Page No.# 1/3 vs The State Of Assam And 7 Ors
2021 Latest Caselaw 537 Gua

Page No.# 1/31

GAHC010188722020

THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)

Case No. : Review.Pet./154/2019

HERAMBA KUMAR SAIKIA AND 141 ORS S/O SRI CHANDR AKANTA SAIKIA VILL- SATGHARIA P.O. SIPAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

2: SRI BHARAT CHANDRA SARMA S/O SRI LAKSHI RAM SARMA VILL- BARBARI P.O. BURHA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

3: MD. MIJANUR RAHMAN S/O MD. MAFIZUDDIN AHMED VILL- MUSLIMGHOPA P.O. SIPAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

4: MD. MUKUT ALI S/O MD. MATLIB ALI VIL- MUSLIMGHOPA P.O. SIPAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

5: SRI HIRANYA KUMAR SAHARIA S/O LT. RATNESWAR SAHARIA Page No.# 2/31

VILL- KABEICHUBA P.O. SIPAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

6: SRI KHAGENDRA KALITA S/O LT. SISHU RAM KALITA VILL- BURHA P.O. BURHA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

7: SRI MAHENDRA KALITA S/O LT. HALI RAM KALITA VILL- PADMAJHAR P.O. BURHA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

8: SRI KHIRENDRA SARMA S/O SRI KUSHESWAR SARMA VILL- KENDUGURI P.O. KENDUGURI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

9: SRI PRABHAWATI DEKA D/O LT.HARMOHAN DEKA VILL- BHUKTABARI P.O. SIPAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

10: SRI GUNJA MONI KALITA D/O LT. KANAK CH. KALITA VILL- KAMARGAON P.S. DIPILA P.S. SIPAJHAR Page No.# 3/31

DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

11: SRI DHRUB JYOTI SARMA C/O LT. ANTI RAM SARMA VILL- UPAHUPARA P.O. MANGALDAI P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784125

12: SRI LANKESWAR KALITA S/O LT. JHUJU RAM KALITA VILL- KAMARGAON P.O. DIPILA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

13: SRI KULENDRA BORA S/O LT. GANO RAM BORA VILL- BIJULIBARI P.O.MAROI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

14: SRI BASANTA KUMAR DAS S/O LT. BETHARAM KUMAR DAS VILL- BIJULIBARI P.O. MAROI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

15: SRI KIRITI DEKA S/O LT. RABIDHAR DEKA VILL- JHAKUAPARA P.O. HAZARIKAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145 Page No.# 4/31

16: SRI LAMBODAR BARUA S/O PONA RAM KALITA VILL- NIRAN CHUBA P.O. PATHARIGHAT P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

17: SRI UDAY SARMA S/O LT. CHANDRA KANTA SARMA VILL- NAYAKPARA P.O. SIPAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

18: SRI MADAN CH. KALITA S/O KHANGIDHAR KALITA VILL- KHASDIPILA P.O. DIPILA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

19: SRI SULAV CH. DEKA S/O LT. SATO RAM DEKA VILL- MATHANGA P.O. OUTOLA P.S.MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784125

20: SRI GOBINDA DEV SARINA S/O TANESWAR DEV SARMA VILL- BARIGAON

P.S. SIPAJHAR (PATHARIGHAT) DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784147

21: SRI DIPALI SARMA Page No.# 5/31

W/O ARUN SARMA VIL- JHAKUAPARA P.O. BHURARGARH P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784147

22: MD. MAINUL HOQUE S/O LT. MANNA SEIKH VILL- ATHKURIA P.O. PATHARIGHAT P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

23: MRS.

W/O SRI JAGAT CH. BARUAH VILL- NO. 2 KALAIGAON P.S. KALAIGAON DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784525

24: SRI PABITRA KUMAR NATH S/O LT. BASUNDHAR NATH VILL- BALIKUCHI P.O. BURHA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

25: SRI INDRA KALITA S/O SRI RATNESWAR KALITA VILL- CHAKIA PARA P.O. CHAMATIAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784147

26: SRI TANKESWAR NATH S/O LT. UTTAM NATH VILL- JAYPUR P.O. HENGALPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR Page No.# 6/31

DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

27: SRI UTTAM CH. NATH S/O LT. JAGAT CH. NATH VIL- HENGALPARA P.O. HENGALAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

28: SRI MD. KUDRAT ALI S/O MD. OHAB ALI VILL- BIYASPARA P.O. BIYASPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

29: SRI HARI CH. DEKA S/O LT. DANDIRAM DEKA VILL- LAKHIMPUR P.O. LAKHIMPUR P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784525

30: SRI DINESWAR DEKA S/O LT. LOHIT DEKA VILL- LAKHIMPUR P.O. LAKHIMPUR P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784525

31: SRI DEBAJANI SAHARIA W/O MR. SUNANDA SAIKIA VILL- BHUKTABARI P.O. SIPAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145 Page No.# 7/31

32: SRI JASODA DEVI D/O LT. NARAYAN SARMA VILL- DUARIPARA P.O. CHENGELIAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

33: SRI GITA BALA DEVI D/O LT. BHABANI SARMA VILL- DUARIPARA P.O. CHENGELIAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

34: SRI JAYANTI BALA NATH D/O LT. KESHAB CH. NATH VILL- NAYAKPARA P.O. SIPAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

35: SRI NABIN CH. KALITA S/O LT. DHANESWAR KALITA VILL- KAMARGAON P.O. DIPILA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

36: SRI TILAK BORA S/O LT. KAMI RAM BORA VILL- BORONGA BARI P.O. CHAMUAPARA P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784529

37: SRI RANJIT DEKA S/O LT. LAPARU DEKA Page No.# 8/31

VILL- HOWLI MOHANPUR P.O. HOWLI MOHANPUR P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784529

38: SRI JIBAN CH. KALITA S/O LT. KABI RAM KALITA VILL-NAGAON P.O. HATIMARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

39: SRI SANI RAM BORA S/O LT. ALAHU BORA VILL- OUTOLA P.O. OUTOLA P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784525

40: SRI LOHIT CH. DEKA S/O LT. FANIDHAR DEKA VILL- UDMARI P.O. TENGABARI P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784525

41: SRI PADUM CH. BORA S/O LT. GANGA RAM BORA VILL- PATHARIGHAT P.O. PATHARIGHAT P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

42: SRI GAJENDRA NATH SAIKIA S/O LT. SANTI RAM SAIKIA

P.O. PATHARIGHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR Page No.# 9/31

DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

43: SRI MADAN CH. NATH S/O LT. MOHI RAM NATH VILL- NAYAKPARA P.O. SIPAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

44: SRI SAILENDRA NATH S/O LT. SOMBAR NATH VILL- DOSOTANI P.O. GARUKHUTI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

45: SRI MAMONI DEVI W/O SRI CHANDRA KR. SARMA VILL- HAZARIKAPARA P.O. HAZARIKAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

46: SRI RAMESH CH. NATH S/O LT. SRIKANTA NATH VILL- MATHAJHAR P.O. GARUKHUTI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

47: SRI TARUN CH. KALITA S/O LT. MOHI RAM KALITA VILL- LATHAPARA P.O. HATIMARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144 Page No.# 10/31

48: SRI NARENDA NATH KALITA S/O LT. DHARANDHAR KALITA VILL- LATHAPARA P.O. HATIMARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

49: SRI JOGAMAI SAIKIA W/O SRI KANAK CH. SAIKIA VILL- NIRANCHUBA P.O. PATHARIGHAT P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

50: SRI UDAY NARAYAN KONWAR S/O LT. RAJENDRA NARAYAN KONWAR VILL- SAIKIAPARA P.O.MENAPARA P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784146

51: SRI PURNIMA BARUAH D/O LT. MANI RAM BARUAH VILL- BORKUMARPARA P.O. AULACHOWKA P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784125

52: MD. KAMALUDDIN AHMED S/OMD. KAISOR ALI VILL- CHALANIKUCHI P.O. BHAKATPARA P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784190

53: SRI JITENDRA NATH DEKA S/O LT.MONI RAM DEKA Page No.# 11/31

VILL- MENAPARA P.O. MENAPARA P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784146

54: SRI BHARTI SAIKIA W/O SRI BHGYA KALITA VILL- HETOW ARIMARI P.O. CHAPAI DALGAON P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784190

55: RAMESH CH DEKA S/O LT. JHALA DEKA VILL- JALJALI P.O. MANGALDAI P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784529

56: SRI KUSHALATA NATH W/O LT. CHANDI RAM NATH VILL- SATKHALI P.O. SATKHALI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

57: SRI DIPU KALITA S/O LT. GUNA RAM KALITA VILL- KENDUGURI P.O. KENDUGURI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

58: AGAN CHANDRA KALITA S/O LT. PRADIP KALITA VILL- HAZARIKAPARA P.O. HAZARIKAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR Page No.# 12/31

DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

59: MRS. MANOWARA BEGUM D/O LT. CHOWKAT ALI VILL- SANOWATARI P.O. SANOWA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

60: SRI DIPALI DEKA W/O RATNESWAR DEKA VILL- NIZ RANGAMATI P.O. RANGMATI P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784529

61: SRI BORODA SARMA DEVI W/O SRI RAMESH SARMA VILL- PATIDARRANG

P.O. PATIDARRANG P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784147

62: MRS. GOLANAR BEGUM W/O MD. KAMARUDDIN AHMED VILL- POTA PUKHURI P.O. BARAMPUR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

63: SRI HARMOHAN DEKA S/O LT. CHENI RAM DEKA VILL- BAMUNJHAR P.O. ANDHERIGHAT P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM Page No.# 13/31

PIN -784148

64: MD. TAFAZUL HOQUE S/OLT. BASIR ALI VILL- SATKHALI P.O. SATKHALI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

65: MRS. MAHMUDA BEGUM W/O MD. PIAR ALI VILL- SANOWA P.O. SANOWA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

66: AMRIT KUMAR KALITA S/O DANDI RAM KALITA VILL- KALJURI P.O. KHOIRABARI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784522

67: SRI GAHIN CH. KALITA S/O LT. RAJAT CH. KALITA VILL- KALJURI P.O. KHOIRABARI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784522

68: SRI DHARMENDRA NARAYAN KONWAR S/O SRI RABINDRA NR. KONWAR VILL- SALOIPARA P.O. DEODHANIGHAT P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784147

69: SRI NAGENDRA KALITA Page No.# 14/31

S/O LT. BHABIN CH. KALITA VILL- SARANG P.O.KUHIRKUCHI P.S. KHOIRABARI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784522

70: SRI MUKUL DEKA S/O SRI JAGAT DEKA VILL- BATABARI P.O. DIGHIRPAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

71: SRI MAHESWAR NATH S/O LT. BHUMIDHAR NATH VILL- KHASSONAPUR P.O. MARUACHOWKI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

72: MD. HARUN RASID S/O LT. HARMUJ ALI VILL- NO. 2 MAJAR CHUBA P.O. GANESH KUWARI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

73: SRI HEM CH. NATH S/O PUSPADHAR NATH VILL- BARPATHAR P.O. TENGERA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

74: SRI DIBAKAR SARMA S/O LT. RAJANI SARMA VILL- BARPATHAR P.O. TENGERA Page No.# 15/31

P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

75: SRI PRADIP BHARALI S/O LT. ANDHU RAM BHARALI VILL- KHALIHAI P.O. BAZNAPATHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

76: SRI BHANU DEVI S/O SRI HEM KANTA SARMA VIL- BAZNAPATHAR P.O. BAZNAPATHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

77: SRI DEBENDR ARAJBONGSHI S/O SRI HARENDRA DEKA VILL- TITKUCHI P.O. BURHA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

78: SRI PARAMANANDA NATH S/O LT. UMA KANTA NATH VILL- BURHA P.O. BURHA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

79: MD. MEER HUSSAIN S/O AKHTAR HUSSAIN P.O. SANTIPUKHURI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144 Page No.# 16/31

80: SRI KUSESWAR SARMA S/OLT. MOHIRAM SARMA VILL- NIZ BARAMPUR P.O. BRAMPUR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

81: SRI KULENDRA SARMA S/O LT. LALIT CH. SARMA VILL- PUB NAGAON P.O. CHAMATIAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

82: SRI ILA DEKA W/O SRI KAMAKSHYA KALITA VILL- HAZARIKAPARA P.O. HAZARIKAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

83: MD. TARIKUDDIN ZIAUL HOQUE S/O LT. NURUL HOQUE VILL- BOLOGARAH P.O. NIZ KHARUPETIA P.S. DHULA DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784115

84: SRI JOGENDRA BARUA S/O LT. RATNESWAR BARUA VILL- TAMULIPARA P.O. DAHI NAGAON P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784429

85: SRI JITENDRA KR. BARO S/O MANO RAM BARO Page No.# 17/31

VILL- NO. 1 MAZGAON P.O. BHAKATPARA P.S. KALAIGAON DIST. UDALGURI PIN - 784190.

86: SRI NILAMONI SARMAH S/OLT. SARBESWAR SARMAH VILL- BHATI KURUA P.O. KURUA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784115

87: SRI BANESWAR BORA S/O LT. JAJAI RAM BORA VILL- KALITAPARA P.O. GANESH KUWARI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

88: SRI NIRMALI BORA D/O LT. SUBHA RAM BORA VILL- WARD NO. 8N MANGALDAI P.O. MANGALDAI P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784125

89: SRI TILESWARI DEKA SAIKIA W/O SRI KRISHNA SAIKIA VILL-HAZARIKAPARA P.O. HAZARIKAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

90: SRI HARENDRA SAIKIA S/O LT. BILI RAM SAIKIA VILL- NO. 1 CHENGAPARA P.O. PATHARIGHAT P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG Page No.# 18/31

ASSAM PIN -784144

91: SRI JAMUNA BALA DEVI W/O SRI JOGESH SARMA VILL- DEBANANDA P.O. HAZARIKAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

92: SRI CHAYANIKA DAS W/O SRI JOGEN SAHARIA VILL- GAONBURHAPARA P.O. MANGALDAI P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784125

93: MD. BAHARUL ISLAM S/O MD. HAZARAT ALI VIL- BATABARI P.O BATABARI P.S. DHULA DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784146

94: SRI GOBINDRA CH. SARMA S/O LT. CHANDRA KT. SARMA VILL- BIJULIBARI P.O. MAROI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

95: ABU BAKKAR SIDDIQUE S/O LT. NAZAM UDDIN VILL- PANIA KHAT P.O. DHULA P.S. DHULA DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784146 Page No.# 19/31

96: SRI BISWARAJ PATHAK S/O LT. DUGDHAN CH. PATHAK VILL- BEZPARA P.O. MANGALDAI P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN - 784146.

97: SRI JAGAT CH. DEKA S/O LT. LALIT CH. DEKA VILL- BARSATRA P.O. DIGHIRPAR P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

98: MD. ALI AKBAR AHMED S/O LT. ALIMUDDIN AHMED VILL- MARUACHOWKI P.O. MARUACHOWKI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

99: MISS ASIA BEGUM W/O MD. ALI AKBAR AHMED VILL- MARUACHOWKI P.O. MARUACHOWKI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

100: SRI GOBINDRA SARMA S/O LT. NARESWAR SARMA VILL- PAKABANGI P.O. BORDOULGURI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

101: SRI ANTI RAM DEKA S/O SRI KAMI NATH DEKA VIL- GADHIA PARA Page No.# 20/31

P.O. CHAPAI CHOWKA P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784529

102: SRI RATUL HAZARIKA S/O LT. LAKSHMAN HAZARIKA

MANGALDAI TOWN P.O. MANGALDAI P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

103: SRI BHUPENDRA NARAYAN MAHANTA S/OLT. KANAK CH. MAHANTA VILL- LOZARA

P.S. PATHARIGHAT DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784147

104: SRI KUNJALATA SAHARIA W/O SRI KUMUD CH. DEKA VILL- HOWLY HENGERAJHAR P.O. HOWLY MOHANPUR P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784125

105: SRI RUPAK CHETRY S/O SRI BAL BAHADUR CHETRY VILL- TAKALIAKUR GRANT P.O. BAZANAPATHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

106: SRI LOHIT SAIKIA S/O LT. BELI RAM SAIKIA VILL- BORACHUBA Page No.# 21/31

P.O. HAZARIKAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

107: MD. ALI HUSSAIN S/O JAMARUDDIN VILL- OZAGAON P.O. KHARUPETIA P.S. DHULA DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784115

108: MD. HASIM ALI S/O LT. HAMID ALI VILL- TARAGAON P.O. CHENGELIAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

109: MD. BILLAL HUSSIAN S/O ABU TALEBUDDIN VILL- NO. 1 THEKERABARI P.O. BATABARI P.S. DHULA DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784146

110: MD. MAHARAM ALI S/OLT. QUMAR ALI VILL- ISLAMPUR P.O. KHARUPETIA P.S. DHULA DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784115

111: SRI DHIRAJ BORA S/O SRI HARI CH. BORA VILL- BIJULIBARI P.O.MAROI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG Page No.# 22/31

ASSAM PIN -784145

112: SRI REBAN CH. NATH S/O SRI RAHCHANDRA DEV NATH VILL- MALIBARITARI P.O. HENGALPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

113: SRI RAMBHAWATI DEVI S/O LT. KANTHA RAM SARMA VILL- GAVARA P.O. DUNI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

114: SRI KULEN KALITA S/O LT. KANAK KALITA VILL- PUB SAMALA KHAT P.O. BHURARGARH P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784147

115: SRI LAKSHYA DHAR DEKA S/O MINARAM DEKA VILL- NAGAON P.O. AULACHOWKA P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784125

116: SRI DIPAK KUMAR DAUKA S/O LT. GAGAN CH. DAUKA

P.O.MANGALDAI P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784125 Page No.# 23/31

117: MD ISHAD ALI S/O LT. AKBAR ALI VILL- ATHKURIAPARA P.O. PATHARIGHAT P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

118: MD. NAZMAL ALI S/O LT. MOSHIN ALI VILL- NAOPOTA P.O. CHENGELIAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

119: SRI UTPAL SAHARIA S/O LT. MANIK SAHARIA VILL- HAZARIKAPARA P.O. HAZARIKAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

120: SRI TAPAN SARMA S/O LT. RABI SARMA VILL- BOINAOJA P.O. AULACHOWKA P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784529

121: SRI JITENDRA KALITA S/O LT. TARANI KALITA VIL- DAGIAPARA P.O. HATIMARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784144

122: SRI MINAKSHI DEKA W/O SRI NANDESWAR DEKA VIL- LOZARA Page No.# 24/31

P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784147

123: SRI ARADHANA NATH W/O SRI MUNINDRA NATH VILL- PANIAKHAT P.O. DHULA P.S. DHULA DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784146

124: SRI BIREN BARUAH S/O LT. KARPUR BARUAH VILL- KAIKARA P.O. PATIDARRANG

P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784147

125: SRI ALAKA DEVI W/O SRI NIPENDRA NATH VILL- BALIPARA P.O. SIPAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

126: SRI GITANJALI DEVI W/O SRI ANANTA SARMA VILL- SARU THEKERABARI P.O. RANGAMATI P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784529

127: SRI DEBEN SARMA S/O LT. DAMODAR SARMA VILL- BHERUA P.O. DUNI Page No.# 25/31

P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784148

128: SRI GUNENDRA DEKA W/O SRI DINESWAR DEKA VILL- JHAKUAPARA P.O. HAZARIKAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

129: SRI MINAKSHI BARUA W/O SRI ANANTA CH. DEKA VILL- WARD NO.10 BHEBARGHT P.O. MANGALDAI P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

130: SRI MANORANJAN SARMA S/O LT. JUGESWAR SARMA VILL- NAYAKPARA P.O. DHEKIPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

131: SRI JEWTI BANIA W/O SRI GIRISH BANIA VILL- PITHAKHOWAPARA P.O. HAZARIKAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

132: MD. TAZZUL HOQUE S/O MD. SIRAJUL HOQUE VILL- WARD NO. 2 MANGALDAI TOWN P.O. MANGALDAI P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM Page No.# 26/31

PIN -784125

133: MD. KUTUBUDDIN AHMED S/O MD. RAHIMUDDIN AHMED VILL- PAKABANGI P.O. BORDOULGURI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

134: MRS. FARIDA KHATUN W/O KUTUBUDDIN AHMED VILL- PAKABANGI P.O. BORDOULGURI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

135: SRI KUSHAL SARMA S/O LT. JOGENDRA SARMA VILL- HAZARIKAPARA P.O. HAZARIKAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

136: SRI CHAKRADHAR DEKA S/O SRI PRABHAT CH. DEKA VILL- BORACHUBA P.O. HAZARIKAPAA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

137: SRI DEBAJANI SAHARIA D/O SRI TANKESWAR SAHARIA VILL- DAKSHIN CHUBURI P.O. SIPAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

138: SRI HEMALATA DEVI Page No.# 27/31

W/O LT. BHUMIDHAR NATH VILL- BARAMGUR P.O. GARUKHUTI P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

139: SRI BHANUMATI DEVI D/O TILAK CH. SARMA VILL- JHAKUAPARA P.O. BHUARGARH P.S. MANGALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM

PIN -784147.

140: SRI GHANASHYAM KR. SAIKIA S/O PITA RAM KUMAR VILL- CHENGAPARA P.O. SIPAJHAR P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

141: MEGHALI RANI SARMAH D/O MATHURA MOHAN SARMAH VILL- GARAIMARA P.O. DHEKIAPARA P.S. SIPAJHAR DIST. DARRANG ASSAM PIN -784145

142: MRS. FULESA BEGUM W/O MD. KHAIRUL HUSSAIN VILL- BANDIA P.O. MANALDAI DIST. DARRANG ASSAM VERSUS

THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 7 ORS. THROUGH THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM EDUCATION (ELEMENTARY) DEPARTMENT Page No.# 28/31

DISPUR GUWAHATI - 781006.

2:THE DIRECTOR EDUCATION (ELEMENTARY) DEPTT.

KAHILIPARA GUWAHATI- 781019. 3:THE DISTRICT ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER DARRANG MANGALDAI PIN- 784125.

4:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS

MANGALDAI DISTRICT CIRCLE MANGALDAI PIN- 784125.

5:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER KALAIGAON BLOCK DARRANG MANGALDAI PIN- 784125.

6:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER SIPAJHAR BLOCK DARRANG MANGALDAI PIN- 784125 7:THE BLOCK ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER DOLGAON BLOCK DARRANG MANGALDAI PIN- 784116.

8:THE SUB-DIVISIONAL SELECTION BOARD MANGALDAI SUB-DIVISION DARRANG CONSTITUTED VIDE NOTIFICATION NNO. B20H667/94/168 DATED 30/4/1997 AND REP. BY ITS CHAIRMAN DR. ZOI NATH SARMA RESIDENT OF UDAYAN HILL SIDE KHARGULI NABAGRAHA ROAD

GHY-4.

------------

Advocate for : MR. K M MAHANTA Advocate for : SC ELEM. EDU appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 7 ORS.

Page No.# 29/31

BEFORE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NELSON SAILO

ORDER Date : 17.02.2021 (K.R.Surana, J.)

Heard Mr. K. K. Mahanta, learned senior counsel, assisted by Mr. S. Borthakur,

learned counsel for the petitioners as well as Mr. N. J. Khataniar, learned

standing counsel for the Elementary Education Department.

2) This petition for review is in respect of a common judgment and order dated

23.02.2017 passed by this Court in WA No. 79/2015 and other connected cases thereby

dismissing the appeal and affirming the judgment and order dated 23.09.2014 passed by the

learned Single Judge in a series of 24 writ petitions, thereby dismissing all those writ

petitions.

3) Having heard the submission made by the learned senior counsel for the petitioners

and the learned standing counsel for the Elementary Education Department, this Court is

prima facie satisfied that the review petition would be maintainable even after dismissal of

SLP Nos. 22263-22265/2017 by order dated 04.10.2017 passed by the Hon'ble Supreme

Court of India by relying upon the ratio laid down in the case of Khoday Distilleries Ltd.

vs. Sri Mahadeshwara Sahakara Sakkare Karkhane Ltd., (2019) 4 SCC 376 .

4) In this review petition, the learned senior counsel for the petitioners have been able

to prima facie satisfy the Court that this Court had proceeded on the premise that all the Page No.# 30/31

appointments made between 20.11.1999 to 4.12.1999 was illegal and irregular as the

appointments were made without the selection and approval of the Sub-Divisional Level

Selection Board for Elementary Education of Mangaldoi Sub-Division for 1999.

5) In this regard, it is projected that the existence of a Select List dated 26.10.1999 of

all candidates under general area of Mangaldoi Sub-Division had come to the notice of the

petitioners after the disposal of WA 79/2015, which prima facie indicates that the said list was

approved by the Director of Elementary Education on 28.10.1991 and same also contains

endorsement under illegible signatures dated 26.10.1999 of (i) the Chairman for and as well

as (ii) Deputy Inspector of Schools/Member Secretary, of the Sub-Divisional Level Elementary

Education Advisory Board for General areas, Mangaldoi Sub-Division, and in this regard, the

learned senior counsel for the petitioners has submitted that in the writ and writ appellate

proceeding, the existence of the aforesaid select list was withheld by State respondents.

6) The observations made herein before are made only to record the prima facie

satisfaction for the purpose of admitting the review petition for hearing.

7) Accordingly, this review petition stands admitted for hearing. As the learned

Standing Counsel accepts notice on behalf of the respondents, requisite extra copies of the

review petition be served on him within 3 days.

8) In view of the nature of grievance made by the petitioners, the learned Standing

counsel for the respondents shall produce all the records relevant to this case.

9) Let the records of the connected writ appeal be tagged.

10) The respondents are granted two weeks time to file their response. Reply, if any, by

the petitioner may be filed within a week thereafter.

Page No.# 31/31

11) The I.A. (Civil)/2323/2020 shall be considered at the time of hearing connected

review petition.

12) Let the copy of the order be provided to the learned departmental counsel.

13) List this matter in the last week of March 2021, on a date to be fixed by the Office.

JUDGE JUDGE

Comparing Assistant