Sangam Lal Mishra vs State Of U.P. & 3 Others
2014 Latest Caselaw 5375 ALL

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
 
 

A.F.R.
 
Court No. - 21
 
Case :- WRIT - C No. - 45444 of 2014
 
Petitioner :- Sangam Lal Mishra
 
Respondent :- State Of U.P. & 3 Others
 
Counsel for Petitioner :- I.K. Dwivedi,Neeraj Dwivedi,R.A. Pal
 
Counsel for Respondent :- C.S.C.,Diwakar Singh,R.P. Shukla
 

 
Hon'ble Amreshwar Pratap Sahi,J.

Hon'ble Vivek Kumar Birla,J.

The petitioner is a fair price shop licence holder who has come up disputing the allotment of a second shop in the Gram Sabha concerned in favour of Bachhan Lal who has been impleaded today as respondent no.5 under our orders passed on the impleadment application represented by Sri Rameshwar Prasad Shukla, Advocate.

We have heard learned counsel for the petitioner, Sri Diwakar Singh, learned counsel for the respondent no.4 and the learned standing counsel for respondents no.1, 2 and 3 and Sri Shukla for the Respondent No.5.

Learned counsel for the parties agree that the matter be disposed of finally at this stage itself on the basis of the pleadings which are on record including the information of the Block Development Officer dated 3.12.2012 which has been supplied by Sri Shukla. The respondents do not propose to file any Counter-Affidavits. Learned counsel for the petitioner has also brought to our notice the Government Order dated 1.10.2013 as also the subsequent orders passed by the District Magistrate for implementation and identification of the units.

The dispute raised by the petitioner is to the allotment of a fresh shop in favour of respondent no.5 which has been approved on two grounds. Firstly, in view of the distance between two villages within the same Gram Sabha and the second ground is that according to the Government Order dated 17.8.2002 as well as the subsequent Government Orders, the number of ration cards has exceeded the number of 800, and the units entitled to receive essential commodities have also crossed the figure of 4,000.

The petitioner, therefore, contends that such grounds are not available to invoke the Government Orders on the facts of this case, inasmuch as the petitioner has brought on record the number of units as existing and certified on 24.6.2014, copy whereof has been filed as Annexure 9 to the writ petition which is less than 4000.

It is further submitted that the aforesaid figures are also reflected in an earlier letter of the Block Development Officer dated 10.1.2013, copy whereof has been filed as Annexure 3 to the writ petition.

We have perused the resolution passed by the Gaon Sabha and we find that the said resolution was forwarded to the Sub Divisional Magistrate, who has passed the orders on 16.7.2014 accepting the same and has directed for grant of another licence in favour of Sri Bachhan Lal. The consequential directions were given to the concerned supply office.

Sri Dwivedi submits that once the figures that have been certified by the Block Development Officer are less than 4,000/- units then in that event the very foundation of the resolution appears to have been passed on incorrect facts.

On the other hand, Sri R.P. Shukla has invited the attention of the Court to the letter dated 3.12.2012 which is of a prior date that indicates that the total number of units is 5215.

It is thus clear that the figure relied upon by the Gaon Sabha is of a previous period whereas the petitioner has relied on certain information that has been issued currently in 2014. The impugned order proceeds on the basis of such information of 2012. The Sub Divisional Magistrate does not appear to have considered the aforesaid aspects which have been raised by the petitioner and for which documents have been brought on record.

We had adjourned the matter to enable us to find out as who is the competent authority empowered to identify the number of units according to the definition of the word "Food Officer" as contained in Clause 2 (m) of the Uttar Pradesh Scheduled Commodities Distribution Order, 2004 read with the powers so assigned to the said Food Officer under the said order.

The Government Order dated 1.10.2013 has been brought to our notice by the learned Counsel for the petitioner which is to the following effect :-

"i= la[;k&[email protected]&6&2013&109 [email protected]

izs"kd]

tkosn mLekuh]

eq[; lfpo]

mRrj izns'k 'kkluA

lsok esa]

leLr ftykf/kdkjh]

mRrj izns'kA

[kk| ,oa jln vuqHkkx&6 y[kuÅ% fnukad 01 vDVwcj] 2013

fo"k;%& yf{kr lkoZtfud forj.k iz.kkyh ds dEI;wVjhdj.k gsrq jk'ku dkMksZ ds fMftVkbts'ku o u;s jk'ku dkMZ fuxZr djus dh izfdz;k& laca/khA

egksn;]

mRrj izns'k esa yf{kr lkoZtfud forj.k iz.kkyh ds dEI;wVjhdj.k gsrq orZeku esa izpfyr jk'kudkMZ ds izk:i esa xzke iapk;rokj jk'ku nqdkuksa ,oa dkMksZ dks ladfyr dj xr o"kksZ esa fMftVkbt fd;k x;k gSA ijUrq lEizfr visf{kr MkVk v|kof/kd ugh gSA vr% iwoZ esa fMftVkbt fd;s x;s jk'ku dkMksZ ds MkVkcsl dks vfrfjDr MkVk ladyu djkrs gq, v|kof/kd fd;k tkuk gSA lkFk gh jk'ku dkMksZ dk lR;kiu o Mh&MqIyhds'ku djkrs gq, u;s jk'ku dkMksZ dks vkWu&ykbu eqfnzr djkrs gq, tkjh fd;k tkuk gSA blds fy, fuEuor~ dk;Z;kstuk fu/kkZfjr dh tkrh gS%&

1- jk'kudkMZ /kkjdksa ds xzke dk uke] cSad [kkrk fooj.k o fuokZpd QksVks igpku i= la[;k dk ladyu fd;k tk,A lkFk gh izR;sd dkMZ/kkjd gsrq U;wure ,d eksckby Qksu uacj rFkk ifjokj ds izR;sd lnL; dh tUefrfFk o"kZ lfgr ladfyr dh tk;A

2- jk'kudkMZ /kkjdksa ds lwpukvksa ds ,d=hdj.k ds nkSjku muds fuokZpd QksVk igpku i= la[;k ds lkFk mDr dh QksVksdkWih Hkh izkIr dh tk,A

3- QwM flD;ksfjVh ,DV ds izkfo/kkuksa ds vUrxZr ykHkkfFkZ;ksa dks [kk|kUu miyC/k u djk;s tkus dh fLFkfr esa [kk| lqj{kk HkRrk fn;k tkuk gksxkA [kk| lqj{kk HkRrk lh/ks ykHkkFkhZ ds [kkrs esa gLrkUrj.k fd;s tkus ds izkfo/kku ds n`f"Vxr jk'kudkMZ /kkjdksa ds cSad [kkrk fooj.k ,d=hdj.k ;Fkk cSad [kkrk la[;k] cSad dk uke] 'kk[kk dksM la[;k] vkbZ0,Q0,l0lh0 dksM ds lkFk mlds cSad dh iklcqd ds izFke i`"B dh QksVksizfr Hkh izkIr dh tk,A

4- jk'kudkMZ /kkjdksa dh lwpuk ds viMs'ku dh izfdz;k esa vik= ifjokjksa ds [email protected] dkMZ fujLr fd;s tk, ,oa fujLr dkMksZ ds LFkku ij fu;ekuqlkj ik= YkkHkkfFkZ;ksa dks u;s dkMZ fn;s tk,A rn~uqlkj fujLr gksus okys o u;s cuus okys dkMksZ dk fooj.k Hkh MkVkcsl esa QhM fd;k tk;sxkA

5- jk'kudkMZ /kkjdksa ls lwpuk izkIr djus dk dk;Z izkFkfed :i ls mfpr nj fodszrkvksa ds ek/;e ls lEiUu djk;k tk, rFkk buds dk;Z ds fudV Ik;Zos{k.k ds fy, ys[kiky] xzke fodkl vf/kdkfj;ksa o xzke iapk;r vf/kdkfj;ksa dks nkf;Ro fn;k tk,A

6- ftykf/kdkjh Lrj ls fnukad 05-10-2013 ls 07-10-2013 rd izR;sd xzke iapk;r esa 04&04 fnu dk dSEi yxk;s tkus dk dk;Zdze tkjh fd;k tk,xkA izR;sd fnu esa vkSlru 400 dkMksZ dk fooj.k Hkjk tkuk visf{kr gSA rn~uqlkj vkSlru 1600 jk'kudkMksZ dk fooj.k mDr 04 fnolh; dSEi esa izkIr gks ldsxkA NwVs gq, O;fDr;ksa ds fy, iqu% 02 fnu dk dSEi izR;sd xzke iapk;r esa yxk;k tk,A mDr dSEiksa }kjk lwpuk ladyu dk dk;Z rhu lIrkg esa fnukad 21-10-2013 ls 15-11-2013 rd djk;k tk,A

ftykf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk mDrkuqlkj tkjh dk;Zdze ds vuqlkj izR;sd xzke iapk;r esa frfFk;ka fu/kkZfjr dj mfpr nj fodszrkvksa }kjk fu/kkZfjr jk'kudkMZ izk:i ij ykHkkfFkZ;ksa ds fooj.k lqlaxr vfHkys[ksa dh izfr ;Fkk fuokZpd QksVks igpku i= dh QksVksdkWih] cSad iklcqd dh QksVksdkWih] ?kks"k.k i= lfgr izkIr fd;s tk,axsA ftykf/kdkjh }kjk mDr dSEiksa esa lwpukvksa dks lR;kfir djkus gsrq ;FkklEHko ys[kiky] xzke fodkl vf/kdkjh] xzke iapk;r vf/kdkjh] vkiwfrZ fyfid o vkiwfrZ fujh{kd dh M~;wVh Hkh yxkbZ tk,xhA

7- mijksDrkuqlkj ladfyr lwpukvksa dks lekukUrj :i ls fnukad 25-10-2013 ls izfrfnu ftyk Lrj ij ftyk iwfrZ vf/kdkjh }kjk lEcfU/kr lkW¶Vos;j esa QhM djk;k tkrk jgsxkA MkVk QhfMax ds dk;Z esa ftyk Lrj ij miyC/k fjokfYoax Q.M dh /kujkf'k dk iz;ksx fd;k tk ldrk gSA

8- jk'kudkMZ /kkjd lEcU/kh ladfyr lwpukvksa dh leLr dEI;wVj QhfMax fnukad 15-11-2013 rd lqfuf'pr dj yh tk,A

9- fnukad 25-11-2013 rd mijksDrkuqlkj bu ladfyr lwpukvksa dk Mh&MqIyhds'[email protected]'[email protected] dk dk;Z ,u0vkbZ0lh0 }kjk iwjk fd;k tk,xkA

10- Mh&[email protected] MkVk ,u0vkbZ0lh0 Hkkjr ljdkj }kjk vius lkW¶Vos;j esa fnukad 30-11-2013 rd *Qzht* dj vfUre dj fn;k tk,xkA

11- lekukUrj :i ls ftykf/kdkfj;ksa ds ek/;e ls fnukad 15-11-2013 rd leLr {ks=h; [kk| vf/kdkfj;ksa rFkk [k.M fodkl vf/kdkfj;ksa dks fMftVy gLrk{kj fuxZr djkdj mUgsa [krkSuh vkfn dh Hkkafr vkWuykbu jk'ku dkMZ eqnz.k o fuxZeu gsrq izf'kf{kr fd;k tk,xkA

12- fnukad 02-12-2013 ls 15-12-2013 rd jk'kudkMksZ dk vkWuykbu eqnz.k ,oa rRi'pkr~ mudk forj.k lqfuf'pr fd;k tk,xkA

13- izf'k{k.k dk;Zdze%&

mDr leLr dk;Z lEiUu djus gsrq fuEukuqlkj izf'k{k.k o rS;kjh dh tk,xh%&

(i) fnukad 03-10-2013 rFkk 04-10-2013 dks leLr ftykf/[email protected]j ftykf/kdkjh] [email protected][; fodkl vf/kdkfj;ksa rFkk leLr miftykf/kdkfj;[email protected][k.M fodkl vf/kdkfj;[email protected] iwfrZ vf/kdkfj;ksa dks ,u0vkbZ0lh0 ls ohfM;ks dkWUQszflax }kjk lwpukvksa ds ,d=hdj.k ds lEcU/k esa izf'kf{kr fd;k tk,xkA bldk dk;Zdze [kk|k;qDr }kjk i`Fkd ls tkjh fd;k tk,xkA

(ii) fnukad 10-10-2013 ls 15-10-2013 rd mijksDrkuqlkj izf'kf{kr mi ftykf/[email protected] iwfrZ vf/[email protected][k.M fodkl vf/kdkfj;ksa }kjk vius {ks=h; [kk| vf/kdkfj;[email protected] fujh{[email protected] fodkl vf/[email protected] iapk;r vf/[email protected][kikyksa dks ,oa jk'ku fodszrkvksa dks lwpuk ladyu ds fy, [email protected] [k.M Lrj ij izf'kf{kr fd;k tk,xkA

(iii) izf'k{k.k dh vof/k esa lwpuk ladyu djus ds izk:i Hkh ftykiwfrZ vf/kdkjh }kjk mfpr nj fodszrkvksa dks miyC/k djk fn;s tk,axsA rnuqlkj fodszrkvksa dks miyC/k djk;s tkus okys izk:iksa esa orZeku miyC/k MkVk Hkh fo|eku gksxkA

14- tulkekU; dks bl o`gn vfHk;ku dk iwjk ykHk nsus gsrq vko';d gS fd tuinksa esa mDr dk;Zdze dk O;kid o izHkkoh izpkj&izlkj Hkh djk;k tk,A

mijksDr o`gn~ o egRoiw.kZ dk;Z dks le;c) :i ls iw.kZ djus ds fy, vkids Lrj ls lHkh lEcfU/kr vf/kdkfj;ksa dks lrr~ funsZ'k fn;s tkus o izHkkoh leh{kk fd;s tkus dh vis{kk dh tkrh gSA

Hkonh;]

¼tkosn mLekuh½

eq[; lfpoA

la[;k&3575¼1½@29&6&2013 rn~fnukadA

mi;qZDr dh izfrfyfi fuEufyf[kr dks lwpukFkZ ,oa vko';d dk;Zokgh gsrq izf"kr%&

1- vk;qDr] [kk| ,oa jln dks lrr~ vuqJo.k djrs gq, voxr djkus gsrqA

2- leLr e.Myk;qDr dks bl vk'k; ds lkFk fd d`i;k mDr dk fdz;kUo;u vius e.My ds leLr tuinksa esa le;c) :i ls djkus dk d"V djsaA

3- leLr mik;qDr ¼[kk|½] mRrj izns'kA

4- leLr ftykiwfrZ vf/kdkjh] mRrj izns'kA

5- xkMZ QkbyA

vkKk ls

¼eqjyh/kj nqcs½

fo'ks"k lfpoA"

The said Government Order has been issued under the powers conferred on the State Government under Clause 2 (m) of the 2004 Order which prescribes several authorities including the Block Development Officer as also one of the officers who is obliged to be trained to carry out the job of identification of the number of units.

Consequently, we are of the opinion that in the face of two conflicting figures by the Block Development Officer as pointed out by the learned counsel for the parties, which has not been considered by the Sub Divisional Magistrate, the impugned order cannot be sustained. Accordingly, the order dated 16.7.2014 and the consequential order dated 24.7.2014 are hereby quashed.

The writ petition is allowed with a direction to the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Meja, District Allahabad to proceed to ascertain the aforesaid facts as disputed between the parties in relation to the number of units as also the provisions of the Government Order applicable to the controversy, and then proceed to pass an order preferably within six weeks' from the date of presentation of a certified copy of this order before him.

Order Date :- 29.8.2014

Anand Sri./-