The Delhi High Court has issued a significant injunction against the owner of an online makeup and skincare product retailer, Oykaa, prohibiting them from using the mark "Oykaa" or any similar mark to "Nykaa." Nykaa is a renowned e-commerce company that specializes in beauty, wellness, and fashion products. The decision comes after Nykaa filed a suit alleging trademark infringement by Oykaa.
Justice Prathiba M. Singh, who presided over the case, ordered that the website www.oykaa.com, and other online listings associated with Oykaa, must be immediately taken down. Furthermore, the court directed that if the website owner does not comply with this order, Nykaa is authorized to approach the appropriate domain name registrar to lock and suspend the "oykaa.com" domain.
Brief Facts of the Case:
In the case of FSN E-COMMERCE VENTURES LTD & ANR. vs. PINTU KUMAR YADAV & ANR. (CS(COMM) 726/2023), the plaintiffs, FSN E-COMMERCE VENTURES LTD (referred to as Nykaa) and Nykaa E-Retail Pvt. Ltd., are engaged in the business of manufacturing, selling, and distributing various cosmetic and wellness products, as well as fashion items. Nykaa has operated an online wellness store since 2012 and has gained substantial recognition and market capitalization in India's cosmetic and wellness sector. They have obtained multiple trademark registrations for the mark "NYKAA" in various classes.
The defendants, Pintu Kumar Yadav and Cosmetify (Defendant No. 1 and Defendant No. 2, respectively), applied for the trademark "OYKAA" in December 2022 in connection with a wide range of cosmetic products in class 3. The plaintiffs contended that this mark was deceptively similar to their mark "NYKAA" despite the absence of the letter 'N.' The defendants were engaged in marketing cosmetic products and operated the website www.oykaa.com.
Nykaa argued that they are the rightful owners of the trademark "NYKAA," which they have used and promoted extensively since 2012. They have also applied for well-known status for this mark with the Trade Mark Registry. They claimed to have obtained multiple trademark registrations for "NYKAA" in various classes, both in India and internationally, and have established a substantial presence in the cosmetics and wellness market.
The defendants, Pintu Kumar Yadav and Cosmetify, did not appear in court and did not present their side of the case. As a result, there were no formal contentions or defenses provided by the defendants in response to Nykaa's claims.
Observations by the Court:
The court observed that Oykaa's adoption of the mark was relatively recent. The name, mark, and overall appearance of Oykaa's website gave the clear impression that Oykaa had deliberately attempted to imitate and copy Nykaa's mark in an effort to gain financial benefits through deceptive practices.
Decision of the Court:
The court granted an ad-interim injunction in favor of Nykaa, stating that the balance of convenience weighed in Nykaa's favor.
Case Title: FSN E-COMMERCE VENTURES LTD & ANR vs PINTU KUMAR YADAV & ANR
Coram: Justice Prathiba M Singh
Case No.: CS(COMM) 726/2023, I.A. 20126/2023, 20127/2023, 20128/2023
Advocates of the Petitioners: Mr Saikrishna Rajagopal, Mr Vivek Ayyagari, Mr Angad S Makkar & Mr Rishabh Rao, Advs.
Advocates of the Respondent: None
Read Order @LatestLaws.com:
Share this Document :Picture Source :
