All Assam Health Centers Female ... vs Preeti Sudan And 3 Ors
2021 Latest Caselaw 2299 Gua

                                                                  Page No.# 1/59

GAHC010137782019




                              THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
   (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)

                               Case No. : Cont.Cas(C)/350/2019

            ALL ASSAM HEALTH CENTERS FEMALE ATTENDANTS ASSOCIATION
            REPRESENTED BY BINITA BAISHYA, AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS, PRESIDENT
            OF ALL ASSAM HEALTH CENTERS FEMALE ATTENDANCE ASSOCIATION,
            H.Q. DIGHALIOTI, P.O. SINGARI MADRASSA, P.S. JURIA, DISTRICT-
            NAGAON, ASSAM.



            VERSUS

            PREETI SUDAN AND 3 ORS.
            THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA, MINISTRY OF HEALTH AND
            FAMILY WELFARE DEPTT., NIRMAN BHAWAN, NEW DELHI- 110108.

            2:SAMIR KUMAR SINHA
             PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
             HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE (A) DEPTT.
             DISPUR
             GUWAHATI-6.

            3:HITESH DEV SARMA
            THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
             FINANCE DEPTT.
             DISPUR
             GUWAHATI-6.

            4:MALLIKA MEDHI
            ACS
            THE DIRECTOR OF HEALTH SERVICES (FAMILY WELFARE)
            ASSAM

Advocate for the Petitioner   : MR. M KHAN

Advocate for the Respondent : MR. S C KEYAL
                                      Page No.# 2/59




Linked Case : Cont.Cas(C)/164/2019

HASINA KHATUN AND 18 ORS.
W/O- MINHJAJ UDDIN MOLLA
VILL- RAVAR CHAL
P.O. AIRKATA
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

2: SAMILA KHATUN
W/O- SAIMUDDIN
VILL- NASHKORA
 DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
 PIN- 783330

3: ANJUMA KHATUN
W/O- AYZAL HOQUE
VILL- CHAL SHERSHO
P.O. BORKOLIA SHERSHO
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

4: JAMILA KHATUN
W/O- MIR AYNAL HOQUE
VILL- AIRKATA
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

5: SOFIA KHATUN
W/O- ABDUR RAHMAN
VILL- MOIRAKUCHI
P.O. AIRKATA
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

6: HAZERA KHATUN
W/O- ABDUL AWAL HUSSAIN
VILL- BASHMURA
                                 Page No.# 3/59

P.O. AIRKATA
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

7: MOMENA KHATUN
W/O- HASHEM ALI TALUKDAR
VILL- BORORAVATARI (GARUKATA)
P.O. BORORAVATARI
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

8: MAMTAZ BEGUM
W/O- ABDUL GAFFUR PARAMANIK
VILL- CHOTO CHIDNIRPAR
P.O. MEDERTARI
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

9: RASHIDA KHATUN
W/O- JOMIR UDDIN
VILL- POKHIA
P.O. MEDERTARI
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

10: ASIA KHATUN
ABDUL MANNAF
VILL- MATHAKATA
P.O. JAMADERHAT
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

11: SANTOBANU NESSA
W/O- ABDUL KARIM SHEKH
VILL- KHASHARTARI
P.O. CHIRAKUTI
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

12: NURJAHAN KHATUN
W/O- SABDER ALI
VILL- BAMUNERBHITA
                                Page No.# 4/59

P.O. MEDERTARI
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

13: SAKIRAN NESSA
W/O- MOKBUL HUSSAIN
VILL- NAYAPAROWA
P.O. CHIRAKUTI
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

14: ANOWARA KHATUN
W/O- ABDUL BASER SARKAR
VILL- MUTHAKHOWA PART-II
P.O. MUTHAKHOWA DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

15: LAILY BIBI
W/O- NUR ISLAM
VILL- CHAPGARH
P.O. KHUDIMARI
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

16: NABIA KHATUN
W/O- KHOIBAR ALI
VILL- CHILAIRPAR
P.O. CHILAIRPAR
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

17: MALEKA BIBI
W/O- MULLA SHEIKH
VILL- MADHUSOMARI PART-II
P.O. MADHUSOLMARI
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

18: SAHERA KHATUN
W/O- ABDUL KADER SARKAR
VILL- NAMACHALA
P.O. SUNDARPARA
                                                               Page No.# 5/59

DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330

19: NURUN NEHAR
W/O- SUKUR ALI
VILL- CHIRAKUTI
P.O. CHIRAKUTI
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783330
VERSUS

PREETI SUDAN AND 2 ORS.
SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA
HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE (RURAL HEALTH DIVISION)
NEW DELHI

2:SAMIR KUMAR SINHA
PRINCIPAL SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
 HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPTT.
 GHY-6
 DIST- KAMRUP (M)
 3:MALLIKA MEDHI
ACS
 DIRECTOR OF HEALTH SERVICES (FW) ASSAM
 SWASTHA BHAWAN
 HENRABARI
 GHY-36
 ------------

Advocate for : MR M H AHMED Advocate for : MR. S C KEYAL appearing for PREETI SUDAN AND 2 ORS.

Linked Case : Cont.Cas(C)/333/2019

PADUMI BARAH AND 23 ORS. W/O- TARANI BORAH VILL- KHATIKUCHI P.O- KHATIKUCHI DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781369

2: PARAMESWARI DEVI W/O- CHANDRANATH SARMA VILL- DIHJARI Page No.# 6/59

P.O- NANKARBHAIRA DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781369

3: FATEMA BIBI W/O- SAMSAR ALI VILL- KHATIKUCHI P.O- KHATIKUCHI DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781369

4: KHATUN BIBI W/O-AZIR ALI VILL- KHATIKUCHI P.O- KHATIKUCHI DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781369

5: MONOMATI BORO W/O- CHANDRA BORO VILL- TINPUKHURI P.O- TINPUKHURI DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781369

6: MAKULI BORO W/O- LATE MANESWAR BORO VILL- TENGABARI P.O- GHAGRAPAR DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781369

7: BINA DAS W/O- UMA KANTA DAS VILL- TAMULPUR P.O- TAMULPUR DIST- BAKSA ASSAM PIN-

8: MIRISSA BEGUM W/O- NURISLAM ALI VILL- MUKALMUA Page No.# 7/59

P.O- MUKALMUA DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781126

9: RANGMALA BEGUM C/O- AZMAD ALI VILL- MUKALMUA P.O- MUKALMUA DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781126

10: NURJAHAN BEGUM W/O- MD SHADULLAH VILL- KURHIAMAR P.O- KURHIAMAR DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781126

11: NURABJAN BEGUM W/O- MD. ANIL ALI VILL- SOKIRGHAT P.O- SOKIRGHAT DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781126

12: MAGJAN NESSA W/O- AMZAD ALI VILL- SHAULKHOWA P.O- LARKUCHI DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781126

13: ABALA KAIBARTA W/O- SRIKANTA KAIBARTA VILL- DARANGIPARA P.O- DARANGIPARA DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781126

14: MARIUM BEGUM W/O- MD. KABIL HUSSAIN VILL- MARUATTARI Page No.# 8/59

P.O- RAMPUR DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781126

15: PAIRAN NESSA W/O- HAMIT ALI VILL- KALARCHAR P.O- MUKALMUA DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781126

16: URU HALOY VILL- CHATAIMARI P.O- CHATAIMARI DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781126

17: BHAGABOTI CHAUDHURY W/O- NAREN CHOUDHURY VILL- KAPLABORI P.O- KAPLABORI DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781126

18: FATIMA BEGUM W/O- AFAHAR ALI VILL- BHANGNAMARI P.O- BHANGNAMARI DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781126

19: BIJAYA DUTTA D/O- LATE UTTAM CH DUTTA VILL- SANIROAD P.O- SANIROAD DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781126

20: DIPALI DUTTA W/O- JAGANATH DUTTA VILL- DAHODI P.O- SOLMORA Page No.# 9/59

DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781126

21: RENU RAMCHIARI W/O- PADMA RAMCHIARI VILL CHATAIBARI P.O- DHOMDOMA DIST- NALBARI ASSAM PIN- 781349

22: LAKHI MANDAL W/O- LATE PAARAN GOPAL MANDAL VILL NO. BAGRIKHUTI DIST- NALBARI PIN- 781368

23: SARMILA KALITA W/O- LATE SUREN KALITA VILL- TAMARKUCH P.O- TAMARKUCHI DIST- NALBARI PIN-

24: BIBHA BHARALI W/O- LATE CHATIN KALITA VILL- BARAGHAT DIST- NALBARI PIN- 781369 VERSUS

PREETI SUDAN AND 2 ORS SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF INDIA HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE (RURAL HEALTH DIVISION) NEW DELHI

2:SAMIR KUMAR SINHA PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPTT GHY- 6 DIST- KAMRUP(M) 3:MALLIKA MEDHI ACS DIRECTOR OF HEALTH SERVICES (FW) ASSAM SWASTHA BHAWAN HENGRABARI Page No.# 10/59

GHY- 36

------------ Advocate for : MR M H AHMED Advocate for : appearing for PREETI SUDAN AND 2 ORS

Linked Case : Cont.Cas(C)/252/2019

PANCHAMI BALA RAY AND 71 ORS. D/O- LT PHULO RAM RAY VILL- KAKAIJANA (KADOMTOLA) P.O. KAKAIJANA DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

2: AMBIYA KHATUN D/O- LT ABDUL HUSSAIN W/O- ABU BAKKAR SIDDIQUE VILL- GOLAPARA PART III EAST P.O. GOLAPARA DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783384

3: MINOTI RAVA D/O- LT NALIT CH. RAVA VILL- SANKARGHOLA P.O. CHALANTAPARA DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

4: SHUMITRA PATHAK W/O- BIPUL PATHAK VILL- KUMARIKATA P.O. CHALANTAPARA DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

5: BIJAY LAKSMI BARUAH W/O- NIBARAN CH. PATHAK VILL AND P.O. KHAGARPUR DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

6: SOFIA KHATUN W/O- FAZLUL HOQUE AHMED VILL- NAYASATRA P.O. NAYASATRA Page No.# 11/59

DIST- BANGAIGAON PIN- 783384

7: NALINI KALITA D/O- LT JAGENDRA KALITA VILL AND P.O. CHALANTAPARA DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

8: NURJAHAN BEGUM W/O- LT MOKSED ALI VILL- JHARPARA P.O. LENGTRISINGHA DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

9: CHAYATI RAY D/O- LT TARA RAM RAY VILL- PAKHIRIGURI P.O. SRIJANGRAM DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

10: AMINA KHATUN D/O- GARIBULLAH SEIKH VILL- DUMERGURI P.O. LENGTISINGA DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

11: ALIFA BEGUM W/O- HABIBAR ALI VILL- JOGIGHOPA P.O. JOGIGHOPA DIST- BANGAIGAON PIN- 783380

12: ELISA KHATUN D/O- DERAJ ALI VILL- NAYASATRA P.O. PIRADHORA DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

13: ANUSURA BEGOM D/O- ABDUL JUBBAR VILL AND P.O. LALMATI DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) Page No.# 12/59

PIN- 783380

14: REBINA BEGOM W/O- ABDUL KALAM AZAD VILL AND P.O. BARIGAON DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

15: HIRAPATI BARMAN W/O- DHIREN BARMAN VILL- BHAKUAMARI P.O. MALEGARH DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

16: ANITA NATH D/O- LT KAMINI KR. NATH VILL- RAGUNANDANPURI P.O. BOITAMARI DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

17: DIPALI BALA BARMAN D/O- SADISH CH. BARMAN VILL- BHUMKATARI P.O. SRIJANGRAM DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

18: SHUBHASHINI ADHIKARI W/O- KRISNA NANDA DAS VILL- SHONTOSHPUR P.O. SHONTOSHPUR DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

19: MALOTI BALA RAY W/O- KHIROD RAY VILL- CHARIPUNIA P.O. BOTGURI DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

20: KANCHAN BALA RAY W/O- MOTILAL RAY VILL- KERKHABARI P.O. NAYAGAON DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) Page No.# 13/59

PIN- 783380

21: CHARU BALA DAS D/O- LT KESHAB CH. SINGHA VILL AND PO. NAYAGAON DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

22: SAFURA KHATUN W/O- MIRAZUL HOQUE VILL- KACHARIPETI P.O. SRIJANGRAM DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN-

23: BISAKHA BALA MONDAL W/O- JAGAN NATH MONDAL VILL- DARIKINAMARI P.O. BOTGURI DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

24: NIYATI RAY W/O- NARAYAN RAY VILL- JALAKHATA

P.O. DHONTOLA BAZAR DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

25: SUMITRA ROY ON THE DEATH OF HER MOTHER NIRMALA BALA RAY D/O- LT MAHANDRA CH. RAY VILL- SINGIMARI P.O. NAYAGAON DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

26: MENAKA RAY D/O- HEM NARAYAN DEV VILL- PANCHAGAON P.O. BOITAMARI DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

27: AMENA KHATUN W/O- ABED ALI Page No.# 14/59

VILL- DHONTOLA P.O. DHONTOLA BAZAR

DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783384

28: MENAKA DAS W/O- LT BISWANATH DAS VILL- KATASHBARI .O. NAYAGAON DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

29: BHADRA BALA RAY W/O- UDOY CH. SARANIA VILL- BETBARI P.O. BANGAIGAON DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

30: SHYAMOLA CHAKRABARTY D/O- LT JOGESH CH. CHAKRABARTY VILL- ABHAYAPURI P.O. ABHAYAPURI DIST- BONGAIGAON (ASSAM) PIN- 783380

31: MINATI NARZARY VILL- PACHALABARI P.O. BETNAPARA DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783380

32: MANJULA BRAHMA VILL- AMTEKA P.O. AMTEKA DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

33: BILATI BASUMATARY VILL- BHADULIPARA P.O. BOROBAZAR DIST- BONGAIGAON ASSAM PIN- 783390 Page No.# 15/59

34: SUMILA BASUMATARY VILL- SILPATA P.O. NORTH KAJALGAON DIST- BONGAIGAON ASSAM PIN- 783390

35: MINAHA BASUMATARY VILL- NORTH KAJALGAON P.O. NORTH KAJALGAON DIST- BONGAIGAON ASSAM PIN- 783390

36: DIPALI BASUMATARY VILL- TILOKGAON P.O. BASUGAON DIST- BONGAIGAON ASSAM PIN- 783390

37: PRAMILA BRAHMA VILL- SOUTH KAZALGAON P.O. SIMLAGURI DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

38: JAMELA BEGUM VILL- BASHBARI P.O. SALABILA DIST- BONGAIGAON ASSAM PIN- 783390

39: PAINATI BALA RAY VILL- ALOUGURI P.O. ALOUGURI DIST- BONGAIGAON ASSAM PIN- 783390

40: BIDYABATI NARZARY VILL- DEOTARI P.O. BALLAMGURI

DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM Page No.# 16/59

PIN- 783390

41: MANJU BASUMATARY VILL- MALIPARA P.O. MALIPARA DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

42: RAHILA NARZARY VILL- SOUTH GANDABIL P.O. AMGURI DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

43: RADHIKA RAY VILL AND P.O. SONAIJHARA DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

44: URMILA BORO VILL- NORTH GARGAON P.O. BHALATOL DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

45: LAIMUTI BASUMATARY VILL- KUNGKRAJHARA P.O. KUNGKRAJHARA DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

46: RINU BALA RAY VILL- DOMPARA P.O. MANIKPUR DIST- BONGAIGAON ASSAM PIN- 783390

47: NIRODA BALA RAY VILL- NOWAPARA PART-1 P.O. MANIKPUR DIST- BONGAIGAON ASSAM PIN- 783390 Page No.# 17/59

48: SWAPNA BASUMATARY VILL- 2 NO. LADANGURI P.O. LADANGURI DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

49: ASHALATA DUTTA VILL- BANGALJHARA P.O. BANGALJHARA DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

50: ADARI GOYARY VILL- GERUKABARI P.O. MOUTARA DIST- BONGAIGAON ASSAM PIN- 783390

51: JAYANTI BASUMATARY VILL- CHOWRANG P.O. PANBARI DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

52: GITA RANI BASUMATARY VILL- KHAMARGURI P.O. BOROBAZAR DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

53: PUSHPA BALA OWARY VILL- DONGAIGAON P.O. SOUTH BIJINI DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

54: ANIMA BALA RAY VILL- SONAIKHALA P.O. SONAIKHALA DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM Page No.# 18/59

PIN- 783390

55: JAYANTI BALA RAY VILL- PUB KHAMARPARA P.O. BAGARGAON DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

56: MAICHANA NATH VILL- BORBILA P.O. MANIKPUR DIST- BONGAIGAON ASSAM PIN- 783390

57: BALATI BASUMATARY VILL- BISHPANI GUNDAMARA P.O. SILIKAGURI DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

58: DUBE BALA BARUAH

P.O. GERUKABARI DIST- BONGAIGAON ASSAM PIN- 783390

59: PRABHABATI DAS VILL- PATILADOHA (BORIPARA) P.O. PATILADOHA DIST- BONGAIGAON ASSAM PIN- 783390

60: JAYANTI BRAHMA VILL- PACHIM GUMURGAON P.O. PACHIM GUMURGAON DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

61: RIBATI MUCHAHARY VILL- KOPTULI P.O. HANCHORA DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) Page No.# 19/59

ASSAM PIN- 783390

62: MINA BASUMATARY VILL- KASHDAHA P.O. BHANDARA DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

63: BINABATI RAY VILL- ABADIPARA P.O. ABADIPARA DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

64: KAMINI BALA RAY VILL- NOYAPARA P.O. MANGALIAN DIST- CHIRANG (BONGAIGAON) ASSAM PIN- 783390

65: MEHBUBA ALAM C/O- M. ALAM (S/C) VILL- KLAMAR MANIKPUR P.O. KRSHNAI P.S. KRISHNAI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

66: DALIMI DAIMARY C/O- URJO DAIMARY (S/C) VILL- DHAIGAON P.O. DHAIGAON DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

67: CHITRA LEKHA RAY D/O- KAMALESWAR RAY (S/C) VILL- DOHIKATA P.O. RAJAPARA P.S. MORNOI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101 Page No.# 20/59

68: RAJU BALA RAY ALAM C/O- BISA RAM RAY (S/C) VILL- LALABARI P.O. LALABORI P.S. MARNAI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

69: ANJALI BALA DAS C/O- S. DAS VILL- MORNOI P.O. MORNOI P.S. MORNOI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

70: JAYEDA BEGUM C/O- LET NARAMASHIK VILL- BHALTAR GHAT P.O. KRISHNAI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

71: KUNTI BALA RABHA C/O- P. RABHA (S/C) VILL- SALPARA P.O. KRISHNAI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

72: JABEDA BEGUM @ BEWA C/O- SUEB ALAM (S/C) VILL- PAIKAN PART 2 (CHARIALI) P.O. GADHARBARI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101 VERSUS

PREETI SUDAN AND 2 ORS. SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE (RURAL HEALTH DIVISION) NEW DELHI Page No.# 21/59

2:SAMIR KUMAR SINHA PRINCIPAL SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPTT. GHY-6 DIST- KAMRUP (M) 3:MALLIKA MEDHI ACS DIRECTOR OF HEALTH SERVICES (FW) ASSAM SWASTHA BHAWAN HENRABARI GHY-36

------------ Advocate for : MR M H AHMED Advocate for : MR. D SAIKIA appearing for PREETI SUDAN AND 2 ORS.

Linked Case : Cont.Cas(C)/209/2019

ANDIBI NATH AND 77 ORS. C/O- LATE HOLIRAM NATH VILL- HOWLYGAON P.O- HOWLY DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781316

2: LAKSHMI BALA BORO C/O- BAHURAM BORO VILL- BENNIBARI P.O- HOWLY DIST- BARPETA BAKSA PIN- 781376

3: SAYEDA KHATUN C/O- MAHIR UDDIN AHMAD VILL- DABALIAPARA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781316

4: JANAKI BALA DAIMARY C/O- JHANESWAR MUSHAHARY VILL- MAYANGPARA P.O- BARANGABARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781318 Page No.# 22/59

5: NILA MUSHAHARY C/O- JHANESWAR MUSHHARY VILL- PALSIGURI P.O- SALBARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781318

6: SONO BANGSIHARI C/O- NAGEN BORO VILL- KACHUMARI P.O- GOLAGAON DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

7: KAMALA BORO C/O- RAMCHANDRA BORO VILL- MAIRAJHAR DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781315

8: BHARATI NATH C/O- DHANESWAR NATH VILL- PHULGURI P.O- BETBARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

9: RANJAN BORO C/O-BIREN BORO C/O- BIREN BORO VILL- JHEBAR P.O- KAMARDAISA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781330

10: JAYANTI GOYARI C/O- KAMESWAR GOYARI VILL- GOLAGAON P.O- GOLAGAON DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

11: RAHESWARI BORO C/O- GOLAK CHANDRA BORO VILL- PUB KHAGRABARI P.O- GOLAGAT DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327 Page No.# 23/59

12: ANIMA DAS C/O- BIPUL DAS VILL- NAUPUTA P.O- GOLAGAON DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

13: MINA KALITA C/O- NIRANJAN KALITA VILL- KURUBAHA P.O- KURUBAHA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781352

14: KANAKLOTA DAS C/O- DHIREN DAS VILL- BAGULAMARI P.O- BALAPET DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781317

15: RINA DAS C/O- PITAMBAR DAS VILL- KALITAPARA P.O- BHALUKA DABA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781317

16: RAJYA BALA ROY C/O- GAJENDRA ROY VILL- BHERBHERI P.O- BHULUKADOBA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781317

17: MANAMATI RAMCHIARY C/O- BHADRESWAR RAMCHIARY VILL- GOLAGAON P.O- GOLAGAON DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

18: NIRU BALA ROY C/O- DUGRU BORO VILL- GAMARIGURI P.O- GOBARDHANA DIST- BARPETA Page No.# 24/59

PIN- 781315

19: DALIMI MUSHAHARY C/O- DANIRAM MUCHAHARY VILL- KHATAJHARGAON P.O- KHATAJHAR PATAR DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781315

20: KALYANI BORO C/O- MEKHAR CHANDRA BORO VILL- GALIBANDA P.O- GALIBANDA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781375

21: SABITRI BASUMATARY C/O- LALBAHADUR RAMCHIARY VILL- GALIBANDA P.O- GALIBANDA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781375

22: URMILA NARZARY C/O- BALEN SARGIARY VILL- GALIBANDA P.O- GALIBANDA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781375

23: SHEWALI DAIMARY C/O- MAHAN SING BASUMATARY VILL- MAYANGPARA P.O- MAYANGPARA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781315

24: GAUTAMI SWARGIARY C/O- NIRANJAN SWARGIARY VILL- SAURAGURI P.O- KALPANI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781315

25: DHARITRI BAISHYA C/O- LATE GIRISWAR BAISHYA VILL- KALBARI P.O- BAGMARA Page No.# 25/59

DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781328

26: BINA KALITA C/O- CHAKRA KALITA VILL- BARALA P.O- CHARNA BAZAR DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781328

27: AKON PATHOARI C/O- PRABHAT DAS VILL- PASCHIM KAGRABARI P.O- JALAHGAT DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

28: MAHESWARI BORO C/O- PRAFULLA MEDHI VILL- BILPARA SILBARI P.O- BAMUNKHATA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

29: JAYANTI SARANIA C/O- NRIPEN SARANIA VILL- VEBLA P.O- JALAH DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

30: MINATI BORO C/O- LAKIKANTA BORO VILL- CHOGURI BUNMAZA P.O- BAMUNKHATA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

31: MANJULA BORONI C/O- RABINDRA BORO VILL- SANPARAR P.O- NIMUA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781318

32: SUCHITRA BORO C/O- SANESWAR BORO VILL- DAMUGAON Page No.# 26/59

P.O- SULIAKHATA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781311

33: SALEHA KHATUN C/O- AKABBAN ALI VILL- PITADIPAM P.O- PITADIPAM DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781352

34: LALBHANU C/O- SHAHAK ALI VILL- PITADIGAON P.O- NAGAON DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781311

35: BHANU NATH C/O- UDHAB NATH VILL- GALIA P.O- GALIA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781309

36: SABITA BALA DAS C/O- KALIKANTA DAS VILL- NALBARI P.O- JALAGAON DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781373

37: MANAMATI BALA NATH C/O- RAMANIMAHAN NATH VILL- RABANGURI P.O- BETBARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

38: JELEKA BHANU C/O- ISMAIL HUSSAIN VILL- RAUMARIGAON P.O- SENIMARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781305

39: HALIMA BEGUM C/O-NAIMUDDIN Page No.# 27/59

VILL- KUDRA BAMUNGURI P.O- SATLA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781312

40: KUMULI KALITA C/O- GANESH KALITA VILL- PEHURAKUA P.O- PULKADABA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781317

41: GIRI BALA NATH C/O- MAHAN NATH VILL- ATIABARI PAKALAGI P.O- RUPOHI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781318

42: DEBOJANI DAS C/O- LAKHESWAR DAS VILL- TAKURAKUCHI P.O- TAKURAKUCHI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

43: DAIBAKI DAS C/O- PRABHAT KALITA VILL- PACHIM KAGRABARI MEDHISUPA P.O- JALAGHAT DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

44: JASADA BASUMATARY C/O- UPEN BASUMATARY VILL- LAOGAON P.O- ODALGURI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781325

45: RABINA BEGUM C/O- ENNASH DEWAN VILL- GELABIL P.O- GUMAFULBARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781302

46: BIROZA PATGIRI Page No.# 28/59

C/O- DULAL PATGIRI VILL- MEDHIKUCHI P.O- HATINAPUR DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781325

47: PRIYALATA GAYARI C/O- JITENDRA NATH GAYARI VILL- UDUGAON P.O- NIMUA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781315

48: DHANSIRI MAHILARY C/O- ABHAY MAHILARY VILL- HAKUGURI P.O- BILASIPARA BAZAR DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781315

49: LATIKA BASUMATARY C/O- BAMUN BASUMATARY VILL- GAUMARA P.O- HALAGURIU DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781318

50: SAITYA BALA DAS C/O- HEBAL DAS VILL- DURAMARI P.O- DURAMARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781317

51: GIRI BALA DAS C/O- PITAMBAR DAS VILL- MAUTUPURI P.O- MAUTUPURI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781316

52: BINATI RAMCHIARY C/O- RATIKANTA BORO VILL- MARIPUR P.O- KARAGARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781307 Page No.# 29/59

53: PADUMI KALITA C/O- NARKANTA KALITA VILL- BANGLINGPARA P.O- BHABANIPUR DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781352

54: MENAKA DAS C/O- DHIRAJ DAS VILL- SAIBARI P.O- PUB RIHABARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781329

55: HASINA BEGUM C/O- JABDUSH SHUBUD VILL- HARIPUR P.O- GUMAFULBARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781302

56: BASANTI BASUMATARY C/O- BABUL BASUMATARY VILL- BARSUNGRI P.O- SHAWDARVITA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781325

57: NURJAHAN BEGUM C/O- AINAL HAQUE VILL- DATIRBARI P.O- SAPARBARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781352

58: CHANDRAPRABHA CHAUDHURY C/O- R CHAUDHURY VILL- GOLIA BHABANIPUR P.O- BHABANIPUR DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781352

59: RINABALA SHARKER (BISHWAS) W/O- SRI SAILENDRA SARKAR VILL- BAMUNDI P.O- ERA BAMUNDI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781311 Page No.# 30/59

60: AMINA BEGUM W/O- SAKET ALI DEWAN VILL- JATIKUSI P.O- BUDHAKUCHI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781309

61: SURIA BEGUM W/O- HASAN ALI VILL- ALIPUR P.O- KADONG BAZAR DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781314

62: MAZIDA BEGUM W/O- SHORIF UDDIN VILL- ADURIPARA P.O- KACHUMARA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

63: RABIA KHATUN W/O- SHAHAB UDDIN VILL- ANDAVANGA P.O- KACHUMARA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781127

64: ANOWARA KHATUN D/O- ARFAN ALI VILL- JOWKHATADIA P.O- DAKASUN DIST- KAMRUP PIN- 781136

65: JARINA KHATUN W/O- MOTIAR HUSEN MALLIK VILL- KURIHA P.O- KAYAKUCHI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781352

66: MALEKA BEGUM W/O- KALIM UDDIN VILL- KURIHA P.O- KAYAKUCHI DIST- BARPETA Page No.# 31/59

PIN- 781352

67: JAHIDA BEGUM W/O- ABDUL MALEQUE VILL- MORICHA P.O- KAYAKUCHI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781352

68: JAHANARA BEGUM W/O- ALI AKBAR MIRDA VILL- KAYAKUCHI PATHAR P.O- KAYAKUCHI PATHAR DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781305

69: CHABINI NATH W/O- CHOWARAM NATH VILL-DHUPGURI (KALBARI) P.O- SIMLAGURI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781313

70: SURATAN NESSA W/O- RAHMAT ALI MANDAL VILL- PUTHIMARI P.O- PUTHIMARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781727

71: MOIBHANU NESSA W/O- KABEJ ALI AHMED VILL- NIRALA P.O- NIRALA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781308

72: SAHERA KHATUN W/O- AJIZUL HOQUE VILL- HALANGAPARA P.O- KASHUMARA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

73: REJIA BEGUM W/O- SABED ALI VILL- MANCHORA P.O- KASHUMARA Page No.# 32/59

DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781327

74: ANIMA BORO C/O- KANAK CH BORO VILL- BATHOUPURI (FAKRIGURI) P.O- SALBARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781318

75: RAMBHA NATH C/O- SUREN NATH VILL- MARIPUR ANANDAPUR P.O- NITANANDA DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781329

76: DIPANTI DAS C/O- LAHIT DAS VILL- BARTARI P.O- SANAPULI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781318

77: MAILADA BARMAN C/O- PRABIN BARMAN VILL- MADULIJAR P.O- SUKSAKA BAZAR DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781317

78: JAMIRAN NEHAR C/O- JAMIR ALI VILL- NESHUKA P.O- KAIRABARI DIST- BARPETA PIN- 781315 VERSUS

PREETI SUDAN AND 2 ORS SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF INDIA HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE (RURAL HEALTH DIVISION) NEW DELHI

2:SAMIR KUMAR SINHA PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPTT GUWAHATI- 06 Page No.# 33/59

DIST- KAMRUP(M) 3:MALLIKA MEDHI DIRECTOR OF HEALTH SERVICES (FW) ASSAM SWASTHA BHAWAN HENGRABARI GHY- 36

------------ Advocate for : MR M H AHMED Advocate for : MR. D SAIKIA appearing for PREETI SUDAN AND 2 ORS

Linked Case : Cont.Cas(C)/303/2019

SUNITY BRAHMA AND 66 ORS. W/O. KHARONDRA BRAHMA VILL. DOLAGAON P.O. KARIGAON DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

2: REENA NARZARY GOGISHANKHAR NARZARY VILL. BESWARGAON P.O. RANGALIKHATA DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

3: RAMANTI BALA BRAHMA W/O. NAGENDRA BRAHMA VILL. BALLAMGURI P.O. BALLAMGURI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

4: DIBEESWARI MUCHAHARY

W/O. BROJEN MUCHAHARY VILL. PADMABIL P.O. AFLAGAON DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

Page No.# 34/59

5: MANJULA BALA BRAHMA D/O. AMRIT BRAHMA VILL. TULSIBIL P.O. TULSIBIL DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

6: NILIMA DEVI W/O. ROBILOCHAN NATH VILL. GENDRABIL P.O. RAINADABRI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

7: ARCHANA BRAHMA W/O. MUKUL GOYARY VILL. SIMLAGURI P.O. DOTMA DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

8: SMT. DINO BALA GOYARAY W/O. CHANDRA SING GOYARY VILL. NEW ISLAMPUR P.O. KACHARIGAON DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

9: KESHBHAN NESSA D/O. KESHAR ALI VILL. TITILIGURI P.O. DOTMA DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

10: BINA RANI BRAHMA W/O. SURENDRA BRAHMA VILL. NORTH RAMFALBIL P.O. NORTH RAMFALBIL DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

Page No.# 35/59

11: NITYA MOYEE KOCH D/O. AMORENDRO KOCH VILL. KOLOBARI (ANTHAIBARI) P.O. SERFANGURI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

12: KHADEJA KHATUN W/O. MOINUL HOQUE VILL. BAMUNIGAON P.O. SAPATGRAM DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

13: NURULA RANI NARA

W/O. LT. SOJANI ADHIKARI VILL. CHOUTARA P.O. BHAORAGURI (AMIAKATA) DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

14: RANGMALA MANDAL W/O. JAYANATH MANDAL VILL. PURBA DAMGAON P.O. BENGTAL DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

15: SMT. JOYMOTI NARZARY W/O. KODEN NARZARY VILL. BALAPARA P.O. TUKRAIJHRA DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

16: PRATIMA MUCHAHARY

W/O. NISHIKANTA MOSHAHARY VILL. PUTHIMARI P.O. PUTHIMARI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM Page No.# 36/59

PIN-783370.

17: FWRMAITHI BRAHMA W/O. GOLAP BRAHMA VILL. AFLAGAON P.O. AFLAGAON DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

18: DULESWARI BASUMATARY W/O. SANTALA BASUMATARY VILL. PATHARGAON P.O. RANCHAIDHAM DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

19: TARA KUMARI DEVI W/O. WHITE BAHADUR CHETRY VILL. HARINAGURI P.O. CHARAIKHOLA DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

20: NIRUPAMA BRAHMA W/O. SABINDAR BRAHMA VILL. LAODONGA P.O. LAODONGA DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

21: BEBI RANI BRAHMA D/O. LT. SAMJIR BRAHMA VILL. JOGDAI P.O. SAPATGRAM DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

22: PRAMILA BRAHMA W/O. LT. LOKENDRA BRAHMA VILL. DUDUMARI P.O. SAPTGRAM DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM Page No.# 37/59

PIN-783370.

23: ANOWARA BEWA W/O. LT. NIJAMUDDIN VILL. KALJHAR DURAMARI P.O. FOKIRAGRAM DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

24: PRAMESWARI BASUMATARY D/O. LT. PAZARAM BASUMATARY VILL. SILAMARI P.O. SERFANGURI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

25: PRATIMA BISWAS W/O. AKHIL BISWAS VILL. KATHALPARA P.O. KATHALPARA DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

26: MASHABI JABIZAN NESSA W/O. ADUS SABUR MIAH VILL. BALAPARAI P.O. SAPATGRAM DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

27: JOSHILA BASUMATARY W/O. THANESWAR BASUMATARY VILL. ATHIABARI P.O. ATHIABARI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

28: MANESWARI MUCHAHARY W/O. LANKESWAR MUCHAHARY VILL. GHORAMARA P.O. CIKADAMI BATABARI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM Page No.# 38/59

PIN-783370.

29: DIPALI BASUMATARY W/O. PHUREN BASUMATARY VILL. MAHENDRAPUR P.O. JHARBARI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

30: DRAUPODI BALA BRAHMA W/O. SURESH BRAHMA VILL. BAGHMARA P.O. DUMURIGURI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

31: JASHODA BALA BASUMATARY D/O. LT. THANESWAR BASUMATARY VILL. BONSUMGURI P.O. JHARBARI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

32: JUSHILA MURMUR W/O. BHAIROF HASDA VILL. PAKHRIGURI P.O. SERFANGURI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

33: MARIUM KATUN W/O. KALILUR RAHMAN VILL. USHATARI P.O. TULSIBIL DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

34: BIROLA NARZARY W/O. VILL. BASHBARI P.O. BISHMURI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

Page No.# 39/59

35: TORULATA BARUAH W/O. LT. BIREN BARUAH VILL. MAJPARA P.O. TITAGURI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

36: HAZIRA BIBI W/O. ABUBAKKAR SHEIKH VILL. RIMIJIMIGHAT P.O. AMINKATA DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

37: SELONI TUDU D/O. KUAR TUDU VILL. SIMOLDOHI P.O. SRIAPUR DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783361.

38: NIRULA MUSHAHARY C/O. SOMBARU NARZARY VILL. BONGAON P.O. RAIMARA DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-78335.

39: RANJILA BASUMATARY VILL. GONGIA P.O. GONGIA DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783350.

40: RAHELA ISWARY W/O. BISTO ISWARY VILL. RAIMONA P.O. RAIMONA DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-7833750.

Page No.# 40/59

41: ASHALOTA KISU VILL. SATYAPUR P.O. SATYAPUR DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783360.

42: BIJULI NARZARY VILL. SINGIMARI P.O. SATYAPUR DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783360.

43: JOYMATI BASUMATARY W/O. PRODIP BASUMATARY VILL. BOROBADHA P.O. JOYMA BANAR DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783360.

44: NILIMA MURMU C/O. BABULAL MURMU VILL. NISAPUR MECH PARA P.O. FACLAOGURI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783333.

45: MUNJU SARKAR C/O. LT. MANTU SARKAR VILL. THAKURPUR P.O. DINGDINGA DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783333.

46: RASHMI BESRA C/O. BIREN BESRA VILL. KARIKOR P.O. BAIRALI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783350.

47: BARDAWI BRAHMA (NARZARY) Page No.# 41/59

C/O. MWKTORG BRAHMA R/O. WARD NO.3 KOKRAJHAR TOWN P.O. KOKRAJHAR DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

48: RUBASHI BRAHMA (BASUMATARY) C/O. UMESH VILL. UTTAR LATAGAON ACHEDAMARI P.O. KALIPUKHURY DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

49: BIBHA RANI BRAHMA D/O. LT. THRENDRA BRAHMA VILL. DALOABARI P.O. DALOABARI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

50: BHAROTI BRAHMA C/O. NOGEN BRAHMA VILL. KHAGRABAR P.O. BANARGAON DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783347.

51: NIRMOLA BRAHMA C/O. MALAY BRAHMA VILL. BASANGAON (BALABARI) P.O. KARIGAON DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783373.

52: KUMARI NARZARY C/O. KHIREN BASUMATARY VILL. BESORBARI P.O. OUGURI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

Page No.# 42/59

53: BASIRON KHATUN W/O. ABDUS SABUR VILL. NANGAL BHANGA P.O. JAIPUR DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783393.

54: ANJUWARA BEGUM W/O. AZIZUR RAHMAN VILL. JAOLIAPARA P.O. SIMOLGAON DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

55: HARIBATI BRAHMA C/O. NOKORSING BRAHMASA VILL. ULTAPANI P.O. ULTAPANI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

56: HERANYAMOYEE BRAHMA VILL. SURJYAKALA P.O. DUMURIGURI DIST. KOKRAJHAR ASSAM PIN-783370.

57: MAZITAN BIBI W/O. SATTAR ALI VILL. SHILBARI P.O. SHILBARI DIST. KOKRAJHAR PIN-783370.

58: MANDIRA CHAKRABARTY C/O. MADHUSUDAN CHAKRABARTY VILL. BHADAIGURI P.O. BHAIGURI DIST. KOKRAJHAR PIN-783360.

59: DIPALI ROY BARMAN W/O. MANTU ROY BARMAN VILL. AND P.O. ANTHAIBARI Page No.# 43/59

DIST. KOKRAJHAR PIN-783360.

60: MIRA NARZARY W/O. NISARU NARZARY VILL. NO.1 TUKRAJHAR P.O. TUKRAJHAR DIST. KOKRAJHAR PIN-7833670.

61: NAKUL BALA DEBI W/O. HORIPODO ROY BAGRIBARI P.O. BAGRIBARI DIST. KOKRAJHAR PIN-783348.

62: SOFIYA KHATUN W/O. FAZAR ALI VILL. KAISHABARI P.O. BAGRIBARI DIST. DHUBRI ASSAM PIN-783348.

63: SAHERA BANU W/O. AFAZUDDIN VILL. MASHANER ALGA P.O. SOAPATA PART-II DIST. DHUBRI ASSAM PIN-783348.

64: HAZERA BIBI W/O. HAKIM UDDIN VILL. TAMAKUBARI P.O. BARKANDA DIST. DHUBRI ASSAM PIN-783348.

65: HOWABI BEGUM W/O. EBAD AQLI SHEIKH VILL. PATAKATA PARTA-II P.O. BAGRIBARI DIST. DHUBRI ASSAM PIN-783349.

Page No.# 44/59

66: HAOWA KHATUN VILL. PANBARI PART-II P.O. PANBARI DIST. DHUBRI ASSAM PIN-783349.

67: RAHIMA KHATUN W/O. ABDUS SABUR MANDAL VILL. KAJAIKATA PART-V P.O. KAJAIKATA DIST. DHUBRI ASSAM PIN-783348.

VERSUS

PREETI SUDAN AND 2 ORS. SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA HEALTH AND FAMILY WELLFARE (RURAL HEALTH DIVISION) NEW DELHI.

2:SAMIR KUMAR SINHA PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE DEPTT. GUWAHATI-06 DIST. KAMRUP(M). 3:MALLIKA MEDHI ACS

DIRECTOR OF HEALTH SERVICES (FW) ASSAM SWASTHA BHAWAN HENRABARI GHY.-36.

------------ Advocate for : MR M H AHMED Advocate for : MR. D SAIKIA appearing for PREETI SUDAN AND 2 ORS.

Linked Case : Cont.Cas(C)/86/2019

HALESWARI BASUMATARY AND 71 ORS. C/O- THANESWAR BASUMATARY VILL- THORKO NOLJHAR P.O- POMISHALI P.S- LAKHIPUR DIST- GOALPARA Page No.# 45/59

ASSAM PIN- 783129

2: KANCHAN BORO C/O- BISHAN CH BORO VILL- JOYRAMKUCHI P.O- JOYRAMKUCHI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783129

3: DRAPATI BASUMATARY C/O- GAJENDRA BASUMATARY VILL- RANGATARI P.O- POMISHALI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783129

4: RABIA KHATUN D/O- HATEM ALI VILL- TAKIMARI P.O- TAKIMARI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783129

5: RUBILA BASUMATARY D/O- MAHIN BASUMATARY VILL- RANGATARI P.O- POMISHALI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783129

6: KAIMA RABHA D/O- SURENDRA RABHA VILL- BORJHARA P.O- BAIDA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783129

7: GAUTAMI RABHA D/O- RANJIT RABHA VILL- DEPALCHANG P.O- DEPALCHANG DIST- GOALPARA Page No.# 46/59

ASSAM PIN- 783129

8: RAYANTI RABHA D/O- BARKHARAM RABHA VILL- MALADHARA P.O- MALADHARA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783129

9: NURJA KHATUN D/O- LUTFOR RAHMAN D/O- LUTFOR RAHMAN VILL- SANAMAYEE P.O- AWLATALI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783129

10: PRATIMA ADHIKARI W/O- JAGADISH ADHIKARI VILL- HOTOGAON P.O- DHAMOR DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783129

11: BINA BALA PAUL W/O- KANAI LAL PAUL VILL- TULSHIBARI P.O- TULSHIBARI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783129

12: ANOWARA KHATUN W/O- AYNAL HOQUE VILL- SUPARIVITA P.O- TULSHIBARI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783129

13: MINATI KOCH W/O- SURJYA KOCH VILL- HASHDOBA DIST- GOALPARA Page No.# 47/59

ASSAM PIN- 783129

14: ASMA KHATUN W/O- ABDUL JOLIL VILL- SHIMULBARI P.O- AWLATOLI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783129

15: JABEDA KHATUN W/O- MOZIBOR ROHMAN VILL- MOZIDNOGOR P.O- AMLATOLI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783129

16: HEMLOTA DAS W/O- BEREN DAS VILL- BAPUJI NAGAR P.O- BALADNAU DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

17: TERAMIBALA RABHA W/O- CHARAN RABHA VILL- NALANGA RABHA VILL- NALANGA PAHARTOLI P.O- BORDAMAL DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783120

18: CHILA RABHA W/O- NIRDEY RABHA VILL- KARUABHASA P.O- BHALUKDUBI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

19: ALIZA BEGUM D/O- GIYASUDDIN VILL- BALIPARA P.O- GOALPARA Page No.# 48/59

DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

20: MULUDA BEGUM D/O- JAMSHED ALI VILL- AZAD NAGAR P.O- GOALPARA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

21: SABITRI BALA BAROI SARKAR W/O- BIMAL SARKAR VILL- KHAGRABARI P.O- BALBALA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

22: NIBHA RANI RABHA W/O- AKON RABHA VILL- DHARANI P.O- BARDAMAL DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783120

23: NIROLA MARAK D/O- ARELENDRO MOMIN VILL- KIRABOLA P.O- BALBOLA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

24: SUCHITRA BALA DAS W/O- HEREMBO KR. DAS VILL- DARKA P.O- DARKA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

25: HEMANI BALA NATH W/O- GOPINATH RABHA VILL- ROKHAPARA P.O- AGIA Page No.# 49/59

DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

26: PROMESWARI RABHA W/O- HAHDEV RABHA VILL- LEMPARA P.O- MARKULA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783120

27: MAYLATA RABHA W/O- JAPTAK RABHA VILL- BAMUNDONGA P.O- MALADHARA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783120

28: SIMAI RABHA W/O- MUKUL RABHA VILL- NADIA PARA P.O- BARGHATA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

29: BASIRON NESSA W/O- MOKBUL HUSSAIN VILL- GODHABARI P.O- BALBALA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783120

30: HAWA KHATUN W/O- AZAHAR ALI VILL- BANGALJHAR P.O- BANSBARI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783120

31: PRENALINA SANGMA D/O- RONGDHONG MARAK VILL- DAORINGPA P.O- AGIA Page No.# 50/59

DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783120

32: KANDI RABHA W/O- PUPHA RABHA VILL- SARAPARA P.O- BORDAMAL DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

33: DAYBOKI RABHA W/O- AMULLY RABHA VILL- HATIGAON P.O- SOARMARI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783120

34: TARA BALA RABHA VILL- DORANI P.O- BARDAMAL DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783120

35: SOFIA KHATUN W/O- JOYNAL ABDIN VILL- KETLETARY P.O- AMBARI BAZAR DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783120

36: AZIRON NESSA W/O- FOIZUDDIN VILL- TIAPARA P.O- JOYPUR DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783120

37: KANCHAN NATH W/O- NARESWAR NATH VILL- NABILABORI P.O- BAKAITARY DIST- GOALPARA Page No.# 51/59

ASSAM PIN-

38: JANAKI BALA SARMA C/O- TIKEN CH SARMA VILL- BAKAITARY P.O- BAKAITARY DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN-

39: SADHANA RABHA C/O- EARAHI RAM RABHA VILL- KHAMRI P.O- MONDEGANJ DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783126

40: NIRUPAMA DEVI D/O- LATE SATISH CH ROY VILL- HATIGAON P.O- TUKURA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783126

41: SABHESWARI BALA RABHA D/O- DUBA RAM RABHA VILL- RONGPATHAR P.O- DUDHNOI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783126

42: FIRIGINA MARAK C/O- DIZEN MARAK VILL- RAKHASHINI P.O- BALADMARI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783101

43: BANTI BALA RABHA D/O- KARINE CH RABHA VILL- BELPARA P.O- RISU BELPARA DIST- GOALPARA Page No.# 52/59

ASSAM PIN- 783126

44: NUMOLI RABHA W/O- LATE HARISH CH RABHA VILL- DABLI P.O- BELA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783124

45: DAWALI RABHA W/O- COMET RABHA VILL- HALIMURA P.O- CHOTARYTIA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783126

46: NIROLA RABHA C/O- PUSHPA RAM HATO RABHA VILL- CHARAK PARA P.O- CHOTO MATIA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783126

47: DIPALI BALA RABHA VILL- DAIRONG MADAPARA P.O- KHARDANG DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783126

48: RAJU BALA RABHA C/O- BISARAM RABHA VILL- LALABORI P.O- LALABORI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783126

49: MINOTI RABHA VILL- CHONIMARI P.O- CHOTOMATIA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783126 Page No.# 53/59

50: SURISHI RABHA VILL- BAMUNI PANIKHOWA P.O-

DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783126

51: DEVAJANI DEVI ROY D/O- DENESH CH ROY VILL- FAFAL P.O- DUDHNOI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783124

52: HIRON HAJOUARY VILL- SARANIAPARA P.O- MOLOPARA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783124

53: JARMESWARI RABHA D/O- BHAKTESWARI RABHA VILL- JAKUAPARA P.O- DARANGIRI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783134

54: SUPROVA PATGIRI W/O- DOMBARU DHAR PATGIRI VILL- SACHIBARI P.O- BAGOBBO DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783123

55: TAJO BALA RABHA VILL- AMBUK MAJ PARA P.O DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783128

56: SAWALI BALA RABHA D/O- JATIN RABHA Page No.# 54/59

VILL- NABANGIRI P.O- DAMRA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783122

57: JAMINI BASUMATARY W/O- RABIN BASUMATARY VILL- BAGUANARY P.O- LALA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783124

58: PROBHATI DAIMARI VILL- SAIPARA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783130

59: DROPOTI BORO VILL DEGOLI P.O- DEGOLI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783123

60: HIRONI BASUMATARY C/O- LAKAHNI KT KHAKLARY VILL- KHARACHKALPARA P.O- DUDHNOI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783123

61: RASHA BALA KHAKLARY VILL- CHECHAPANI P.O DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783130

62: SUCHITRA BALA RABHA W/O-KIRAN RABHA VILL- MALAM P.O- KOTHAKUTHI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM Page No.# 55/59

PIN- 783123

63: PADMABOTI RABHA D/O- BIPIN CH RABHA VILL- KANYAKUCHI P.O- KAHIBARI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783130

64: ELABOTI NATH VILL- ATHIABARI P.O- DARRANGIRI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783123

65: LOHITA MASHARI W/O- BASANTA KOCHARI VILL- ROWMARI P.O- RANGJULI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783130

66: GOGANATH C/O- BINOD NATH VILL- AMJONGA P.O- AMJONGA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783124

67: NORMODA KOCHARI C/O- MOMAN CH KOCHARI VILL- BOKHARAPARA P.O DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN-

68: NILIMA DAS W/O- NAGEN DAS VILL- CHAPLAI P.O- BAGOOBA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783123 Page No.# 56/59

69: PUTULI RABHA C/O- SORA CH RABHA VILL- SILUK P.O- SILUKPARA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783122

70: SABBA KHAKLARY VILL- GATHIYA PARA P.O- DHUPDHARA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783130

71: DROPOTI BALA BORO VILL- PUTHIMARI P.O- BAGDUBA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783123

72: ROMULA BALA BORO C/O- MOTIYA RAM BORO VILL- POTIMARI P.O- BAGDHOBA DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783123

73: LASHBOTY SANGMA VILL- NISUNGRAM P.O DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783124

74: SOKINA KHATUN W/O- ROSTOM ALI VILL- BARPATHAR P.O- TIPLAI DIST- GOALPARA ASSAM PIN- 783130 VERSUS

PREETI SUDAN AND 2 ORS Page No.# 57/59

SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF INDIA HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE (RURAL HEALTH DIVISION) NEW DELHI

2:SAMIR KUMAR SINHA PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM HEALTH ND FAMILY WELFARE DEPTT GUWAHATI- 06 DIST- KAMRUP (M) 3:MALLIKA MEDHI ACS DIRECTOR OF HEALTH SERVICES (FW) ASSAM SWASTHA BHAWAN HENGRABARI GHY- 36

------------ Advocate for : MR M H AHMED Advocate for : appearing for PREETI SUDAN AND 2 ORS

BEFORE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA

ORDER Date : 24.09.2021

All sides are duly represented by their learned counsel.

Ms. P. Das, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Mr. S.C. Keyal, learned counsel for the respondent no. 1 prays for some time to obtain instruction as to whether the respondent no.1 is still in office.

Mr. B. Gogoi, learned standing counsel for the Health Department submits that the present incumbent to the post of Principle Secretary to the Govt. of Assam, Health and Family Welfare Department is Mr. Anurag Goyal, IAS and the Page No.# 58/59

present incumbent to the post of Director of Health Services, (Family Welfare), Assam is Munindra Nate, ACS.

The learned counsel for the petitioner shall take note of the same and take appropriate steps by putting the new incumbent to notice of requirement to comply with the directions contained in the common judgment and order dated 23.10.2017 passed in WP(C) 900/2012 and connected cases.

The learned counsel for the respondent nos. 2 and 3 has submitted upon instruction that the State government is in the process of finalizing payment to all the female attendants and the total remuneration to be paid to all the female attendants would be about Rs.69,79,15,909/- @ Rs.900/- per month per female attendant and therefore, the State is taking sometime to provide for adequate resources to satisfy the said payment. It is submitted that the recently the file has been sent to the learned Advocate General for the State for his opinion and only thereafter, appropriate directions can be issued by the State government. Accordingly, the learned counsel for respondent nos. 2 and 3 submits that although the said respondents are no longer in office, but he would be in a position to apprise this Court about the further development in the matter.

Mr. M.H. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioner in Cont.Cas(C) 209/2019 has brought to the notice of the Court the order dated 17.03.2021 wherein this Court had granted one last opportunity to the respondents to take appropriate steps and measures, failing which it was indicated that the Court would be inclined to pass appropriate orders. The respondents shall take note of the said order and expeditiously take appropriate steps.

It is made clear that if the said common judgment and order dated 23.10.2017 passed in WP(C) 900/2012 is not complied with, the Court on the Page No.# 59/59

next date would proceed further in the matter on merit.

List on 12.11.2021 along with Cont.Cas(C) 340/2019 and Cont.Cas(C) 550/2019.

JUDGE

Comparing Assistant