Ratan Singh vs State Of U.P. & Another
2014 Latest Caselaw 4356 ALL

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
 
 


 
Court No. - 21
 

 
Case :- WRIT - C No. - 42184 of 2014
 

 
Petitioner :- Ratan Singh
 
Respondent :- State Of U.P. & Another
 
Counsel for Petitioner :- Y.P. Yadav,Nirbhay Kumar
 
Counsel for Respondent :- C.S.C.,Baleshwar Chaturvedi
 

 
Hon'ble Amreshwar Pratap Sahi,J.

Hon'ble Vivek Kumar Birla,J.

Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri Baleshwar Chaturvedi for the respondent.

The petitioner applied for a tubewell connection for a five horse power electrically operated motor in the year 2010.

The contention of the petitioner is that he was never informed about the estimate pertaining to the said connection and he was waiting for a reply from the respondent electricity department.

Recently, on information received he has come to know that the estimate dated 27.2.2010, copy whereof is Annexure 2 to the writ petition had been prepared and since the petitioner did not comply with the aforesaid invoice and the conditions thereof, the petitioner's application form appears to have been consigned.

We have also perused the said estimate, and from the last part of Clause 3 it appears that some months were provided to the petitioner to complete the formalities which does not appear to have been done.

Almost four years have passed by and in such circumstances the application cannot be revived and the petitioner would have to exercise other options.

However, in the instant case Sri Chaturvedi informs that the Government Order dated 15.5.2012 at Serial No. 19 of Schedule has declared the block of the petitioner, namely Hathras a dark area and as such no such connection for tubewell can be granted. The Government Order dated 15.5.2012 alongwith the relevant schedule is extracted hereinunder:-

is"kd]

tkosn mLekuh]

eq[; lfpo]

mRrj izns'k 'kkluA

lsok esa]

1&leLr izeq[k [email protected] 4&leLr ftykf/kdkjh

mRrj izns'k 'kkluA mRrj izns'kA

2&leLr foHkkxk/;{[email protected] 5&leLr eq[; fodkl vf/kdkjh

dk;kZy;k/;{k] mRrj izns'kA mRrj izns'kA

3&leLr e.Myk;qDr]

mRrj izns'kA

y?kq flpkbZ ,oa HkwxHkZ ty vuqHkkx&1 y[kuÅ % fnukad % ebZ 15 2012

fo"k;& HkwxHkZ ty lalk/kuksa ds uohure vkadyu ¼ 31 ekpZ] 2009 ij vk/kkfjr½ ds vuqlkj fodkl [k.Mksa ds oxhZdj.k dh lwph dk is"k.kA

egksn;]

vki voxr gksaxs fd izns'k esa HkwxHkZ ty lalk/kuksa dk okf"kZd vkadyu ty lalk/ku ea=ky;] Hkkjr ljdkj }kjk xfBr Hkwty vkadyu lfefr&1997 ¼th0bZ0lh0&97½ ds ekxZ&funsZ'kksa ,oa esFkksMksykth ds vk/kkj ij orZeku esa izR;sd pkj o"kksZ ds vUrjky ij fd;k tkrk gSA HkwxHkZ ty foHkkx }kjk izns'k esa o"kZ 2004 ds i'pkr~ Hkwty lalk/kuksa dk fodkl [k.Mokj vkadyu o"kZ 2008&09 ¼31 ekpZ] 2009½ dh Hkwty fLFkfr ds vk/kkj ij lEikfnr fd;k x;k gSA bl v/;;u ds vk/kkj ij foHkkx }kjk rS;kj dh x;h ^^Hkwty vkadyu fjiksVZ] 2009^^ dsUnzh; Hkwty ifj"kn dks ty lalk/ku ea=ky;] Hkkjr ljdkj ds vuqeksnukFkZ ,oa fuxZeukFkZ izsf"kr dh x;h FkhA

2& ty lalk/ku ea=ky; }kjk vuqeksfnr mDr fjiksVZ 'kklu dks izkIr gks x;h gSA fjiksVZ es 31 ekpZ] 2009 ij vk/kkfjr Hkwty lalk/kuks dh miyC/krk ,oa fodkl Lrj dk ifjn`'; fn;k x;k gS] ftlds vuqlkj izns'k ds 820 fodkl [k.Mks es ls 76 fodkl [k.M vfrnksfgr ¼Over- exploited½ 32 fodkl [k.M fdzfVdy] 107 fodkl [k.M lseh fdzfVdy rFkk 'ks"k 605 fodkl [k.M lqjf{kr Js.kh es oxhZd`r fd;s x;s gSaA tcfd 31 ekpZ] 2004 dh Hkwty fLFkfr ds vk/kkj ij iwoZ es fd;s x;s vkdyu es dsoy 37 fodkl [k.M vfrnksfgr] 13 fodkl [k.M fdzfVdy] 88 fodkl [k.M lseh fdzfVdy rFkk 682 lqjf{kr Js.kh es lwfpc} fd;s x;s FksA blls ;g Li"V gS fd izns'k es Hkwty lalk/kuks ij c<+rh fuHkZjrk ,oa vR;f/kd nksgu ds ifj.kke Lo:i ladV xzLr fodkl [k.Mks dh la[;k es foxr o"kkZ es mYyss[kuh; ¼significant½ o`f} gq;h gSA ;g ,d fpUrk tud fLFkfr gSA

3& mYys[kuh; gS fd uohu Hkwty vkdyu] 2009 ds vuqlkj oxhZd`r 76 vfrnksfgr ,oa 32 fdzfVdy fodkl [k.M] ;kuh dqy 108 fodkl [k.Mks] tks izns'k ds 34 tuinks es vofLFkr gS] es vo 'kklukns'k la[;k % [email protected] & 2&08&[email protected] ¼42½@98 fnuakd 31 ebZ] 2006] la[;k % [email protected]@12 ¼14½@2001 fnuakd 19 twu] 2004 ,oa la[;k % [email protected]&2&98&[email protected] ¼34½@98] fnuakd 04 flrEcj] 1998 ds izkfo/kkuks ds vUrxZr dze'k% fu'kqYd cksfjax ;kstuk] e/;e xgjs uydwi ;kstuk ,oa futh xgjs uydwiks dh ;kstuk dk fdz;kU;ou ugh fd;k tk;sxkA

4& mDr Hkwty vkadyu] 2009 ij vk/kkfjr fodkl [k.Mks ds oxhZdj.k dh lwph ¼vfrnksfgr] fdzfVdy ,oa lsehfdzfVdy½ layXu dj eq>s ;g dgus dh vis{kk dh x;h gS fd Hkwty izcU/ku dh n`f"V ls oxhZd`r fofHkUu Js.kh ds fodkl [k.Mks] esa le;& le; ij HkwxHkZ ty foHkkx }kjk fuxZr ekxZ funsZ'kks ds vuqlkj lEcfU/kr foHkkx vius foHkkx dh vko';Drkvks ds vuq:i Hkwty fodkl] izcU/ku] o"kkZ ty lap;u ,oa Hkwty fjtkpZ ls lEcfU/kr dk;Z&;kstuk,a rS;kj dj dk;Zokgh djus dk d"V djsaaA d`i;k vius vf/kuLFk leLr lEcfU/kr [email protected] dks Hkh mDr ls voxr djkus dk d"V djsaA

5& mDr fjiksVZ ds lEcU/k es vf/kd tkudkjh ds fy, funsZ'kd HkwxHkZ ty foHkkx] mRrj izns'k uoak ry] bfUnjk Hkou y[kuÅ ¼nwjHkk"k% 0522&2287233] 2287068] QSDl % 0522&2288471] bZ&esy % [email protected]½ ,oa muds {ks=h; [k.Mks ls lEidZ fd;k tk ldrk gSA

layXud&mijksDrkuqlkjA

Hkonh;

¼tkosn mLekuh½

eq[; lfpoA

la[;k& [email protected]&1&2012

izfrfyfi fuEufyf[kr dks lwpukFkZ ,oa vko';d dk;Zokgh gsrq iszf"kr gS %&

1&futh lfpo] ekuuh; ea=h th] y?kq flpkbZ ,oa HkwxHkZ ty foHkkx mRrj izns'k 'kkluA

2& LVkQ vkfQlj] eq[; lfpo mRrj izns'k 'kkluA

3& LVkQ vkfQlj] d`f"k mRiknu vk;qDr] mRrj izns'k 'kkluA

4& v/;{k] mRrj izns'k ty izcU/ku ,oa fu;ked vk;ksxA

5& v/;{k] dsUnzh; Hkwty ifj"kn ubZ fnYyhA

6& eq[; egkizcU/kd] ukckMZ] y[kuÅA

7& izcU/k funs'kd] mRrj izns'k jkT; 'kgdkjh xzkE; fodkl cSad fyfeVsM 10 eky ,osU;w y[kuÅA

8& funs'kd] HkwxHkZ ty foHkkx] mRrj izns'k y[kuÅA

vkKk ls

¼nqxkZ 'kadj feJ½

izeq[k lfpoA

HkwxHkZ ty foHkkx mRrj izns'k

izns'k esa Hkwty fodkl dh fLFkfr % fodkl[k.Mks dk tuinokj oxhZdj.k ¼31 ekpZ 2009½ ¼vfrnksfgr] fdzfVdy o lseh fdzfVdy fodkl[k.Mks dh lwph½

dz0 la0

Tkuin

fodkl[k.M

vfrnksfgr

fdzfVdy

lseh fdzfVdy

vkxjk

1&vdksyk

1&lS;Wk

1&vNusjk

2&cjkSyh vghj

2& txusj

3&fcpiqjh

3& [ksjkx<+

4&Qrsgiqj fldjh

5& [kUnkSyh

6&lelkckn

vyhx<+

1& vrjkSyh

1& pUnksl

2&bxykl

3& [ksSj

bykgkckn

1& djNuk

1& cgknqjiqj

2& /kkuqiqj

3& dkSM+hgkj

4& izrkiiqj

5& lSnkckn

6& Åjok

vEcsndjuxj

1& Hkhrh

ckxir

1& ckxir

1& cM++kSr

2& fcukSyh

3& NijkSyh

4& [ksdM+k

5& fiykuk

caknk

1& franokjh

cjsyh

1& e>xoak

2& ehjxat

fctukSj

1& uwjiqj

1& L;ksgkjk

2& tyhyiqj

cnk;w

1& vEch;kiqj

1& txr

2& vklQiqj

2& lkykjiqj

3& fclkSyh

4& xqUukSj

5& bLykeuxj

6& tqukobZ

7& lgloku

cqyUn'kgj

1& xqykoVh

1& vxkSrk

2& [kqtkZ

2& ch0 ch0 uxj

3& igklw

4& fldUnjkckn

fp=dwV

1& dohZ

1& jkeuxj

,Vk

1& ekjgjk

1& vyhxat

2& fu/kkSyhdyWk

3& ldhV

QStkckn

1& chdkiqj

2& rk:u

Qrsgiqj

1& vekSyh

1& ,sjk;Wk

2& glok

2& cgqvk

3& gFkxako

3& nsoebZ

4& eyoWk

4& [ktqgk

5& rsfy;kuh

6& fotbZiqj

fQjkstkckn

1& vjWko

2& ,dk

3& fQjkstkckn

4& uk[khZ

5& VwUMyk

th0ch0

uxj

1& tsoj

1& folj[k

2& nudkSj

xkft;kckn

1& yksuh

1& Hkkstiqj

1& gkiqM+

2& flEHkkoyh

xkthiqj

1& xkthiqj

2& t[kfu;Wk

3& dj.Mk

4& lSniqj

gkFkjl

¼egkek;k uxj½

1& gkFkjl

1& lknkckn

1& lgiÅ

2& ewjlku

3& lkluh

ts0ih0 uxj

1& vejksgk

1& /kukSjk

2& xtjkSyk

3& gluiqj

4& tks;k

tkSuiqj

1& cDlk

1& cnykiqj

1& cjlBh

2& djUtkdyk

2& /kekZiqj

2& MksHkh

3& dsjkdr

3& egjktxat

3& [kqVgu

4& fljdksuh

4& eqQ~rhxat

5& fldjkjk

6& lqtkuxat

>aklh

1& eÅjkuhiqj

1& caxjk

1& cchuk

2& cM+kxako

3& fpjxako

dUukSt

1& tykykckn

1& dUukSt

2& rkyxzke

dkuiqj uxj

1& Hkhrjxako

1& ?kkVeiqj

2& ljlkSy

3& f'kojktiqj

dak'khjke uxj

1& dklxat

dkS'kkEch

1& pk;y

1& dM+k

1& usoknk

2& fljkFkw

2& ea>uiqj

3& ewjrxat

y[kuÅ

1& eky

2& efygkckn

3& eksguykyxat

egksck

1& tSriqj

1& dcjbZ

2& iuokjh

esSuiqjh

1& ojukoy

2& eSuiqjh

eFkqjk

1& cYnso

1& Qjg

2& ukSg >hy

2& eWkV

3& jk;k

esjB

1& [kj[kkSnk

1& nkSjkyk

2& jtiqjk

2& gfLrukiqj

3& eokuk

fetkZiqj

1& e>oWk

1& Nkuos

2& lh[kM

2& lhVh

3& dksu

eqjknkckn

1& vleksyh

1& fcykjh

1& fMykjh

2& cgtksbZ

2& Mhx<+iqj

2& eqjknkckn ¼lnj½

3& cfu;k[ksM+k

4& iWoklk

5& lEHky

eqtQ~Qj uxj

1& c?kjk

1& pjFkkoy

2& cq<+kuk

2& tkulB

3& dSjkuk

4& dka/kyk

5& 'kkgiqj

6& 'kkeyh

7& Fkkuk Hkou

8& Åu

izrkix<+

1& izrkix<+ lnj

1& l.Mok pfUnzdk

1& ckck csy[kjukFk

2& f'kox<+

2& iV~Vh

jk;cjsyh

1& ljsuh

1& cgknqjiqj

2& gfjpUnziqj

3& [khjksa

4& ykyxat

5& egjktxat

6& vjkgh

7& lrkoW

jkeiqj

1& pejkSvk

1& 'kkgkckn

2& lSnuxj

lgkjuiqj

1& cfy;k[ksM+h

2& xaxksg

3& eqtQ~Qjkckn

4& ukxy

5& uadqM+

6& ukukSrk

7& iqoWkjdk

8& ljlkok

lar jfonkl uxj

1& veksyh

2& Kkuiqj

3& lqfj;akoWk

lksuHknz

1& ?kksjkoy

lqyrkuiqj

1& v[k.M uxj

2& HknS;k

3& Hkknj

4& nwcsiqj

5& txnh'kiqj

6& t;flagiqj

7& izrkiiqj deS/kk

8& laxzkeiqj

9& 'kkgx<+

10& 'kqdqy cktkj

okjk.klh

1& vkjkth ykbu

1& cM+kxWko

2& gjgqvk

2& fpjbZxako

3& pksykiqj

4& dk'kh fo|kihB

5& fi.Mjk

dqy ;ksx

uksV%& izns'k ds 'ks"k 605 fodkl [k.M lqjf{kr Js.kh esa oxhZd`r gSaA

¼ty lalk/ku ea=ky;] Hkkjr ljdkj }kjk vuqeksfnr½

In the aforesaid circumstances, it will be open to the petitioner to apply afresh as and when the State Government chooses to lift such ban as imposed under the Government Order dated 15.5.2012.

With the aforesaid observations, the writ petition is consigned to records.

Order Date :- 13.8.2014

Lalit Shukla