Saturday, 09, May, 2026
 
 
 
Expand O P Jindal Global University
 
  
  
 
 
 

Mudalaiah vs Sri P Shivakumar
2025 Latest Caselaw 9799 Kant

Citation : 2025 Latest Caselaw 9799 Kant
Judgement Date : 5 November, 2025

Karnataka High Court

Mudalaiah vs Sri P Shivakumar on 5 November, 2025

     IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

       DATED THIS THE 5TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2025

                        PRESENT

        THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN

                          AND

          THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH RAI K

           WRIT APPEAL NO.260 OF 2023 (L-RES)
                         C/W.
        CIVIL CONTEMPT PETITION NO.950 OF 2023,
           WRIT APPEAL NO.468 OF 2023 (L-RES)

IN WA NO.260 OF 2023:

BETWEEN:

CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
CENTRAL SILK BOARD COMPLEX,
5TH FLOOR, BTM LAYOUT,
HOSUR ROAD,MADIWALA,
BENGALURU - 560 068,
REPRESENTED BY ITS
MEMBER SECRETARY,
MR. R.R. OKHANDIAR.
                                           ...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. ARAVIND KAMATH, ASGI A/W
    SRI. MADHUKAR M. DESHPANDE, CGSC)

AND:

1.     SRI S RAMESHA,
       S/O SHIVARAMAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       MANASAWADI ROAD,
       OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE,
       MYSORE - 570 008.
 -

                          2




2.   SRI .M N. SURESHA,
     S/O NARAYANACHAR,
     AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
     TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
     SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
     NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
     MANASAWADI ROAD,
     OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE,
     MYSORE - 570 008.

3.   SRI.L. GOPALA,
     S/O LATE LAKSHMEGOWDA,
     AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS,
     TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
     SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
     NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
     MANASAWADI ROAD,
     OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE,
     MYSORE - 570 008.

4.   SRI MAHADEVA,
     S/O LATE. KALEGOWDA,
     AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
     TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
     SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
     NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
     MANASAWADI ROAD,
     OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE,
     MYSORE - 570 008.

5.   SRI ANDANI,
     S/O LATE SIDDAIAH,
     AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
     TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
     SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE, NATIONAL
     SILK SEED ORGANISATION, MANASAWADI ROAD,
     OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE,
     MYSORE - 570 008.

6.   SRI.S.K. KALEGOWDA,
     S/O SRI KALEGOWDA ,
     AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
     TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
 -

                             3




       SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       MANASAWADI ROAD,
       OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

7.     SRI NANJUNDASWAMY,
       S/O LATE NANJAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       MANASAWADI ROAD,
       OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

8.     SRI . THAMMANNA,
       S/O LATE CHANNEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       MANASAWADI ROAD,
       OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

9.     SRI S SRIDHAR,
       S/O LATE SIDDEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA OPPOSITE SUB JAIL,
       HUNSUR ROAD,
       KRISHNARAJANAGAR-571 602.

10 .   SRI PARAMESHAIAH,
       S/O KUNDAJOGI,
       AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
 -

                             4




       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA OPPOSITE SUB JAIL,
       HUNSUR ROAD,
       KRISHNARAJANAGAR-571 602.

11 .   SRI SIDDIQ SHARIFF,
       S/O AHMED AHARIFF,
       AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA OPPOSITE SUB JAIL,
       HUNSUR ROAD,
       KRISHNARAJANAGAR-571 602.

12 .   SRI H C KUMAR,
       S/O CHIKKEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
       BASIC SEED FARM NATIONAL SILK,
       WORM SEED ORGANIZATION
       VIDYARANYAPURAM FARM,
       J.L.B. ROAD,
       MYSURU-570 008.

13 .   SRI C M JAYARAM,
       S/O LATE MANCHEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER SILK WORM,
       SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       RAMANAGAR-562 129.

14 .   SRI L BASAVARAJU,
       S/O LINGAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER SILK WORM,
       SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
 -

                               5




       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       NEAR BASAVESHWARA TEMPLE,
       KANAKAPURA ROAD,
       MALAVALLI-571 430.

15 .   SRI B NANDEESHA,
       S/O LATE S BASAVALINGAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER SILK WORM,
       SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       MANASAWADI ROAD,
       OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE
       MYSURU-570 008.

16 .   SRI BEERAIAH,
       S/O SRI DODDAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER SILK WORM,
       SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       P B NO 07, B M ROAD,
       NEAR GOUSIAY ENGINEERING COLLEGE,
       RAMANAGARAM - 571 511,
       BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT.

17 .   SRI GOPALA KRISHAN,
       S/O LATE B.C. RAMASHETTY,
       AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER SILK WORM,
       SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       NEAR GOUSIAY ENGINEERING COLLEGE,
       RAMANAGARAM - 571511,
       BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT.

18 .   SRI RAJANNA,
       S/OLATE K KARE GOWDA,
 -

                            6




       AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER SILK WORM,
       SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT OF INDIA,
       NEAR GOUSIAY ENGINEERING COLLEGE,
       RAMANAGARAM - 571 511,
       BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT.

19 .   SRI CHIKKANNA,
       S/O LATE ARASAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER SILK WORM,
       SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       NEAR GOUSIAY ENGINEERING COLLEGE,
       RAMANAGARAM - 571 511,
       BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT.

20 .   SRI JAYARAMU,
       S/O SRI MUDALAGIRAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER SILK WORM,
       SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       RAMANAGARAM - 571 511.

21 .   SRI S SHEKAR,
       S/O SRI SWAMY,
       AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
 -

                             7




       MYSORE - 570 008.

22 .   SRI. B. LINGARAJU,
       S/O LATE. T. BASAVAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
       TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

23 .   SRI. KEMPANNA,
       S/O KEMPEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
       TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

24 .   SRI K SHANKAR RAO,
       S/O LATE KRISHNOJI RAO,
       AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
       TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

25 .   SRI CHIKKAMALU,
       S/O LATE MALEGOWDA,
 -

                            8




       AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
       TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

26 .   SRI BHARANAPPA,
       S/OLATE KRISHNAPPA,
       AGED ABUT 60 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

27 .   SRI CHALUVARAJU,
       S/O LATE MARIGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

28 .   SRI VENKATAIAH,
       S/O LATE RANGAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
 -

                              9




       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

29 .   SRI M NAGARAJU,
       S/O LATE MARIYAPPA,
       AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

30 .   SRI P KUMARASWAMY,
       S/O PAPANNA,
       AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

31 .   SRI P PRAKASH,
       S/O BETTEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
 -

                            10




       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

32 .   SRI H C RUDRASWAMY,
       S/O LATE H V CHIKKANASWAMY,
       AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

33 .   SRI BASAVA,
       S/O LATE THIMMAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

34 .   SRI VIDYASAGAR,
       S/O LATE M V MUNIRATHNAM,
       AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

35 .   SRI MOHAMMED ZAIBULLA,
 -

                            11




       S/O LATE BUDAIN CAPTAIN,
       AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

36 .   SRI CHANNABASAVA,
       S/O LATE HANKAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

37 .   SRI H SRINIVASA,
       S/O SRI HANUMANTHAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

38 .   SRI K RAJU,
       SO J KEMPAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
 -

                             12




       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

39 .   SMT. NINGAMMA,
       W/O CHALUVAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

40 .   SMT. JAYAMMA,
       W/O KRISHNAPPA,
       AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI OAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

41 .   SMT. CHAMAMMA,
       W/O KUPPA,
       AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
 -

                            13




       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

42 .   SRI SIDDARAJU,
       S/O LATE HONNAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

43 .   SRI P MANJUNATHA,
       S/O LATE PUTTASWAMY GOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

44 .   SRI CHANNAIAH,
       S/O LATE CHANNAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.
 -

                            14




45 .   SRI N PAPANNA,
       S/O NINGAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

46 .   SRI NANJUNDA,
       S/O LATE RUDRAPPA,
       AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

47 .   SRI BASAVAIAH,
       S/O LATE KUNMADEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

48 .   SRI P SUBRAMANYA,
       S/O PERUMAL,
       AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
 -

                            15




       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

49 .   SRI CHIKKASIDDAIAH,
       S/O LATE CHIKKALINGAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

50 .   SRI KUMAR,
       S/O LATE NINGAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

51 .   SMT. CHIKKAMMA,
       D/O MADEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
 -

                              16




       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

52 .   SRI K THAMMAIAH,
       S/O KEMPAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

53 .   SRI N GOVINDAIAH,
       S/O LATE NARASIMHAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
       P3 BASIC SEED FARM,
       NATIONAL SILKWORM SEED PROJECT,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       NAGAMANGALA-571 432.

54 .   SRI PUTTAMADAIAH,
       S/O S M NANJAPPA,
       AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
       P3 BASIC SEED FARM,
       NATIONAL SILKWORM SEED PROJECT,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       NAGAMANGALA-571 432.

55 .   SRI N T VENKATESH,
       S/O THIMMEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
 -

                            17




       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
       P3 BASIC SEED FARM,
       NATIONAL SILKWORM SEED PROJECT,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       NAGAMANGALA-571 432.

56 .   SRI HUCHEERA,
       S/O LATE HUCHEERAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
       P3 BASIC SEED FARM,
       NATIONAL SILKWORM SEED PROJECT,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       NAGAMANGALA-571 432.

57 .   SRI D T KARISHETTY,
       S/O LATE THIMMARAYA SHETTY,
       AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
       P3 BASIC SEED FARM,
       NATIONAL SILKWORM SEED PROJECT,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       NAGAMANGALA-571 432.

58 .   SRI SHIVALINGAIAH,
       S/O LATE KEMPAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
       P3 BASIC SEED FARM,
       NATIONAL SILKWORM SEED PROJECT,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       NAGAMANGALA-571 432.

59 .   SRI N NANJUNDAPPA,
       S/O S M NANJAPPA,
 -

                            18




       AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
       P3 BASIC SEED FARM,
       NATIONAL SILKWORM SEED PROJECT,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       NAGAMANGALA-571 432.

60 .   SRI N M JAVAREGOWDA,
       S/O LATE MAYANNEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
       P3 BASIC SEED FARM,
       NATIONAL SILKWORM SEED PROJECT,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       NAGAMANGALA-571 432.

61 .   SRI MAYANNA,
       S/O LATE HUCHAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
       P3 BASIC SEED FARM,
       NATIONAL SILKWORM SEED PROJECT,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       NAGAMANGALA-571 432.

62 .   SRI RAMAIAH,
       S/O SRI NINGAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       OFFICE OF THE JOINT DIRECTOR,
       REGIONAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       A UNIT UNDER CSR & TI, MYSURU
       NANJANGUD ROAD
       CHAMARAJANAGAR-571 313.
 -

                            19




63 .   SRI D MARISWAMY,
       S/O DODDAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

64 .   SRI H N GOVINDARAJU,
       S/O SRI NARASIMHAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
       BASIC SEED FARM
       NATIONAL SILK WORM SEED ORGANISATION,
       VIDYARANYAPURAM FARM,
       J.L.B. ROAD,
       MYSURU-570 008.

65 .   SRI N BASAVARAJU,
       S/O LATE NANJAPPA,
       AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI OAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

66 .   SRI P.T. SRINIVASA,
       S/O SRI K. THIMMAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
 -

                              20




       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

67 .   SRI MALLIKARJUNA,
       S/O MALLEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

68 .   SRI MALLASWAMY,
       S/O SIDDEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

69 .   SRI N L VIJAYAKUMAR,
       S/O LATE N LAKSHMIPATHI,
       AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
 -

                            21




       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

70 .   SRI. PAPANNA,
       S/O SRI CHIKKAHALAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

71 .   SRI ANANDA MURTHY,
       S/O LATE SIDDAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

72 .   SRI. M. SHIVAKUMAR,
       S/O LATE MALLAIAH
       AGED MAJOR,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.
 -

                            22




73 .   SRI. S. SURESHA,
       S/O SANNAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

74 .   SRI. M. BASAVARAJU,
       S/O LATE MAHADAIAH
       AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

75 .   SRI. NANJINDA,
       S/O SRI EARAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

76 .   SRI.K.B. DORESWAMY,
       S/O BEREGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
 -

                            23




       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANDAVADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

77 .   SMT. SAROJAMMA,
       D/O REVANASIDDAIAH
       AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SILKWORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       MANASAWADI ROAD,
       OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

78 .   SMT. LEELAVATHI,
       D/O LATE SIDDABASANAIK,
       AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SILKWORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       MANASAWADI ROAD,
       OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

79 .   SMT. SUNITRA,
       D/O LATE. PATTAHELLAPPA,
       AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SILKWORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       MANASAWADI ROAD,
       OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

80 .   SMT. SUKANYADEVI,
       D/O C. NAGAIAH
       AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
 -

                            24




       SILKWORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       MANASAWADI ROAD,
       OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

81 .   SRI. NAGARAJA,
       S/O LATE SUBBASHETTY,
       AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER SILK WORM,
       SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       NEAR GOUSIAY ENGINEERING COLLEGE,
       RAMANAGARAM - 571 511,
       BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT.

82 .   SRI. CHANNAPPA,
       S/O SRI BETHALAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER SILK WORM,
       SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       NEAR GOUSIAY ENGINEERING COLLEGE,
       RAMANAGARAM - 571 511,
       BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT.

83 .   SRI. H.S. MUKUNDA,
       S/O LATE H.B. SESHDAR IYENGAR,
       AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER SILK WORM,
       OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR
       R.E.C. SUB-UNIT,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       2ND CROSS, PARK EXTENSION,
       BALARAJ URS ROAD,
       SHIMOGA-570 021.

84 .   SRI. S. KRISHNA,
 -

                            25




       AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE, NATIONAL
       SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       MANASAWADI ROAD,
       OPPOSITE TO RATNA THEATRE,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

85 .   SRI. S. NINGAIAH,
       S/O LATE SANDAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANSWADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

86 .   SRI. V. UMESH,
       S/O SRI. D. VENKOBA RAO,
       AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
       AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       MANANSWADI ROAD,
       SRIRAMPURAM,
       MYSORE SOUTH,
       MYSORE - 570 008.

87 .   SRI. C. REVANASIDDAIAH,
       S/O LATE CHIKKANNA,
       AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER SILK WORM,
       SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
 -

                            26




       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       NEAR GOUSIAY ENGINEERING COLLEGE,
       RAMANAGARAM - 571 511,
       BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT.

88 .   SRI. RANGANATHA,
       S/O SRI. CHIKKARANGAIAH,
       AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
       OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR,
       SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       KANAKAPURA ROAD,
       MALAVALLI-571 430,
       MANDYA DISTRICT.

89 .   SRI. N.B. NAGEGOWDA,
       S/O LATE. BUSEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SERICULTURAL SERVICE CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
       JAYANAGAR, NEW EXTENSION
       HOSAHALALA ROAD,
       KRISHNARAJPET - 571 426,
       MANDYA DISTRICT.

90.    SRI. K.B. VISHWANATHA,
       S/O LATE B. BOREGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR,
       NEW EXTENSION HOSAHALALA ROAD
       KRISHNARAJPET-571 426,
       MANDYA DISTRICT.
 -

                            27




91 .   SRI. K.B. CHANDREGOWDA,
       S/O SRI. KEMPEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
       SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD
       GOVT. OF INDIA
       SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR
       NEW EXTENSION HOSAHALALA ROAD
       KRISHNARAJPET,
       MANDYA DISTRICT.

92 .   SRI. SIDDALINGA,
       S/O LATE NANJEGOWA,
       AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR,
       NEW EXTENSION HOSAHALALA ROAD,
       KRISHNARAJPET,
       MANDYA DISTRICT.

93 .   SRI. NINGA SHETTY,
       S/O LATE SHAMBU SHETTY,
       AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR,
       NEW EXTENSION HOSAHALALA ROAD,
       KRISHNARAJPET,
       MANDYA DISTRICT.
 -

                              28




94 .   SRI. B.S. DINESHA,
       S/O SRI. D.G. SIDDALINGAPPA,
       AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER,
       SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE,
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION,
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
       GOVT. OF INDIA,
       SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR,
       NEW EXTENSION HOSAHALALA ROAD,
       KRISHNARAJPET,
       MANDYA DISTRICT.

95 .   SRI. NAGEGOWDA,
       S/O LATE M.N. DEVEGOWDA,
       AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
       SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD
       GOVT. OF INDIA
       SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR
       NEW EXTENSION HOSAHALALA ROAD
       KRISHNARAJPET,
       MANDYA DISTRICT.

96 .   SRI. A.V. LAKSHMANA
       S/O SRI VENKATAGIRI GOWDA
       AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
       SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD
       GOVT. OF INDIA
       SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR
       NEW EXTENSION HOSAHALALA ROAD
       KRISHNARAJPET,MANDYA DISTRICT.

97 .   SRI. B.P. MANJEGOWDA
 -

                            29




       S/O LATE PUTTASWAMY GOWDA
       AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
       SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
       CENTRAL SILK BOARD
       GOVT. OF INDIA
       SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR
       NEW EXTENSION HOSAHALALA ROAD
       KRISHNARAJPET,
       MANDYA DISTRICT.

98 .   SRI M B BASAVARAJEGOWDA
       S/O SRI BOREGOWDA
       AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS
       TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
       SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANSISATION
       CENRAL SILK BOARD
       GOVT OF INDIA, SILK BUILIDNG
       JAYANAGAR
       NEW EXTENSION, HOSAHALALA ROAD
       KRISHNARAJAPET
       MANDYA DISTRICT

99 .   SRI T P THIMMAPPA
       S/O RAJEGOWDA
       AGED ABOUT 51 EYARS
       TIME SCALE FARMWORKER
       SILKWORM SEED PRODUCTION CNETRE
       NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION
       MANASASWADI ROAD
       OPP TO RATHNA THEATRE
       MYSORE 570008

100 . SRI M NARARAJU
      S/O SRI. CHIKKAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
 -

                          30




     CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND TRAINING
     INSTITUTE
     CENTRAL SILK BOARD
     GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
     MANANDAVADI ROAD
     SRI RAMAPURAM
     MYSORE SOUTH
     MYSURU-570 008.

101 . SMT. THULASAMMA,
      S/O SRI. SIDDAIAH,
      AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SILKWORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANSIATION
      CETNRAL SILK BOARD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      P BNO NO 7, B M ROAD
      NEAR GOUSIYA ENGINERNG COLLEGE
      RAMANGAR 571511
      BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT

102 . SRI DEVARAJU,
      S/O LATE JAVARESHETTY,
      AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WOKER
      CETNRAL SERICULTURE RESEARCH
      AND TRAINING INSTITUTE
      CENTRAL SILK BAORD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      MANADAVADI RAOD
      SRIRAMAPURAM MYSORE SOUTH
      MYSORE 570008

103 . SMT CHIKKATAYAMMA
      D/O LATE MALLEGOWDA,
      AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WOKER
      CETNRAL SERICULTURE RESEARCH
      AND TRAINING INSTITUTE
      CENTRAL SILK BAORD
 -

                            31




     GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
     MANADAVADI RAOD
     SRIRAMAPURAM MYSORE SOUTH
     MYSORE 570 008.

104 . SRI S RAMAKUMAR
      S/O LATE S SUBBAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WOKER
      CETNRAL SERICULTURE RESEARCH
      AND TRAINING INSTITUTE
      CENTRAL SILK BAORD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      MANADAVADI RAOD
      SRIRAMAPURAM MYSORE SOUTH
      MYSORE 570 008.

105 . SRI B RAMACHANDRA
      S/O LATE BASAVAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WOKER
      CETNRAL SERICULTURE RESEARCH
      AND TRAINING INSTITUTE
      CENTRAL SILK BAORD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      MANADAVADI RAOD
      SRIRAMAPURAM MYSORE SOUTH
      MYSORE 570 008.

106 . SRI B MARISWAMY
      S/O LATE BASAVAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WOKER
      CETNRAL SERICULTURE RESEARCH
      AND TRAINING INSTITUTE
      CENTRAL SILK BAORD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      MANADAVADI ROAD
      SRIRAMAPURAM MYSORE SOUTH
      MYSORE 570 008.

107 . SRI SOMASHEKARA
      S/O LATE T SIDDAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
 -

                           32




     TIME SCALE FARM WOKER
     CETNRAL SERICULTURE RESEARCH
     AND TRAINING INSTITUTE
     CENTRAL SILK BAORD
     GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
     MANADAVADI ROAD
     SRIRAMAPURAM MYSORE SOUTH
     MYSORE 570008.

108 . SRI S KRISHNA
      S/O LATE SANAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
      TIME SACLE FARM WOKDER
      OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR
      SILK WORM SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK WORM SEED ORGANISATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINSITRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      KANAKAPURA ROAD
      MALAVALLI 571430
      MANDYA DISTRICT

109 . SRI PUTTARAMACHARI
      S/O SRI KALACHARI
      AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTER
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANISATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR
      NEW EXTENSION, HOSAHALALA ROAD
      KRISHNARAJAPET-571 426
      MANDYA DISTRICT

110 . SMT. B GOWRAMMA
      D/O SRI CHIKKEGOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRER
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANSIATION
      CETNRAL SILK BOARD
 -

                           33




     MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
     GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
     SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR
     NEW EXTENSION
     HOSAHALALA ROAD
     KRISHNARAJAPET-571 426
     MANDYA DISTRICT

111 . SRI RUKMANGADARAJU
      S/O LATE NINGE GOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR
      NEW EXTENSION, HOSAHALALA ROAD
      KRISHNARAJAPET-571 426
      MANDYA DISTRICT

112 . SRI BHEEMAIAH
      S/O SRI M K MALLAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE
      SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER
      P4 BASIC SEED FARM,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      DEVARAYAPATNA
      B M ROAD, KANDALI POST
      NEAR CSRTC QUARTERS
      HASSAN-573 217

113 . SRI K S BASAVARAJA
      S/O LATE SIDDAMALLAPPA
      AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE
      SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER
      P4 BASIC SEED FARM
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
 -

                              34




     DEVARAYAPATNA
     B M ROAD, KANDALI POST
     NEAR CSRTC QUARTERS
     HASSAN-573 217

114 . SRI T H KRISHNEGOWDA
      S/O SRI HONNAPPA
      AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE
      SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER
      P4 BASIC SEED FARM
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      DEVARAYAPATNA
      B M ROAD, KANDALI POST
      NEAR CSRTC QUARTERS
      HASSAN-573217

115 . SRI C L EREGOWDA
      S/O LATE LAKSHMEGOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE
      SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER
      P4 BASIC SEED FARM
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      DEVARAYAPATNA
      B M ROAD, KANDALI POST
      NEAR CSRTC QUARTERS
      HASSAN-573217

116 . SRI K L KRISHNEGOWDA
      S/O LATE LAKSHMEGOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE
      SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER
      P4 BASIC SEED FARM
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
 -

                              35




     DEVARAYAPATNA
     B M ROAD, KANDALI POST
     NEAR CSRTC QUARTERS
     HASSAN-573217

117 . SRI HEMANTHA KUMAR
      S/O LATE RAJEGOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 41 YAERS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE
      SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER
      P4 BASIC SEED FARM
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      DEVARAYAPATNA
      B M ROAD, KANDALI POST
      NEAR CSRTC QUARTERS
      HASSAN-573217

118 . SRI J N MOHANA
      S/O LATE S NANJUNDAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      SILK BUILDING
      JAYANAGAR NEW EXTENSION
      HOSAHALALA ROAD
      KRISHNARAJPET -571 426
      MANDYA DISTRICT

119 . SMT. O GOWRAMMA
      W/O SRI SANNEGOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
 -

                           36




     CENTRAL SILK BOARD
     MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
     GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
     SILK BUILDING
     JAYANAGAR NEW EXTENSION
     HOSAHALALA ROAD
     KRISHNARAJPET-571426
     MANDYA DISTRICT

120 . SRI S J GANESHA
      S/O SRI S T JAVAREGOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      SILK BUILDING
      JAYANAGAR NEW EXTENSION
      HOSAHALALA ROAD
      KRISHNARAJPET-571426
      MANDYA DISTRICT

121 . SRI J B GOPAL GOWDA
      S/O LATE SANBOREGOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      SILK BUILDING
      JAYANAGAR NEW EXTENSION
      HOSAHALALA ROAD
      KRISHNARAJPET-571426
      MANDYA DISTRICT
 -

                           37




122 . SRI B K VASANTH GOWDA
      S/O LATE KIDDAPPA
      AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      SILK BUILDING
      JAYANAGAR NEW EXTENSION
      HOSAHALALA ROAD
      KRISHNARAJPET -571426
      MANDYA DISTRICT

123 . SRI SRIKANTACHARI
      S/O SRI K N KALACHARI
      AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      SILK BUILDING
      JAYANAGAR NEW EXTENSION
      HOSAHALALA ROAD
      KRISHNARAJPET
      MANDYA DISTRICT

124 . SRI KRISHNEGOWDA
      S/O SRI DODDEGOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
 -

                             38




     GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
     SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR NEW EXTENSION
     HOSAHALALA ROAD
     KRISHNARAJPET-571 426
     MANDYA DISTRICT

125 . SRI.K. GIRI GOWDA
      S/O LATE GOWDE GOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      SILK BUILDING
      JAYANAGAR NEW EXTENSION
      HOSAHALALA ROAD
      KRISHNARAJPET-571 426
      MANDYA DISTRICT

126 . SRI. PUTTASWAMY GOWDA
      S/O LATE SANNE GOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      SILK BUILDING
      JAYANAGAR NEW EXTENSION
      HOSAHALALA ROAD
      KRISHNARAJPET-571426
      MANDYA DISTRICT

127 . SMT.PREMAMMA
      D/O LATE THAMANNA
      AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
 -

                          39




     TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
     SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
     NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
     CENTRAL SILK BOARD
     MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
     GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
     SILK BUILDING
     JAYANAGAR NEW EXTENSION
     HOSAHALALA ROAD
     KRISHNARAJPET-571426
     MANDYA DISTRICT

128 . SRI.M. MAHADEVAIAH
      S/O SRI MADAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND TRAINING
      INSTITUTE CENTRAL SILK BOARD GOVERNMENT OF
      INDIA
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM, MYSORE SOUTH
      MYSORE-570 008.

129 . SRI.SIDDARAJU
      S/O LATE DODDASIDDAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND TRAINING
      INSTITUTE CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,SRIRAMPURAM, MYSORE
      SOUTH MYSORE-570 008.

130 . SRI.SRIKANTASWAMY
      S/O LATE NINGAPPA
      AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND TRAINING
      INSTITUTE CENTRAL SILK BOARD
 -

                           40




     GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
     MANANDAVADI ROAD,SRIRAMPURAM, MYSORE
     SOUTH MYSORE-570 008.

131 . SRI.CHALUVARAJU
      S/O LATE JAVAREGOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND TRAINING
      INSTITUTE CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM, MYSORE SOUTH
      MYSORE-570 008.

132 . SRI.K. PUTTASWAMY
      S/O LATE KALISIDDAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND TRAINING
      INSTITUTE CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM, MYSORE SOUTH
      MYSORE-570 008.

133 . SRI.SANNASWAMY
      S/O SRI KALAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURAL SERVICE CENTRE,
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR
      NEW EXTENSION, HOSAHALALA ROAD,
      KRISHNARAJPET-571 426
      MANDYA DISTRICT.
 -

                           41




134 . SRI.M.K. BOREOWDA
      MAJOR BY AGE,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURAL SERVICE CENTRE,
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR
      NEW EXTENSION, HOSAHALALA ROAD,
      KRISHNARAJPET-571426,
      MANDYA DISTRICT.

135 . SRI.Y.GANESHA
      S/O LATE SHINGERAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURAL SERVICE CENTRE,
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR
      NEW EXTENSION, HOSAHALALA ROAD,
      KRISHNARAJPET-571426
      MANDYA DISTRICT.

136 . SRI.H.L.RAMAIAH
      S/O SRI LINGANNA
      AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      CHAKANAHALLI POST,
      YADUR HOBLI, KUNIGAL TALUK
      TUMKUR DISTRICT.-572142.
 -

                           42




137 . SRI.S.N. RAMA BHATTA
      S/O SRI. S.N.NARAYAN
      AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
      NATIONAL SILK WORM SEED ORGANIZATION,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR
      NEW EXTENSION, HOSAHALALA ROAD,
      KRISHNARAJPET-571426
      MANDYA DISTRICT

138 . SRI. SHASHI GOWDA
      S/O SRI HUCHE OWDA
      AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
      NATIONAL SILK WORM SEED ORGANIZATION,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR
      NEW EXTENSION, HOSAHALALA ROAD,
      KRISHNARAJPET-571426
      MANDYA DISTRICT.

139 . SRI G K RAMESH
      S/O LATE KALEGOWDA,
      AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE SENIOR TECHNICAL ASSISTANT
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK WORM SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      NEAR SRI CHOWDESHWARI PETROL BUNK
      B M ROAD GAYATHRI EXTENSION
      CHANNARAYAPATNA 573116,
 -

                           43




     HASSAN DISTRICT

140 . SRI K R RAVI KUMAR,
      S/O LATE RAJAIAH,
      AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
      AND TRAINING INSTITUTE
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRRAMPURAM, MYSORE SOUTH,
      MYSORE 570008

141 . SRI H N RAMAKRISHNA
      S/O LATE NINGEGOWDA,
      AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR
      NEW EXTENSION HOSAHALALU ROAD
      KRISHNARAJPET 571426
      MANDYA DISTRICT

142 . SRI HEMANTH KUMAR
      S/O LATE RACHA SHETTY,
      AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
      AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM, MYSORE SOUTH,
      MYSORE 570008.
 -

                           44




143 . SRI C VYRAMADI
      S/O LATE CHELUVAIAH,
      AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
      AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM, MYSORE SOUTH,
      MYSORE 570008.

144 . SMT. M S BHAGYALAKSHMI
      D/O LATE SIDDHAIAH,
      AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR
      SILK WORK SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK WORM SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      KANAKAPURA ROAD,
      MALAVALLI 571 430
      MANDYA DISTRICT

145 . SRI CHIKKASIDDAIAH
      S/O LATE SIDDAIAH,
      AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
      AND TRAINING INSTITUTE,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM, MYSORE SOUTH
      MYSORE 570008

146 . SRI CHINCHAIAH
 -

                           45




     S/O SRI CHUNCHAIAH,
     AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
     TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
     OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR
     SILK WORK SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE
     NATIONAL SILK WORK SEED ORGANIZATION
     CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
     MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
     GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
     KANAKAPURA ROAD,
     MALAVALLI 571430,
     MANDYA DISTRICT

147 . SRI VENKATESHA
      S/O LATE VENKATAIAH,
      AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR
      SILK WORK SEED PRODUCTION CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK WORK SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      P B NO 7, B M ROAD
      NEAR GOUSIYA ENGINEERING COLLEGE
      RAMANAGARAM 571511,
      BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT

148 . SRI BETTEGOWDA
      S/O LATE CHALUVEGOWDA,
      AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE
      NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      MINISTRY OF TEXTILES
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      SILK BUILDING JAYANAGAR
 -

                            46




     NEW EXTENSION HOSAHALALA ROAD
     KRISHNARAJPET-571426
     MANDYA DISTRICT

149 . SRI KUMAR
      S/O LATE SINGARAIAH,
      AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE
      SENIOR TECHNICAL ASSISTANT
      SERICULTURE SERVICE CENTRE,
      NATIONAL SILK WORM SEED ORGANIZATION
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      NEAR SRI CHOWDESHWARI PETROL BUNK
      B M ROAD, GAYATHRI EXTENSION,
      CHANNARAYAPATNA 573116,
      HASSAN DISTRICT

150 . SRI SHIVA MURTHY
      S/O LATE KADALAPPA,
      AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER,
      RESEARCH EXTENSION CENTRAL
      SILK BOARD,(GOVERNMENT OF INDIA),
      MARAGHATTA, CHIKKAPURA POST,
      CHITRADURGA TALUK AND
      CHITRADURGA DISTRICT 577520

151 . SRI SHAMBANNA
      S/O LATE MARALAPPA,
      AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER,
      RESEARCH EXTENSION CENTRE
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      (GOVERNMENT OF INDIA),
      MARAGHATTA, CHIKKAPURA POST,
 -

                            47




     CHITRADURGA TALUK AND
     CHITRADURGA DISTRICT 577520

152 . SRI T CHANNAPPA
      S/O SRI SANNA THIPPAIAH,
      AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE
      SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER,
      RESEARCH EXTENSION CENTRE
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      (GOVERNMENT OF INDIA),
      MARAGHATTA, CHIKKAPURA POST,
      CHITRADURGA TALUK AND
      CHITRADURGA DISTRICT 577520

153 . SRI HANUMANTHAPPA
      S/O LATE DURGAPPA,
      AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER,
      RESEARCH EXTENSION CENTRE
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      (GOVERNMENT OF INDIA),
      MARAGHATTA, CHIKKAPURA POST,
      CHITRADURGA TALUK AND
      CHITRADURGA DISTRICT 577520

154 . SRI T CHIDANANDAPPA
      S/O LATE THIMMAPPA
      AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER,
      RESEARCH EXTENSION CENTRE
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      (GOVERNMENT OF INDIA),
      MARAGHATTA, CHIKKAPURA POST,
      CHITRADURGA TALUK
 -

                            48




     AND DISTRICT 577 520

155 . SRI Y SHANKAR MURTHY
      S/O SRI V HERUNGATAPPA
      AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER,
      RESEARCH EXTENSION CENTRE
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      (GOVERNMENT OF INDIA),
      MARAGHATTA, CHIKKAPURA POST,
      CHITRADURGA TALUK
      AND DISTRICT 577520

156 . SRI MAHADEVAPPA
      S/O SRI YELAPPA,
      AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER,
      RESEARCH EXTENSION CENTRE
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      (GOVERNMENT OF INDIA),
      MARAGHATTA, CHIKKAPURA POST,
      CHITRADURGA TALUK
      AND DISTRICT 577520

157 . SRI T GOPALA KRISHNA
      S/O LATE THIPPAIAH,
      AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER,
      RESEARCH EXTENSION CENTRE
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      (GOVERNMENT OF INDIA),
      MARAGHATTA, CHIKKAPURA POST,
      CHITRADURGA TALUK
      AND DISTRICT 577520

158 . SRI RAJAPPA
 -

                           49




     S/O LATE RANGAPPA
     AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
     TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
     OFFICE OF THE SENIOR RESEARCH OFFICER,
     RESEARCH EXTENSION CENTRE
     CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
     (GOVERNMENT OF INDIA),
     MARAGHATTA, CHIKKAPURA POST,
     CHITRADURGA TALUK
     AND DISTRICT 577520

159 . SRI. IBRAHIM
      S/O SRI. KHASIM SAB
      AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE JOINT DIRECTOR
      REGIONAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
      (A UNIT UNDER CST & TI, MYSURU)
      NANJANGUD ROAD
      CHAMARAJANAGAR-571 313

160 . SRI. SHIVASHANKARA
      S/O SRI. SIDDAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
      TRAINING INSTITUTE,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM,
      MYSORE SOUTH,
      MYSORE - 570 008.

161 . SRI. SHIVANNA
      S/O SRI. KALAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
      TRAINING INSTITUTE,
 -

                            50




     CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
     GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
     MANANDAVADI ROAD,
     SRIRAMPURAM,
     MYSORE SOUTH,
     MYSORE - 570 008.

162 . SRI. CHANDRAPPA
      S/O SRI. CHIKKANNA
      AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
      TRAINING INSTITUTE,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM,
      MYSORE SOUTH,
      MYSORE - 570 008.

163 . SMT. CHAMAMMA
      D/O LATE. PAPA
      AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
      TRAINING INSTITUTE,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM,
      MYSORE SOUTH,
      MYSORE - 570 008.

164 . SRI. DAYANANDA SWAMY
      S/O LATE PUTTAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
      TRAINING INSTITUTE,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM,
 -

                           51




     MYSORE SOUTH,
     MYSORE - 570 008.

165 . SRI. MAHADEVA
      S/O SRI. CHIKAANKAPPA
      AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS,
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
      TRAINING INSTITUTE,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM,
      MYSORE SOUTH,
      MYSORE - 570 008.

166 . SRI. SRIDHARA
      S/O SRI. CHALUVAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
      TRAINING INSTITUTE,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM,
      MYSORE SOUTH,
      MYSORE - 570 008.

167 . SRI. M. NANJUNDA
      S/O LATE. MARIGOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
      TRAINING INSTITUTE,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM,
      MYSORE SOUTH,
      MYSORE - 570 008.

168 . SRI. R. THYAGARAJA
 -

                           52




     S/O LATE. RAMAIAH
     AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
     TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
     CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
     TRAINING INSTITUTE,
     CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
     GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
     MANANDAVADI ROAD,
     SRIRAMPURAM,
     MYSORE SOUTH,
     MYSORE - 570 008.

169 . SRI. V. RAMASWAMY
      S/O SRI. VADAGALE GOWDA
      AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
      TRAINING INSTITUTE,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM,
      MYSORE SOUTH,
      MYSORE - 570 008.

170 . SRI. MAHADEVAIAH
      S/O SRI. MANCHAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL RESEARCH AND
      TRAINING INSTITUTE,
      CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
      GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
      MANANDAVADI ROAD,
      SRIRAMPURAM,
      MYSORE SOUTH,
      MYSORE - 570 008.

171 . SRI. SHIVAIAH
      S/O SRI. CHIKKA NINGAIAH
      AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      SERICULTURAL SERVICE CENTRE,
 -

                                53




     NATIONAL SILK SEED ORGANIZATION,
     CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
     MINISTRY OF TEXTILES,
     GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
     SILK BUILDING, JAYANAGAR,
     NEW EXTENSION HOSAHALALA ROAD,
     KRISHNARAJPET-571 426
     MANDYA DISTRICT.

172 . SRI. VEERABHAMACHARY
      S/O LATE PUTTACHAR
      AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      TIME SCALE FARM WORKER
      OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR
      SILK TESTING HOUSE
      CENTRAL SERICULTURAL
      RESEARCH AND TRAINING INSTITUTE
      VATAL NAGARAJ ROAD, OKLIPURAM
      BENGALURU-560 021
                                          ...RESPONDENTS


(BY SRI. ASHOK S. HARANAHALLI, SR. COUNSEL FOR
    SRI. V.S. NAIK, ADVOCATE)

     THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED U/S 4 OF THE KARNATAKA
HIGH COURT ACT, 1961, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE ORDER
DATED 19.10.2022 PASSED BY THE LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE IN
WP NO-19130/2007 (L-RES) C/W WP NO-20513/2007 (L-RES)
AND CONSEQUENTLY DISMISS THE WP NO-19130/2007 (L-RES)
C/W WP NO-20513/2007 (L-RES).


IN CCC NO.950/2023:
BETWEEN:
MUDALAIAH,
THE SECRETARY,
AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
CENTRAL SILK BOARD EMPLOYEE'S UNION
 -

                                54




NO.121/A, 1ST MAIN ROAD,
1ST CROSS,
SHAKTHI GARDEN,
MUDALAPALYA,
BENGALURU-560 026.
                                          ...COMPLAINANT
(BY SRI. ASHOK S. HARANAHALLI, SR. COUNSEL FOR
    SRI. V.S. NAIK, ADVOCATE)

AND:

SRI. P. SHIVA KUMAR,
MEMBER SECRETARY,
CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
CENTRAL SILK BOARD COMPLEX,
5TH FLOOR, B.T.M. LAYOUT,
HOSUR ROAD, MADIVALA,
BENGALURU-560 068.
                                                 ...ACCUSED
(BY SRI. ARAVIND KAMATH, ASGI A/W
    SRI. MADHUKAR M. DESHPANDE, CGSC)

       THIS CCC IS FILED UNDER SECTIONS 11 AND 12 OF THE
CONTEMPT OF COURTS ACT, PRAYING TO INITIATE CONTEMPT
PROCEEDINGS AND PUNISH THE ACCUSED BOARD FOR HAVING
DELEBERATELY DISOBEYED ORDER DATED 19.10.2022 PASSED
BY THIS HON'BLE COURT IN WP NO.20513/2007 AND OTHER
CONNECTED WRIT PETITIONS VIDE ANNEXURE-A.


IN WA NO.468/2023:

BETWEEN:

THE SECRETARY
CENTRAL SILK BOARD EMPLOYEES UNION,
C/O MANJUNATHA STORES,
NO.268/2, III MAIN,
PIPELINE,
KASTURBANAGAR,
MYSURU ROAD,
 -

                                55




BENGALURU-560 026.
                                             ...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. ASHOK S. HARANAHALLI, SR. COUNSEL FOR
    SRI. V.S. NAIK, ADVOCATE)
AND:
THE MEMBER SECRETARY,
CENTRAL SILK BOARD,
CENTRAL SILK BOARD COMPLEX,
5TH FLOOR, B.T.M. LAYOUT,
HOSUR ROAD, MADIVALA,
BENGALURU-560 068.
                                              ...RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. ARAVIND KAMATH, ASGI A/W
      SRI. MADHUKAR M. DESHPANDE, CGSC)

       THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED U/S 4 OF THE KARNATAKA
HIGH COURT ACT, 1961, PRAYING TO ALLOW THE WRIT APPEAL
AND SET ASIDE THE ORDER PASSED BY THE LEARNED SINGLE
JUDGE DATED 19.10.2022 IN WRIT PETITION NO.20513/2007 TO
THE EXTENT THE APPELLANT IS AGGRIEVED AND FURTHER BE
PLEASED TO ALLOW WRIT PETITION NO.20513/2007 IN ITS
ENTIRETY AND GRANT SUCH OTHER AND FURTHER RELIEFS AS
THIS HON'BLE COURT DEEMS FIT AND PROPER UNDER THE
FACTS AND CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE INCLUDING THE
COSTS THROUGHOUT.

        THESE WRIT APPEALS AND CCC HAVING BEEN HEARD AND
RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT ON 10.09.2025 AND COMING ON FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT         OF    JUDGMENT   THIS      DAY,   ANU
SIVARAMAN J., PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:


CORAM:      HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN
            and
            HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH RAI K
 -

                                      56




                            CAV JUDGMENT

(PER: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN)

Writ Appeal No.260/2023 is filed by the Central Silk

Board and Writ Appeal No.468/2023 is filed by the

Secretary, Central Silk Board Employees Union against the

order dated 19.10.2022 passed by the learned Single Judge

in Writ Petition No.19130/2007 connected with Writ Petition

No.20513/2007 (L-RES) and Contempt of Court Case

No.950/2023 is filed by the Secretary, Central Silk Board

Employees Union for disobedience of the same order.

2. We have heard Shri. Aravind Kamath, learned

Additional Solicitor General of India along with Shri.

Madhukar M Deshpande, learned Central Government

Standing Counsel appearing for the Secretary, Central Silk

Board Employees Union and Shri. Ashok S Haranahalli,

learned senior counsel as instructed by Shri. V.S. Naik,

learned advocate appearing for the private respondents.

3. The respondents in Writ Appeal No.260/2023, one

hundred and seventy two in number, had filed the writ

petitions challenging the award of the Central Government

-

Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, Bengaluru ('CGIT' for

short) dated 19.09.2007. They had raised a contention that

they are all qualified, eligible and entitled to get the benefits

of the Scheme known as the "Casual Labourers" (Grant of

Temporary Status and Regularization Scheme, 1993) from

the date of its issuance.

4. A dispute arose between the workmen and the

appellant and on conciliation failing, the following reference

was made by the Central Government to the CGIT as

under:-

"Whether the claim of the Central Silk Road Employees' Union to adopt the Casual Labourers (Grant of Temporary Status and Regularization Scheme of Government of India, 1993 and Pay Scales of the 5th Pay Commission in respect of casual and timescale farm workers by the Management of the Central Silk Board, Bangalore is justified? If not, to what relief the workmen are entitled to?"

5. The contention of the private respondents was

that the scheme in question was formulated by the Central

Government and came into force on 10.09.1993. The Union

sought the benefits of the Scheme, but the same was not

-

granted by the Board. The matter was referred for

conciliation and on conciliation having failed; the Central

Government referred the dispute to the CGIT. The parties

filed their respective pleadings. The CGIT dismissed the

reference by its award dated 19.09.2007 stating that the

Management Board is a statutory body controlled by the

Textile Ministry and that the approval granted to the Scheme

on 01.12.2005 had been withdrawn by the Government.

Accepting the contention that the Scheme required the

sanction of the Central Government and that such sanction

had been withdrawn, the CGIT rejected the reference. It

was found that the casual labourers working under the

Board have no right for conferment of temporary status and

that it is only if the Scheme were to be adopted by the

Board that the claim of the workmen would arise under the

Scheme. It was found that though the Board had

recommended the implementation of the Scheme and

permission was initially granted by the Central Government,

the same was withdrawn and therefore there was no

sanction for implementation of the Scheme in the Board.

-

The aggrieved workmen had challenged the said award

before this Court.

6. The learned Single Judge considered the

contentions and found that the respondent - Board in its

115th meeting dated 19.03.2005, had passed a unanimous

resolution to implement the Scheme in favour of the

workmen of the Board. The said resolution passed by the

respondent - Board was approved by the Central

Government vide order dated 25.11.2005 and

Communications dated 15.12.2005 and 10.01.2006 were

issued by the Central Government and the Board, granting

approval for extension of the Scheme in favour of the

workmen. Thereafter, the Central Government issued a

communication dated 20.01.2006 followed by Board Circular

dated 01.02.2006, withdrawing the approval already granted

on 25.11.2005. The learned Single Judge found that since

the approval for implementation of the Scheme had been

granted by the Central Government after considering all

relevant aspects and since the said approval had been

effectuated by issuing Circulars dated 15.12.2005 and

-

10.01.2006 and also on account of the fact that no reason

whatsoever was stated in the order withdrawing the

approval, the withdrawal of the approval could not be

countenanced. Accordingly, the writ petitions were partly

allowed. The judgment and award dated 19.09.2007 passed

in C.R.No.122/1999 by the CGIT-cum-Labour Court were set

aside. The reference dated 16.11.1999 was allowed-in-part

and the respondent - Board was directed to implement,

grant and extend the Casual Labourers (Grant of Temporary

Status and Regularization) Scheme of Government of India,

1993, in favour of the petitioners and all other workmen of

the respondent - Board with all benefits accruing there from

for the period from 19.03.2005 onwards and settle all the

dues in their favour. The Central Silk Board is in appeal as

regards the positive directions of the learned Single Judge

while the Union is in appeal against limiting of the benefit

from 19.03.2005.

7. The Additional Solicitor General of India

appearing for the appellant - Central Silk Board submits that

there was no challenge as against the Order of the Central

-

Government withdrawing the approval and that the learned

Single Judge grievously erred in granting a benefit that was

not even sought for by the writ petitioners. It is submitted

that the learned Single Judge ought to have noticed that

what was being exercised was only supervisory jurisdiction

under Article 227 of the Constitution of India and that the

learned Single Judge could not have issued the directions as

sought for. Further, it is contended that there was clearly no

error apparent on the face of the record or any perversity, if

the findings of the CGIT-cum-Labour Court. In the absence

of such patent legality or perversity, the writ Court was not

justified in having passed the orders which were not even

sought for.

8. The learned counsel appearing for the Central Silk

Board before the learned Single Judge had placed reliance

on the following decisions:-

• B. Srinivasa Reddy v. Karnataka Urban Water Supply and Drainage Board Employees' Association & Ors reported in AIR 2006 SC 3106;

-

• Food Corporation of India and Ors. Vs. Bhanu Lodh and Ors reported in AIR 2005 SC 2775;

• Punjab National Bank and others v. Manjeet Singh and another reported in AIR 2007 SC 262;

• Ceat Ltd., Vs. Murphy India Employees Union reported in AIR 2006 SC 2412;

• Kapra Mazdoor Ekta Union v. Management of M/s. Birla Cotton spinning and weaving Mills Ltd., & Others reported in AIR 2005 SC 1782;

    •   Reepak     Kansal        v.    Union       and   others
        reported in (2021) 9 SCC 251;

    •   The   State      of    Maharashtra          &    Anr   v.

Bhagwan & Ors in Civil Appeals No.7632- 7684/2021 dated 10.01.2022;

• State of Maharasthra and other v. Anita and Another reported in (2016)8 SCC 293;


    •   W.M. ANGANI v. Badri Das and others
        decided     in         C.A.NO.881/1961             dated
        25.03.1963;

• Oil And Natural Gas Corporation v. Krishna Gopal and others in Civil Appeal No.1878/2016 dated 07.02.2020;

-

• The New Maneck Chowk Spinning and Weaving Co. Ltd., Ahmedabad and others v. The Textile Labour Association, Ahmedabad reported in AIR 1961 SC 867;

• B.N. Nagarajan and others v. State of Mysore and Ors reported in AIR 1966 SC 1942;

• Sukhdev Singh and Ors. V. Bhagatram Sardar Singh Raghuvanshi and Anr reported in AIR 1975 SC 1331, and

• Tulsi Das and others v. Govt. of A.P. and others reported in AIR 2003 SC 43.

9. The learned senior counsel appearing for the

respondents - workmen, would, on the other hand, contend

that contentions raised in the appeal are highly hyper-

technical and cannot be countenanced in a writ appeal filed

from an order passed by the learned Single Judge in a

labour matter. It is submitted that in case the contention of

the appellant that what was being exercised by the learned

Single Judge was only the power of superintendence under

Article 227 of the Constitution of India were to be accepted,

there would be no scope for an appeal being filed by the

appellant from an order passed in the writ petition filed

-

under Article 227 of the Constitution of India alone. It is

contended that it is only if the adjudication by the learned

Single Judge was under Article 226 of the Constitution of

India as well that the writ appeal would be maintainable.

10. Further, it is contended that it was after

considering all the relevant aspects of the matter including

the financial implications as evident from Annexures 'B' to 'F'

produced along with the writ petitions that the Board had

recommended the implementation of the Scheme to its

employees. The financial impact was clearly considered and

the Board was of the clear opinion that the benefits were

liable to be extended to the Workmen. It was considering all

these aspects of the matter that approval had been granted

by the Central Government. Thereafter, no reasons

whatsoever were stated by the Central Government for

withdrawing its approval. It is further contended that since

the dispute raised before the CGIT-cum-Labour Court was

specifically with regard to implementation of the Scheme to

employees of the Board, the reliefs granted by the learned

Single Judge were well within the purview of the orders that

-

could have been granted by the Labour Court and therefore

the impugned judgment is unassailable.

11. The learned senior counsel appearing for the

respondents would place reliance on the following decisions

in support of the contentions:-

• The Bharat Bank Limited, Delhi v. The Employees of the Bharat Bank Limited, Delhi and the Bharat Bank Employee's Union, Delhi reported in AIR 1950 SC 188;

• Western India Automobile Association v.

The Industrial Tribunal, Bombay and Ors. reported in AIR 1949 Federal Court 111;

• Messrs. Crown Aluminium Works v. Their Workmen reported in AIR 1958 SC 30;

• Oil and Natural Gas Corporation Limited v.

Petroleum Coal Labour Union and Others reported in (2015) 6 SCC 494;

• Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation and Another v. Casteribe Rajya Parivahan Karmchari Sanghatana reported in (2009) 8 SCC 556;

• Gujarat Steel Tubes Ltd v. Gujarat Steel Tubes Mazdoor Sabha and Others reported in AIR 1980 SC 1896, and

-

• General Manager, Electrical Rengali Hydro Elcetric Project, Orissa and Others v. Giridhari Sahu and Others reported in (2019) 10 SCC 695.

12. We have considered the contentions advanced.

The employees had raised a dispute with regard to non-

implementation of the 1993 Scheme to the Casual

Employees of the appellant - Board. The dispute had been

referred for adjudication to the CGIT. A writ petition filed by

the workmen challenging the Order of the Central

Government withdrawing the approval granted to the Silk

Board to implement the Scheme was disposed of recording

that the dispute is pending before the CGIT and leaving

open all contentions to be adjudicated therein. The question

whether the workmen are entitled to the benefit of the 1993

Scheme in respect of Casual and Timescale Farm Workers

was specifically referred to the CGIT for adjudication. The

Board took a contention before the CGIT that the benefit

could not be extended to its workmen since the approval

granted by the Central Government to implement the

Scheme in the Board had been withdrawn. The CGIT came

-

to the conclusion that the Scheme could be implemented in

the Board only with the approval of the Central Government

and since such approval stood withdrawn, the employees

have no claim. It was this award which was under challenge

before the learned Single Judge.

13. The Apex Court in Gujarat Steel Tubes Limited

and Others v. Gujarat Steel Tubes Mazdoor Sabha and

Others reported in (1980) 2 SCC 593, has clearly held that

an arbitrator under Section 10-A of the Industrial Disputes Act,

1947 is a Tribunal amenable to the writ jurisdiction of the High

Court. Further, in Bharat Bank Limited v. Employees of

Bharat Bank Limited reported in (1950) SCC 470, the

nature of adjudication by the Industrial Tribunal was discussed

in detail and it was held that a Special Leave Petition under

Article 136 of the Constitution of India is maintainable. In

Radhey Shyam v. Chhabi Nath and Others reported in

(2015) 5 SCC 423, it was held that all Courts and Tribunals in

the jurisdiction of the High Court are subordinate to it and

subject to its control and supervision under Article 227 of the

Constitution of India. It was further held that orders of Civil

-

Court stand on a different footing from orders of authorities or

Tribunals or Courts other than judicial Civil Courts and that a

Writ of Certiorari would not be maintainable as against an order

of a Civil Court. However, so far as orders of the Labour Court

are concerned, it is clear that the power can be exercised both

under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.

14. In an adjudication under the Industrial Disputes

Act, 1947, it has to be remembered that what is intended is

the resolution of disputes and the progress of industry

without impediments and the hyper-technical contentions

may have no place in an adjudication in Labour Law.

Consequently, all questions which are required to be

considered for arriving at a proper decision as to whether

the award of the Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court was

proper or not are within the realm of the adjudication in

judicial review as well. Further, it is clear from the

judgments of the Apex Court that are relied on by the

workmen that the adjudication by the Tribunal is subject to

judicial review by this Court as well. It is also pertinent to

note that a Writ Petition had been filed challenging the

-

withdrawal of the permission granted by the Central

Government, which was disposed of by this Court by

judgment dated 14.08.2007 on the ground that the

Industrial Dispute was pending before the Labour Court. All

contentions of the parties raised in the writ petitions were

left open to be considered by the CGIT. The learned Single

Judge considered the pleadings and the materials on record

and came to the conclusion that the decision taken by the

Central Government to revoke the approval already granted

was not informed by any reason and that the approval had

initially been granted after considering all the relevant

aspects. The learned Single Judge therefore proceeded to

hold that the withdrawal of the approval was bad in law and

that the employees were entitled to the benefits on the basis

of the approval granted on 27.12.2005. In the said

circumstances, the contention that the validity of the order

withdrawing sanction could not have been considered by the

learned Single Judge cannot be accepted.

15. We are of the opinion that the learned Single

Judge, exercising the power of judicial review, was well

-

within his powers to consider whether the rejection of the

claim made by the Workmen before the CGIT was proper or

not. Apparently, the learned Single Judge considered the

contentions and the materials on record and came to a

conclusion that the approval had been recommended and

granted after considering all relevant aspects including the

financial capability of the Board. This is evident from the

recommendation of the Board and the order granting

approval. Such grant of approval and implementation of the

Scheme was duly intimated to the workmen by issuance of a

Circular by the Board. Thereafter, the approval was

withdrawn. No reasons whatsoever were stated for the

withdrawal of approval. The text of the order of withdrawal

reads as follows:-

" I am directed to refer to this Ministry's letter of even number dated 25.11.2005 on the above subject and to say that the recommendation to apply the Casual Laborers grant of Temporary Status and Regularization Schemes of Government of India 1993 to the causal farm workers and Time Scale Farm Workers of Central Silk Board has not been approved. The orders issued vide Ministry's letter No.25011/30/93-Silk dated 25.11.2005 are withdrawn forthwith. The Central Silk Board may take the position before the High

-

Court/Industrial Tribunal that the scheme is not applicable to its farm workers who are governed by their own rules. Thus the order dated 25.11.2005 is withdrawn forthwith and Central Silk Board is advised to take the position before the Hon'ble High Court/Industrial Tribunal as stated above."

Since an answer to the dispute raised before the CGIT

could be arrived at only on considering the legality or

otherwise of the order of withdrawal of approval, we are of

the opinion that the learned Single Judge was justified in

having held that the withdrawal of approval was not proper

and was not supported by any reasons.

16. We notice that the Union has filed an appeal

against the judgment on the ground that the resolution

passed by the Board in its meeting held on 19.03.2005 was

to extend the benefit of the Scheme. It is therefore

contended that the Timescale Farm Workers working in the

Board were entitled to the benefit of the Scheme with effect

from 1993 itself and the limiting of the benefit from

19.03.2005 is therefore not proper.

-

17. Having considered the contentions advanced, we

notice that the Board had recommended the grant of

benefits of 1993 Scheme prospectively, with effect from

01.12.2005. It was this approval which was withdrawn by

letter dated 20.01.2006. The learned Single Judge has

considered the rival contentions and is also considered the

order of approval as well as the Circulars and Memoranda

issued and has held that the benefit of the Scheme is to be

made applicable with effect from 19.03.2005, that is, the

date on which the Board decided to implement the Scheme

in favour of the workmen. Having considered the

contentions advanced, we find no ground to interfere in the

exercise of discretion by the learned Single Judge.

18. In the result:-

(i) Writ Appeals No.260/2023 and 468/2023 fail and the same are accordingly dismissed.

(ii) Necessary action to be taken within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.

-

(iii) In the light of the directions issued, Contempt of Court Case No.950/2023 is closed.

All pending interlocutory applications shall stand

dismissed.

Sd/-

(ANU SIVARAMAN) JUDGE

Sd/-

(RAJESH RAI K) JUDGE

cp*

 
Download the LatestLaws.com Mobile App
 
 
Latestlaws Newsletter
 

Publish Your Article

 

Campus Ambassador

 

Media Partner

 

Campus Buzz

 

LatestLaws Guest Court Correspondent

LatestLaws Guest Court Correspondent Apply Now!
 

LatestLaws.com presents: Lexidem Offline Internship Program, 2026

 

LatestLaws.com presents 'Lexidem Online Internship, 2026', Apply Now!

 
 

LatestLaws Partner Event : IJJ

 

LatestLaws Partner Event : Smt. Nirmala Devi Bam Memorial International Moot Court Competition

 
 
Latestlaws Newsletter