter cannot be decided in the writ

petition and nothing has been produced and/or established to show

that the impugned notification is erroneous.

16. Further, the case of the petitioners is that the private

respondents are surplus contract employees and in order to give a

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 60

solution to human problems, they are regularized in their respective

services. Since regularization is not a recognized mode of

recruitment under the Recruitment Rules, those regularized

contract Lecturers from a different category and they ought to be

placed below the direct recruits of the same recruitment year cannot

be gone into, for the reason that whether the regularization of the

private respondents is legal or illegal is not the subject-matter of an

issue in this writ petition. If the petitioners are so aggrieved by the

regularization of the contract Lecturers of the Government Higher

Secondary Schools, they will have to question the same at the

relevant point of time and the same cannot be questioned in the

present writ petition.

17. At this juncture, the learned Government Advocate

submitted that the determination of seniority of the employees

working in the Government is regulated by the Office Memorandum

of the Government of Manipur and after following the rules and the

applicable Office Memorandum only, the impugned tentative

seniority list has been prepared.

18. Though the petitioners, by relying upon various Office

Memorandums of the Manipur submitted that the determination of

inter-se seniority amongst the direct recruits and the promotee and

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 61

the regularized contract Lecturers ought to be placed below the

direct recruits appointed on the recommendation of the MPSC, the

said aspects of two issues cannot be gone into in the present writ

petition.

19. It appears that pursuant to the impugned tentative

seniority list, the petitioners 2 and 17 alone have submitted their

objections. Nothing has been produced by the petitioners to show

that the other petitioners have also submitted their objection to the

impugned tentative seniority list. If an employee is so aggrieved by

the tentative seniority list published by the department, it is the

bounden duty of the employee to submit his/her objection within the

time given in the notification publishing the tentative seniority list.

By using and relying upon the said representations of the petitioners

2 and 17, the petitioners numbering 95 have filed the present writ

petition questioning the impugned tentative seniority list.

20. The impugned tentative seniority list was published on

20.04.2022, thereby the Deputy Secretary (Education-S),

Government of Manipur calling for claims and objections to the

tentative seniority list of Lecturers by prescribing the time limit on or

before 12.5.2022 with a condition that the claims and objections

received after the last date shall not be entertained.The petitioners

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 62

2 and 17 have submitted their objections/claims to the impugned

seniority list on 11.05.2022 and the writ petition was filed on

16.6.2022 without giving a reasonable time to the department to

consider the objections/claims made by them. Thus, the writ

petition appears to be premature. In the case on hand, the receipt

of the objections/claims of the petitioners 2 and 17 dated 11.5.2022

has not been disputed by the official respondents.

21. Since the petitioners have raised an issue that the

contract Lecturers of the Government Higher Secondary Schools

should be placed enbloc below the direct recruits appointed on the

recommendation of the MPSC, this Court is of the view that in order

to give quietus to the matter, it would be appropriate to direct the

official respondents to treat the objections/claims submitted by the

petitioners 2 and 17 as common to all the petitioners and,

accordingly, pass an order in accordance with law taking note of the

same as common grievance of the petitioners.

22. Accordingly,

a) the writ petition is dismissed as premature.

b) respondents No. 1 and 2 are directed to consider

the claims/objections dated 11.5.2022 submitted

by the petitioners 2 to 17 to the impugned tentative

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022 P a g e | 63

seniority list and pass orders in accordance with

law taking note of the same as common grievance

of the petitioners to give quietus to the issue.

c) the petitioners are at liberty to challenge if they

aggrieved the order to be passed by the

respondents No.1 and 2 based on the

claims/objections dated 11.05.2022.

d) No cost.

JUDGE

FR/NFR

Sushil

W.P.(C) No. 451 of 2022