Page No.# 1/ vs The State Of Assam And Ors
2024 Latest Caselaw 2963 Gua

Gauhati High Court

Page No.# 1/ vs The State Of Assam And Ors on 3 May, 2024

                                                                   Page No.# 1/10

GAHC010190912022




                      THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
  (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)

                          Case No. : WP(C)/6331/2022

         BINOD KARMAKAR AND ORS
         S/O BIKASH KARMAKAR, VILL - P.O - KHAIRABARI, DIST- BARPETA
         (ASSAM), PIN- 781315 CASTE - SC

         2: DHIRAJ KUMAR
          C/O TARVN KUMAR VILL- MIRZA P.O-MIRZA DIST-KAMRUP (ASSAM) PIN-
         781125

         3: PURABI BARUAH
          D/O- RAJEN BARUAH R/O- HOUSE NO-4 VILL-KALITAPARA P.O- AZARA
         DIST- KAMRUP (M) (ASSAM) PIN-781017. CASTE GENERAL

         4: PRIYANKA SARKAR
          C/O- LATE SUBASH SARKAR VILL- BHASKAR NAGAR P.O- BINOVA
         NAGAR DIST- KAMRUP (ASSAM) PIN-781018

         5: ARIFA BEGUM
          C/O SARIFUDDIN AHMED VILL-KALYANPUR WARD NO-8 P.O- MORIGAON
         DIST- MORIGAON (ASSAM) PIN-782105 CASTE. GENERAL (EWS)

         6: NAZMUL ALOM LASKAR
          S/O- LT. FAIZUR ROHMAN LASKAR VILL RAMPUR PO- KARICHERRA
         BAZAR PS KATLICHERRA DIST- HAILAKANDI PIN 788165 STATE - ASSAM.
         CASTE - GENERAL

         7: ALI AHMED TAPADAR
          S/O- JAMAL UDDIN TAPADAR VILL- MAHAMMEDPUR P.O- RONGPUR
         SOUTH DIST-HAILAKANDI (ASSAM) PIN-788163
         CASTE -GENERAL EWS

         8: ALAM UDDIN LASKAR
          S/O-JALAL UDDIN LASKAR VILL- NITYANANDAPUR PART-I P.O-
         NITYANANDAPUR P.S- LALA DIST- HAILAKANDI
          PIN- 788168
                                                          Page No.# 2/10


9: DIPJYOTI SHARMA
 S/O- MANOJ SHARMA VILL-GOLIA P.ODIST- SANITPUR (BISWANATH) PIN-
784176

10: MRIDULA SINGHA
W/O- SUBHADRA SINHA R/O- GOKILA P.O. TINOKHAL DIST. KARIMGANJ
ASSAM-788724

11: MADHABI SINGHA
 D/O- MADHAB SINGHA R/O- BAITAKHAL P.O. KATABARI DIST.
KARIMGANJ ASSAM-788726

12: ARIF UDDIN AHMED
 S/O- ASIM UDDIN AHMED R/O- KALGACHIA P. O- KALGACHIA P.S-
KALGACHIA DIST - BARPETA (ASSAM). PIN 781319. CASTE-GENERAL

13: ABRAHAM MURMU
 S/O-LUIS MURMU VILL-TEBITOLA P.O-TEBITOLA P.S-TAMULPUR DIST-
BAKSA. CASTEOBC

14: GITANJALI DAS
 D/O. KAMINI KANTA DAS VILL. MAJORKURI P.O. RAMDIA P.S. HAJO DIST.
KAMRUP (R) PIN-781102. CASTE - SC

15: LUCIA MURMU
 D/O- LATE NIRMAL MURMU R/O- CHOKRAGAON P. O- AMBAGAON P. S-
HARISINGHA DIST - UDALGURI ASSAM. CASTE OBC

16: SUBHAM GHOSH
 S/O-NITAI GHOSH R/O- RANGJIA WARD NO.6 P.O AND P.S-RANGIA
DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM. CASTE - OBC

17: ASHADUL ISLAM
 C/O-MD ABDUL MANNAN R/O- SALMARABORI P. O- BECHAMARI P. S-
DHING DIST - NAGAON ASSAM.CASTE- GENERAL (EWS)

18: RINGKUL AHMED
 /O - SUMSUDDIN AHMED
VILL - BAGALIPARA
P.O- LAHARIGHAT .
P.S- LAHARIGHAT.
DIST - MORIGAON
(ASSAM) PIN- 782127.
CASTE- GENERAL (EWS)

19: MASHUDA KHATUN
 C/O- IKRAM HUSSAIN AHMED R/O- SALMARABORI P. O- BECHAMARI P.
                                                            Page No.# 3/10

S- DHING DIST - NAGAON ASSAM. CASTE - GENERAL

20: MUSADDIKA AHMED
 C/O- ERSHAD AHMED VILL- KALYANPUR P.O- MORIGAON DIST-
MORIGAON PIN-782105 CASTE. GENERAL (EWS)

21: NURUL AMIN
 LATE AFIJUDDIN MUNSHI VILL- NO-4 BHOJMARI P.O- TEWARIPAL DIST-
BISWANATH PIN-784175. CASTE OBC

22: SAHIDUL ISLAM
 S/O- JONAB ALI VILL- NO-2 KUMALIA P.O- PANIBHARAL DIST-
BISWANATH PIN-784176. CASTE-OBC

23: HIMAKSHI SAHARIA
 D/O-SASHINDRA NATH SAHARIA R/O- BELKONA P.O-BIHDIA P.S-BAIHATA
CHARIALI DISTRICT-KAMRUP ASSAM

24: JYOTSNA RANI DEVI
 D/O- SUBUDH CHANDRA NATH VILL- MAYENGIA GAON P.O- CHARAI
BAHI DIST- MORIGAON (ASSAM) PIN-782106. CASTE-OBC

25: SANJUKTA DAS
 D/O- BIMALENDU DAS R/O- HOUSE NO.28 B.K KAKATI ROAD P. O-
ULUBARI GUWAHATI DIST - KAMRUP (METRO) ASSAM

26: NITYA KISHORE DEY
 S/O- NARENDRA DEY R/O-ATANAGAR P. O- KANAI BAZAR DIST -
KARIMGANJ ASSAM. CASTE - OBC

27: BANASHREE DAS
 D/O-LAKSHMI RAM DAS R/O- MIRZA P.O-MIRZA P.S -PALASHBARI
DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM. CASTE-OBC

28: BISHAL LASKAR
 S/O- RAKESH LASKAR VILL- KHELMA PT-I P.O- GUMRA BAZAR DIST-
CACHAR (ASSAM) PIN-788815

29: MOHESH BAISHNAB
 S/O- LAKSHINDAR BAISHNAB VILL- KHELMA PT-I P.O- GUMRA BAZAR
DIST- CACHAR (ASSAM

30: ASHA LATA DEVI
 S/O- SAILESH NATH VILL-BAKRIHAWAR PART I P.O- PANCHGRAM DIST-
HAILAKANDI (ASSAM) PIN-788802. CASTE-OBC

31: CHIMPA DAS
 D/O-RABINDRA NATH DAS R/O- MIRZA NARAYANPUR P.O-MIRZA P.S
                                                         Page No.# 4/10

-PALASHBARI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM. CASTE - OBC

32: ARPITA ROY
 D/O HARI ROY R/O- NAYAPATAN P.O- BHANGA BAZAR DIST- KARIMGANJ
(ASSAM) PIN-788701
 CAST - GENERAL

33: RINKI DEKA
 C/O- KHAGENDRA NATH DEKA VILL- SARIKOT P.O- SARIKOT DIST-
KAMRUP (R) ASSAM PIN-781380. CASTE-GENERAL (EWS).

34: KRISHNA CHAUHAN
 S/O-BASUDEO CHAUHAN VILLAGE-WATIZOR NO 2 P.O.-WATIZOR NO 2
P.S-KHERONI DIST-WEST KARBI ANGLONG PIN-782446 ASSAM . CASTE -
OBC .

35: MAKIBUL ISLAM
 S/O- ABDUR RAHMAN R/O- SUKMANAH P. O- SUKMANAH P.S- BARPETA
DIST - BARPETA ASSAM. GENERAL(EWS)

36: MRIDUPABAN SARMAH
 C/O- PROFULLA SARMAH VILL-BARICHOWA BRAHMIN GAON P.O-
MUDOIGAON DIST- GOLAGHAT (ASSAM) PIN-785614
 CASTE- GENERAL

37: NAZMA BEGUM
 C/O- NAZIR ALI VILL-MAHIPALKUCHI P.O- BALIKUCHI DIST- KAMRUP (R)
(ASSAM) PIN-781381 CASTE- GENERAL

38: GITANJOLI HAZARIKA
 C/O- RANJIT DEKA VILL-BARBARI P.O- BURHA DIST- DARRANG (ASSAM)
PIN-784148. CASTE-GENERAL(EWS)

39: SURAJIT DEY
 S/O- SUBAL DEY VILL- DAKHIN GOLAGHAT BASTI P.O- HOJAI DIST-HOJAI
PIN-782435. CASTE-OBC

40: ANKUR KASHYAP
 C/O- LATE PRADIP SARMAH VILL- 3 NO SANTIPUR P.O CHUNGAJAN DIST-
GOLAGHAT PIN-785601CASTE- GENERAL(EWS

41: RINIMA BARUAH
 C/O BIREN BARUAH VILL- KUMARGAON P.O- DERGAON DIST-
GOLAGHAT PIN-785615 CASTE- OBC

42: GEETANJALI BORA
 C/O- SHRI JOY RAM BORA R/O- NEW AMOLAPATTY M.G. ROAD DIST -
NAGAON ASSAM. CASTE-OBC
                                                          Page No.# 5/10


43: JULI MUDOI
 C/O- DULEN BAISHYA R/O-PHUKANKHAT P. O-SINGIA P. S- SAMAGURI
DIST - NAGAON ASSAM. CASTE--SC

44: DEEPIKA BHOWMICK
 D/O DULAL BHOWMICK R/O THANA ROAD KARIMGANJ P.O. AND P.S.-
KARIMGANJ DIST-KARIMGANJ ASSAM
CASTE- GENERAL

45: R K BINDIYA SANA
 D/O- BIRENDRA SANA RAJKUMAR R/O- VILL. CHANDAM LEIKAI P.O.
KAPTANPUR
 DIST. CACHAR ASSAM-788119
CASTE- OBC

46: ANJANA SINGHA
 C/O- KRISHNA KUMAR SINGHA CASTE-OBC VILL- KASHIPUR P.O-
BORKHOLA DIST- CACHAR (ASSAM) PIN-788110

47: BABILON BORA
 D/O- LATE NAREN CH. BORA VILL-RUPAIBARI P.O- AHATGURI DIST-
MORIGAON (ASSAM) PIN-782412 CASTE OBC

48: ARUNDHATI GOSWAMI
 C/O- LATE SATYENDRA GOSWAMI
VILL. P.O- GOBINDAPUR DIST- BARPETA PIN-781326. CASTE - GENERAL
(EWS)

49: RUBIA KHATUN
 D/O- MD AZIZUR RAHMAN VILLAGE- UDALI KACHARI GAON P.O.- UDALI
BAZAR DIST- HOJAI (ASSAM) PIN- 782446 .
CASTE - OBC

50: BEAUTY DEVI
 C/O LATE MANIK SARMA
VILL- MOLIA GAON P.O- DHEKIAL DIST- GOLAGHAT PIN-785622 .CASTE-
GENERAL (EWS

51: JEHIRUL ISLAM
 S/O ALIMUDDIN
VILL. KACHARIJAN PO-KARATIPAM DIS. MORIGAON PIN-782105 ASSAM
CASTE-GENERAL (EWS).

52: PRANAMI BORA
 C/O GONESH CH. BORA VILL- CHORACHOWA GAON P.O-PANICHAKUA
DIST-JORHAT PIN-785006
                                                              Page No.# 6/10

53: GEETIKA SARMA
 D/O- NARAYAN CH. SARMA VILL-BALIPARA P.O- BHALUKI DIST-
BARPETA (ASSAM) PIN-781371

54: JULHAS HUSSAIN
 S/O- SIRAJ UDDIN VILL - DAKSHIN KACHUBARI P.O.- CHANDKHIRA P.S.-
PATHARKANDHI DIST.- KARIMGANJ ASSAM PIN- 788725. CASTE GENERAL

55: BASUDEV SARMAH
 C/O- LATE MONILAL SARMAH R/O- SANTAPUR P. O- LAHOLIAL P. S-
BIHPURIA DIST - LAKHIMPUR ASSAM CASTE. GENERAL

56: RUPABATI SUTRADHARA
 C/O- DHARMESWAR SUTRADHAR
VILL-CHOWKAPARA
 DORAPARA
 P.O- AGIA
 DIST- GOALPARA
 PIN-783120. CASTE-SC

57: KIRAN DUTTA
 D/O- BIPUL CH. DUTTA R/O- DA- GATI P. O- AZAD P.S- PANIGAON DIST -
LAKHIMPUR ASSAM.

58: SUHEL AHMED
 S/O LATE NOOR AHMED VILL- KANKALASH P.O- BHANGA BAZAR DIST-
KARIMGANJ (ASSAM) PIN-788701 CASTE - GENERAL (EWS)

59: DIKSHA DAS
 D/O LATE DIPAK KUMAR DAS R/O SILCHAR NATIONAL HIGHWAY P.O.-
SILCHAR P.S.-SILCHAR SADAR DIST-CACHAR ASSAM. CASTE- SC

60: SAFIQUL ISLAM
 S/O- ABDUL SATTAR R/O- BERAJAN P. O- MANSIRI P. S- TEZPUR
 DIST - SONITPUR ASSAM. CASTE- OBC

61: MOHAMMED SALIM AHMED
 S/O MOHAMMED JALAL UDDIN VILL- GULCHARA P.O- GULCHARA DIST-
KARIMGANJ (ASSAM) PIN-788720 CASTE- GENERAL

62: SAPNA YASMIN
 D/O- ABDUL MALIK R/O- KARAIKANDI PART 2 P. O- RAJARTILLA P. S-
KATIGORAH DIST - CACHAR ASSAM. CASTE-GENERAL.

63: TUTUMONI SAIKIA
 D/O- SUKUMAL SAIKIA R/O- AJARLOGA P. O- CHARIDUAR P. S-
CHARIDUAR DIST - SONITPUR ASSAM. CASTE- OBC
                                                         Page No.# 7/10

64: ATIKUL ALOM
 S/O- SAHADAT HUSSAIN R/O- KHATANIAPARA P. O- DHULA P.S- DHULA
DIST - DARRANG ASSAM. CASTE- GENERAL (EWS)

65: SOFIA KHATUN
 D/O- USMAN GONI R/O- WARD NO-7 SUNARUPATTY KHARUPETIA P. O-
KHARUPETIA P.S- KHARUPETIA DIST - DARRANG ASSAM. CASTE- MOBC

66: SUSMITA BHATTACHARJEE
 D/O SWAPAN KR. BHATTACHARJEE VILL-SUSMITA BHATTACHARJEE
LALA VIVEKANANDA ROAD P.O-LALA POLICE STATION DIST-
HAILAKANDI PIN-788163

67: DILWAR HUSSAIN
 S/O RAFIQUL HAQUE VILL- KAZIRGRAM P.O- BHANGA BAZAR DIST-
KARIMGANJ (ASSAM) PIN-788701 CASTE- GENERAL (EWS)

68: AZHARUDDIN LASKAR
 S/O MD RAHIMUDDIN LASKAR VILL-HURAULI DURGANAGAR PART V
P.O-UDHARBOND DIST-CACHAR (ASSAM) PIN-788030 CASTE - GENERAL
( EWS )

69: SUTOPA DAS
 D/O LATE SURAJIT CHANDRA DAS VILL-UDHARBOND P.O- UDHARBOND
DIST-CACHAR (ASSAM) PIN-788030 CASTE- GENERAL

70: PANKAJ KUMAR PAUL
 S/O LATE BIJOY PAUL VILL-BHATIGRAM DURGANAGAR PART V P.O-
UDHARBOND DIST-CACHAR (ASSAM) PIN-788030 CASTE - GENERAL

71: JAHIRUL ISLAM
 S/O ABDUS SUKKUR VILL- KATALUNI P.O-KANAIBAZAR P.S-
PATHARKANDI DIST- KARIMGANJ (ASSAM) PIN-788724 CASTE - GENERAL
(EWS)

72: NAJMA PARBIN
W/O - ZAKIR HUSSAIN VILL- BARJHAR BAGICHA P.O. - BHAKATPARA
DIST - UDALGURI (ASSAM) PIN - 784190 CASTE - GENERAL(EWS)

73: AHANARA KHANAM
 D/O. BANIZ KHAN VILL. HATIZANA P.O. JOSHIHATIPARA DIST. BARPETA
PIN-781316.

74: MUNJURUL ALOM AKAND
 S/O- SURAT ALI AKAND R/O- KACHARI GAON P. O- KAMANDANGA P.S-
TAMARHAT DIST - DHUBRI ASSAM.

75: ABUL FARAK
                                                            Page No.# 8/10

S/O- MD ABDUL GANI R/O- JANGALPARA P. O- JANGALPARA P.S-
KHARUPETIA DIST - DARRANG ASSAM.

76: CHANDRAMA BARUAH
 C/O-DIPEN BARUAH. VILL-AMORABATI P.O-DUDHNOI PIN- 783124 DIST-
GOALPARA

77: UMA NATH CHETRY
 C/O- LT. THARKA BAHADUR CHETRY VILL-DONGIBIL P.O-DONGIBIL P.S-
BIHPURIA DIST-LAKHIMPUR PIN-784161

78: SANGHITA DEY
 D/O SWAPAN KUMAR DEY VILL DEBESHWAR BHABAN JAGAT KUTIR
DIST- SILCHAR (ASSAM) PIN-788004

79: PRANAMANGSHU BARMAN
 S/O- SRI SUBHASH BARMAN R/O- VILL- TARAPUR NETAJI NAGAR P.O.
SILCHAR DIST.- CACHAR ASSAM 788003

80: PRIYANKA DEY
 D/O PARESH DEY VILL-JOYPUR FALTUTULA GAON P.O-JOYPUR DIST-
DIBRUGARH (ASSAM) PIN-786614

81: ARUP BISWAS
 S/O ANIL CH. BISWAS R/O AMDAKHAL P.O. AND P.S.-KARIMGANJ DIST-
KARIMGANJ ASSAM

82: EKRAMUL HUSSAIN CHOUDHURY
 S/O- ABDUL KALAM CHOUDHURY VILL-MASLY P.O- BHANGA BAZAR
DIST- KARIMGANG PIN-788701

83: RUPAM DAS
 S/O- SRI KIRENDRA CHANDRA DAS R/O- VILL- SUNIARPAR P.O.
GOBINDAGANJ BAZAR DIST.- KARIMGANJ ASSAM 788733

84: BIPRO BHUSAN GOSWAMI
 S/O BIMAN BIHARI GOSWAMI VILL. P.O. - MIRJAPUR DIST-KARIMGANJ
(ASSAM) PIN-788701

85: PRAFULLA KONCH
 S/O- MAHURAM KONCH R/O- VILL. BORPAKOCH P.O. MASKHUWA DIST.
DHEMAJI. ASSAM-787058

86: JONMANI SHIL
 D/O ANIL KUMAR SHIL VILL. KHARALAL PAARA P.O. DUDHNOI DIST.
GOALPARA PIN-783124

87: GOURISHANKAR ROY
                                                                            Page No.# 9/10

            S/O LT. DINESH CHANDRA ROY VILL. BAGARGOOL DIST. KARIMGANJ
            ASSAM
            PIN-788701 CASTE S

            VERSUS

            THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ORS.
            REP. BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
            EDUCATION ELEMENTARY DEPTT. GUWAHATI-781006

            2:THE DEPTT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION
             ERSTWHILE DIRECTOR OF ELEMENTARY EDUCATION
            KAHILIPARA
             GUWAHATI-781019
            ASSAM

            3:THE AXOM SARBA SIKSHA ABHIJAN MISSON
             REPRESENTED BY THE MISSION DIRECTOR
             SARBA SIKSHA ABHIJAN MISSION
            ASSAM
             KAHILIPARA
             GUWAHATI 781019.

            4:THE MISSION DIRECTOR
             SARBA SIKSHA ABHIJAN MISSION
            ASSAM
             KAHILIPARA
             GUWAHATI-781019

Advocate for the Petitioner   : MR. K M MAHANTA

Advocate for the Respondent : SC, ELEM. EDU




                                  BEFORE
                 HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR

                                        ORDER

03.05.2024

Mr. K.K. Mahanta, learned Senior counsel appearing for the petitioners by referring to the directions as passed by this Court vide judgment and order dated 03.02.2021, Page No.# 10/10

passed in Writ Appeal No.24/2021, read with the order dated 12.02.2021 passed by this Court in I.A.(Civil) No.258/2021, submits that a coordinate bench of this Court in a similar matter, by noticing the judgment passed by the Division Bench in the matter, had disposed of the writ petition with certain directions, requiring the appointment against the 960 vacancies as now kept reserved in the matter.

It is contended by Mr. Mahanta, learned Senior counsel for the petitioners that the directions as passed by this Court vide the judgment and order dated 08.08.2023 in WP(C) No.7600/2022 has still not been implemented by the respondents and accordingly, the petitioners are still not been favoured with an order of appointment, although their rights for being so appointed has finally been determined by this Court.

Mr. B. Choudhury, learned standing counsel, SSA, shall on the next date, invariably bring on record instructions which would be now received in writing by him from the competent authority of the SSA, Assam, as to why the categorical direction passed by this Court in the earlier round of litigation have not been taken to its logical conclusion. In the event, the instructions as sought for are not placed on record, at 2:00 p.m. on the next date so fixed, the Mission Director, SSA shall remain present before this Court to explain and assist this Court in proceeding to dispose of the matter.

List this matter again on 28.05.2024.

Sd/- N. Unni Krishnan Nair JUDGE

Comparing Assistant