Mrs. Phebe M.Thomas vs Thiruvalla Medical Mission ...
2023 Latest Caselaw 8798 Ker

                IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
                                PRESENT
              THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.V.KUNHIKRISHNAN
     MONDAY, THE 14TH DAY OF AUGUST 2023 / 23RD SRAVANA, 1945
                        WP(C) NO. 27010 OF 2023
PETITIONER:

          MRS. PHEBE M.THOMAS
          AGED 40 YEARS
          NURSING SUPERINTENDENT, T.M.M HOSPITAL,
          (THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION) P.O. BOX NO. 74,
          THIRUVALLA, KERALA, NOW WORKING ON
          DEPUTATION AT ITS SISTER CONCERN T.M.MHOSPITAL,
          VAZHOOR , VAZHOOR P.O, KODUNGOOR,
          KOTTAYAM DISTRICT, PIN 686504.
          BY ADVS.
          TISSY ROSE K CHERIYAN
          ASHIKA JOSHY
          SHABNA.N


RESPONDENTS:

1 THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION HOSPITAL AT THIRUVALLA OWNED BY THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION P.O. BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, REPRESENTED BY ITS ADMINISTRATOR MR. GEORGE MATHEW, PIN - 689101 2 THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION REG.NO.54 OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O. BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA,, PIN - 689101 3 MR. BENNY PHILIP KATTUPARAMBIL HOUSE, MUTHOOR P.O, THIRUVALLA, SECRETARY, THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION,REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101 4 MR. JOHN BENJAMIN WP(C) NO.27010 OF 2023

EBEN EZER, ANDUPARAMBIL, NEAR BRETHREN CHURCH, PUTHUPALLY PO, KOTTAYAM, VICE CHAIRMAN, THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION,REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

5 MR. SUNNY THOMAS KARACKATTU HOME APPLIANCES, PAZHAVANGADI PO, RANNI, CHAIRMAN, THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION,REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

6 MR. GEORGE KOSHY KARIMKUTTICKAL, MYLAPRA TOWN P. O, JOINT SECRETARY, THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION,REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA. PIN 689101.

7 MR. EBBY GEORGE KADUTHANATHU HOUSE, THIRUVALLA , TREASURER, THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION,REG. NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

8 MR. RAJU THOMAS THOMBIL VADAKETHIL, PARIYARAM P.O, ELANTHUR, PATHANAMTHITTA, JOINT TREASURER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, WP(C) NO.27010 OF 2023

REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

9 MR. STANLEY MATHEW THOMAS KANNANKARA HOUSE, KUTTAPUZHA PO, THIRUVALLA, MEMBER, THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V.VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101..

10 MR. DENNY JOHN KENAKAYIL, NORTH JANATHA, YMJ ROAD, PALARIVATTOM, COCHIN MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O. BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

11 MR. PETER JOSEPH HOUSE NO 65, AMBAKUZHY PARK, ST MARTIN ROAD, PALARIVATTOM, MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

12 DR. ATTASSERIL REJI JOHNSON ATTASSERIL, VARAYANOOR, PULLAD, THIRUVALLA, MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, WP(C) NO.27010 OF 2023

THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN - 689101 13 MR. JACOB MATHEW V, 3/686 N, VEES VALLEY VILLAS, RUBBER BOARD PO, PUTHUPALLY, KOTTAYAM, MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

14 MR REJI SAM CHERIAN PARAYIL PUTHENVEEDU, KALLISSERY P.O, CHENGANNUR MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

15 MR JAISON JAMES PANANVILA, PARATTUKONAM ROAD, OPPO BSNL QUARTERS, NALANCHIRA, TRIVANDRUM, MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

16 MR. THOMAS JOHN HEBRON DOCTORS GARDEN, MEDICAL COLLEGE PO, TRIVANDRUM MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

WP(C) NO.27010 OF 2023

17 MR. SAJI MATHEW CHARTERED ACCOUNTANT, 50/555, GANDHI SQUARE ROAD,POONITHURA PO, OPPO. FEDERAL BANK, PETTA, KOCHI, MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

18 MR. BIJU ABRAHAM KADUTHATTU, CHAMAMPATHAL, VAZHOOR, KOTTAYAM DIST MEMBER, THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION,REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA , PIN 689101. 19 MR. DR JAISON J VALIAKULANGARA VALIAKULANGARA DENTAL CLINIC & IMPLANT CENTRE, VAIKOM, KOTTAYAM, KERALA, MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN - 689101 20 MR. JACOB CHERIAN VENKADATHU CHIRACKAL, PUTHUPALLY, KOTTAYAM, MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA , PIN 689101.

21 MR. T. JACOB ALEXANDER THEVARVELIL HOUSE, ETTICHUVADU P.O, WP(C) NO.27010 OF 2023

RANNI, MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

22 MR. TOBBY SKARIA THEKEKKARA HOUSE, PULICKAL KAVALA P.O, KOTTAYAM, MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

23 MR. ALEXKUTTY ABYSADAN, PARAKKARA, THATTA, ADOOR, MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101, PIN - 691525 24 MR. SUNNY T PHILIP P. O BOX NO 5, MALLASSERY , MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

25 MR ANIL RAJAN NO.31/12, SRI POORNANJANEYA LAY OUT, HBR, HENNUR ROAD, BANGLORE, MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, WP(C) NO.27010 OF 2023

PIN 689101.

26 MR. BIJU P VARGHESE PANAMOOTTIL HOUSE, CHALAKUZHY, AZHIYIDATHUCHIRA P.O, THIRUVALLA, MEMBER, THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION,REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O. BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

27 MR SAM ABRAHAM PARAYIL PARAYIL PUTHEN VEEDU, KALLISSERY PO, CHENGANNUR MEMBER, THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION,REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O. BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101. 28 MR. BINOD ELEMPLAKAL MATHAI MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN - 689101 29 MR. SABU ABRAHAM FLAT NO E3 JEWEL CROWN APARTMENTS, PALARIVATTOM, KOCHI MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN - 682025 30 MR. HAPPY MATHEW KILIROOPARAMPIL, PONKUNNAM P.O, WP(C) NO.27010 OF 2023

PONKUNNAM, KOTTAYAM MEMBER. THE DEWAN BAHADUR DR. V. VARGHESE HOSPITAL TRUST ASSOCIATION, REG.NO.54OF 1981 OF KOTTAYAM, THIRUVALLA MEDICAL MISSION, P.O.BOX NO. 74, THIRUVALLA, KERALA, PIN 689101.

THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 14.08.2023, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: WP(C) NO.27010 OF 2023

P.V.KUNHIKRISHNAN, J.

------------------------------ W.P.(C) No.27010 of 2023

---------------------------------------------- Dated this the 14th day of August, 2023

JUDGMENT

When this writ petition came up for

consideration, the learned counsel appearing for

the petitioner seeks permission to withdraw the

writ petition. Permission is granted.

Therefore, this writ petition is dismissed as

withdrawn with liberty to file it again.

Sd/-

                                    P.V.KUNHIKRISHNAN
DM                                         JUDGE