Punam Mishra vs The State Of Jharkhand
2023 Latest Caselaw 715 Jhar

             IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
                          W.P.(S) No. 5344 of 2017
1.    Punam Mishra
2.    Tuhin Kanti Kundu
3.    Champa Mandal
4.    Sukhen Kr. Mandal
5.    Md. Abdul Kayum
6.    Fahmina Khatun
7.    Enamul Hoque
8.    Md. Anjarul Shaikh
9.    Md. Rofikul Islam
10.   Md. Nurul Hoque
11.   Md. Mahbubur Rahman
12.   Ajajul Haque
13.   Rakib Shekh
14.   Satyen Mandal
15.   Md. Wajibul Haque
16.   Mukhtar Hussain @ Mokhtar Hossen
17.   Ismail Haque
18.   Md. Saidur Rahman
19.   Md. Alauddin
20.   Md. Daud Hussain
21.   Ruksana Sultana
22.   Md. Alauddin
23.   Manarul Hoque
24.   Md. Habibur Rahman
25.   Mousumi Ghosh
26.   Tumpa Das
27.   Gaurango Sarkar
28.   Md. Faruque Ahmad
29.   Alauddin Shaikh
30.   Md. Safikul Alam
31.   Khadija Khatun
32.   Ziyaul Haque
33.   Habibur Rahman
34.   Abdul Maid Sheikh
35.   Madhabi Das
36.   Moslema Khatun
37.   Md. Zasimuddin Sheikh
38.   Md. Mojibur Rahman
39.   Md. Kamrul Hassan
40.   Ajmal Shaikh
41.   Mursalim Sheikh
42.   Md. Samim Akhtar
43.   Sumant Kumar Biswas
44.   Mushtaque Ahmad
45.   Md. Jamirul Haque
46.   Md. Jahangir Alam
47.   Md. Motahar Hossain
48.   Nasim Ahmad
49.   Ritunjay Kumar
50.   Ebrahim Sheikh
51.   Pradeep Kumar Biswas
52.   Md. Tafijul Sheikh
53.   Md. Maksud Alam
54.   Md. Nasir Sk
55.   Humayun Shaikh
                            -2-
56. Anowarul Haque
57. Muktarul Haque
58. Md. Ajfarul Haque
59. Md. Khoswar Ali
60. Md. Kadirul Islam
61. Ziaul Haque
62. Most. Mabia Khatoon
63. Md. Afsar Ali
64. Abul Kalam
65. Md. Malik Ansari
66. Saijuddin Shaikh
67. Mojibur Rahman
68. Suresh Bhandari
69. Sunil Kr. Bhandari
70. Ritesh Ranjan
71. Samir Momin
72. Abhimunnu Gupta
73. Ramji Bhagat
74. Md. Najme Ali
75. Mirjahan Biswas
76. Shahadul Shaikh
77. Binita Das
78. Md. Abu Taher Shaikh
79. Shaibur Rahman
80. Kazi Naimuddin
81. Rajesh Pd. Saha
82. Roselin Hembrom
83. Rosemary Soren
84. Savitri Sofia Murmu
85. Lily Lazma Murmu
86. Sakal Hembrom
87. Saurav Suman
88. Sanatan Hembrom
89. Dasu Hembrom
90. Danial Marandi
91. Menoti Marandi
92. Roshan Soren
93. Sheela Hembrom
94. Bimal Soren
95. Hosanuzzaman
96. Takdeer Shaikh
97. Jay Prakash Ram
98. Md. Najibur Rahman
99. Bedaruddin Shaikh
100. Juber Ali
101. Ayub Shaikh
102. Md. Hajekul Alam
103. Krishna Sarkar
104. Sabila Khatun
105. Md. Jainul Islam
106. Md. Tahir Alam
107. Ashok Kumar Verma
108. Anjali Ghosh
109. Naznin
110. Md. Ketabul Sk
111. Pramod Gond
                               -3-
112. Chittoranjan Bhandari
113. Abdul Salim
114. Md. Azaharul Hoque
115. Md. Rehan Shaikh
116. Set Mandal Kisku
117. Jahangir Shaikh
118. Samsul Alam
119. Najiya Sultana
120. Tushi Khatun
121. Jaba Parmanik
122. Sampu Begum
123. Sufiul Alam
124. Abul Kalam
125. Noor Islam
126. Md. Sarjaul Hoque
127. Muzaffer Ahmed
128. Ziaul Haque
129. Dilip Hansda
130. Quazi Gulam Mohiuddin
131. Ananta Kumar Rabidas
132. Sonmuni Kisku
133. Amit Rajbanshi
134. Mosammat Aklima Begam
135. Jaideo Mandal
136. Manjarul Haque
137. Md. Kamr Tohid Hussain
138. Laxman Kumar
139. Renu Begam
140. Sebina Khatun
141. Rbekul Shaikh
142. Md. Altab Hussain
143. Fajle Ahamad Shaikh
144. Devilal Hembrom
145. Khitish Chandra Mandal
146. Jeevan Mandal
147. Swapan Kumar Madal
148. Mojammel Hoque
149. Ruksana Khatun
150. Abdul Halim
151. Kalipado Sarkar
152. Shrikant Mandal
153. Md. Zakir Hossain
154. Atikur Rohman
155. Noor Islam Sk
156. Imdadul Islam
157. Shahanaz Begum
158. Jawahar Lal Rajak
159. Masud Alam
160. Parmeshwar Rajak
161. Atul Kumar Ghosh
162. Mursheda Khatun
163. Sanjit Kumar Rajak
164. Abhay Kumar Mal
165. Rina Kumari
166. Antajul Hoque
167. Seth Hembram
                                -4-
168. Rasikul Alam
169. Zafar Ali Babul
170. Suniram Tudu
171. Moktarul Hossain
172. Md. Mokbul Hossain
173. Md. Shafiqul Alam
174. Md. Noor Islam Sk.
175. Md. Nazir Hussain
176. Firdausi Begum
177. Mosammat Sakina Firdaus
178. Doli Khatun
179. Dilwar Hossain
180. Rafikul Alam
181. Motiur Rahman
182. Abdul Rashid
183. Suktara Latifa Khatun
184. Abeda Sultana
185. Md. Adam Ali
186. Md. Naimul Islam
187. Md. Abdul Fazal
188. Sarbeshwar Kumar Das
189. Md. Husne Mubarak
190. Md. Amirul Islam
191. Jainal Abedin
192. Golam Ambia
193. Runa Laila Arjuban
194. Abdul Alam
195. Abdul Samime
196. Bani Israyil
197. Sadek Ali
198. Khadiza Begam
199. Md. Sahabuddin Sk
200. Md. Luthfal Hoque
201. Rameshwar Besra
202. Madan Kr. Mahto
203. Md. Mojammel Hoque
204. Safiur Rahman
205. Tariqul Islam
206. Md. Mokbul Hussain
207. Qamrul Nesha
208. Manjarul Islam
209. Md. Tohidul Islam
210. Fajukl Kabir
211. Enamul Hoque
212. Md. Sahabuddin Sk
213. Md. Mehbub Alam Khan
214. Md. Ajmal Khan
215. Abdul Bamid Khan
216. Radhe Shyam Rabidas
217. Md. Fajle Rabbi
218. Md. Abdus Salam
219. Md. Ziaul Hoque
220. Md. Zahangir Alam
221. Iqbal Hussain
222. Md. Setabuddin
223. Md. Akhtar Hussain
                                     -5-
224. Md. Mostufa Shaikh
225. Md. Ataur Rahman
226. Md. Raushan Ali
227. Ayesha Khatun
228. Abu Hanjela Shaikh
229. Jai Prakash Kumar
230. Sohagini Marandi
231. Anjela Hansda
232. Jyotishila Marandi
233. Gangamuni Marandi
234. Jiten Soren
235. Sunita Hembrom
236. Maryla Murmu
237. Vibha Devi
238. Sandhya Rani Dey
239. Rosa Murmu
240. Prishila Soren
241. Malti Marandi
242. Santina Tudu
243. Lily Marandi
244. Sunita Marandi
245. Lilays Kapri
246. Sunita Baskey
247. Mithilesh Rebidas
248. Bably Marandi
249. Munshi Murmu
250. Babudhan Tudu
251. Porwit Tudu
252. Md. Saidur Rahman
253. Rajesh Gour
254. Babu Ram Kishku
255. Niru Rabidas
256. Md. Sahidur Rahman
257. Ekramul Haque
258. Aminul Islam
259. Md. Ketabul Shaikh
260. Indrani Mishra                                   ...     Petitioners
                             -Versus-
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. The Chief Secretary, Govt. of Jharkhand, P.O. + P.S. Dhurwa, District
   Ranchi, Jharkhand.
3. The Principal Secretary, Deptt. of Personnel, Raj Bhasa &
   Administration Reforms, Government of Jharkhand, Project Bhawan,
   P.O. & P.S. Dhurwa, Dist. Ranchi, Jharkhand.
4. The Principal Secretary, Human Resources Development Department,
   Govt. of Jharkhand, Project Bhawan, Dhurwa, P.O. + P.S. Dhurwa,
   District Ranchi, Jharkhand.
5. The Director, Primary Education, Human Resources Development
   Department, Government of Jharkhand, Project Bhawan Dhurwa, P.O.
   + P.S. Dhurwa, District Ranchi, Jharkhand.
6. The Director, Jharkhand Education Project Council Project, New Co-
   operative Building Shyamli, P.O. + P.S. Doranda, District Ranchi.
7. The Deputy Commissioner, Pakur, P.O. + P.S. + District Pakur,
   Jharkhand.
8. The Deputy Superintendent Education, Pakur, P.O. + P.S. + District
   Pakur, Jharkhand.                               ...         Respondents
                                             -6-

                CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANANDA SEN
                                        ----

For the Petitioners : Md. Asadul Haque, Advocate For the Respondents : AC to GP-I Mr. Krishna Murari, Advocate Mr. Raj Vardhan, Advocate

----

7/ 10.02.2023 Heard learned counsel for the petitioners and learned counsel for the respondents.

2. The issue of regularisation of para teachers has been set at rest by a Division Bench of this Court in W.P.(S) No.315 of 2016 and analogous cases vide judgment dated 16.12.2022. It has been held that the para teachers cannot be regularized.

3. In this writ petition, the petitioners, who are para teachers, are claiming for regularisation. The issue is thus, covered by the judgment dated 16.12.2022 passed in W.P.(S) No.315 of 2016.

4. Considering the aforesaid fact, this writ petition is also dismissed in terms of the judgment dated 16.12.2022 passed by the Division Bench of this Court in W.P.(S) No.315 of 2016 and analogous cases.

(Ananda Sen, J.) Madhav/-