Rajasthan High Court - Jodhpur

Abdul Jabbar vs Aftab Mohammed (2025:Rj-Jd:13677) on 11 March, 2025

Author: Rekha Borana

Bench: Rekha Borana

[2025:RJ-JD:13677]

      HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT
                       JODHPUR
                 S.B. Civil Misc. Appeal No. 3085/2024

1.       Abdul Jabbar S/o Late Shri Fakir Mohammed, Aged About
         62 Years, Resident Of Sadar Bazar Makrana District
         Nagaur
2.       Abdul Hameed S/o Late Shri Fakir Mohammed, Aged
         About 48 Years, Resident Of Sadar Bazar Makrana District
         Nagaur
3.       Abdul Samad S/o Late Shri Fakir Mohammed, Aged About
         46 Years, Resident Of Sadar Bazar Makrana District
         Nagaur
4.       Abdul Gaffar S/o Late Shri Fakir Mohammed, Aged About
         43 Years, Resident Of Sadar Bazar Makrana District
         Nagaur
                                                                  ----Appellants
                                    Versus
1.       Aftab Mohammed S/o Late Shri Jumma Ji, Resident Of
         Tiba Mohalla Makrana District Nagaur
2.       Lrs Of Gulam Nabi, S/o Late Shri Jumma Ji
3.       Shahina D/o Late Gulam Nabi, R/o Tiba Mohalla, Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
4.       Nasiban D/o Late Gulam Nabi, R/o Tiba Mohalla, Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
5.       Yasmin D/o Late Gulam Nabi, R/o Tiba Mohalla, Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
6.       Kalsum D/o Late Gulam Nabi, R/o Tiba Mohalla, Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
7.       Sameem      D/o    Late     Gulam        Nabi,     R/o   Tiba   Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
8.       Afsana D/o Late Gulam Nabi, R/o Tiba Mohalla, Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
9.       Farzana D/o Late Gulam Nabi, R/o Tiba Mohalla, Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
10.      Gulnaz D/o Late Gulam Nabi, R/o Tiba Mohalla, Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
11.      Mohammed Ali S/o Late Gulam Nabi, R/o Tiba Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.


                     (Downloaded on 11/03/2025 at 09:46:27 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:13677]                   (2 of 9)                    [CMA-3085/2024]


12.      Hasan Ali S/o Late Gulam Nabi, R/o Tiba Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
13.      Mohammed Iqbal S/o Late Shri Jumma Ji, R/o Tiba
         Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
14.      Munna Ahmed S/o Late Shri Jumma Ji, R/o Tiba Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
15.      Mohammed Ramzan S/o Late Shri Jumma Ji, R/o Tiba
         Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
16.      Zakir Hussain S/o Late Shri Jumma Ji, R/o Tiba Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
17.      Zabir Ahmed S/o Late Shri Jumma Ji, R/o Tiba Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
18.      Lrs Of Abdul Qayyum, S/o Late Shri Jumma Ji
19.      Sabra Begum W/o Late Shri Abdul Qayyum, R/o Tiba
         Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
20.      Abdul Manaan S/o Late Shri Abdul Qayyum, R/o Tiba
         Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
21.      Haider Ali S/o Late Shri Abdul Qayyum, R/o Tiba Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
22.      Khairoon D/o Late Shri Abdul Qayyum, R/o Tiba Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
23.      Seema D/o Late Shri Abdul Qayyum, R/o Tiba Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
24.      Shabnam D/o Late Shri Abdul Qayyum, R/o Tiba Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
25.      Nazia D/o Late Shri Abdul Qayyum, R/o Tiba Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
26.      Fojiya D/o Late Shri Abdul Qayyum, R/o Tiba Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
27.      Jameel Ahmed S/o Habeeb, R/o Tiba Mohalla, Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
28.      Lrs Of Abdul Rehman, S/o Habeeb
29.      Khatun W/o Late Shri Abdul Rehman, R/o Tiba Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
30.      Abdul Hameed S/o Late Shri Abdul Rehman, R/o Tiba
         Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
31.      Abdul Raheem S/o Late Shri Abdul Rehman, R/o Tiba

                     (Downloaded on 11/03/2025 at 09:46:27 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:13677]                   (3 of 9)                        [CMA-3085/2024]


         Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
32.      Abdul Hak S/o Late Shri Abdul Rehman, R/o Tiba Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
33.      Masarrat Jannat Parveen D/o Late Shri Adbul Rehman, R/
         o Tiba Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
34.      Lrs Of Noor Mohammed, S/o Habeeb
35.      Maina Begum W/o Late Shri Noor Mohammed, R/o Tiba
         Masjid, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
36.      Wasim Akram S/o Late Shri Noor Mohammed, R/o Tiba
         Masjid, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
37.      Saajda D/o Late Shri Noor Mohammed, R/o Tiba Masjid,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
38.      Mohammed Furkan S/o Late Shri Noor Mohammed, R/o
         Tiba Masjid, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
39.      Dilshan S/o Late Shri Noor Mohammed, R/o Tiba Masjid,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
40.      Shamsad Parveen D/o Late Shri Noor Mohammed, R/o
         Tiba Masjid, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
41.      Munavvar Alam S/o Late Shri Noor Mohammed, R/o Tiba
         Masjid, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
42.      Tarannum Naaz D/o Late Shri Noor Mohammed, Minor
         Through Natural Guardian Mother Maina Begum W/o Late
         Shri Noor Mohammed, R/o Tiba Masjid, Makrana, Dist.
         Nagaur.
43.      Mohammed Sadiq S/o Habeeb, R/o Tiba Masjid, Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
44.      Nannu S/o Haseeb, R/o Tiba Masjid, Makrana, Dist.
         Nagaur.
45.      Abdul Hakim S/o Habeeb, R/o Tiba Masjid, Makrana, Dist.
         Nagaur.
46.      Haji Mukhtyar S/o Kadar, R/o Maniharo Ka Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
47.      Lrs Of Abdul Aziz, S/o Abdul Majid
48.      Naseem W/o Late Shri Abdul Aziz, R/o Maniharo Ka
         Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
49.      Mohammed        Furkan      S/o     Late     Shri       Abdul   Aziz,   R/o
         Maniharo Ka Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.


                     (Downloaded on 11/03/2025 at 09:46:27 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:13677]                   (4 of 9)                    [CMA-3085/2024]


50.      Wasim Akram S/o Late Shri Abdul Aziz, R/o Maniharo Ka
         Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
51.      Shoaib Akhtar S/o Late Shri Abdul Aziz, R/o Maniharo Ka
         Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
52.      Salma Begum D/o Late Shri Abdul Aziz, R/o Maniharo Ka
         Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
53.      Fehmida Begum D/o Late Shri Abdul Aziz, R/o Maniharo
         Ka Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
54.      Furkan S/o Late Shri Abdul Aziz, R/o Maniharo Ka
         Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
55.      Raja S/o Abdul Majid, R/o Maniharo Ka Mohalla, Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
56.      Abdul Rasheed S/o Abdul Majid, R/o Maniharo Ka Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
57.      Anwar Ahmed S/o Abdul Majid, R/o Maniharo Ka Mohalla,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
58.      Mohammed Ramzan S/o Abdul Majid, R/o Maniharo Ka
         Mohalla, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
59.      Mohammed Shareef S/o Nisar Ahmed, R/o Makrana, Dist.
         Nagaur.
60.      Arfan S/o Nisar Ahmed, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
61.      Rihan S/o Nisar Ahmed, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
62.      Lrs Of Sagir Ahmed, S/o Mukeem
63.      Mohammed Aslam S/o Late Shri Sagir Ahmed, R/o Near
         Raza Masjid, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
64.      Mohammed Akram S/o Late Shri Sagir Ahmed, R/o Near
         Raza Masjid, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
65.      Mohammed Arif S/o Late Shri Sagir Ahmed, R/o Near
         Raza Masjid, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
66.      Ruby D/o Late Shri Sagir Ahmed, R/o Near Raza Masjid,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
67.      Rizu @ Rizwana D/o Late Shri Sagir Ahmed, R/o Near
         Raza Masjid, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
68.      Nazia D/o Late Shri Sagir Ahmed, R/o Near Raza Masjid,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
69.      Subala D/o Late Shri Sagir Ahmed, R/o Near Raza Masjid,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.

                     (Downloaded on 11/03/2025 at 09:46:27 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:13677]                   (5 of 9)                    [CMA-3085/2024]


70.      Nazma D/o Late Shri Sagir Ahmed, R/o Near Raza Masjid,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
71.      Mohammed Asif S/o Late Shri Sagir Ahmed, Minor
         Through His Natural Guardian Brother Mohammed Aslam
         S/o Late Shri Sagir Ahmed, R/o Near Raza Masjid,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
72.      Lrs Of Abdul Rashid, S/o Late Shri Abdullah
73.      Abdul Hafeez S/o Late Shri Abdul Rashid, R/o Noorani
         Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
74.      Noor Hasan S/o Late Shri Abdul Rashid, R/o Noorani
         Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
75.      Afzal Ali S/o Late Shri Abdul Rashid, R/o Noorani
         Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
76.      Mohammed Ramzan S/o Late Shri Abdul Rashid, R/o
         Noorani Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
77.      Parveen Begum D/o Late Shri Abdul Rashid, R/o Noorani
         Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
78.      Shameem Begum D/o Late Shri Abdul Rashid, R/o
         Noorani Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
79.      Zarina Bano D/o Late Shri Abdul Rashid, R/o Noorani
         Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
80.      Lrs Of Mohammed Shafi, S/o Late Shri Abdullah
81.      Jannat W/o Late Shri Mohammed Shafi, R/o Noorani
         Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
82.      Mohammed Imran S/o Late Shri Mohammed Shafi, R/o
         Noorani Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
83.      Naseem Bano D/o Late Shri Mohammed Shafi, R/o
         Noorani Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
84.      Furkan Ahmed S/o Late Shri Mohammed Shafi, R/o
         Noorani Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
85.      Mohammed Asif S/o Late Shri Mohammed Shafi, R/o
         Noorani Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
86.      Tabbassum Bano D/o Late Shri Mohammed Shafi, R/o
         Noorani Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
87.      Fayaz Ahmed S/o Late Shri Abdullah, R/o Noorani
         Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
88.      Khurshid Ahmed S/o Late Shri Abdullah, R/o Noorani


                     (Downloaded on 11/03/2025 at 09:46:27 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:13677]                   (6 of 9)                    [CMA-3085/2024]


         Madarsa, Iqbalpura, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
89.      Lrs Of Shoukat Ali, S/o Late Shri Yakub
90.      Sharifan W/o Late Shri Shoukat Ali, R/o Kazi Gali, Sadar
         Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
91.      Ruksana D/o Late Shri Shoukat Ali, R/o Kazi Gali, Sadar
         Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
92.      Afsana D/o Late Shri Shoukat Ali, R/o Kazi Gali, Sadar
         Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
93.      Farzana D/o Late Shri Shoukat Ali, R/o Kazi Gali, Sadar
         Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
94.      Naazmeem D/o Late Shri Shoukat Ali, R/o Kazi Gali,
         Sadar Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
95.      Saazmeem D/o Late Shri Shoukat Ali, R/o Kazi Gali,
         Sadar Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
96.      Gulnaz D/o Late Shri Shoukat Ali, R/o Kazi Gali, Sadar
         Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
97.      Rehmatullah S/o Late Shri Shoukat Ali, R/o Kazi Gali,
         Sadar Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
98.      Chand Mohammed S/o Late Shri Yakub, R/o Kazi Gali,
         Sadar Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
99.      Lrs Of Mohammed Haroon, S/o Late Shri Yakub
100.     Arif Mohammed S/o Late Shri Mohammed Haroon, R/o
         Kazi Gali, Sadar Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
101.     Faraan S/o Late Shri Mohammed Haroon, R/o Kazi Gali,
         Sadar Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
102.     Manaan S/o Late Shri Mohammed Haroon, R/o Kazi Gali,
         Sadar Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
103.     Baya D/o Late Shri Mohammed Haroon, R/o Kazi Gali,
         Sadar Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
104.     Shehnaz D/o Late Shri Mohammed Haroon, R/o Kazi Gali,
         Sadar Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
105.     Chhotiya D/o Late Shri Mohammed Haroon, R/o Kazi Gali,
         Sadar Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
106.     Noor Hasan @ Seth S/o Late Shri Yakub, R/o Kazi Gali,
         Sadar Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
107.     Abdul Wahid S/o Late Shri Yakub, R/o Kazi Gali, Sadar
         Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.

                     (Downloaded on 11/03/2025 at 09:46:27 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:13677]                   (7 of 9)                    [CMA-3085/2024]


108.     Abdul Hafiz S/o Late Shri Yakub, R/o Kazi Gali, Sadar
         Bazar, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
109.     Lrs Of Ramzan, S/o Kamru
110.     Shareef S/o Late Shri Ramzan, R/o Behind Moti Mahal
         Hotel, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
111.     Aslam S/o Late Shri Ramzan, R/o Behind Moti Mahal
         Hotel, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
112.     Shabbir S/o Late Shri Ramzan, R/o Behind Moti Mahal
         Hotel, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
113.     Zakir S/o Late Shri Ramzan, R/o Behind Moti Mahal Hotel,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
114.     Lrs Of Umar, S/o Kamru
115.     Sufiya Begum W/o Late Shri Umar, R/o Behind Moti Mahal
         Hotel, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
116.     Fareen D/o Late Shri Umar, R/o Behind Moti Mahal Hotel,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
117.     Nadeem S/o Late Shri Umar, R/o Behind Moti Mahal Hotel,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
118.     Fehmida D/o Late Shri Umar, R/o Behind Moti Mahal
         Hotel, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
119.     Nasreen D/o Late Shri Umar, R/o Behind Moti Mahal
         Hotel, Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
120.     Saazda D/o Late Shri Umar, R/o Behind Moti Mahal Hotel,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
121.     Razzak S/o Late Kamru, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
         (Deleted Vide Order Dated 25-07-2024)
122.     Lrs Of Mohammed Ismail, S/o Late Shri Kamru
123.     Yakub S/o Late Shri Mohammed Ismail, R/o Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
124.     Shahbaan S/o Late Shri Mohammed Ismail, R/o Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
125.     Shahida D/o Late Shri Mohammed Ismail, R/o Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
126.     Fehmida D/o Late Shri Mohammed Ismail, R/o Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
127.     Sanjida D/o Late Shri Mohammed Ismail, R/o Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.

                     (Downloaded on 11/03/2025 at 09:46:27 PM)
 [2025:RJ-JD:13677]                   (8 of 9)                    [CMA-3085/2024]


128.     Sabeda D/o Late Shri Mohammed Ismail, R/o Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
129.     Majeda D/o Late Shri Mohammed Ismail, R/o Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
130.     Dilshan D/o Late Shri Mohammed Ismail, R/o Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
131.     Yunuf S/o Late Shri Kamru, R/o Sadar Bazar, Makrana,
         Dist. Nagaur.
132.     Lrs Of Abdul Rehman, S/o Abdul Hakim
133.     Jameel S/o Late Shri Abdul Rehman, R/o Sadar Bazar,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
134.     Sikander S/o Late Shri Abdul Rehman, R/o Sadar Bazar,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
135.     Anwar S/o Late Shri Abdul Rehman, R/o Sadar Bazar,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
136.     Mumtaz D/o Late Shri Abdul Rehman, R/o Sadar Bazar,
         Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
137.     Allahnoor S/o Abdul Hakim, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
138.     Ibrahim S/o Billu, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
139.     Yusuf S/o Billu, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
140.     Hameed S/o Billu, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
141.     Haroon S/o Billu, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
142.     Shakeel S/o Billu, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
143.     Farukh S/o Billu, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
144.     Hafeez S/o Billu, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
145.     Rasheed S/o Chhotu Ji, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
146.     Samad S/o Chhotu Ji, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
147.     Mohammed Saleem S/o Imamuddin, R/o Makrana, Dist.
         Nagaur.
148.     Mohammed Farookh S/o Imamuddin, R/o Makrana, Dist.
         Nagaur.
149.     Mohammed Shabir S/o Imamuddin, R/o Makrana, Dist.
         Nagaur.
150.     Shahadat S/o Isak, R/o Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
151.     State Of Rajasthan, Through District Collector, Nagaur.
152.     Director, Mines And Geology Department, Udaipur.

                     (Downloaded on 11/03/2025 at 09:46:27 PM)
                                    [2025:RJ-JD:13677]                         (9 of 9)                          [CMA-3085/2024]


                                   153.     Mining      Engineer,          Mines         And     Geology        Department,
                                            Makrana, Dist. Nagaur.
                                                                                                          ----Respondents


                                   For Appellant(s)                :     Mr. Mahendra Thanvi
                                   For Respondent(s)               :     Mr. Devi Lal R. Vyas



                                                   HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE REKHA BORANA
Judgment
11/03/2025
1. The present appeal has been filed against the order dated
23.09.2024 passed by Additional District Judge, Makrana, District
Nagaur in Civil Misc. Case No.01/2012 (CIS No.94/2019) whereby
the application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2,CPC had been
decided.
2. Counsel for the respondents submitted that the original suit
in question being Civil Original Suit No.01/2012 itself has been
decided vide judgment and decree dated 16.01.2025 and hence,
the present appeal has rendered infructuous.
3. Certified copy of the judgment and decree dated 16.01.2025