Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati

Kambhampati Penchalaiah vs Shashi Bhushan Kumar, I.A.S. on 8 February, 2024

IN TRE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATL
{Original Jurisdistian} °
THURSDAY, THE ERGHTH DAY OF FEBRUARY,

TYVO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FOUR
-PRESENTD:

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TARLADA RAJASEKHAR RAO.
CONTEMPT CASE NO: 49843 OF 2023

iL Ke unbhaznpati i Penchalaiah Died).
Sep. by his 1 & Son "'Kambhampati Chinnak ah,
. Aged out 52. years © ee Agric: iltare, --_

2. ukkaia Anlceiah,
Sig Papalah, .
Aged about 50 years, Coe: Agriculture,

os Kulkkala Panaiah (Died)
ne by his LR son Kukk ala Ankaiah, . _

9 Papaiah;. eo, : : _ ae
'Aged pout 58s years. oot Agricnt Ure, oo

2 hee"

. oN 3 . .

Al ~Kambhampati Lakshmnaiah (Died) |

. | Revd OY. his LR daughter Jali akarn Rei srteen
wie Mallaiah,

Aged ¢ about 42 years, Oce: Ho susewife,

8, _ Kambhe sapail s Adhai ae ™

Rep. by his LR Elderson Kam * asenpat Nar aims uln,
t sio Palaish Joe
7 Aged about 37 years, Dec Ago,

. 6. Karmb hampati Penchalaiah Wied).
. Rep. by: bis LR. soh Karmbhampat! Narasimhuly,
Aged about: 3? / years, Qe; Agric culture, :

Boman del akshmaith, _

GO Sid Narasaiah, 7
Age about &2 years, Ove; Agriculturd,-.
va .
Set a
7 lan



AR

hee

Tages,

at

alah,

co

cet
oy

2

rrYyyy

La

AAR

4 ped |
ony ong

nae anbecal

4

of -

ty fitin |
is wp ots
i baa
vat bes f
"2 trem 1G
3 sn
ron" a 3
ban od
wae
pe fot

s

¢ Say
UM,
0 vas

IX

Fr
ad
hy

ak
BEL,
our 4

Y
?

ubbai

a
LES.

he

. 7
PASH

ab
ds
by

AY

ed
Kambhar

art

ON

as
ie
x

¥
A

aad

a a
an ms ey .
. weed ay
nes oe uy a .
yeong ° Ba ie -
rf gene a ms
Saeed -
qoved,
:



MORAN CE Abd Oe te ce turttenetdeee:t

aX

$2
mond

vet a
Ae os,

<

Aged about 65 years, Oeer. Ag

Yallampani Ramaish, S/o Shesa igh,
Gr 'culture,
Yakesiri I vakshmaiah (Died) .
RB ep. 5 y his LR da ighter Adhuri Pencha lama
wid Sh esaiah, oS

are Clwses Learasveies
F Aged. about S7 years, Osc: Housewife,

Talakam Venkataiah Die d} .
Rep. by his LR son Jalakam Subbarayudu,

Aged about 5b years, Qce: Agriouiture

Ka ambhampati G Gansu ulaiah (died)
Rep. by his sok Kambhampati Avulaiah,

a byrad eb RS apes sen ARE x
Aged about SS years, Ceo: Agriculture

Kambhampatt'R Ramanaiah (Died), poe

2

Rep. by his L AR daughter Unik kav VATRADU Pia bha vathi,

wo Rajaiah,
Aged about 5 90 yea iS, Occ Housewife

K 'ambham pat i i Subba Jah s/o Chenchaiah,
Aged about &Q yes ars, Oce: Agriculture

¥ kasi Th nitupaldian S¥o Penchaldiah,
Aged about S2 years, Occ: Agri

Patra Sura a Ned),

Repeby bisavife P atta Satojanammia,

Aged 3 about So years, Ose: Housewife

Yakasirl Peachalaigh (Died)
Rep. by4 icf LR s son" Yakasiri Sivaiah,

Aged abc UE SG years, Ose: Agtisulture,

Jala ke arn Subba ume wie Venkataiah,

Aged about 50 yea is; Deo: 'Hou use wife


np
" oa oy

¥
3

oe
won
a
pe 7
foot o
ea
ia .
oe rh
= ed
aa "es
: ¢ sy
- . gn
roy ' .
er] Sang hand
weced . os. rw og
a me ee. 4 eile
"og yan es
on agen wk: rok :
EE bee "3 tong
wg OLS we, ce:
wen ie
+ 4 geet
eral J
OD: porn. os
"me LON haces
fo" x3 "
fed BS ge
Nevo? oe wid
' poe:
rome ae
a See 8G
ores : welt
ot . OS "pe
gs fp ey
ioral . heb rt
red SO gant
orey 3 at *
fod . rn :
a 8 S % 6%
ice pe A ne ms)
: og we a tee
ioe oS , %
On fe a cr
st OD a fs td cs] brates i
Se nt bog BA ne RE oo a
78 LE 6 ME SR soldd beet aed
ng ig pooh ea) fy td ,
Ct ny me Fae £3 ered oh,
ag 2 OY AE ERE moo
og. oy pe OS fog ao)
werent LY ong bee ES os eg
EG om vee 8 em "oh ipa ree . &
i A 8 A oot vecteg ENS ms
ae nth xd an KS whet
ad ae " feos im) nd vet wd
ot : ' ' ¢
ae ar are oo rs
' (NS ay om pe OS, "i
wot UO ep og

'Pr
x
R
af
24
2
we
Re
A

Loa ory .
"} ay ste) ' >
Cod . emt -
z Pm, ha a *
: 3 oy ee : wey . nop 6
: or; : Ey at >
rey . " Wo "
ey, Mo re!
; ory res,
mee
Me



tat

Se

a
{2,

Ag
ach

 Dhuggureddy Kamularnma (Diee
Bap, 4 AIS ] oR § Brandson Amus

Indla Naras giah ¢ (led),

ease SLR grandson Suri:y Yanadaiah
S/o Pedda Ankaiah .
Aged about 59 years, Oco: Agriculture, :

<

4

Wakk ale} Narayana (Die .),

"ey
%

Rep. | By Ris LR grandday ugh ter Surn Koncamma,
wid Rai Tigh, . .
Aged about 62 y ars, Oce: Housewife,

C Chapala Narayana (Died), _
Rep. by his LR arandson: urn Ramanaiah,
Séo Ramaiah, - .

Aged about 51 years, Oce: Agnsulture,

viadly & Narasa Re ddy (hed)

fh

Ty any a

Rep. by his LR grandson Chutdes f sage valab,
fy .

sioChinna ¥ Verk ata awaniy, o
Aged about 34 years, Oon: Agriculture

f znka Lakehini Na -asamma, ns

Rep. by his LE grandson Avula Venkata Keisheaiah,
sfo Yallniah, | .
Aged about 48 years, Qoc: Agriculture,

Lanks: Chinna Kon nuaiah (Med)... oe
Rep. by his LR grandson Sucu Nerasimhulu,

s/o Bodaiah, a a
Aged about 28 years, Deo: Agriguiture, 7

Aothurcre hirepalir Reddy (Died), -
'Rep. by his LR Grandson Sum Geng salah,

we

Aged about 62 2 years, Oeer Ag grioult iture,


. € wn . pent

oe inet at

eye, 2 . "LS whe?
ELS us Le

Deer an:

RAS Oe es

LO peed 1 A OSES Ot peed £ sey
% tee eon

Oh ogy o Gh ot es

oa. ed 3

eric:
R
1
bout
V

na

ve

ars: i A

fe he el ics oe "a

a whed oS . "SEL ™

, Spe % on wed

opt Ls TE cae re

trees im y tet "a

ot a a} a3 a 0

oe ag ae ae wt A

fo bis fe £2 O0 Tp 2,
« oa ° " . cf + .
a LL . is, wo 3 vened fh. ery
wage oe Kea ae) t wy wey WY


2%

LF
on

LA
mea}

7s)
iy et

ay
cy

Fae
peteds

mite

c
JX

Rep randsor: a hu kee

MPU pale (Died),

% raphy |
WR Rt a eswar MU,
Aged about 3 f years, Occ: Agrioulture,

Gollapalll Venkata Swamy ( (Died),
Rep. by his _ grands on . q

'sia ¥ ellaial

Aged about. a7 years, Ooe: Agric sulture,

Vac lapu uu Subba Rao (Died J.
Rep. by his 1. R grandsan. Chukka C C Chinne a 3 Verkatesu,
s/o Yellaiah. ws Le
A \ged about 46 5 years, , Ove Agriculture,

Gorn Subba Be eddy , (Died),

Rep. by his LR ® grandson n Chi ca Venka ATRL,
sfa- Yel! alah, oo

Mallu Venkataiah ie ed,

Rep, by his LR eran andson v Ava: Ramaish, :

BiG B cnchalaiah,
Aged ¢ about 42 years, Ove: Agricul re,

"ty we B®

Thumtindla Subbs Rayudy ied),

Rep. by his L R grandson C traklea | Penchalaiah; ~
s/o Yellaiah a -

Aged about 43 y s, Ove: Agriculture

Bernky Rosaiak (Died), |

Rep. by his LR erandsan: Chukka Ramalah,

s/o Yellaiah, oe

Out 40 yess, © Jo: Agric culture,

3
0h

Oo we
hed.

& :
oo

| Reddi ipagu Narasalah. (hte 2d),

Rep. by his SDR or ere andson Avula Bi lalate.
S/o Penchalaiah, = ee
Aged about 37 years, Oca: Agriculture,

Tree


ce

Sanam a:

ey
<3.

x

SUE

x

x

oS
1
oe
tA
ae

Ag
a patie

$
Dan
thy

>

nanaiak
ti

a

~ O
+ EN
i

&

Y

a

Ri
at
4

'a Elon:

ue

a!

Y

bed. gah

Lh,

LA

ary ee
Rg thesh,

ma

q

<
S Boe

Penchale

ot.
¥
i
&


._-
N

3
Ww

FO. Kambhampati Chinnalah (ied),
| Rep. by his LR grandson Avula Pe
s/o Penchalaiah, -_
Aged about, 320 years, See: Agriculture,

~

a EFL, Panta St Gangamona ed a

Rep. by ner LR grancson » Ay rule Nar asaiah,
afo Pe vachalaiah, .
Aged about $1 years, Occ: Agricuten re,

oan
ro

. 'Thikkevarapou Subbaiah ¢ (hed),
Rep. by his LR grandson ¥ata: Ramanaiah,
sfo Peedda. Subbaiah,. .
Aged about 52 years, Oce: : Agrioulture,

Lad

oar nbhampati Avulaiah (Died), .
Rep. by his LR gr anddaughter Veta Padamavathi, -
wo Venkata Subbaiah
Aged about 58 Years, Ove: : Housewife:
Tal Naligond 'a Konda Reddy (Diedjooc
Rep. by his LR: grandson Avula Chinna Narasitahulu, |
sfo Penchalalah, nas
Aged. about 47 years, Qoe: Agriculture,

aS Kambhampati Nag valah (Died),
Rep. by his LE ora ndd lauphtes Avala. Penchala amina,
vO Jacamaiah: :

Age ed abouLSg years, Doe: Housewife,

Patra Subbarayadu u DNedy 0

Rep. by his LR grandson Suru Potichalainh: ca
s/o Yanadai italy wie
Aged about 51 years, Oce: Agricul ture,

eee Kambhampati Chinnal al { (Died),

Rep. by his LR grandson: KRallicha appid idev enkaiah,
wid Ramanaiah, 7 °
Aged about 34 -years, Geo: Agrisulturs,

Sapennee



cad '4
+ ;
2
a4
es
ood
peered
"aE
vio
AS
erent
yee
ee
a
Or
Png «
et a3
ony head
a
SS
ooR ogee :
oe do ?
pas) oe
a 2S t3
tg up te
3 "3 c,, u
4 oy Sad Lond EE
Ce eed e . "e Pe
a ~ fh De ey
ies e83 Ened 4 i go
Fi hos , a ey
G oy cs oh Mh, oS
"4 aa Spey ig AP Soe
: & 2 a ny et we
' o aw 0, TS wn,
ee a th * wy es rs ae %
fs ones . ei ee ory "A
ewe ea + uty ws * Fed, oy
' wets omy an as Mod" ay "S45 hee
a re San EE te oy weg:
x z oF * .
oe ms tEord eS is @ --_
¥ A fat ob pea $
reeneenecen Ey oa © ome mls aA wehoct Eon, B
23 gy ie hy, et nba 4 eke beg Lo
fevnerrteeen: is 4 OS 8a he OE ond wit ~ Bo Ea og
we ben ONS os 46) Fa " . Cs e eg SA ° faa
paren By yo messed ee wd - '
cone ie ar' ; > prt TS om ee) % Le ty
ot pea nod + ee, % - 3 Ea pas: BR one
mi nee ay $234." ad bane Zale) "St 8B ONT,
B m 2p "2 O' oon ae " RAD
A Pa Es a Me cic oa
ot wie 4 rey ne ONS ee af. Ferisy a4 ead
ea wy 7, Nut GM ath oe Yeoh
Rey
2
*
. 7 oder apy
. ' ° oy core "a fe
-- wy tot Md .
x mn ad nee t


C82
ws

Ka

Xo.

EG
oD

; ay

a fa risa nals ab;

Munneris Venkat ta Subh ena
Rep. bY his LP. granddaughter. .

wh Ve cera Raghavuly,
Aged about (30 years, Goo: 9

Poluboina Petichalalah (Died), oo
Rep. by his LR eras sdson Surah Narasimbuly,
sfo Chinna Rarngiah, .

Aged about $2 years , Dec o: Agriculture,

Vakasiri Verikata unma { (Died), -

Rep. by her LR ¢ gtancson Sura \ fallem. ee padaiah,
sfo Chinna Ra math, -
Aged a about 34 years, Oe c: Agrion ulture

Bathala aHakka alah Med), .
Rep. by his LR grandson Chukka: N arasimhalus
' Penchalaiah, a
Aged al nout S8 years, Qee: Agri culture,

Pohuboina & Seothamma (Died), los se --_
Re ep. by her LR grandson.Awu la-Venkateshy ae
8fd 5 Ve nkataiah,

a

Aged about $1 years, Geo: A Agrion ture,

Cora Venkatalah | (ied),

Rep. by his LR grandds eughi vier Avala §

wit Venkataiah
Aged about 61. Years, Doo: H Housewife

2N

Thadeti Penchalai ah (Di Bde.

Rep. by his L RB gre ndson Chu ka Vame ne rishna, »

s/o Kishnaiak, |
Aged about 26 years, , Ove A "sr foulture,

Mabbu Sul bbamm: (Die he
Rep. by her LR. 'Brandson

ae


i,
one
veered!

a,

x

a
Pt wod
a
$2

ee

f 3 aN
Es ee % an.
eed ae
S "
roost bont
S reeds «
5 3
nd 5
"LA woes
ae Soet
134) regs
vee DAY
PA or
hag ea che |
: . :
nie wa - at «
: > ta ta np 5
vt r ay oe 5 ;
ren 0% os a 5 3
bane 4 Se g
fs tw Nene Saat cn, ' %
beroel
"Naot HES. i, . : la 7
$4 ih a os cot ~.
e < eg beg et ie
ae : ' ag me a
¥. ee 4 3 ; e
Tet bere a a3 g 2 :
ae SE fee . & a
So ey Pom py : oa
: ms | XG a a
f i. a
ey ees aes vod wered S nb _
an wack oa . Papen bekog wa OMA
Oe seb) aes us f no AD oh
S z Fa tt "fi oa
ees ais wae od op ve te
"oe ga ~ a sen cane "3
» 7 a : ty 'cs ve a
; he oy is : ba a &
ob ay ok Ba So m Ee
wee OP aS when 6S $3 wy Es a |
as) P outs ani ped oe coe
| } ~ oa * :
Oe nk a <4 wooed. aace
et ee ae gy Ok oi ps 3
oO 83 ty CaS 3) ot i, ~ ..
Cu 7 we bo pei won oe at -
| . > ry. 7 ' ' e
Jala i sg Bet, Po re -
yer «
; : * . fey,
cn x 'eaao s
3 "n5 Lo tren. wx tN ws pont
J ; " fen
ch io 4 C2 % ch, CoM ¢ on >
é
;

prreenere

aA bcd RS Ad NN tet tce bode nag Pedy


| iog,

Ae
LUGS,

TOE,

4G 7

£199.

Agu Thirupala (Died),

Rep, by his LR: grandson. Pindika Nerasimbulu,
ria Yellaiah, 7

Aged about 8? years, Oo ce: Agrioulture,

Thiruyven dala Subba Ramainh : (ON a), .

Rep. by his LR grandson Bom: nlla Gangalak,
sie Boda. ah,

Aged about 62 Years, Oce: Auriculture e,

Rehemai Pe enchalaiah ({ ied), a
Rep, by his LR grandson Bom: mille Musalaiah:
sigs & N ae arasaiah dy

Aged about $7 years; Qce: Agriculture, >

Kambhamy pac f. akshmaiah (Died),
SpA

Rep. by his LR granddaughter: Chik Lakh fammays

wo Yellaish,
Aged about 7 2 * years, Oeocs I Touse ewite,

oe hadi Rama Lakshu unaina (Died),
ep. by her 7. at grandson Bone Ha Veegiah
6 Bodaiah,

Aged abou t Sty ars, Dee: Agric: ulture

Umunadi Venkata Reddy. (Died},.-
Rep. by his LR grandson. Ch apals oRaje eshy:
sid Yellaiah,.

Aged about 32 ye ars, Os are Agric ture,

i, anka: Narayari atama. @ Hedy,

Rep, by her LR grandson Avela Ramanaiah,

s/o By itohai aly



UIE

N

ark

Bets



38, ee Gouse Gasha(ied}, Rep.
avo Subbaish, Aged ianeee Bah
ne the Pettioners are resid lenis of Somash
Mandal, SPS. Ne! tore Cistict}

by PHS LR ge andson Yata Venkata Subbaiah,
Ooo Agricasture.
% avi lage, Ananthasagaram

. ..Patiiioners

AND

1. Shashi Bhushan Kumar, LAS. The State of Andhra Pr adesh Rep. by us
Fyincipal Secretary, Water Resources Oe epariment, Secretadal, Velagapud,

Armaravaihl Guntur b strict, Andhra mace

ah Stale.

2. M. Rama Mohan, The Speci ial Cafiectar (LA.
Da,
f

}, Gsleru Nagan Suala orayarithi
YOS.R. Kacapa District
(LA), Somasda Project, Unity

"F

GNSS} Office of New Collectorata, Kada
x Bhaskar. ihe Special Depuh Collects
Rajampeta, YS.R. Kadana Distric
MVenkata Ramana Reddy. The Executive Engineer Somasila Project,
Division No TV, Almasur, S PSR Nelore District,

is

dn

Respondents

WHER EAS ihe Pellioners have presented under Sections 1G to 92 of the
Contempt of Courts Act 1974, above case through their counsel Sd CH.C Krishna
Reddy, praying that this Hon'ble High Court may be sleased fo punish fhe respondents
herein for flouting the orders in WLP.No.22019 of 2021, dated 18.03. 2023:

WHEREAS the said case coming on for hearing on this day and « vhereas the
High Court upor perusing the affidavit feild herein and the orders of | High Gouri dated
34.09.2023, 15.41.2028 & 29.14.2023 made herein and upoON Bearing the arguments -
of Sr CH.C Krishna Reddy, Advocate for the Petitioner and of MS &.Siva Muniari,
Advocate for the respondent Nos.1 & 4. SH C Vamsi Krishna, Advocate for the
Respondent No 2, made the following

ORDER:

"The Special Deputy Calfector {LA}, Somasila Project, Unity, Ralampet has Sled & counter and stated that this Court has disposed of the Writ Patitian without fing of the counter in the Wri Sedition and alsa on the ground admitting that where the O-form Patia ware signed by the then Tahsildar, Sidhout on 05.09.4986 but it is not signed hy the then Tatesiidar, Ponagalur and a notice was issued to the petiioners to appear before them for soncucting of enquiry before the Special Deputy Collector (Land Agquishion), Somasiia Project, Unity, Rajampet on 08.12.2023 at 11:00 a.m. along with praof of documaniary evidence like DKT House Sie Pattas, Rathon Cards, Aadhar cards, Death, Legal Heir Gerilficates, House Tax Receipts ate.,

Sut the petilleners ars not tured up for anguiry. Therefors, it is presumed that the Petitioners have no proof of dacumantary evidences in the subject matter, Hence,

itis revealed that petitionara are note eligible for payment of compensation in terme af

fall Bench Judgment of the Hon'ble High Court in LAG-cum-Revenug divisional Qificer ¥. Mekaia Pandu andl others'.

As seen fram the order of this Court, the inarned Government Pleacer has admitted that W.P.No,. 22049 of 2021 is agverad by the carson arder and the petitioners are the original assignees ars aniitied for sompensation and agreed to direct the rsapondaenis to pay the campensall tion ta the petitioners, basing on the said representation made by the isarned Government Pleader, the Writ Petition is disposed at,

Therefers, the cantention raised by the respondents Special Daputy Callectar {Land Acquisition}, Somasila Prajest, Unity, Rajampet is false.

This Court basing upon the rapresentation made by the learned Gavernnent Reader, tie Writ Petition is disposed of, but sow it tha counter, respondentidesarent ig stating that no opportunity was given while ciepasing of the case, which ja said to 3 false ,

Therefore, the Special Deputy Collector {Land Acquishion} shall present befora thie Court on the next date of hearing.

3 . 8998 Fo

Post the sratter an 19.02.2084." - edi. MLRA! Aesth BABU

DEPL ny RES ST