Rajasthan High Court
Babu Lal S/O Shri Noparam vs State Of Rajasthan on 27 January, 2021
Bench: Mahendar Kumar Goyal
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Criminal Miscellaneous (Petition) No. 5826/2020
Shiv Ram Gurjar S/o Sh. Jagdesh Gurjar, Aged About 28 Years,
R/o Khushalpura Boli District Sawai Madhopur (Rajasthan)
----Petitioner
Versus
State Of Rajasthan, Through PP
----Respondent
AND
Other similar matters as per Schedule-A appended to this
order
This Order shall govern all the cases, the particulars of
which have been given in Schedule-A appended to this
order.
For Petitioner(s) : Mr. N.A. Naqvi, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Syed Adeel Naqvi, Mr. Sandeep
Jain and Mukesh Kumar Meena,
Mr. Manoj Kumar Sharma, Mr. Rahul
Agarwal, Mr. Umesh Dixit, Mr. Mohar
Pal Meena, Mr. Paveen Kumar Jain,
Mr. Bharat Yadav, Arvind Sharma, Mr.
Dharmendra Gurjar, Mr. Sumit Kumar
Jain, Mr. Virendra Yadav, Satish
Kumar Khandelwal, Mr. Ram Prasad,
Mr. Shivji Lal Sharma, Satish Kumar
Khandelwal, Mr. Nitin Kumar Sharma,
Mr. Tarun Jain, Mr. Mukesh Sharma,
Mr. Girish Khandelwal, Ms. Vijay
Laxmi Gautam, Mr. Manish Kumar
Sharma, Mr. Deepak Khandelwal, Ms.
Chhavi Chaturvedi, Mr. Brijesh Kumar
Bhardwaj, Mr. Dinesh Kumar Garg,
Mr. Atul Kumar Jain, Mr. Vivek Joshi,
Mr. Dinesh Kumar Joshi, Mr. Arpit
Shrivastav, Mr. Jiteshu Chugh, Mr.
Saubhash Sharma, Mr. Prahlad
Sharma, Mr. Yogesh Singhal, Mr. Amit
Dhadhich, Mr. S. Gaharana, Ms. Lata
Sharma, Mr. B.R. Chaudhary, Mr. D.D.
Khandelwal, Mr. Shyam Bihari Gautam
For Respondent(s) : Mr. F.R. Meena, PP
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MAHENDAR KUMAR GOYAL
(2 of 6) [CRLMP-5826/2020]
Order
27/01/2021
1. All these petitions relate to the prayer for release of tractors
and trolleys, which have been seized by the Police
Authorities/Mining Authorities/Forest Officials for various reasons
including carrying "bazri", by way of illegal mining in Rajasthan
and selling out the same etc. and have been filed against the
order passed by the concerned Magistrate whereby application
under Section 451 & 457 Cr.P.C for releasing of tractor and trolley
was rejected and in some cases affirmed in revision also and
therefore, the same are being heard together.
2. Learned counsel for the petitioners relying upon the
judgments passed by this court in S.B. Criminal Misc. Petition No.
2723/2019 (Asharam & Ors. Vs. State of Rajasthan &
connected misc. petitions) decided by common order dated
3.2.2020, S. B. Criminal Misc. (Petition) NO.2687/2020 (Nandlal
Vs. State of Rajasthan) decided on 1.10.2020, in the case of
Nathulal Vs. State of Rajasthan (S.B. Criminal Misc. Petition
No.2755/2020) decided on 1.10.2020, which also took into
consideration the interim order passed in PIL "Khem Singh Vs.
State of Rajasthan", (D.B.Civil Writ Petition NO.4239/2019)
as well as judgment passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the
case of Sunderbhai Ambalal Desai & Ors. Vs. State of Gujrat:
(2002) 10 SCC 283, submitted that the vehicles be released on
appropriate terms and conditions.
3. Learned Public Prosecutor has opposed these criminal misc.
petitions.
(3 of 6) [CRLMP-5826/2020]
4. The issue is no more res-integra in light of judgments passed
by this Court in cases of Asharam (supra), Nandlal (supra),
Nathulal (supra), Khem Singh (supra) and judgment of
Hon'ble the Supreme Court of India in case of Sunderbhai
Ambalal Desai (supra).
5. Keeping in view the law as noticed herein above and the fact
that no confiscation order has been passed till date for illegal
mining and that the imposition of fine or penalty would be on the
person (owner) and not on the vehicle, this court is inclined to
follow the view taken in Asharam's case (supra).
6. Accordingly, these petitions are allowed and the orders
impugned herein passed by the learned Court below are quashed
and set aside. The tractor and trolley as mentioned in these
petitions as per Schedule-A annexed to this order shall be
released as per the conditions laid down in Para 14(a) to (f) of
Asharam's case (supra).
7. However, it is made clear that if vehicle(s) has been
confiscated under the relevant provisions of the Act, then said
vehicle(s) shall not be released by the concerned Magistrate
keeping in view of law laid down in the case of Laxman Versus
State of Rajasthan: DB Criminal Misc. Petition No.60/2018
decided on 6.4.2018.
8. In view thereof, all these criminal misc. petitions are allowed
with aforesaid directions.
(MAHENDAR KUMAR GOYAL),J
MADAN MEENA /91
(4 of 6) [CRLMP-5826/2020]
SCHEDULE - "A"
Sr. Item No. in Case Type Case No. Vehicle Type Vehicle Reg. No.
No. cause list
dt.
27.1.2021
1. 91 CRLMP 5826/2020 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-9919
2. 92 CRLMP 5895/2020 Tractor with Trolley RJ-02-RE-2999
3. 93 CRLMP 5896/2020 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-1806
RJ-25-EV-0804
4. 94 CRLMP 6041/2020 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RA-6278
5. 95 CRLMP 6288/2020 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-6825
6. 96 CRLMP 6368/2020 Tractor with Trolley CHASSIS No.
T053509239GJ
7. 97 CRLMP 6532/2020 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RB-1587
8. 98 CRLMP 60/2021 TRUCK RJ-47-GA-2238
9. 99 CRLMP 71/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-9904
10. 100 CRLMP 72/2021 Tractor with Trolley CHASSIS No.
MBNGAAJXNLJC00
11. 101 CRLMP 74/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-3120
12. 102 CRLMP 111/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-05-RC-3556
13. 103 CRLMP 112/2021 Tractor with Trolley 1.CHASSIS No.
T053509241GJ
2.CHASSIS No.
T053508023GJ
14. 104 CRLMP 114/2021 Tractor with Trolley 1.RJ-26-RB-3343
2.RJ-06-RC-0605
15. 105 CRLMP 127/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RA-8527
16. 106 CRLMP 143/2021 TROLLEY RJ-26-RB-5277
17. 107 CRLMP 154/2021 Tractor with Trolley INGINE No.
NLC5NJJ0090
18. 108 CRLMP 155/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-4142
19. 109 CRLMP 156/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-8585
20. 110 CRLMP 162/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-6859
21. 111 CRLMP 163/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-9684
22. 112 CRLMP 164/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-6159
23. 113 CRLMP 166/2021 Tractor with Trolley CHASSIS NO.
MBNAAAJXEJJE006
24. 114 CRLMP 167/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RA-2369
25. 115 CRLMP 168/2021 Tractor with Trolley CHASSIS No.
MBNAAAJXEKJL007
26. 116 CRLMP 170/2021 TRUCK MP-06-HC-2845
27. 117 CRLMP 171/2021 TRUCK RJ-05-GA-5337
28. 119 CRLMP 6157/2020 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RB-0925
29. 120 CRLMP 6173/2020 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RB-2991
30. 125 CRLMP 6531/2020 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-5651
31. 130 CRLW 37/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-9032
32. 131 CRLMP 66/2021 TRUCK RJ-14-GC-4872
33. 137 CRLMP 277/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-5606
34. 138 CRLMP 294/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-8733
35. 139 CRLMP 353/2021 JCB MACHINE RJ-17-EA-1959
36. 140 CRLMP 362/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RA-7989
37. 142 CRLMP 387/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-2690
38. 143 CRLMP 398/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-08-RA-5359
RJ-25-EV-0037
(5 of 6) [CRLMP-5826/2020]
39. 146 CRLMP 436/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-29-RB-3706
40. 147 CRLMP 437/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-29-RB-2739
41. 152 CRLMP 557/2021 TRUCK MP-07-HB-5820
42. 156 CRLMP 566/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-11-RB-2400
43. 158 CRLMP 584/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-09-R-7909
44. 163 CRLMP 599/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-X-5899
45. 169 CRLMP 614/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-9883
RJ-25-EV-0442
46. 170 CRLMP 615/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-14-RC-7175
47. 171 CRLMP 616/2021 Tractor with Trolley 1.RJ-25-RB-1529
2.CHASSIS No.
MBNGAAJXNLJH01
48. 172 CRLMP 617/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-29-RB-4309
49. 173 CRLMP 618/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-29-RA-7280
RJ-25-EV-0729
50. 174 CRLMP 619/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-52-RA-1589
51. 175 CRLMP 620/2021 JCB MACHINE RJ-26-EA-0506
52. 176 CRLMP 622/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-8729
53. 193 CRLMP 6046/2020 Tractor with Trolley RJ-14-RA-2633
54. 196 CRLW 103/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-7602
55. 197 CRLW 130/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-7279
56. 198 CRLW 133/2021 Tractor with Trolley CHASSIS No.
MBNGAAJDULJF00
57. 199 CRLW 134/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-14-RD-1553
58. 202 CRLMP 333/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-4213
RJ-25-EV-1514
59. 203 CRLMP 341/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-2719
RJ-25-EV-0516
60. 205 CRLMP 364/2021 Tractor with Trolley CHASSIS No.
MBNAK49ADLTL54
61. 206 CRLMP 370/2021 Tractor with Trolley 1.CHASSIS No.
T053509241GJ
2.CHASSIS No.
T053508023GJ
62. 207 CRLMP 371/2021 Tractor with Trolley 1.RJ-26-RB-9006
2.RJ-29-RB-1101
63. 208 CRLMP 372/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-6194
64. 210 CRLMP 397/2021 Tractor with Trolley 1.RJ-14-RD-7111
2.RJ-26-RB-7720
3.INGINE No.
S337B37881
65. 211 CRLMP 419/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RB-2872
66. 212 CRLMP 420/2021 DUMPER RJ-11-GB-4645
67. 213 CRLMP 421/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-6344
RJ-25-EV-1503
68. 214 CRLMP 422/2021 Trolley -----------
69. 216 CRLMP 429/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RA-7616
70. 217 CRLMP 585/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-7413
71. 221 CRLMP 590/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RC-0443
72. 222 CRLMP 591/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-7111
73. 223 CRLMP 593/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RB-1988
74. 224 CRLMP 594/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RB-3229
75. 226 CRLMP 600/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RB-0716
76. 227 CRLMP 605/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RA-5503
77. 228 CRLMP 606/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RB-3048
78. 229 CRLMP 607/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-7013
(6 of 6) [CRLMP-5826/2020]
79. 231 CRLMP 627/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RB-3598
80. 248 CRLW 139/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-6536
81. 249 CRLW 154/2021 Tractor with Trolley Chassis No.
MBNBN55AALCL07
82. 250 CRLW 157/2021 Tractor with Trolley Chassis No.
MBNGAAJDULJF00
83. 251 CRLMP 480/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-8441
84. 252 CRLMP 493/2021 Tractor with Trolley Chassis No.
MEA8D061FL12723
85. 253 CRLMP 719/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-02-RC-5089
86. 254 CRLMP 749/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-02-RE-0752
87. 255 CRLW 149/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-29-EV-0824
88. 256 CRLW 151/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-6590
89. 257 CRLW 153/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-29-RB-3542
90. 258 CRLMP 287/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-21-RH-5725
91. 259 CRLMP 6091/2020 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-8515
92. 260 CRLMP 491/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RA-6853
93. 261 CRLMP 502/2021 Tractor with Trolley 1.RJ-17-RC-0293
2.RJ-28-RC-0738
94. 262 CRLMP 504/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-34-RB-2677
95. 263 CRLMP 507/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-25-RB-7663
RJ-25-EV-1197
96. 264 CRLMP 506/2021 Tractor with Trolley CHASSIS
NO.MBNGKKEKPLJ
D00164
97. 265 CRLMP 780/2021 Tractor with Trolley RJ-26-RB-8505
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
