Kerala High Court
Mar Athanesius College Association vs Marthoma Cheriyapalli on 5 September, 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C. JAYACHANDRAN
Thursday, the 5th day of September 2024 / 14th Bhadra, 1946
OP(C) NO. 1392 OF 2018
IA 1225/2015 IN OS 2/2008 OF ASSISTANT SESSIONS COURT/SUB COURT/ COMMERCIAL
COURT, MUVATTUPUZHA, ERNAKULAM
PETITIONERS/DEFENDANTS 1 &2/RESPONDENTS 1 & 2:
1. MAR ATHANESIUS COLLEGE ASSOCIATION
2. DR.WINNY VARGHESE, MANAGER MAR ATHANASIUS COLLEGE OF ARTS &
SCIENCE, KOTHAMANGALAM.
BY ADVS.NARENDRA KUMAR M,HARSHADEV M.(K/1106/2013),GEORGE JACOB
(JOSE)(K/65/1980),
RESPONDENTS/PLAINTIFFS 1 TO 86/ DEFENDANTS 3 TO 50:
1. MARTHOMA CHERIYAPALLI
2. M.S ELDHOSE, AGED 65 YEARS S/O SKARIA, MARACHERIL HOUSE,
KUTHUKUZHI-686 691 (RESPONDENTS NO.3 TO 133 ARE DELETED AS PER ORDER
DATED 6/6/2018 AH(J).), PIN - 686687
3. K.V.GEEVARGHESE, AGED 70 YEARS S/O VARGHESE, KALLUNKAL HOUSE,
KARUKADOM, PIN - 686691
4. C.K.MATHAI, AGED 73 YEARS S/O KURIAN, CHUNDATTU HOUSE' VENDU VAZHI,
PIN - 686690
5. V.V.ITTAN, AGED 69 YEARS S/O VARKEY, VETTIKKUNNEL HOUSE, KARUKADOM,
PIN - 686690
6. SALIM CHERIAN, AGED 60 YEARS S/O KUNJICHAERIA, MALAIYIL HOUSE, NEAR
SUB STATION, KOTHAMANGALAM, PIN - 68666
7. P.P.PAULOSEM, AGED 76 YEARS S/O PAILY, PAZHAUKKALIL
HOUSE,KOZHIPPILLY, PIN - 686691
8. T.P.MATHAI, AGED 80 YEARS PURAVATH, THEKKILAKKATTY HOUSE,
KOZHIPPILLY, PIN - 686688
9. KUNJACHAN, AGED 73 YEARS S/O A.KURUVILLA, ANACHIRA HOUSE,
KOTHAMANGALAM, PIN - 68666
10. K.P.GEORGE, AGED 65 YEARS S/O PAULOSE, KOORAPPILLIL HOUSE,
KOTHAMANGALAM, PIN - 68666
11. K.P.GEORGE, AGED 56 YEARS S/O PAILY, KOOTHMATTACHIL HOUSE,
MATHIRAPPILLY, PIN - 686691
12. K.V.JOLLY, AGED 60 YEARS S/O VARKEY, KUNNAPPILLIL HOUSE,
MATHIRAPPILLY, PIN - 686691
13. P.M.ELDHOSE, AGED 57 YEARS S/O MATHAI, PUTHETHU HOUSE, THANKALAM,
PIN - 686691
14. PAUL THOMAS, AGED 63 YEARS S/O THOMAS, VALIYAPARAMBIL HOUSE,
CHELADU,, PIN - 686681
15. JOSEPH MATHAI, AGED 63 YEARS S/O THOMAS, VALIYAPARAMBIL HOUSE
CHELADU, KOTHAMANGALAM, PIN - 686679
16. K.P.CHACKOCHAN AGED 62 YEARS S/O PAILY,KAIPPILLIL HOUSE, ELEBRA, PIN
- 686691
17. P.V.PAULOSE, AGED 58 YEARS S/O VARKEY, PADINAREKAKKUDY HOUSE
ELAVANADU, PIN - 686691
18. ALIYAS GEORGE AGED 69 YEARS S/O GEEVARGHESE, MALAYIL HOUSE,
VENDUVAZHI, PIN - 686691
19. P.V.PAULOSE, AGED 69 YEARS S/O VARKEY, PAZHAKKALIL HOUSE,
VENDUVAZHI, PIN - 686683
20. K.P.MATHEW, AGED 55 YEARS S/O PAULOSE, KUNNASERIL HOUSE, KARUKADOM,
PIN - 686687
21. JENNIS PAULOSE, AGED 41 YEARS S/O PAULOSE, MUNDIKUDY HOUSE, NEAR M.A
COLLEGE, KOTHAMANGALAM, PIN - 686666
22. KURIAKOSE VARGHESE AGED 55 YEARS S/O VARGHESE, PULLANTHIKADAM HOUSE
KUTHUKUZHI, PIN - 686666
23. BABU MATHEW AGED 64 YEARS S/O MATHEW, KAIPPILLIL HOUSE, NEAR M.A
COLLEGE, KOTHAMANGALAM, PIN - 686666
24. BINOY THOMAS AGED 51 YEARS S/O THOMAS THOMAS, MANNAMECHERIL HOUSE,
PERUMANOOR, PIN - 682015
25. VARGHESE ULAHANNAN, AGED 45 YEARS S/O ULAHANNAN, ONELIL HOUSE,
RAMALLOR, PIN - 686684
26. BIJU MATHAI, AGED 46 YEARS S/O MATHAI, POTTACKAL HOUSE,
MALAINKEEZHU, PIN - 695571
27. M.A.GEORGE AGED 52 YEARS S/O ABRAHAM, MANYATH HOUSE RAMALLOOR, PIN -
686691
28. ELDHO BASIL S/O.ELDHO, MALIYELIL HOUSE, THANKALMA-686 691.
29. K.M.THANKACHAN S/O.MATHAI, KOUGAMPILLIL HOUSE, THANKALAM-686 691.
30. NOBY PAULOSE S/O.PAULOSE, KOCHUVEETTIL HOUSE, THANKALAM-686 691.
31. BIBIN JOHN S/O.JOHN, KIDNGAYTHUKJAYIL HOUSE, CHELAD-686 681.
32. BASIL PAULOSE S/O.PAULOSE, VALAYIL HOUSE, NELLIKUZHY-686 681.
33. BINU T.P. S/O.PAULOSE, THACHETHUKUDY HOUSE, THANAKALAM-686 691.
34. BINOY DAS S/O.DAS, MALKAYIL HOUSE, EDAVANADU-686 691.
35. P.C.ELDHOSE S/O.CHERIYA, PALAKADAN HOUSE, ELEMBRA-686 691.
36. REV.FR.JOSE JOHN, S/O.YOHANNAN, PARANAYIL HOUSE, CHENKARA, PRESENT
VICAR OF MARTHOMA CHERIYA PALLY, KOTHAMANGALAM-686 666.
37. P.M. ELDHO, AGED 67, S/O MATHAI, PALAPPILLIL HOUSE, KARUKADOM
686691.
38. ABY VARGHESE, AGED 49, S/O VARGHESE, CHELATTUKALAPPURA HOUSE,
THANKALAM 686691.
39. ADV. SHIBU KURIAKOSE, AGED 52, S/O KURIAKOSE, PARACKAL HOUSE,
KOTHAMANGALAM 686666.
40. C.P. KURIAKOSE, AGED 56, S/O PAULOSE, CHUNDATTU HOUSE, ELAMBRA.
686691
41. JOHNSON KURIAKOSE, AGED 53, S/O KURIAKOSE, THEKKILAKKATTU HOUSE,
KOZHIPPILLY. 686691
42. K.K. JOSEPH AGED 66, S/O KURIAKOSE, KARIMKUTHUPPURAM HOUSE,
ELAVANADU. 686691
43. K.J. THOMAS, AGED 56, S/O JACOB, KATTANGANAL HOUSE, KONOOR, 680 308.
44. K.K. ABRAHAM AGED 59, S/O KURIAKOSE, KOMBATTU HOUSE, MATHIRIPPILLIL.
686691
45. POULOSE AGED 65, S/O VARKEY, KUZHIYALIL HOUSE, KOZHIPPILLY. 686691
46. P.V. RAJAN, AGED 52, S/O VARGHESE, PAZHAKKAL HOUSE, KOZHIPPILLY.
686691
47. K.P. SHAJU, AGED 51, S/O PAILY, KOOTHAMATTATHIL HOUSE, KOZHIPPILLY.
686691
48. YACOB AGED 80, S/O POTHEN, MAMMOOTIL HOUSE, KOZHIPPILLY. 686691
49. DR. BALU CHACKO, AGED 56, S/O CHAKAPPAN, KOCHATTU HOUSE,
MALAINKEEZHU, 695571
50. P.P. ALIAS AGED 75, S/O PAILY, PANIKKADAM, MUTHANKUZHY 683542
51. I. KURIAN, AGED 67, S/O ISSHAC, KOOPPIL HOUSE, RAMALLOOR. 686691
52. ELDHO VARKEY, AGED 72, S/O VARKEY, PALAKKADAN, THANKALAM. 686691
53. BENNY VARGHESE, AGED 52, S/O VARKEY, PALAKKAN, THANKALAM. 686691
54. BENNY ABRAHAM ,AGED 53, S/O ABRAHAM, KATTUNGANAYIL HOUSE, THAKALAM.
686691
55. C.I. ELDHOSE, AGED 56, S/O ITTIYIRA, CHERUPURATH HOUSE, THANKALAM.
686691
56. GIBI (THOMAS), AGED 49, S/O THOMAS, KOOTTAPPALAYIL, THANKALAM.
686691
57. THOMAS PAUL AGED 44, S/O PAULOSE, PANACKAL HOUSE, KOTHAMANGALAM.
686666
58. BINU A. KURUVILA, AGED 54, S/O KURUVILA, ANACHIRA HOUSE, KUTTOOR
689106
59. SHAJI THOMAS, AGED 55, S/O THOMAS, MALAYIL HOUSE, ELAMBRA. 686691
60. JOHN, AGED 60, S/O THOMAS, KEERAMBLAYIL HOUSE, VANDUVAZHI. 686691
61. P.C. JOSE, AGED 60, S/O CHERIYA, PALAKKADAN HOUSE, ELAMBRA. 686691
62. K.P. GEORGE, AGED 64, S/O PAULOSE, KUNNASSERIL HOUSE, KARUKADOM.
686691
63. C.K. MATHAI AGED 67, S/O KURIAKOSE, CHUNDATHU HOUSE,. VANDUVAZHI.
686691
64. M.M. SUNNY, AGED 49, S/O MATHAI, MANNAMPARAMBIL HOUSE, VANDUVAZHI.
686691
65. ROY PAUL, AGED 55, S/O PAILY, PAZHIKKALIL HOUSE, VANDUVAZHI. 686691
66. SAJI M.T. AGED 47, S/O THOMAS, MADATHIKUDY HOUSE, KARUKADOM. 686691
67. P.I. ELIAS, AGED 69, S/O ISSAC, PARAKKARA HOUSE, ELAMBRA. 686691
68. RAJU YOHANNAN, AGED 69, S/O YOHANNAN, MALAYIL HOUSE, VENDUVAZHY.
686691
69. P.V. PAULOSE, AGED 73, S/O VARKEY, PAZHUKKALIL, VENDUVAZHY 686691
70. C.I. ROY AGED 62, S/O ITTIAVIRA, CHERUPURAM HOUSE, THANKALAM. 686691
71. GEEVARGHESE, AGED 78, S/O VARKEY PALLIKKARA HOUSE, KOTHAMANGALAM.
686666
72. PAULOSE (BENNY) AGED 54, S/O K.P. ULAHANNAN, KUZHIKADAM HOUSE,
KUROOR. 686666
73. GEORGE, AGED 69, S/O MATHAI, KATTUCHIRA HOUSE, ANGADI.689674
74. ELDHO, AGED 68, S/O PAILY, PUOHAYATH, KARINGAZHA.686681
75. ABRAHAM, AGED 82, S/O VARGHESE, PULIKKAKUDY, MALAYINKEEZHU.695571
76. BIJU, AGED 48, S/O P.P. ABRAHAM, PALLIMALIL HOUSE, KAROOR. 686575
77. JOLLY AGED 56, S/O THOMAS, ARAKUDY HOUSE, EDANAD.686574
78. ALIAS, AGED 46, S/O K.V. VARKEY, KEERAPLAYIL HOUSE, KUROOR. 686666
79. LAL AGED 59, S/O A.P. VARGHESE, APPACKAL HOUSE, KUROOR. 686666
80. CHARLEY AGED 50, S/O M.P. MATHEW, PUOHEEKKAL HOUSE, ELAMBRA.
81. BABY, AGED 63, S/O PAULOSE, PAZHUKKALIL HOUSE, KARUKADOM. 686691
82. BINU, AGED 52, S/O VARKEY, KULANGARAKUDY HOUSE, MATHIRAPILLY. 686691
83. VARGHESE, AGED 57, S/O MATHAI, MANNAPARAMBIL HOUSE, VENDUVAZHY.
686691
84. BABY, AGED 53, S/O VARKEY, KULANGARAKUDY HOUSE, MATHIRAPILLY. 686691
85. ROBY, AGED 60, S/O VARGHESE, CHUNDATHU HOUSE, KARUKADOM. 686691
86. RENNY VARGHESE, AGED 53, S/O VARGHESE, PAZHUKALIL HOUSE, THANKALAM.
686691
87. MAR ATHANASIUS COLLEGE OF ARTS & SCIENCE REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER,
M.P. VARGHESE 686666
88. P.T. THOMAS, PALAMBADAM HOUSE KOTTAYAM. 686001
89. MARTHA MARIAM VALIYA PALLI, KOTHAMANGALAM REPRESENTED BY SRI. BABU
P. KURIAKOSE, PEECHAKKARAYIL HOUSE, MATHIRAPPILLY. 686691
90. JOY P. JACOB, SRKALLANICKAL HOUSE, KINGNIMATTOM PO,
KOLENCHERY.682311
91. K.K. DANI MANJAYIL HOUSE, KEERAMPARA, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686681
92. T.J. THAMPI, THAZHATHOOT HOUSE, KAVALNGAD, NELLIMATTOM,
KOTHAMANGALAM. 686693
93. ST. MARY'S JACOBITE CHURCH KURUPPAMPADY, REPRESENTED BY SRI. E.M.
PAULOSE, EMBASSERIL HOUSE, IRINGOL PO. 688011
94. DR. WINNY VARGHESE MANJUMMELKUDIYIL HOUSE, KEERAMPARA,
KOTHAMANGALAM. 686681
95. THEKKILIKKATTU BAS ANIA PALLY CHELAD, REPRESENTED BY SRI.
A.K.ABRAHAM, AMBAZHACHALIL HOUSE, KARUKADOM, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686691
96. ST. MARY'S CHURCH, KARAKUNNAM, REPRESENTED BY A.K. ABRAHAM,
AMBAZHACHALIL HOUSE, KARUKADOM, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686691
97. PROF. E.M. PAULOSE, ERUMALA HOUSE, PANIPRA PO, PIN 686 692.
98. DR. PAULOSE ABRAHAM, PALLIMALIL, KOTHAMANGALAM 686666
99. SRI. K.V. JAMES KATTANGNAL HOUSE, THANKALAM, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686691
100. P.K. PAULOSE PEECHAKKARA HOUSE, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686666
101. P.S. PAILY, PARAKKAL HOUSE, RAMALLOOR, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686691
102. P.M. MARKOSE PALAKKADAN HOUSE, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686666
103. VARGHESE PALLIKKARA, ELOOR HOUSE, KUMARAPURAM. 683565
104. ROY MATHEW, MALAYIL HOUSE, VENDUVAZHY, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686691
105. K.V. PAULOSE, KALLUMKAL HOUSE, KEERAMPARA, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686666
106. ANIL VARGHESE, KALLUMKAL HOUSE, KEERAMPARA, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686691
107. C.V. THOMAS, KOTTISSERIKUDYIL HOUSE, MALAYINKEEZHU, KOTHAMANGALAM
695571.
108. K.P. ROY, KOTTALIL HOUSE, PLAMUDY, KOTTAPPADY. 686692
109. K.P. BABU, KANNETH HOUSE, RAMALLOOR, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686691
110. BABY M. VARGHESE MANNARAPRAYIL HOUSE, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686666
111. DR. M.M. POULOSE, MANJUMMEKUDIYIL HOUSE, KEERAMPARA, KOTHAMANGALAM.
686681
112. T.U. KURUVILA, THOMBRAYIL HOUSE, CHELAD PO, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686681
113. M.I. MARKOSE, MALAYIL HOUSE, PINDIMANA, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686692
114. GEORGE K. PETER KOCHUPARAMBIL HOUSE, MALIPARA PO, KOTHAMANGALAM.
686692
115. K.M. CHACKO, KALLUMKAL HOUSE, KOTTAPPADY, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686692
116. A.G. GEORGE, ELAVUMKUDIYIL HOUSE, MATHIRAPPILLY. 686691
117. SAJU PAUL MLA PANTHALUNGAL HOUSE, VENGOOR PO. 683546
118. E.K. MATHAI, EACHARANKUDY, AIMURY, KOOVAPPADY. 683544
119. M.K. BABU, MANJUMMEKUDIYIL, KEERAMPARA. 686681
120. K.M. ABRAHAM KULANGARA THATHOLIL, NORTH PARAVUR. 683514
121. O.M. MATHEW ORUVETTITHARA, NAGAMPADAM. 686001
122. B.MON PHILIPPOSE, THEKKETHALACKAL, PUTHENGADI. 673021
123. ADV. MATHEW K.VARGHESE, KALIAMATTATHIL, MEKKADAMPU PO. 682316
124. DR. P.V. JOSEPH, PUKKUNNEL, PUTHUPPADY. 673586
125. SAILM KORA, THAZHATHOOTTU, KAVALANGAD, NELLIMATTAM. 686693
126. GEORGEKUTTY VARGHESE, UPPEAZHAKKATTU, KOTHAMANGALAM. 686666
127. ST. MARY'S ORTHODOX CHURCH, UMMINIKKUNNU REPRESENTED BY P.V. SOMAN,
PADINJATTIL HOUSE, POTHANICADU PO. 686671
128. MATHEW PAULOSE, PARAPPAT, PANAICHAYAM, NEDUNGAPRA PO. 682024
129. BINU P MATHEW, PARAPPATTU, VEETTAMPARA. 679102
130. ADV. T.P. MATHAI, OLD RAILWAY STATION ROAD, KOCHI 18.
131. PRASAD P VARGHESE, PUKKUNNEL, PUTHUPPADY PO. 673586
132. MARY VARGHESE, AGED ABOUT 82, W/O M.P. VARGHESE, MANJUMEKUDY HOUSE,
KEERAMPARA. 686681
133. SARAMMA VARGHESE, AGED ABOUT 68, W/O VARGHESE, CHETTIYAMKUDIYIL
HOUSE, POTHANIKKAD KARA, POTHANIKAD POST. 686671 (RESPONDENTS 3 TO
133 ARE DELETED FROM THE PARTY ARRAY OF THIS OP(C) VIDE ORDER DATED
6/6/2018.)
134. K.V.JAMES AGED 66 YEARS S/O.VARKEY, KOTTANGANAL, KOTHAMANGALAM, PIN-
686 691 (IMPLEADED AS THE ADDITIONAL 3RD RESPONDENT VIDE ORDER DATED
12.10.2023 IN I.A. 1/2023)
FOR R1 & R2- BY ADVS.M/S.D.ANIL KUMAR &
FOR R 134- SRI.ROY CHACKO,
This OP (Civil) having come up for orders on 05-09-2024, and upon
perusing the letter dated 27-08-2024 of the District Judge, Ernakulam
forwarding the letter dated 23-08-2024 and this Court's judgment dated
09-11-2023 in the OP(C), the court on the same day passed the following.:
-1-
C.JAYACHANDRAN, J
===========================
O.P.(C)No.1392 of 2018
=====================================
Dated this the 5th day of September, 2024
O R D E R
Perused the letter dated 23.08.2024 of the
Civil Judge (Senior Division), Muvattupuzha.
Having regard to the contents of that letter to
the effect that all further proceedings pursuant
to the order dated 01.03.2024 in I.A.No.1225 of
2015 in O.S.No.2 of 2008 are stayed as per orders
in O.P.(C)No.893 of 2024, this Court noticed that
no further directions are required. However, the
learned Civil Judge will ensure that the matter is
taken up immediately after the prohibitory order
in O.P(C)No.893 of 2024 is vacated and to dispose
of the matter as expeditiously as possible.
Sd/-
C. JAYACHANDRAN,
JUDGE
RPR/-
05-09-2024 /True Copy/ Assistant Registrar
