The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (Central District) of Delhi, on Monday, ordered Emami Limited to pay a fine of Rs 15 lakh for making misleading claims regarding its “Fair and Handsome” fairness cream. The complaint, filed by Nikhil Jain in 2013, accused the company of advertising that its product would deliver fairness in just three weeks, even though these claims were unsupported by any concrete evidence and failed to mention necessary conditions for the product’s effectiveness.
The Commission, consisting of President Inder Jeet Singh and member Rashmi Bansal, found that the advertisements and packaging of the cream were deceptive, violating consumer rights. It concluded that the instructions on the product packaging were insufficient and misleading, as they promised fairness through regular use without mentioning the other factors required for achieving the stated results.
In its order, the Commission highlighted the inadequacy of the information provided to consumers, noting: "The conclusions drawn above, makes it crystal clear that the OP (Emami) is offering the product – Fair and Handsome cream with few, negligible and limited instructions on the packaging and labelling that its regular use for three weeks will result in fairness in the skin of man, despite knowing that instructions mentioned are incomplete instructions and for want of following the other requirements, it will not give the result claimed."
Emami’s defense centered on the argument that its product was scientifically tested and adhered to quality controls. The company claimed that its fairness results could vary based on individual factors like diet, exercise, and lifestyle choices. However, the consumer forum dismissed this, pointing out that the product's packaging failed to mention these additional requirements, leading to misleading expectations for consumers. The court also remarked, "A reasonable/average intelligent customer will also take the convincing impression that by following those exclusive instructions mentioned on the package, it would give the results claimed on the product."
This is not the first time Emami has faced legal repercussions for its marketing tactics. In 2015, the same consumer court ruled in favor of the complainant, imposing a Rs 15 lakh fine. However, the decision was overturned after an appeal, and the case was sent back for a fresh hearing. In the latest ruling, the Commission has ordered Emami to pay Rs 14.5 lakh to the Delhi State Consumer Welfare Fund and Rs 50,000 in compensation to Jain. Additionally, Emami has been directed to pay Rs 10,000 towards Jain's litigation costs.
The court further ordered Emami to immediately withdraw all advertisements, packaging, and promotional materials that make unsubstantiated claims about the fairness cream. This includes the use of misleading visuals and endorsements, particularly those featuring brand ambassadors, as the company’s marketing strategy failed to disclose the incomplete nature of the product's instructions.
Picture Source :
