Madras High Court
Government Of Tamil Nadu vs Unknown on 18 July, 2023
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Dated: 18.07.2023
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R.SURESH KUMAR
AND
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE K.KUMARESH BABU
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
and M.P.Nos.1 of 2012 [ in all W.As.]
and M.P.Nos.2 of 2012 [in 2754, 2755 and 2756 of 2012]
1. Government of Tamil Nadu,
Rep. By the Principal Secretary to Government,
Higher Education (F2) Department,
Secretariat, Chennai – 600 009.
2. Director of Collegiate Education,
Directorate of Collegiate Education,
DPI Compound,
College Road, Chennai – 600 006. ... Appellants in all W.As.
Vs
Respondents in W.A.No.2753 of 2012
1. K.Malathi
Associate Professor Department of Economics
Arignar Anna Government College For Women
Walajapet.
2. Dr.V.Kanthimathi
Associate Professor In Botory Quaid-e-
millath Government College (w) Chennai-2.
3. A.R.Rajamani
Associate Professor Of Commerce Thirumagal
Government Arts College Gudiyatham.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.1/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
4. Dr.R.Vedavalli
Associate Professor Department Of English
Presidency College Chennai-5.
5. Dr.P.R.Umarani
Associate Professor Department Of Physics
Presidency College Chennai-5.
6. Dr.Amutha Pandian
Associate Professor Department Of English
Presidency College Chennai-5.
7. R.Sarumathi
Associate Professor Department Of Chemistry
Queen Marrys College Chennai-4.
8. Dr.(Mrs). P.Kulamolial
Associate Professor Department Of English
Queen Marrys College Chennai-4.
9. R.Geetha Rani
Associate Professor Department Of English
Quaid-millat Govt. College (w) Chennai-2.
10. Mrs.Savithri Sundar
Associate Professor Department Of English
Queen Marrys College Chennai-4.
11. P.Asaithambi
Associate Professor Department Of English
Presidency College Chennai-5.
12. V.Thangamani
Associate Professor Of Zoology Govt. Arts
College Chidambaram.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.2/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
13. M.ravichandran
Associate Professor Of English Dr.ambedkar
Govt. Arts College Vysarpadi Chennai-39.
14. K.Manoharan
Associate Professor Of Physics Periyar Arts
College Cuddalore.
15. S.Gnanasekaran
Associate Professor Of Maths Periyar Arts
College Cuddalore.
16. R.Jayanthidevi
Associate Professor Of Zoology Periyar Arts
College Cuddalore.
17. K.R.Ravindran
Associate Professor Of Geology Govt.
Arts College Salem-636 007.
18. G.Jagadeesan
Associate Professor Of Geography Govt.
Arts College Salem-636 007.
19. V.Manivannan
Associate Professor Of Geology Govt. Of
Arts College Salem-636 007.
20. C.S.Suriya Narayanan
Associate Professor Of Botony Govt. Arts
College Salem-636 007.
21. M.Jayanthi Violet
Associate Professor Of Chemistry Govt.
Arts College For Women Salem-636 008.
22. R.Dhanalakshmi
Associate Professor Of Maths Govt. Arts
College For Women Salem-636 008.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.3/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
23. S.Manimozhi
Associate Professor Of Chemistry Govt.
Arts College For Women Salem-636 008.
24. N.Kannan
Associate Professor Of Economics Periyar
Arts College Cuddalore.
25. S.Kemasari
S.G. Lecturer In Physics Bharathi Womens
College Chennai.
26. Mangaikuruparan
SG Lecturer In Home Science Govt Arts
College For Women Madurai
27. V.Asha
Sg.Lecturer In Physcs Govt. College (men)
Nandanam Chennai-35.
28. P.Vijayalakshmi
SG Lecturer In English Presidence College
Chennai-5.
29. K.Snethal
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry Shre
Meenakshi Govt College For Women Madurai
30. Rubala Juliet
Selection Grade Lecturer In Physics Mvm
Govt Arts College For Women Dindigul
31. E.Fulten Jose Newman
Selection Grade In Botany
Botony Presidency College Chennai 5
32. S.Rajarajan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Microbiology
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.4/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
Presidency Collelge Chennai
33. V.Balakrishnan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry Dr.
Ambedkar Govt Arts College Vysarpadi
Chennai
34. G.Rajeswari
Selection Grade Lecturer In Physics Govt
Arts College Women Madurai 2
35. K.R.Sekar
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Arignar Anna Govt College Attur
36. M.B.Chandrasekaran
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry Govt
Arts Collge Vysarpadi Chennai 39
37. C.Ramakrishnan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry Rajah
Serfoji Govt Arts Collge Thanjavur
38. L.Mariappan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Aringar Anna Govt College Attur
39. A.N.S.vasudevan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Thiruvalluvar Govt Arts College Rasipuram
40. S.Kalimuthu
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry Govt
Arts College Mettur.
41. R.Raju
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry Govt
Arts College Salem 7
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.5/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
42. P.Sathyamoorthi
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry Govt
Arts College Vysarpadi Chennai 39
43. M.Ramachandran
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Alagappa Govt Arts Collge Karaikudi
44. Swarna Sethuraman
Selection Grade Lecturer In Physics Queen
Marys Collge Chennai
45. P.S.Raguraman
Selection Grade Lecturer In Sanskrit
Presidency College Chennai 5
46. V.Vasanthakumari
Selection Grade Lecturer In Bio Chemistry
Govt Arts College Sivagangai.
47. A.K.Chandra
Selection Grade Lecturer In Sanskrit
Presidency College Chennai 5
48. Chandra Venkatasubramanian
Selection Grade Lecturer In Home Science
Queen Marys College Chennai 4
49. R.Duraisamy
Selection Grade Lecturer In Botony
Thiruviga Govt Arts College Thiruvarur
50. J.S.Manickarajan
Selection Grade Lecturer In English Govt
Arts College(men) Kumbakonam
51. A.S.M.Malinisamy
Selection Grade Lecturer In English Queen
Marys College Chennai 4
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.6/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
52. R.Alagarsamy
Associate Professor In Commerce Alagappa
Govt Arts College Karaikudi
53. M.Radhakrishnan
Associate Professor In Commerce Alagappa
Govt Arts College Karaikudi
54. V.Balasubramanian
Associate Professor In Commerce Alagappa
Govt Arts College Karaikudi
55. S.P.Sathiavageesan
Associate Professor In Geology Alagappa
Govt Arts College Karaikudi
56. A.Anwarbasha
Associate Professor In History Alagappa
Govt Arts College Karaikudi
57. S.M.Sundram
Associate Professor In Commerce Alagappa
Govt Arts College Karaikudi.
58. K.Subramanian,
Associate Professor in Maths,
Alagappa Govt Arts College, Karaikudi.
59. J.Roopkumar
Associate Professor in Physics,
Alagappa Govt Arts College, Karaikudi.
60. P.Chellappa,
Associate Professor in Physics,
Alagappa Govt. Arts College, Karaikudi.
61. M.Jeyaraj,
Associate Professor in Physics,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.7/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
Alagappa Government Arts College,
Karaikudi.
62. P.Perumal,
Associate Professor in Physics,
Alagappa Government Arts College, Karaikudi.
63. M.Ramasamy,
Associate Professor in Physics,
Alagappa Government Arts College, Karaikudi.
64. Tmt.Dr.R.Vijaya
Aringar Anna Government
Arts College (Women)
Walajapettai. ... Respondents/ in W.A.No.2753/2012
Respondents in W.A.No.2754 of 2012
1. K.Rathinam
W/o.P.Kandasamy,
No.H.25, TNHB Quarters,
Ponvila Nagar, Trichy Road,
Nammakkal.
2. K.M.Prabhu
Lecturer In English Govt. Arts College For
Men Chennai-35.
3. K.M.Kandhi
Lecturer In English Queen Marys College
Chennai-4.
4. S.Kemasari
SG Lecturer In Physics Bharathi Womens
College Chennai.
5. A.Alagarsamy,
Associate Professor in Commerce,
Alagappa Government Arts College,
Karaikudi.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.8/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
6. Mangaikurubaran
SG Lecturer In Home Science Shri Meenakshi
Govt. Of Arts College For Women Madurai.
7.V.Asha
SG Lecturer In Physcs Govt. College (men)
Nandanam Chennai-35.
8. P.Vijayalakshmi
SGLecturer In English Presidence College
Chennai-5.
9. K.Snethal
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry Shri
Meenakshi Govt. College For Women Madurai.
10. Rubala Juliet
Selection Grade Lecturer In Physics Mvm
Govt. Arts College For Women Dindigul.
11. E.Fulten Jose Newman
Selection Grade Lecturer In Botony
Presidency College Chennai-5.
12. S.Rajarajan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Microbiology
Presidency College Chennai-5.
13. V.Balakrishnan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry Dr.
Ambedkar Govt. Arts College Vysarpadi
Chennai.
14. G.Rajeswari
Selection Grade Lecturer In Physics Govt.
Arts College Women Madurai-2.
15. K.R.Sekar
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.9/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
Arignar Anna Govt. College Attur.
16. M.B.Chandrasekaran
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Government Arts College Vysarpadi Chennai-39.
17. C.Ramakrishnan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry Rajah
Serfoji Govt. Arts College Thanjavur.
18. L.Mariappan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Arignar Anna Government College Attur.
19. A.N.S.Vasudevan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Thiruvalluvar Govt. Arts College Rasipuram.
20. S.Kalimuthu
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Government Arts College Mettur.
21. R.Raju
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Government Arts College Salem 7.
22. P.Sathyamoorthi
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Government Arts College Vyasarpadi Chennai-39.
23. M.Ramachandran
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Alagappan Government Arts College Karaikudi.
24. Swarna Sethuraman
Selection Grade Lecturer In Physics Queen
Marrys College Chennai.
25. P.S.Raguraman
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.10/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
Selection Grade Lecturer In Sanskrit
Presidency College Chennai 5.
26. V.Vasanthakumari
Selection Grade Lecturer In Bio- chemistry
Government Arts College Sivagangai.
27. A.K.Chandra
Selection Grade Lecturer In Sanskrit
Presidency College Chennai 5.
28. Chandra Venkatasubramanian
Selection Grade Lecturer In Home Science
Queen Marrys College Chennai 4.
29. R.Durisamy
Selection Grade Lecturer In Botany
Thiruviga Govt. Arts College Thiruvarur.
30. J.S.Manickarajan
Selection Grade Lecturer In English Govt.
Arts College(men) Kumbakkonam.
31. A.S.M.Malinisamy
Selection Grade Lecturer In English Queen
Marys College Chennai-4.
32. M.Radhakrishnan
Associate Professor In Commerce Alagappa
Govt. Arts College Karaikudi.
33. V.Balasubramanian
Associate Professor In Commerce Alagappa
Govt. Arts College Karaikudi
34. S.P.Sathiavageesan
Associate Professor In Geology Alagappa
Govt. Arts College Karaikudi
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.11/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
35. A.Anwarbasha
Associate Professor In History Alagappa
Govt. Arts College Karaikudi
36. S.M.Sundaram
Associate Professor In Commerce Alagappa
Govt. Arts College Karaikudi.
37. K.Subramanian
Associate Professor in Maths,
Alagappa Government Arts College, Karaikudi.
38. J.Roopkumar,
Associate Professor in Physics,
Alagappa Government Arts College, Karaikudi.
39. P.Chellappa,
Associate Professor in Maths,
Alagappa Government Arts College, Karaikudi.
40. M.Jeyaraj,
Associate Professor in Physics,
Alagappa Government Arts College, Karaikudi.
41. P.Perumal,
Associate Professor in Physics,
Alagappa Government Arts College, Karaikudi.
42. M.Ramasamy
Associate Professor in Physics,
Alagappa Government Arts College,
Karaikudi. ... Respondents in W.A.2754/2012
W.A.No.2755 of 2012
1.S.Tamilmani,
General Secretary,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.12/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
The Tamil Nadu Government,
Collegiate Teacher's Association,
Narasingam Nilayam,
No.2, Sydoji Street,
Triplicane, Chennai – 600 005.
2. V.Prabakaran,
Associate Professor of Zoology,
Dr.Ambedkar Government Arts College,
Vyasarpadi, Chennai – 600 039.
3. Joseph Durai,
Associate Professor of Economics,
Presidency College,
Chennai – 600 005.
4. S.Kemasri,
S.G.Lecturer in Physics,
Bharathi Women's College, Chennai.
5. Mangaikuruparan,
SG Lecturer in Home Science,
Government Arts College for Women,
Madurai.
6. V.Asha,
SG Lecturer in Physics,
Government College (Men).
Nandanam, Chennai – 600 035.
7. P.Vijayalakshmi,
SG Lecturer in English,
Presidency College,
Chennai – 600 005.
8. K.Senthal,
Selection Grade Lecturer in Chemistry,
Shri Meenakshi Government College for Women,
Madurai. .. Respondents in W.A.No.2755/2012
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.13/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
W.A.No.2756 of 2012
1. K.M.Prabhu,
Principal,
Chikanna Government Arts College, Tirupur.
2.A.M.Lingammal
S.G.Lecturer in Physics,
Ramalingam Government Arts College for Women,
Namakkal.
3. S.Kemasri,
S.G.Lecturer in Physics,
Bharathi Women's College, Chennai.
4. Mangaikuruparan,
SG Lecturer in Home Science,
Government Arts College for Women,
Madurai.
5. V.Asha,
SG Lecturer in Physics,
Government College (Men).
Nandanam, Chennai – 600 035.
6. P.Vijayalakshmi,
SG Lecturer in English,
Presidency College,
Chennai – 600 005.
7. K.Senthal,
Selection Grade Lecturer in Chemistry,
Shri Meenakshi Government College for Women,
Madurai.
8. Rubala Juliet
Selection Grade Lecturer In Physics Mvm
Govt. Arts College For Women Dindigul.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.14/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
9. E.Fulten Jose Newman
Selection Grade Lecturer In Botony
Presidency College Chennai-5.
10. S.Rajarajan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Microbiology
Presidency College Chennai-5.
11. V.Balakrishnan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry Dr.
Ambedkar Govt. Arts College Vysarpadi
Chennai.
12. G.Rajeswari
Selection Grade Lecturer In Physics Govt.
Arts College Women Madurai-2.
13. K.R.Sekar
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Arignar Anna Govt. College Attur.
14. M.B.Chandrasekaran
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Government Arts College Vysarpadi Chennai-39.
15. C.Ramakrishnan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry Rajah
Serfoji Govt. Arts College Thanjavur.
16. L.Mariappan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Arignar Anna Government College Attur.
17. A.N.S.Vasudevan
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Thiruvalluvar Govt. Arts College Rasipuram.
18. S.Kalimuthu
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.15/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
Government Arts College Mettur.
19. R.Raju
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Government Arts College Salem 7.
20. P.Sathyamoorthi
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Government Arts College Vyasarpadi Chennai-39.
21. M.Ramachandran
Selection Grade Lecturer In Chemistry
Alagappan Government Arts College,
Karaikudi. ... Respondents in W.A.No.2756/2012
COMMON PRAYER: Writ Appeals filed under Clause 15 of Letters
Patent to set aside the order dated 25.01.2012 passed in W.P.Nos.14485,
15159, 15364 and 19800 of 2011 and allow these writ appeal.
For Appellants : Mr.K.V.Sajeev Kumar
[ in all W.As.] Special Govt. Pleader
JUDGMENT
(Judgement of the Court was made by Mr.R.SURESH KUMAR.,J.)
The issue raised in these writ appeals have already been raised in
connected writ appeals in W.A.Nos.1108 and 1109 of 2012, which also
arose out of the common impugned order passed by the Writ Court dated
25.01.2012 and the same since has been decided by our order dated
17.07.2023, we feel that nothing could be persuaded further in these
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.16/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
appeals as the writ appeals filed by the concerned Teachers were
dismissed as withdrawn and connected writ appeals were dismissed by
our order dated 17.07.2023.Therefore, following the same these writ
appeals are also disposed of to the terms indicated in the aforesaid
judgment in W.A.Nos.1108 and 1109 of 2012 and accordingly disposed
of. No costs. Connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.
(R.S.K.,J.) (K.B., J.)
18.07.2023
Index: Yes/No
Speaking Order/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation:Yes/No
mp
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.17/18
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
R.SURESH KUMAR., J.
and
K.KUMARESH BABU.,J.
mp
Writ Appeal Nos.2753 to 2756 of 2012
18.07.2023
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
Page No.18/18
