Rajasthan High Court - Jodhpur

Meena Kumari Pareta vs The State Of Rajasthan ... on 2 May, 2025

Author: Vinit Kumar Mathur

Bench: Vinit Kumar Mathur

[2025:RJ-JD:20991]

      HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT
                       JODHPUR
                 S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 3335/2025

1.       Meena Kumari Pareta D/o Hemraj Pareta, W/o Namichand
         Parth, Aged About 40 Years, R/o 01 Golana, Tehsil
         Khanpur, Dist. Jhalawar, Raj. At Present Posting Sub
         Center Baisar, Block Khanpur, Dist. Jhalawar.
2.       Ganga Bariya D/o Deepa Vadakhiya, W/o Ramesh Bariya,
         Aged About 44 Years, R/o Village And Post Kalinjara,
         Tehsil Kushalgarh, Dist. Banswara, Raj. At Present Posting
         Phc Ramgarh, Chc Kushalgarh, Dist. Banswara.
3.       Chanda Jain D/o Dharamchand Somia, W/o Pramod
         Kumar Jain, Aged About 44 Years, R/o Village Badrana,
         Post Gogala, Tehsil Jhadol (Ph), Dist. Udaipur, Raj. At
         Present Posting Phc Mohammad Phalasiya, Block Jhadol
         (Ph), Dist. Udaipur.
4.       Sushma Rani Yadav D/o Kherati Lal Yadav, W/o Mahaveer
         Singh, Aged About 50 Years, R/o Village Rampur, Tehsil
         Kotkasim, Dist. Alwar, Raj. At Present Posting Phc
         Gopinath Ka Gadda, Chc Partapur, Dist. Banswara.
5.       Kesari Chauhan D/o Bheru Lal Chauhan, W/o Dinesh
         Chandra Parmar, Aged About 43 Years, R/o Vpo Jhikali,
         Dist. Banswara, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter
         Khajura Subdistrict Hospital Kushalgahr, Dist. Banswara.
6.       Sushila Lunia D/o Satyanarayan Lunia, W/o Shriram
         Prajapati, Aged About 43 Years, R/o Shriyadi Mohalla
         Morajhari, Dist. Ajmer, Raj. At Present Posting S/c
         Chachundra Chc Bandanwara, Block Bhinaya, Dist. Ajmer.
7.       Kamlesh Kumari D/o Leelu Ram, W/o Bhup Singh, Aged
         About 49 Years, R/o Ward No. 8 Village Utradabas, Tehsil
         Bhadra, Dist. Hanumangarh, Raj. At Present Posting Sdh
         Bhadra, Block Bhadra, Dist. Hanumangarh.
8.       Nirmala Meghwal W/o Praveen Kumar Meghwal, Aged
         About 44 Years, R/o Village Gurad, Post Manpur, Tehsil
         Jhadol (F), Dist. Udaipur, Raj. At Present Posting S/c
         Maruwas, Block Badgaon, Dist. Udaipur.
9.       Mukesh Mehra D/o Gopal Lal Mehra, Aged About 52
         Years, R/o Hero Honda Service Center Kethuni Pol, Dist.
         Kota, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Aarampura, Block
         Ladpura, Dist. Kota.
10.      Rekha Choudhary W/o Krishna Kumar Jurel, Aged About
         53 Years, R/o 13A, Nadi Ka Fatak Benad Road Chodhri
         Bhawan Madhav Nagar, Jotwara, Dist. Jaipur, Raj. At
         Present Posting Subcenter Kohali Prempura Phc Litali


                     (Downloaded on 05/05/2025 at 09:31:43 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:20991]                  (2 of 15)                    [CW-3335/2025]


         Bamanwas, Dist. Sawaimadhopur.
11.      Vimla Vyas D/o Ramchandraji W/o Vishnu Kumar Vyas,
         Aged About 49 Years, R/o Village B.k. Sareri, Tehsil Asind,
         Dist. Bhilwara, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter
         Udaliyas, Phc B.k. Sareri, Dist. Bhilwara.
12.      Rekha D/o Dharmendra Damor, W/o Mukesh Roat, Aged
         About 42 Years, R/o Village Navaghara, Tehsil Dovra, Dist.
         Dungarpur, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Kankradara,
         Chc Maghol, Block And Dist. Dungarpur.
13.      Surekha Pareek D/o Bhagwan Lal Pareek, W/o
         Satyanarayan Pareek, Aged About 46 Years, R/o 5F56
         New Houseing Board Tilak Nagar, Dist. Bhilwara, Raj. At
         Present Posting Subcenter Chavandiya Phc Sawaipur, Dist.
         Bhilwara.
14.      Rakesh D/o Ram Singh, W/o Ram Kumar, Aged About 34
         Years, R/o Berwas, Post Bhokar, Tehsil Kotkasim, Dist.
         Alwar, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Rohinwara
         Sayala, Dist. Jalore.
15.      Sugna Rao D/o Mangi Lal Rao, W/o Anil Kumar Rao, Aged
         About 42 Years, R/o Piplas Ka Rasta Aloli Kadera, Dist.
         Ajmer, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Chitiwas, Block
         Sawar, Dist. Ajmer.
16.      Geeta Asawara D/o Chandra Prakash Asawara, W/o Braj
         Bihari, Aged About 46 Years, R/o 28 Anandvihar Road No.
         2 Tekri Girwa, Dist. Udaipur, Raj. At Present Posting Uphc
         Bhopalpura, Block Urban Cmho Udaipur.
17.      Kesar Meghwal W/o Rajmal Meghwal, Aged About 45
         Years, R/o Village Amarpur, Tehsil Bhinder, Dist. Udaipur,
         Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Kapdio Ka Khera Chc
         Kheroda, Block Bhinder Dist. Udaipur.
18.      Kaushlya Patidar W/o Jagdish Chandra Patidar, Aged
         About 43 Years, R/o Vpo Jolana, Tehsil Arthuna, Dist.
         Banswara, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Tejpur, Phc
         Ghalkiya, Block Talwara, Dist. Banswara.
19.      Seema Devi Jain W/o Kamlesh Kumar, Aged About 52
         Years, R/o F-166 Azad Nagar Behind Gautam Ashram,
         Dist. Bhilwara, Raj. At Present Posting Chc Bagor Block
         Mandal, Dist. Bhilwara.
20.      Kanku Nayak W/o Prakash Kumar Labana, Aged About 48
         Years, R/o Vpo Bichhiwara, Dist. Dungarpur, Raj. At
         Present Posting Phc Chundawara, Block Bichhiwara, Dist.
         Dungarpur.
21.      Indira Patel W/o Chandrasekhar, Aged About 44 Years, R/

                     (Downloaded on 05/05/2025 at 09:31:43 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:20991]                  (3 of 15)                    [CW-3335/2025]


         o 4/18 Mahisarovar New Housing Board, Dist. Banswara,
         Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Motagaon Block Ghatol,
         Dist. Banswara.
22.      Pep Kunwar D/o Ram Singh, W/o Dilip Singh, Aged About
         55 Years, R/o Kastam Choraha Nagar Dharamshala Ke
         Piche Dist Banswara, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter
         Magarda Phc Tambesara, Block Sajjangarh, Dist.
         Banswara.
23.      Rajkumari Ojha D/o Rameshwar Lal Ojha, Aged About 44
         Years, R/o Motinagar Asind, Dist. Bhilwara, Raj. At
         Present Posting Hwc Dhariya, Block Rani, Dist. Pali.
24.      Sanjida Bano Sheikh W/o Amin Hussain Sheikh, Aged
         About 43 Years, R/o Vpo Bagor, Tehsil Mandal, Dist.
         Bhilwara, Raj. At Present Posting Hwc Adsipura, Block
         Sarada, Dist. Bhilwara.
25.      Praveena Vaishnav W/o Dev Prakash Vaishnav, Aged
         About 51 Years, R/o Mandir Chowk Patelwara, Serari Badi,
         Dist Banswara, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Rohniya
         Khera, Phc Khodan, Block Partapur, Dist. Banswara.
26.      Rekha Khatik W/o Rajesh Kumar Khatik, Aged About 45
         Years, R/o Khemli Station, Tehsil Mavli, Dist. Udaipur, Raj.
         At Present Posting Uphc Police Line Udaipur.
27.      Urmila Devi D/o Babu Lal W/o Suvran Singh, Aged About
         55 Years, R/o Vpo Khatoti, Tehsi Naibai, Dist. Bharatpur,
         Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Jelatera, Phc Khara,
         Dist. Jalore.
28.      Pushpa Kunwar Deora W/o Heera Singh Deora, Aged
         About 44 Years, R/o Genavatiya Basti Lai Ka Guda Badi,
         Dist. Udaipur, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Barda
         Phc Dhar, Block Badgaon, Dist. Udaipur.
29.      Kalavati Patidar D/o Sukhlal Patidar, W/o Mukesh Chandra
         Patidar, Aged About 44 Years, R/o Vpo Raiyana Tehsil
         Arthuna, Dist. Banswara, Raj. At Present Posting Phc
         Odwara, Block Arthuna, Dist. Banswara.
30.      Vandana Kumari D/o Guljari Lal, W/o Ashok Kumar Nana,
         Aged About 43 Years, R/o Nimach Mata Scheme Dewali
         (Rural) Shastri Circle, Dist. Udaipur, Raj. At Present
         Posting Phc Fathepura, Udaipur.
31.      Anita Yadav D/o Baldav Yadav, W/o Suresh Chandra
         Yadav, Aged About 42 Years, R/o Tahla Suhana, Dist.
         Kota, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Bhojariya, Dist.
         Barmer.
32.      Aketa Desai D/o Govind Lal Desai, W/o Vishang Kumar,

                     (Downloaded on 05/05/2025 at 09:31:43 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:20991]                  (4 of 15)                    [CW-3335/2025]


         Aged About 45 Years, R/o Vpo Simalwara, Dist.
         Dungarpur, Raj. At Present Posting S/c Jhalai Chc/phc
         Simalwara, Dist. Dungarpur.
33.      Sushila Rathor D/o Lalchand Rathor, W/o Mahaveer
         Rathor, Aged About 54 Years, R/o Akhade Ki Gali
         Jhalarapatan Dist. Jhalawar, Raj. At Present Posting Sub
         Center Jheekdia Chc Ratlai, Dist. Jhalawar.
34.      Prem Meghwal D/o Manna Ram Meghwal, W/o Suresh
         Kumar Meghwal, Aged About 40 Years, R/o Vpo Magawas
         Damana, Tehsil Jhadol, Dist. Udaipur, Raj. At Present
         Posting Subcenter Chandwas Phc-Chc Jhadol, Dist.
         Udaipur.
35.      Surekha Goud (Trivedi) D/o Karu Lal Trivedi, W/o Naresh
         Gaur, Aged About 43 Years, R/o Vpo Navalshyam, Tehsil
         Bichhiwara, Dist. Dungarpur, Raj. At Present Posting
         Subcenter Karauli Phc Sabali, Block Bichhiwara, Dist.
         Dungarpur.
36.      Khangar Chanda Ben D/o Kastur Chand, W/o Mohan
         Singh, Aged About 54 Years, R/o Vpo Kaima, Tehsil
         Nadauti, Dist. Karuli, Raj. At Present Posting Chc Kemri,
         Block Gudachanderji, Dist. Karuli.
37.      Chandrakanta Joshi D/o Karu Lal Trivedi, W/o Krishan
         Chandra Joshi, Aged About 45 Years, R/o 4-M-15
         Shivajinagar Sahid Park Housing Board Dungarpur, Raj. At
         Present Posting Subcenter Naya Talab Chc Gamdi Ahara
         Bchmo Bichhiwara Dist. Dungarpur.
38.      Daksha Joshi D/o Heera Lal Joshi, W/o Bhagya Ram Joshi,
         Aged About 52 Years, R/o Vpo Punali, Tehsil Dovda, Dist.
         Dungarpur.    Raj.   At   Present    Posting   Subcenter
         Gadaeklingji Phc Baroda, Block Aspur, Dist. Dungarpur.
39.      Chandrakanta Sharma W/o Ghanshyam Upadhaya, D/o
         Shankar Lal Sharma, Aged About 51 Years, R/o Near R2R
         Saloon Malola Road Gyatri Nagar, Bhilwara, Raj. At
         Present Posting Chc Asind, Block Asind, Dist. Bhilwara.
40.      Manisha Patidar D/o Kedar Lal Patidar, Aged About 41
         Years, R/o Vpo Seredi Badi, Tehsil Gadi, Dist. Banswara,
         Raj. At Present Posting Chc Seredi Badi, Block Partapur,
         Dist. Banswara.
41.      Neeta Kumari Trivedi D/o Karu Lal Trivedi, W/o Hemant
         Trivedi, Aged About 47 Years, R/o 284 Shiv Colony Jadav
         Nursery Ke Pass Hiranmangri Sector-6 Dist. Udaipur, Raj.
         At Present Posting Subcenter Bhimal, Block Mavali, Dist.
         Udaipur.


                     (Downloaded on 05/05/2025 at 09:31:43 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:20991]                  (5 of 15)                    [CW-3335/2025]


42.      Kanchan Khatik W/o Radheshyam Khatik, Aged About 43
         Years, R/o Gulabpura (Rural), Dist. Bhilwara, Raj. At
         Present Posting Subcenter Mainapadar, Block Anandpuri,
         Dist. Banswara.
43.      Sumitra Teli W/o Shaitan Teli, Aged About 40 Years, R/o
         Dev Ka Thana, Bundi, Raj. At Present Posting Phc Kalibhit,
         Subcenter Bherav, Dist. Udaipur.
44.      Bimla Devi D/o Harchand, W/o Raj Kumar, Aged About 49
         Years, R/o Sihag Bislan, Beeslan, Churu, Raj, At Present
         Posting Bhojan, Block Rajgarh, Dist. Churu.
45.      Sunita W/o Ram Bhagat, Aged About 41 Years, R/o
         Narnoliya Likhva, Dist. Jhunjhunun, Raj. At Present
         Posting Subcenter Bhagwatpura, Sdh Kushalgarh, Dist.
         Banswara.
46.      Bimala Kumari D/o Amar Singh, W/o Randheer Singh,
         Aged About 38 Years, R/o Village Bairasar Bara, Jaitpura,
         Tehsil Rajgarh, Dist. Churu, Raj. At Present Posting
         Subcenter Bhundwa, Phc Mengalwa, Block Sayla, Dist.
         Jhalor.
47.      Priti Bhatt W/o Mukesh Pandya, Aged About 48 Years, R/o
         Ward No. 2 Campa Colony Dhambola, Dist. Dungarpur,
         Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Sujanlai, Dist.
         Dungarpur.
48.      Sangita Patidar W/o Dayalal Patidar, Aged About 44 Years,
         R/o Vpo Seethal, Tehsil Simalwara, Dist. Dungarpur, Raj.
         At Present Posting Subcenter Seethal Chc Phc Simalwara,
         Dist. Dungarpur.
49.      Kavita Jadon D/o Kishan Singh Jadon, Aged About 47
         Years, R/o Kota, Kota, Raj. At Present Posting Urban
         Primary Center Govindnagar, Kota.
50.      Devanti Nama D/o Prabhu Lal Nama, W/o Chandra
         Prakash Nama, Aged About 52 Years, R/o 299 Mahaveer
         Nagar Iiphase Kota, Dist. Kota Raj. At Present Posting
         Bamooliya Jogiyan, Block Anta, Dist. Baran.
51.      Preeti Sharma D/o Shri Narayan Sharma, W/o Pradeep
         Sharma, Aged About 40 Years, R/o Sanatan Dharam
         Mandir Vallabhbari Gumanpura Kota Dist. Kota Raj. At
         Present Posting Anm Subcenter Khurai, Block Chabra,
         Dist. Baran.
52.      Usha Jangid D/o Ramniwas, W/o Sharvan Kumar, Aged
         About 44 Years, R/o Village Birodibadi Choti, Post Birodi,
         Tehsil Laxmangarh, Dist. Sikar Raj. At Present Posting
         Anm Subcenter Amatara, Block Bamanwas, Dist.


                     (Downloaded on 05/05/2025 at 09:31:43 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:20991]                  (6 of 15)                    [CW-3335/2025]


         Sawaimadhopur.
53.      Rashmi Chouhan D/o Rajendra Singh, W/o Abhay Singh,
         Aged About 39 Years, R/o 2-F-9 Mahaveer Nagar Vistar
         Yojna Kota, Dist. Kota, Raj. At Present Posting Uphc
         Anantpura Dist. Kota.
54.      Devyani Pandya D/o Prem Shankar Pandya, Aged About
         47 Years, R/o Yash Lok Villa Sevak Samaaj Nohre Ke
         Piche Near Sabji Mandi Mathugamda Road Near Iti
         College Rnt Colony, Dungarpur, Dist. Dungarpur, Raj. At
         Present Posting S/c Bori, Dungarpur.
55.      Rinku Rathore D/o Rajendra Singh Rathore, W/o Prashant
         Singh Hada, Aged About 41 Years, R/o Central Bank Ke
         Pass Kunhadi, Kota, Raj. At Present Posting S/c Uphc
         Sakatpura, Dist. Kota.
56.      Mithlesh Kumari Nagar D/o Ghanshyam Nagar, W/o
         Devkaran Nagar, Aged About 40 Years, R/o Village
         Haripura, Post Shergarh, Tehsil Atru, Dist. Baran, Raj. At
         Present Posting Phc Katawar, Tehsil Atru, Dist. Baran.
57.      Anita Kumari D/o Hosiyar Singh, W/o Ramesh Kumar,
         Aged About 39 Years, R/o Vpo Bhanshal, Tehsil Rajgarh,
         Dist. Churu, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Nodiya,
         Phc Joghalsar, Block Bidasar, Dist. Churu.
58.      Sangeeta Verma D/o Bhanwar Lal, W/o Pawan Kumar,
         Aged About 42 Years, R/o Vill Gudrawas, Tehsil Fathepur,
         Dist. Sikar, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Ganeshpura
         Phc Rajpur, Block Sahabad, Dist. Baran.
59.      Pushpa Devi W/o Mahesh Kumar Kumawat, Aged About
         42 Years, R/o Sarsava Ka Mohalla Manda Bhimsingh, Dist.
         Jaipur, Raj. At Present Posting Phc Manda Bhimsingh,
         Jaipur.
60.      Ninder Paul W/o Kulwant Singh, Aged About 53 Years, R/o
         Ward No. 03 Village 36-Gb, Tehsil Srivijaynagar, Dist.
         Ganganagar, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter 36-Gb,
         Block Vijaynagar, Jaipur.
61.      Jyoti Devi D/o Ramanand, W/o Hitendra Kumar, Aged
         About 51 Years, R/o Vpo Bhadunda Khurd, Tehsil And
         Dist. Jhunjhunun, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter
         Rewasa Phc Raisana, Block Gudachanderji, Dist. Karauli.
62.      Anita D/o Dalip Singh, W/o Rajesh Kumar, Aged About 41
         Years, R/o Vpo Kalari, Tehsil Rajgarh, Dist. Churu, Raj. At
         Present Posting Subcenter Mundiyau, Phc Surpaliya, Block
         Jayal, Dist. Nagaur.
63.      Krishna Kumari W/o Narayan Ram Meghwal, Aged About

                     (Downloaded on 05/05/2025 at 09:31:43 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:20991]                  (7 of 15)                    [CW-3335/2025]


         36 Years, R/o 4-Lc(A) Tehsil Srivijaynagar, Dist.
         Sriganganagar, Raj. At Present Posting 1Msd Anupgarh,
         Dist Sriganganagar.
64.      Rekha Sikligar W/o Narayan Sikligar, Aged About 43
         Years, R/o 96 Wariyon Ki Ghanti Pande Ki Pol Girwa,
         Udaipur, Raj. At Present Posting Uphc Sahari Subcenter
         Bhopalpura, Udaipur, Raj.
65.      Suman D/o Inder Singh, W/o Santlal, Aged About 38
         Years, R/o Vpo Bijoli Pilod, Tehsil Surajgarh, Dist.
         Jhunjhunun, Raj. At Present Posting City Dispensary
         Vidhyavihar Pilani, Dist. Jhunjhunun.
66.      Hemlata Merotha W/o Shivnarayan Merotha, Aged About
         48 Years, R/o Nailkanth Colony Seeshwali Anta Antah,
         Dist. Baran, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Balakera,
         Antha, Baran.
67.      Sita Devi D/o Tekchand, W/o Balveer Singh, Aged About
         43 Years, R/o Vpo Doomali Khurd, Tehsil Buhana, Dist.
         Jhunjhun, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Baredi Chc
         Sarola Kalla, Block Khanpur, Dist. Jhalawar.
68.      Sudarshan Ved D/o Mangi Lal Ved, Aged About 55 Years,
         R/o Pani Ki Tanki Ke Pass Barsani, Dist. Bhilwara, Raj. At
         Present Posting S/c Bajunda, Tehsil Badnor, Dist. Beawar.
69.      Sawroop Kanwar W/o Bheru Singh, Aged About 44 Years,
         R/o Barath Ka Geon Barath Ka Gaon, Dist. Jaisalmer, Raj.
         At Present Posting Subcenter Barath Ka Gaon Dist.
         Jaisalmer.
70.      Suman Kumari D/o Sher Singh, W/o Jogendra Singh,
         Aged About 36 Years, R/o C-18 Baiji Ki Kothi Jhalana
         Dungri, Faze-4, Dist. Jaipur, At Present Posting Subcenter
         Bhawpura, Block Jamwaramgarh, Dist. Jaipur-I.
71.      Amika Devi W/o Udaivir Singh, Aged About 41 Years, R/o
         Jharoda, Dist. Jhunjhun, Raj. At Present Posting Phc Rojri,
         Block Gharsana, Dist. Sriganganagar.
72.      Parmeshwari W/o Khem Chandra, Aged About 38 Years,
         R/o 94 Bheleri Ke Raste Per Khinvasar, Churu, Raj. At
         Present Posting Subcenter Kitap Chc Bandanwara, Block
         Bhinath, Dist. Ajmer.
73.      Samta Sharma D/o Prem Shankar Sharma, W/o
         Bhagchand Sharma, Aged About 46 Years, R/o Kaalsho Ka
         Mohalla Kaaniya, Dist. Ajmer, Raj. At Present Posting
         Subcenter Amesar, Phc Sambhugarh, Block Asind, Dist.
         Bhilwara.
74.      Kanchan Devi Kumawat D/o Ramgopal Kumawat, W/o

                     (Downloaded on 05/05/2025 at 09:31:43 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:20991]                  (8 of 15)                    [CW-3335/2025]


         Puranmal Kumawat, Aged About 45 Years, R/o B-22
         Alkapuri Murlipura, Dist. Jaipur, Raj. At Present Posting
         State Insurance Dispensary -9 V.k.i. Area Road No. 9
         Jaipur.
75.      Vijay Laxmi Chhipa D/o Satish Chandra Chhipa, W/o
         Laxman Lal Chhipa, Aged About 46 Years, R/o Village
         Sathana, Tehsil Masuda, Vijaynagar, Dist. Ajmer. At
         Present Posting Subcenter Daulatpura, Jaipur.
76.      Krishan Kumari Meena D/o Girdhari Lal Meena, Aged
         About 42 Years, R/o Prakash Colony Hindusthan Metal
         College Road Baran, Raj. At Present Posting Phc Badwa,
         Block Anta, Dist. Baran.
77.      Sumanlata W/o Vijay Pal, Aged About 50 Years, R/o Vpo
         Kalakhari, Tehsil Buhawana, Dist. Jhunjhunu, Raj. At
         Present Posting Subcetner Jagdishpura Phc Mehmadpur,
         Block Hindon, Dist. Karauli.
78.      Kali Rani D/o Kripa Ram, W/o Man Singh, Aged About 39
         Years, R/o Vpo Chainpura Chhota, Tehsil Rajgarh, Dist.
         Churu, Raj. At Present Posting Phc Surpaliya, Block Jayal,
         Dist. Nagaur.
79.      Anju Bala W/o Subhash Sonaniya, Aged About 41 Years,
         R/o Brahman Mohalla Ghumansar Kalan Khudania, Dist.
         Jhunjhunu,   Raj.  At   Present     Posting Subcenter
         Khorameena Block Amer, Dist. Jaipur-I.
80.      Munni Devi D/o Tokh Ram, W/o Mahendra Singh, Aged
         About 38 Years, R/o Jatto Ka Mohalla Bhesli, Dist. Churu,
         At Present Posting Subcenter Chandari, Block Ladnu, Dist.
         Didwana-Kuchaman.
81.      Vijendra Choudhary D/o Ramkumar, W/o Sanjay
         Choudhary, Aged About 43 Years, R/o Shobha Ka Bas
         Dhanuri, Dist. Jhunjhunu, Raj. At Present Posting
         Subcenter Sunari, Block Ladnu, Dist. Didwana-Kuchaman.
82.      Sarita W/o Dhanveer Singh, Aged About 40 Years, R/o Rk
         Residency Sindhi Colony Rajapark Jaipur, Raj. At Present
         Posting Subcenter Dangarwara, Chc Andhi, Block Andhi,
         Jaipur-I.
83.      Sangeeta Rawal W/o Rameshwar Rao, Aged About 37
         Years, R/o Kishan Petrol Pump Ke Samne Bali, Dist. Pali,
         Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Punariya, Block Bali,
         Dist. Pali.
84.      Manju Kumari D/o Mala Ram, W/o Sikander Singh, Aged
         About 39 Years, R/o Badasari Ka Bas, Tehsil Surajgarh,
         Dist. Jhunjhunu Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter


                     (Downloaded on 05/05/2025 at 09:31:43 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:20991]                  (9 of 15)                    [CW-3335/2025]


         Kakrana, Phc Bhonawas, Block Paota, Dist. Kotputli.
85.      Susheela Kumari W/o Somveer, Aged About 38 Years, R/o
         Chima Ka Was Berla, Dist. Jhunjhunu, Raj. At Present
         Posting Subcenter Nareli, Block Mandal, Dist. Bhilwara.
86.      Sunita Meena W/o Ramdev Meena, Aged About 42 Years,
         R/o Guda Gokulpura, Tehsil Hindoli, Dist. Bundi, Raj. At
         Present Posting Phc Thana, Dist. Bundi.
87.      Vimla W/o Rajkumar, Aged About 46 Years, R/o Vpo
         Thirpali Bari Churu, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter 49
         Gb      Srivijaynagar,    Block     Srivijaynagar,   Dist.
         Sriganganagar.
88.      Maheshwari Meena D/o Ramchanran Meena, W/o
         Karunashankar, Aged About 38 Years, R/o Keshopura,
         Pipalda, Itawa, Dist. Kota, Raj. At Present Posting
         Subcenter Ratdiya, Tehsil Anta, Dist. Baran.
89.      Amarjit Kaur W/o Nachater Singh, Aged About 46 Years,
         R/o 50 Gb Tehsil Srivijaynagar, Dist. Anupgarh Raj. At
         Present Posting Chak 40 Gb Subcenter 40 Gb, Tehsil
         Srivijaynagar, Dist. Sriganganagar.
90.      Usha Shrimali D/o Shantilal Ojha, W/o Pramod Shrimali,
         Aged About 42 Years, R/o Nichla Chora Sema,
         Rajsamand, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Sagrun,
         Block Khamnor, Dist. Rajsamand.
91.      Usha Devi D/o Hariram, W/o Surendra Kumar, Aged About
         39 Years, R/o Bidsar, Via Bidsar, Tehsil Laxmangarh, Dist.
         Sikar, Raj. At Present Posting Anm Phc Center Bichha,
         Block Ramgarh Pachwara, Dist. Dausa.
92.      Anita Kumari W/o Vinod Kumar, Aged About 47 Years, R/o
         Kanawasi, Dist. Churu, Raj. At Present Posting Phc
         Manana, Block Makrana, Dist. Didwana-Kuchaman.
93.      Mohan Kumari Mali D/o Lalu Ram Mali, W/o Badri Lal Mali,
         Aged About 48 Years, R/o Panotiya Gilund, Dist.
         Rajsamand, Raj. At Present Posting Sub Center Betumbi,
         Phc Gilund, Block Railmangra, Dist. Rajsamand.
94.      Guddi Sunar W/o Kalu Lal Soni, Aged About 47 Years, R/o
         Vpo Ozara, Tehsil Hamirgarh, Dist. Bhilwara, Raj. At
         Present Posting Sub Center Pithas, Tehsil Mandal, Dist.
         Bhilwara.
95.      Krishna Kumari Meena D/o Ghantoliram Meena, W/o
         Rameshwar Meena, Aged About 44 Years, R/o Village
         Kamalpurio Ka Pura, Tehsil Todabhim, Dist. Karauli, Raj.
         At Present Posting Anm Subcenter Gotada, Phc
         Khavaravji, Block Nagalrajawat, Dist. Dausa.

                     (Downloaded on 05/05/2025 at 09:31:43 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:20991]                 (10 of 15)                    [CW-3335/2025]


96.      Gayatri Sharma D/o Mohan Lal Sharma, W/o Navratan
         Sharma, Aged About 41 Years, R/o Vpo Shambhugarh,
         Tehsil Asind, Dist. Bhilwara, Raj. At Present Posting S/c
         Motipur, Phc Kaliyas, Block Asind, Dist. Bhilwara.
97.      Ravina Meena W/o Pappu Lal Meena, Aged About 32
         Years, R/o Vpo Kalakho Ambari, Tehsil Sikrath, Dist.
         Dausa, Raj. At Present Posting Uphc Somnath Tiraha,
         Dist. Dausa.
98.      Mahima Verma D/o Mahaveer Verma, W/o Vijendra
         Meghwal, Aged About 31 Years, R/o Meghwalo Ka Mohalla
         Balchand Paada, Bundi, Dist. Bundi Raj. At Present
         Posting Chc Lakheri, Dist. Bundi.
99.      Madhu Kumari Soni D/o Naval Kishor Soni, Aged About 31
         Years, R/o Kale Mahalo Ki Gali Bundi, Dist. Bundi, Raj. At
         Present Posting Rcho Bundi.
100.     Ashoka Meena D/o Madan Lal Meena, W/o Geetaram
         Meena, Aged About 31 Years, R/o 23 Meeno Ka Mohalla,
         Raghunathpura, Tehsil Nainwa, Dist. Bundi Raj. At Present
         Posting Anm Block Nainwa, Bundi.
101.     Girjesh Hada D/o Narayan Singh Hada, W/o Lokendra
         Singh Ranawat, Aged About 35 Years, R/o Dhandola, Post
         Kuradiya Jahazpur, Dist. Bhilwara, Raj. At Present Posting
         S/c Ghambheera, Block Nainwa, Bundi.
102.     Paramjeet Kaur D/o Gyan Singh, W/o Jasvinder Singh,
         Aged About 35 Years, R/o Ward No. 2 15 P, 12H,
         Ganganagar, Dist. Ganganagar, Raj. At Present Posting
         Bcmho Office Anupgarh, Ganganagar.
103.     Anita Kumari D/o Roop Singh, Aged About 34 Years, R/o
         Vpo Mundiya, Tehsil Todabhim, Dist. Karauli, Raj. At
         Present Posting Phc Mahmdpur, Block Hindon, Karauli.
104.     Sonali Gupta D/o Suresh Gupta, W/o Rameshwar Prasad,
         Aged About 40 Years, R/o Village And Post Namana, Tehsil
         And Dist. Bundi Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter
         Gardeda Block And Dist Bundi.
105.     Shahjad Banu D/o Ibhiram Khan, W/o Phool Mohammad
         Khan, Aged About 45 Years, R/o Ward No. 17 Dhul Kot,
         Behind Of Royal Palace, Shahpura, Dist. Bhilwara Raj. At
         Present Posting Subcenter Mindoliya, (Shahpura), Dist.
         Bhilwara.
106.     Jay Shri W/o Ashok Kumar, Aged About 52 Years, R/o
         Kheri Seela, Dist. Nagaur, Raj. At Present Posting
         Subcenter Altawa, Dist. Nagaur.
107.     Kelam W/o Rameshwar, Aged About 32 Years, R/o Sarano


                     (Downloaded on 05/05/2025 at 09:31:43 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:20991]                 (11 of 15)                      [CW-3335/2025]


         Ki Dhani Kucheepala, Dist. Nagaur, Raj. At Present
         Posting Subcenter Ratnas, Block Makrana, Dist. Didwana-
         Kuchaman.
108.     Asha Chouhan D/o Yogesh Parihar, Aged About 50 Years,
         R/o Heera Gali Kayest Mohalla Near Bijasanmata Mandir
         Purani Mandi, Ajmer Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter
         Dangarwara, Block Rajgarh, Dist. Alwar.
109.     Pramod Sen D/o Kishangopal, W/o Premchand Sen, Aged
         About 46 Years, R/o Village Bohat, Tehsil Mangrol, Dist.
         Baran, Raj. At Present Posting Subcenter Hingolia Phc
         Bohat, Block Mangrol, Dist. Baran.
110.     Anjula Soni W/o Bhimraj Soni, Aged About 55 Years, R/o
         Village Harigarh, Dist. Jhalawar, Raj. At Present Posting S/
         c Dobda Khanpur (Block) Jhalawar.
111.     Saroj Singh D/o Hari Singh, Aged About 47 Years, R/o
         196-B Rama, Bhadrajun, Dist. Jalore, Raj. At Present
         Posting Naya Rama, Phc Bhorda, Block Ahore, Dist.
         Jalore.
112.     Bablu D/o Khuma Ram, Aged About 31 Years, R/o Chc
         Center Itawa, Bamniya, Tehsil Makrana, Dist. Didwana-
         Kuchaman, Raj. At Present Posting Chc Gachhipura, Dist.
         Didwana Kuchaman.
113.     Shahena Khan W/o Sakir Husain, D/o Abdul Hamid Khan,
         Aged About 56 Years, R/o 337 Noor Manzil Street No. 7
         Behind St. Pol School, Alipura, Udaipur, Raj. At Present
         Posting Phc Goverdhan Villas Dewali, Dist. Udaipur.
114.     Vandana Rathore W/o Jeevan Singh, Aged About 59
         Years, R/o Village Pheela, Dist. Udaipur, Raj. At Present
         Posting Subcenter Ratanpura Chc Bambor, Dist. Udaipur.
                                                                 ----Petitioners
                                    Versus
1.       The State Of Rajasthan, Through Additional Chief
         Secretary, Medical And Health Department, Government
         Of Rajasthan Secretariat, Jaipur.
2.       Director, (Public Health) Medical And Health Service,
         Rajasthan, Swasthya Bhawan, Tilak Marg, Jaipur.
3.       Additional Director, (Administrative) Medical And Health
         Service, Rajasthan, Swasthya Bhawan, Tilak Marg, Jaipur.
4.       Chief Medical And Health Officer, Banswara.
5.       Chief Medical And Health Officer, Udaipur.
6.       Chief Medical And Health Officer, Ajmer.
7.       Chief Medical And Health Officer, Hanumangarh.

                     (Downloaded on 05/05/2025 at 09:31:43 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:20991]                       (12 of 15)                      [CW-3335/2025]


8.       Chief Medical And Health Officer, Kota.
9.       Chief Medical And Health Officer, Swaimadhopur.
10.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Bhilwara.
11.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Dungarpur.
12.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Jhalawar.
13.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Pali.
14.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Jalor.
15.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Barmer.
16.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Jodhpur.
17.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Karauli.
18.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Churu.
19.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Baran.
20.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Jaipur.
21.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Nagaur.
22.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Sriganganagar.
23.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Jhunjhunun.
24.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Beawar.
25.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Jaisalmer.
26.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Kotputli.
27.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Bundi.
28.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Dausa.
29.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Alwar.
30.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Rajsamnd.
31.      Chief Medical And Health Officer, Didwana- Kuchaman.
                                                                     ----Respondents


For Petitioner(s)              :    Mr. Tanwar Singh Rathore



         HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINIT KUMAR MATHUR

Order

02/05/2025

1. Learned counsel for the petitioners submit that the

controversy involved in the present case is squarely covered by a

judgment of this Court rendered in S.B. Civil Writ Petition

[2025:RJ-JD:20991] (13 of 15) [CW-3335/2025]

No.14444/2015 (Smt. Saroj Bala Bhatt & Anr. Vs. State of

Rajasthan & Ors.) and other connected matter, decided

on04.08.2022, which reads as under:-

"The present writ petitions have been filed against the order dated 31.10.2015 whereby the earlier order vide which the monetary benefits in pursuance to the selection grade were granted to the petitioners has been ordered to be cancelled. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the issues as to from which date the benefit of selection grade and regularisation has to be granted and whether the benefit already granted can be withdrawn, were under consideration in the matter of State of Rajasthan & Ors. Vs. Chandra Ram (D.B. Special Appeal Writ No.589/2015) decided on 07.07.2017. While replying to the said issues, the Division Bench held as under:

"37. QUESTION A For the reasons and discussions aforesaid and in view of the law declared by the Supreme Court in the case of Jagdish Narain Chaturvedi and Surendra Mahnot & Ors. (supra); we are of the opinion that the respondent -employee would stand regularized from the date of regularization in service and not prior to that.

38. QUESTION B Taking into consideration the recent decision, prior to two decades the regularization period was not questioned by anybody, therefore, in a writ petition filed by the petitioner it will not be appropriate for us to allow the Government to end the regularization. However, regularization will be from the date of regularization done by the department and not prior thereto.

39. QUESTION C The contention of the counsel for the employees is required to be accepted and it cannot be annulled unless it has been annulled by appropriate authority.

[2025:RJ-JD:20991] (14 of 15) [CW-3335/2025]

However, the benefits shall not be withdrawn but in future when the benefits are to be accorded for further promotion, the same will be considered on the basis of new law declared by the Supreme Court i.e. period will be considered from the date of regularization. When the future benefit of 9, 18 and/or27 will be considered their ad-hoc service will not be considered for the purpose of benefit of 9, 18 and/or 27years. But if benefit has already been granted for all the three scales; the same shall not be withdrawn and norecovery will be made from the employees.

40. QUESTION D In view of our answer in above matters, it is very clear that for the purpose of regularisation the date of regularisation will be from the date of regular appointment. In that view of the matter, there cannot be two dates for the purpose of seniority and the other benefits. However, earlier services will be considered for the purpose of the same if there is a shortage in pensionary benefits.

41. QUESTION E In view of the observations made by the Supreme Court, as referred to above, the ad-hocism will not be considered for seniority. In that view of the matter, there will be only one date for regularization, date of regularizing ad-hoc period will not have any effect on seniority. In our considered opinion, the Division Bench of this Court in the case of State of Rajasthan & Ors. vs. Gopa Ram in DB Civil Special Appeal No.44/2016, decided on 18.04.2016 had no right to distinguish the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Jagdish Narayan Chaturvedi (Supra) and State of Rajasthan vs. Surendra Mohnot & Ors. (supra). Thus, the decision of State of Rajasthan & Ors.

vs. Gopa Ram (supra)did not lay down correct law. The correct law would be the law declared by the Supreme Court in the two judgments referred hereinabove."

Learned counsel for the respondents also

[2025:RJ-JD:20991] (15 of 15) [CW-3335/2025]

admitted the issue in question to be covered by Chandra Ram's case (supra).

In view of the ratio as laid down in Chandra Ram's case (supra), the present writ petitions are allowed on the same terms and conditions. All the pending applications also stand disposed of."

2. For the self same reasons, the present writ petition is

disposed of in light of the judgment rendered by this Court in the

case of Smt. Saroj Bala Bhatt (supra).

3. It is made clear that any recovery made by the respondents

in pursuance of the grant of ACP, the petitioners will be free to

move an appropriate representations in accordance with law for

the refund of the recovery.

4. The order has been passed based on the submissions made

in the petition, the respondents would be free to examine the

veracity of the submissions made in the petition and only in case

the averments made therein are found to be correct, the

petitioners would be entitled to the relief sought.