Kerala High Court

Sahanas Beevi Vellamunda Sayyid vs Kerala University Of Health Sciences on 1 December, 2023

Author: T.R.Ravi

Bench: T.R.Ravi

          IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
                             PRESENT
               THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE T.R.RAVI
FRIDAY, THE 1ST DAY OF DECEMBER 2023 / 10TH AGRAHAYANA, 1945
                     WP(C) NO. 39472 OF 2023
PETITIONERS:

    1     BIBIN M
          AGED 24 YEARS
          S/O MARIDAS, BETHAL BHAVAN VATTAPATHAL VAGAMON PO
          IDUKKI, PIN - 685503
    2     MUHAMMED RIYAZ PULIKKAL
          AGED 23 YEARS
          S/O KADAR KUNHI KP, SANA MANZIL PALLIPARAMBA PO
          KOLENCHERY KANNUR, PIN - 670601
    3     MUHAMMAD FAVAS P
          AGED 22 YEARS
          S/O ABDUL KADER P, BISMILLA HOUSE KORANPEEDIKA
          PARIYARAM PO KANNUR, PIN - 670502
    4     NAJRA RAHMAN EK
          AGED 24 YEARS
          D/O ABDUL RAHMAN , REJINA MANZIL PO ACHAMTHURUTHI,
          PIN - 671351
    5     SIYANA N
          AGED 23 YEARS
          D/O NISAR K, NK MANZIL KATTILKADAVU PO KOLLAM, PIN
          - 690518
    6     VIJI VIJAY
          AGED 24 YEARS
          S/O VIJAYAKUMAR E, ALAMPOTTA ROADRIKATHUVEEDU
          KOOVALASSERY PO TVM, PIN - 695512
    7     VAISHNAVI K
          AGED 24 YEARS
          D/O KALIDAS, KURYGODE THUNDU VILAVEED PANIKERSLANE
          SASTHASMANGALAM PO TVM, PIN - 695010
    8     ANASWARA SUDHAKARAN
          AGED 24 YEARS
          D/O SUDHAKARAN D, NEDUVELITHARAYIL POMMEZHA
          THEKKEKARA PO MAVELIKARA, PIN - 690107
    9     SHAHNA SHERIN O
          AGED 23 YEARS
          D/O HAMZA O, ODUPARA HOUSE AMAYUR PO PATTAMBI
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                 2

           PALAKKAD, PIN - 679303
    10     THASLEENA THAHLIN
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O MOOSA KM, KOTTEPARAMBIL HOUSE TRIKKALATHOOR
           PO ERANAMKULAM, PIN - 683541
    11     ANKITHA LAKSHMI
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O SADANANTHSN, PUNARTHM HOUSE MANJUMMEL PO
           ERANAKULAM, PIN - 682011
    12     HALEEMA PA
           AGED 25 YEARS
           D/O ABBAS PA, PALLIPARAMBIL HOUSE EDATIRUTHY PO
           KATTOOR THRISSUR, PIN - 680703
    13     FAVAS V
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O V ABDUL SUNEER, VAZHAYIL HOUSE VELLAMUNDA
           PO, PIN - 670731
    14     AYANA DILEEP
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O DILEEP KUMAR, AYANAM THIRUNALOOR PO
           CHERTHALA ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 688541
    15     ALEN CHERIYAN
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O CHERIYAN CE, ERUVACHIRA HOUSE OPP DISTRCT
           HOSPITAL VELLAPALLY LANE KOTTYAM, PIN - 686001
    16     HASNATH SHAMLI
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O ASHRAF, MADAMAPATT HOUSE TIRUR, PIN -
           676109
           BY ADVS.
           RAHUL SASI
           NEETHU PREM
           P.ARDRA MENON
           ALFIN NADARSHAW


RESPONDENTS:

    1      KERALA UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCE
           REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR MEDICAL COLLEGE
           P.O THRISSUR, PIN - 680596
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                      3

    2          VICE-CHANCELLOR
               KERALA UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCE MEDICAL
               COLLEGE P.O THRISSUR, PIN - 680596
    3          THE CONTROLLER OF EXAMINATION
               KERALA UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCE MEDICAL
               COLLEGE P.O THRISSUR, PIN - 680596
    4          THE PHARMACY COUNCIL OF INDIA
               COMBINED COUNCIL'S BUILDING KOTLA ROAD, AIWAN-
               E-GHALIB MARG NEW DELHI, PIN - 110002
               BY ADV P.SREEKUMAR



        THIS    WRIT    PETITION     (CIVIL)    HAVING      COME   UP   FOR
ADMISSION       ON   01.12.2023,     ALONG     WITH    WP(C).37059/2023,
37608/2023,       THE   COURT   ON   THE     SAME     DAY   DELIVERED   THE
FOLLOWING:
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                 4



          IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
                             PRESENT
             THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE T.R.RAVI
 FRIDAY, THE 1ST DAY OF DECEMBER 2023 / 10TH AGRAHAYANA,
                               1945
                    WP(C) NO. 37059 OF 2023
PETITIONERS:

    1      SHIBIL M
           AGED 28 YEARS
           S/O MAHABOOB M, MUNDAMBRA HOUSE VANIYAMBALAM
           P.O, PIN - 679339
    2      SHAHA PARVIN P
           AGED 24 YEARS
           D/O HAMZA P, POONGATTEL HOUSE, PERUMBADAPPU
           P.O, PUTHANPALLY, MALAPPURAM, PIN - 679580
    3      MUHAMMED IRFAD K V
           AGED 24 YEARS
           S/O ABDUL KHADER K P, IRFANA'S, KOLMOTTA,
           NANICHERI P.O, PARASSINIKKADAVU, PIN - 670563
    4      ASWATHI V.V
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O SHEEJAN K.K, DEEKSHITHAM, KANICHERI P.O,
           KOODALI, PIN - 670593
    5      JASEEM UMMER
           AGED 24 YEARS
           S/O UMEER P.K, FATHIMA MANZIL, MATTUL NORTH,
           MOOSAKKAN PALLI, PIN - 670325
    6      ABHAY KRISHNA M
           AGED 22 YEARS
           S/O MOHANAN K, MOOTHAL HOUSE, CHERUVATHUR,
           KASARAGOD, PIN - 671313
    7      JASEEL K.M.P
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O MAIMI T.P, JAS VILLA, NALAMPEEDIKA,
           KOLACHERY P.O,, PIN - 670601
    8      MUHAMMED FAIJAS K.P
           AGED 23 YEARS
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                 5

           S/O ABDUL MAJEED T.K, T.K HOUSE, MADAKKARA P.O,
           IRINAVE, PIN - 670301
    9      MUHAMMAD FAVAS T
           AGED 24 YEARS
           FALULULLA C AL SAFA, VILAKKODE P.O, KANNUR, PIN
           - 670703
    10     AYISHABI K.A
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O IBRAHIM PUNNAKKAN, K.A HOUSE, PIN - 670143
    11     MEREENA SOJAN
           AGED 24 YEARS
           D/O SOJAN GEORGE, MANICKATHU HOUSE,
           THAMALLACKAL P.O, THAMALLACKAL, PIN - 690548
    12     BILAL BIN MUHAMMED SALI
           AGED 24 YEARS
           S/O MUHAMMED SALI, BINUJA MANZIL, JANATHA ROAD,
           VYTTILA, PIN - 682019
    13     AMAL SKARIA IPE
           AGED 24 YEARS
           S/O IPE K.S, KAKKATTU HOUSE, MEENADOM P.O,
           KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686516
    14     MAYA V
           AGED 25 YEARS
           D/O KARTHIKEYAN M, CHIRACAKAL VADAKKATHIL,
           PALLIPAD P.O, HARIPAD, PIN - 690512
    15     JUBIN K JOSEPH
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O JOSEPH K J, GEORGIA VILLA HOUSE, VEMPALLY
           P.O, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686633
    16     ANNE JOSY
           AGED 25 YEARS
           D/O JOSY T.D, THAIVELIKKAKOM, VATTAYAL,
           THIRUVAMPADY P.O, ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 688002
    17     SUMITHRA S
           AGED 22 YEARS
           D/O SWAMINATHAN P.S, PALAPPALLIL HOUSE, PONAKOM
           MAVELIKARA P.O, ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 690101
    18     JEENA SHAJI
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O SHAJI T.L, THAYIL HOUSE, VAYALAR P.O,
           CHERTHALA, ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 688536
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                 6

    19     ANJALI RAJEEV
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O RAJEEVAN PILLAI, ANURENJANUM, MUZHANGODI,
           THODIYOOR, P.O, KARUNAGAPPALLY, PIN - 690523
    20     SARJADA NARGEESE K K
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O ABU SALEEM, KARUVARA KANDIYIL HOUSE,
           PALLIPOYIL KAKKODI, KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673611
    21     MOHAMMED MUNEERA A.A
           AGED 24 YEARS
           S/O ASHRAR A, ANJILAKADAVATH HOUSE, KOCHANNUR
           P.O, THRISSUR, PIN - 679562
    22     SHARON SHAJU,
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O A.G SHAJU, ARAKKAL HOUSE, KUNDALIYAR P.O,
           THRISSUR, PIN - 680616
    23     JASNA A
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O ABDUL RAHMAN, AISHWARYA MANZIL, MARAKKAVU,
           ERIMAYUR P.O, PALAKKAD, PIN - 678546
    24     SOORYA K.P
           AGED 23 YEARS
           KATTIPARAMBIL HOUSE, JANATHA BAZHAR, TIRUR,
           MALAPPURAM, PIN - 676101
    25     SABNA LATHEEF
           AGED 24 YEARS
           D/O ABDUL LATHEEF, AL AYAN VADAPPARAMBU,
           KANNADI P.O, PALAKKAD, PIN - 678701
    26     MOHAMMED VASIF
           AGED 25 YEARS
           S/O ABDU RAHIMAN T, THEYYAMPATTIL HOUSE,
           KALLINGAL KALPAKANCHERI P.O, MALAPPURAM, PIN -
           676551
    27     FATHIMA HANNA
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O MOHAMMED NAUSHAD, DARUL AMAAN, SUB STATION,
           MUNDAYAD, KANNUR, PIN - 670594
    28     ANJALI JAYAKUMAR
           AGED 24 YEARS
           D/O JAYAKUMAR G, KRISHNASADANAM, KOLLAKADAVU
           P.O, CHENGANNUR, ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 690509
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                 7

    29     MOHAMED RABEEH
           AGED 25 YEARS
           S/O A KASIM, IRFANAS, PALLIPROM P.O, MUNDAYAD,
           KANNUR, PIN - 670594
    30     MUHAMMED SHABIN C
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O ALI, CHENGOT HOUSE, NADUVANNUR P.O,
           CALICUT, PIN - 673614
    31     IRFANA
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O ISMAIL C.H, CHANDROTH HOUSE, THUNERI P.O,
           NADAPURAM, KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673505
    32     DRISHYA N.P
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O PAVITHRAN N.P, DRISHYA NIVAS,
           VARAPRAKUNIYIL P.O, CHENDAYAD, PANOOR, PIN -
           670692
    33     ALEENA M.M
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O M.T MICHEAL, MOOLEKKATT HOUSE, MADUTHUMPADI
           P.O, THRISSUR, PIN - 680733
    34     AKSHAY K.P
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O PUSHPARAJ K.G, KOTTARAPATE HOUSE, KARIKKAD,
           PERUMBILAVU, THRISSUR, PIN - 680519
    35     SUJESH K
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O SUKUMARAN, KALLIDUMBIL HOUSE, CHEMBRA,
           MEENADATHUR P.O, MALAPPURAM, PIN - 676307
    36     RIFANA,
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O RAHMAN K.A, KUNNUMPURATH HOUSE, NAMBIAR
           PALLAM, THRISSUR, PIN - 679532
    37     DEVIKA S
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O SHANKARANARAYANAN P, PATTATHIL HOSUE,
           VELUTHUR P.O, THRISSUR, PIN - 680012
    38     ANAGHA FRANCIS E
           AGED 22 YEARS
           D/O FRANCIS E.T, EDAKKALATHUR HOUSE, KAKKASSERY
           P.O, PIN - 680511
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                 8

    39     ANANTHU A.K
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O ANIL R.S, ANANTHU BHAVAN, KUZHIMATHICADU
           P.O, KAREEPRA, PIN - 691509
    40     R. SNEHA
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O R RAMESHKUMAR, NELLIMADU HOUSE, KANNIMARI
           P.O, CHITTUR, PALAKKAD, PIN - 678534
    41     FATHIMA RISVANA M
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O ASHRAF M, MENATTIL HOUSE, OMACHAPPUZHA P.O,
           KARINGAPPARA, MALAPPURAM, PIN - 676320
    42     HAMNA P.I
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O IBRAHIM, PUTHANPURAKKAL HOUSE, PIN - 679591
    43     GOPIKA MURALEE
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O MURALEE DHARAN NAIR, ALENCHERIL HOUSE,
           CHOORAKODE, KALLADIKODE P.O, PALAKKAD, PIN -
           678596
    44     SHAMSEENA
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O SHAMSUDHEEN K.P, SHAMSEENA MANZIL, KAVIL
           PEEDIKA HOUSE, MANNUR, PIN - 602025
    45     HANNA ASHRAF
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O ASHRAF O.K, ORIPARAMBIL HOUSE,
           PERINGOTTUKARA, PIN - 680565
    46     HISANA M.S
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O SAINUDHEEN. M, MAMMANATHAYAL HOUSE, KALLOOR
           P.O, VADAKKAEKAD, PIN - 679562
    47     NAEHA
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O K.A KAMARUDHEENA, POKKAKILLATH HOUSE ,
           PANCHARAMUKKU, P.O CHAKAMKANDAM, PIN - 680522
    48     AYSHA SAMIYA
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O ABDUL SALIM, PANATTAKAYIL HOUSE, NATTIKA
           P.O, THRISSUR, PIN - 680566
    49     ANAGHA K.R
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                 9

           AGED 22 YEARS
           D/O RADHAKRISHNAN K.B, KAMBILY HOUSE, PATTIKKAD
           P.O, THEKKUMPADAM, THRISSUR, PIN - 680652
    50     STENY SAVIO
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O SAVIO ANTONY, NAMBUDAKATH HOUSE,
           SANTHIGIRI, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686580
    51     DON CYRIAC
           AGED 23 YEARS
           CYRIAC K.S, KALLUVELIL HOUSE, KURAVILANGAD P.O,
           PIN - 686633
    52     JUSTIN JIMMY MATHEW
           AGED 24 YEARS
           S/O JIMMY MATHEW PALATHOTHATHIL HOUSE,
           THODUPUZHA, PIN - 685581
    53     HANNA THUSSALAHA
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O ABDUL SALAM, PUTHENPURA KHAJA HOUSE,
           ERAMATHOOR P.O, MANNAR, PIN - 689622
    54     VARGHESE A.T
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O THOMAS A.Y, AREECKAL HOUSE, MEKKAD P.O,
           KARAKKATTUKUNNU, PIN - 683589
    55     ANU DAVIS
           AGED 25 YEARS
           D/O DAVIS K.P, KACHAPPILLY HOUSE, KOTTANELLUR
           P.O, PIN - 680662
    56     AYANA K PRAKASAN
           AGED 22 YEARS
           D/O PRAKSAN K.K, KARAVATT HOUSE, PARAPPUKKARA
           P.O, THRISSUR, PIN - 680310
    57     SOUMYA V.C
           AGED 25 YEARS
           D/O CHANDRASEKHAR, VETTATH HOUSE, EZHAKKAD,
           MUNDUR, PALAKKAD, PIN - 678631
    58     ANUSREE A.D
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O DAMODARAN M, ANJU NIVAS MUTHANGA, WAYANAD,
           PIN - 673592
    59     RESHMI P.R
           AGED 23 YEARS
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                 10

           RAVI V PULLIKATHARAYIL HOUSE, T.V PURAM P.O,
           VAIKOM, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686141
    60     RIMA RAHMAN
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O ABDURAHIMAN, PARUTHIKUTH HOUSE,
           THACHIGANDAM, PIN - 679325
    61     APARNA T
           AGED 23 YEARS
           THULASIDAS K.C, SNEHATHEERAM HOUSE, KARAD,
           PARAMBA P.O, PIN - 673632
    62     NAJMA JAHAN P.K
           AGED 24 YEARS
           S/O UMMER P.K, PANNIKKODAN HOUSE, NALLAMTHANNI
           P.O, PULLIYIL, KARULAI, NILAMBUR, PIN - 679330
    63     POOJA A.P
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O RAJESH P.P, PUNNATHOTTATHIL HOUSE,
           KIDANGHU, ORUMA 204/A, PERINTHALMANNA P.O, PIN
           - 679322
    64     NAZREEN T
           AGED 25 YEARS
           D/O THAJUDHEEN N, MANNATH, MELEDATH PARAMBA,
           THONICHIRA, NADUVATTOM, KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673015
    65     SHAHIM SIYATH
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O SIDIQUE T.S, THADIAN KOLLIL HOUSE, MUTTIL
           P.O, WAYANAD, PIN - 673122
    66     ADHIL K.P
           AGED 25 YEARS
           S/O ASHARAF K.P, KALAYAMKODU PARAMBIL HOUSE,
           MEPPADI, PIN - 673577
    67     SREYAS SURESH
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O SURESH BABU K.R, SREENILAYAM HOUSE,
           KANMANAM P.O, THUVAKKAD, TIRUR, MALAPPURAM, PIN
           - 676101
    68     AKHILA A.K
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O KESAVAN, AYINIKANDI, INDIYERIKUNNU,
           THETTAMALA P.O, WAYANAD, PIN - 670731
    69     FAHMIDHA YASMIN
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                 11

           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O ALAVIKUTTY C, CHOLAKKAL HOUSE, TIPPU NAGAR,
           V.K PADI, MAMPURAM P.O,, PIN - 673001
    70     MUFEEDA S
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O SHAJAHAN J, SHEEJA MANZIL, KUNNICODE P.O,
           AVANEESWARAM, PIN - 691508
    71     FATHIMA YOONUS
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O P.S YOONUSE, PERUMBETTIKKATTIL HOUSE, PIN -
           685553
    72     KEZIA THOMAS
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O THOMAS ABRAHAM, CHERAMPERIL HOUSE, MAALAM
           P.O, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686019
    73     SANDRA SURESH
           AGED 24 YEARS
           D/O SURESH V.T, THEKKEKUTTU HOUSE, KIDANGOOR
           P.O, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686572
    74     NIDHEESH TITUS
           AGED 22 YEARS
           S/O TITUS L, SANU NIVAS RAJAGIRI, SSTHAMCOTTA
           P.O, PIN - 690521
    75     JOAN MATHEW
           AGED 22 YEARS
           S/O MATHEW CHACKO, KIZHAKKEDATHU VEEDU,
           PANAVELY P.O, KOTTARAKKARA, PIN - 691532
    76     AMANUL MURSHID K.P
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O MUSTHAFA K.P, KURUDAM PARAMBIL HOUSE,
           PATTITHARA P.O, PALAKKAD, PIN - 679534
    77     ASHWIN P.S
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O SURESH BABU P.A, PALAKKAPARAMBIL HOUSE,
           MUNDAKKOTTUKURISSI P.O, SHORANUR, PALAKKAD, PIN
           - 679122
    78     RESHMA M.R
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O RAJAN, ERAVAKKAD P.O, PALAKKAD, PIN - 67955
    79     TONNY PRINSON
           AGED 23 YEARS
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                 12

           S/O C.M PRINSON, CHEERAN HOUSE, PAZHNJI P.O,
           THRISSUR, PIN - 680542
    80     SHILPA SHIVAN
           AGED 25 YEARS
           D/O SIVARAMAN CHARUVILAKIZHAKKATHIL,
           THURUTHIKKARA P.O, KOLLAM, PIN - 690540
    81     ANAKHA BAIJU
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O BAIJU C.G,CHIRATTAM PARAMBIL HOUSE,
           THIRUVANCHOOR, PIN - 68601
    82     JINU MARIYAM K
           AGED 22 YEARS
           S/O V.K KURIAN, LEENU BHAVAN, EAST KALLADA P.O,
           KOLLAM, PIN - 691502
    83     HELNAMOL A.S
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O SAHI ABRAHAM ALUNIKUNNUZHATHIL HOUSE,
           KUTTOOR P.O, THIRUVALLA, PIN - 68910
    84     NANDALAL S
           AGED 23 YEARS
           SURESH K, NANDANAM, PULLANICODE, POVARKALA, PIN
           - 695311
    85     AKSHAY KUMAR P
           AGED 24 YEARS
           S/O BABU P, PARAMBATH HOUSE, PUZHATHI, THERU
           P.O, CHIRAKKAL, KANNUR, PIN - 670011
    86     TIBIN
           AGED 22 YEARS
           S/O TOMY, PAZHUKUDIYIL HOUSE, THACHAMPARA P.O,
           PALAKKAD, PIN - 678593
    87     JASEENA P
           AGED 24 YEARS
           D/O SUBAIR P, PANGAT HOUSE, AC BAZAR,
           MOONNIYUR, PIN - 673637
    88     VARSHA C.R
           AGED 22 YEARS
           D/O RADHAKRISHNAN C, CHIRAKKATTUKUZHIYIL HOUSE,
           DESAMANGALAM P.O, PIN - 679532
    89     NAHEEDA K.P
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O NOUSHAD K.P, AGHAR VILLA, CHEROOTH THAZHAM
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                  13

               PALATH, PIN - 673611
    90         SUNU SEBASTIAN
               AGED 24 YEARS
               D/O SEBASTIAN JOSEPH KOCHUVEETTIL HOUSE,
               ADIVARAM, PIN - 686582
    91         ASIFALI ADAM P.H
               AGED 23 YEARS
               S/O HAMIDALI P.A, PERLA HOUSE, PERLA POST, PIN
               - 671552
    92         ASWATHY MOHAN
               AGED 23 YEARS
               D/O MOHAN, KAVANUTHARA MALAKUNNAM P.O,, PIN -
               686535
               BY ADVS.
               RAHUL SASI
               NEETHU PREM
               P.ARDRA MENON
               ALFIN NADARSHAW

RESPONDENTS:
    1    KERALA UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES
         REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR MEDICAL COLLEGE P.
         O THRISSUR, PIN - 680596
    2          THE VICE- CHANCELLOR
               KERALA UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES MEDICAL
               COLLEGE P. O THRISSUR, PIN - 680596
    3          THE CONTROLLER OF EXAMINATIONS
               KERALA UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES MEDICAL
               COLLEGE P. O THRISSUR, PIN - 680596
    4          THE PHARMACY COUNCIL OF INDIA
               COMBINED COUNCIL'S BUILDING KOTLA ROAD, AIWAN-
               E-GHALIB MARG NEW DELHI, PIN - 110002
               BY ADV MANU S. DSG OF INDIA


               SRI. P. SREEKUMAR, SC.

        THIS    WRIT   PETITION   (CIVIL)   HAVING   COME   UP   FOR
ADMISSION ON 01.12.2023, ALONG WITH WP(C).39472/2023 AND
CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                 14



          IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
                             PRESENT
             THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE T.R.RAVI
 FRIDAY, THE 1ST DAY OF DECEMBER 2023 / 10TH AGRAHAYANA,
                               1945
                    WP(C) NO. 37608 OF 2023
PETITIONERS:

    1      SAHANAS BEEVI VELLAMUNDA SAYYID
           AGED 24 YEARS
           D/O SAYYID ALI THANGAL, THANGALS HOUSE
           PARAKKAL, PALLIYATH, POOLAKKOL P.O, VATAKARA,
           KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673507
    2      SHAHANA THASNEEM
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O ASSAINAR, NANMANA HOUSE, MUYIPPOTH HOUSE,
           MAPPAYUR, PIN - 673524
    3      KEERTHANA P.M
           AGED 25 YEARS
           D/O GANGAN P.M, PULIYAMMAKKUL HOUSE, EDAKKARA,
           CHELANNUR, KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673616
    4      AARSHA V.V
           AGED 24 YEARS
           D/O SASEENDREN V.V, VADAKKE VAYAKKAL, VELUR
           P.O, ATHOLI, KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673315
    5      ARJUN P.J
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O P.K JAYAN PAINAKKUDIYIL HOUSE, KADAVOOR
           P.O, PANAMKARA., PIN - 686671
    6      AYGIN JOHNSON
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O JOHNSON T.T, THERMADOM HOUSE, ARANATTUKARA
           P.O, TRISSUR, PIN - 680618
    7      SHAHABAS SHAFI C.P
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O SHAFI K.P, MAHIJ'S HOUSE, KANNADIPARAMBA,
           KANNUR, PIN - 670601
    8      ANNUSREE K
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                 15

           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O ACHUTHAN K, KUTTIYIL HOUSE, ALATHIYOOR P.O,
           TIRUR, MALAPPURAM, PIN - 676102
    9      RINIMOL P.S
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O SEBASTIAN G, PANNITHURUTHUVELI HOUSE,
           CHERTHALA SOUTH P.O, ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 688539
    10     MUHAMMAD SHARUKH
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O MUHAMMED ANSARI, KAVUMMURIYIL HOUSE,
           CHUNKAPPARA, ALAPRA P.O, KOTTAYAM, PIN - 686544
    11     JASMINE
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O JOHN MATHEW, THOPPIL HOUSE, KAIPUZHA NORTH
           P.O, KULANADA, PATHANAMTHITTA, PIN - 689503
    12     FAHIMA K.S
           AGED 23 YEARS
           D/O SIRAJ, FAIZ MANZIL, NSC BOSE ROAD,
           PALAKKAD, PIN - 678001
    13     MOHAMMED AJMAL S
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O SHIHABUDEEN E, AJMAL MANZIL, VELLOOR,
           KOITHOORKONAM P.O, TRIVANDRUM, PIN - 695584
    14     FAWAS V
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O ABDUL SUNEER, VAZHAYIL HOUSE, VELLAMUNDA
           P.O, PIN - 670731
    15     ASHIN JOSEPH
           AGED 23 YEARS
           S/O JOJO JOSEPH, OZHUKAYIL HOUSE, EZHUKUMVAYAL
           P.O, IDUKKI, PIN - 685553
           BY ADVS.
           RAHUL SASI
           NEETHU PREM
           P.ARDRA MENON
           ALFIN NADARSHAW


RESPONDENTS:

    1      KERALA UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES
           REPRESENTED BY ITS REGISTRAR MEDICAL COLLEGE P.
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                  16

               O THRISSUR, PIN - 680596
    2          THE VICE- CHANCELLOR
               KERALA UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES MEDICAL
               COLLEGE P. O THRISSUR, PIN - 680596
    3          THE CONTROLLER OF EXAMINATIONS
               KERALA UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES MEDICAL
               COLLEGE P. O THRISSUR, PIN - 680596
    4          THE PHARMACY COUNCIL OF INDIA
               COMBINED COUNCIL'S BUILDING KOTLA ROAD, AIWAN-
               E-GHALIB MARG NEW DELHI, PIN - 110002
               BY ADV MANU S. DSG OF INDIA



        THIS    WRIT   PETITION   (CIVIL)   HAVING   COME   UP   FOR
ADMISSION ON 01.12.2023, ALONG WITH WP(C).39472/2023 AND
CONNECTED CASES, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
 [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]


                                 17


                            JUDGMENT

[WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]

In all these cases, the petitioners are students, who

want to attend the 8th semester course of the Bachelor of

Pharmacy (B Pharm) offered by the 1st respondent University.

They have not cleared the examinations in some of the

semesters. Reliance is placed on the Pharmacy Council of

India Regulations, which says that a student who has

successfully completed the semesters 1 to 4 is entitled to

carry forward the examinations of other semesters till the 8 th

semester. The Regulations issued by the University do not

permit such a course. As per the University Regulations, for

attending the 8th semester course, a student should have

passed in all the 7 semesters.

2. The only question is whether the Pharmacy Council

Regulations prevail over the University Regulations. The

University Regulations have not been challenged in these Writ

Petitions. Without the challenge towards the Regulations and

without a finding by a court of law that the Regulation is bad,

the prayer in the Writ Petition cannot be granted. [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]

3. The learned counsel for the petitioners submits

that the only reason for approaching this Court is for seeking

an indulgence, since the petitioners belong to the batch which

was affected by COVID-19 pandemic and hence, a leniency

should be shown to them. It is submitted that the leniency is

possible if instead of the University Regulation the Regulations

of the Pharmacy Council of India is considered as the one

applicable.

4. I do not think such a course of action is possible.

The remedy if at all for the petitioners is to approach the

University and Pharmacy Council of India for such a leniency.

The court cannot by exercising the discretionary power under

Article 226, pass orders, which are in violation of the

statutory Regulations.

In the above circumstances, these Writ Petitions fail and

the same are dismissed without prejudice to the right of the

petitioners to approach the University and Pharmacy Council

for considering their case leniently.

                                        Sd/-     T.R.RAVI,
                                                  JUDGE
lsn

[WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]

APPENDIX OF WP(C) 37059/2023

PETITIONER EXHIBITS Exhibit P1 TRUE COPY OF THE GENERAL COURSE REGULATION, 2017 FORMULATED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT UNIVERSITY IN RESPECT OF B. PHARM COURSE Exhibit P2 TRUE COPY OF THE TABULATION SHOWING THE TENTATIVE DATES OF EXAMINATIONS OF EACH SEMESTER AND THE ACTUAL DATE ON WHICH SUCH EXAMINATIONS WERE CONDUCTED IN RESPECT OF 2018 B. PHARM BATCH Exhibit P3 TRUE COPY OF THE TABULATION SHOWING THE DATES OF EXAMINATIONS OF EACH SEMESTER AND THE DATES WHEN THE RESULTS WERE PUBLISHED IN RESPECT OF 2018 B. PHARM BATCH Exhibit P4 TRUE COPY OF TABULATION SHOWING THE DATES WHEN 8TH SEMESTER EXAMINATION OF 2018 BATCHES OF B PHARM COURSES WERE CONDUCTED BY VARIOUS UNIVERSITIES IN INDIA Exhibit P5 TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATIONS OF FINAL YEAR/ SEMESTER EXAMINATION OF B PHARM COURSE OFFERED BY JAWAHARLAL NEHRU TECHNOLOGICAL UNIVERSITY, HYDERABAD, RAJIV GANDHI UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES, BENGALURU AND THE TAMIL NADU DR. M.G.R MEDICAL UNIVERSITY, CHENNAI Exhibit P6 TRUE COPY OF THE EXAM NOTIFICATION BEARING NO. 2022/17535/1/EX PHY/KUHS DATED 07.06.2022 Exhibit P7 TRUE COPY OF THE RULES AND SYBALLUS FOR B. PHARM COURSE FORMULATED BY THE 4TH RESPONDENT AUTHORITY Exhibit P8 TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED 16.08.2023 SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONERS HEREIN TO THE 1ST RESPONDENT [WP(C) Nos.39472/2023, 37059/2023, 37608/2023]

APPENDIX OF WP(C) 37608/2023

APPENDIX OF WP(C) 39472/2023

RESPONDENTS EXHIBITS: NIL

TRUE COPY

P.A TO JUDGE LSN