'A Jail cell is not a recovery mechanism': HC Calls out Family Court for keeping maintenance Defaulter behind bars beyond what the Law Permits

Recently, the Allahabad High Court questioned the continued incarceration of a man in a maintenance case, seeking an explanation from the Family Court in Mathura for keeping him in custody since May 2025. The Court’s intervention highlights growing judicial concern over misuse of coercive powers in enforcing maintenance orders, particularly where imprisonment appears to exceed statutory limits.

The matter arose from a criminal revision filed by Prem Singh challenging a Family Court order passed under Section 125(3) CrPC. The petitioner contended that he had been kept in continuous custody through successive orders without being released, effectively resulting in prolonged imprisonment for non-payment of maintenance. It was argued that such a practice violates the statutory scheme, which permits only limited detention for default.

Relying on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Rajnesh v. Neha and a recent High Court precedent, counsel submitted that recovery of maintenance should primarily follow civil mechanisms like attachment of property, and that repeated arrest warrants cannot be used as a substitute for lawful recovery.

Justice Praveen Kumar Giri took note of the statutory framework under Section 125(3) CrPC, which caps imprisonment for non-payment of maintenance at one month per default after execution of a warrant. The Court found the allegation of continuous custody without release serious enough to warrant scrutiny, observing that such detention may run contrary to the legal limits prescribed.

Emphasizing the need for procedural compliance, the Court effectively questioned the legality of repeated incarceration, noting that imprisonment under maintenance law is limited and cannot be used as an indefinite coercive tool.

The Court has directed the Principal Judge, Family Court, Mathura to submit a detailed explanation before the next date of hearing.

Disclaimer: This news/ article includes information received via a syndicated news feed. The original rights remain with the respective publisher.