M.B. Sadasiivaiah vs The Principal Secretary To ...
2022 Latest Caselaw 12103 Kant

                           1



     IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

       DATED THIS THE 23RD DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2022

                        PRESENT

              THE HON'BLE MR. ALOK ARADHE
                  ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE

                          AND

      THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.VISHWAJITH SHETTY

           WRIT APPEAL NO.4338/2017 (S-RES)
                         C/W
            WRIT APPEAL NOs.5815/2017(S-R)
                  & 2474/2018 (S-RES)

IN W.A.NO.4338/2017:

BETWEEN:

1.   M.B. SADASIIVAIAH
     69 YEARS, S/O V VEERABHADRAIAH
     'DEEPTHI', 3RD CROSS
     ASHOKNAGAR, TUMKUR - 572 103
     (SRI SIDDAGANGA COLLEGE OF ARTS,
     SCIENCE AND COMMERCE, TUMKUR)
     PPO NO.277626/RPR.

2.   DR. VENKATARAJU A
     69 YEARS
     S/O ANANTHAPDMANABHA BHAT M
     'SUPRADEEP', ARB COLONY, I CROSS
     ASHOKNAGAR, SHIMOGA - 577 201
     (ACHARYA TULSI NATIONAL COLLEGE
     OF COMMERCE, SHIMOGA)
     PPO NO.277626/RPR.

3.   CHANNABASAPPA P
     69 YEARS
     S/O P. KARIBASAPPA
     'BASAVASHREE', 3RD MAIN
     3RD CROSS, JAYANAGARA EAST
     TUMKUR - 572 102
     (SRI. SIDDAGANGA COLLEGE
                            2



     FOR WOMEN, TUMKUR)
     PPO NO.291716/RPR.

4.   D MANJUNATH ADIGA
     67 YEARS
     S/O D. SEETHARAMA ADIGA
     KRITHIKA, 7TH MAIN
     ASHOKNAGAR, TUMKUR - 572 103
     (SRI SIDDAGANGA COLLEGE OF
     ARTS, SCIENCE AND COMMERCE,
     TUMKUR), PPO NO.314467/RPR/UGC.

5.   DR. M.P. SHANKARAPPA
     67 YEARS
     S/O PARVATHAIAH
     HOUSE NO.5212, 2ND MAIN ROAD
     SADASHIVANAGAR, TUMKUR - 572 104
     (SRI SIDDAGANGA COLLEGE OF ARTS,
     SCIENCE AND COMMERCE, TUMKUR)
     PPO NO.382771/RPR/UGC.

6.   NAGARAJU K.C
     66 YEARS, S/O G. CHANAPPA
     NO.482, 6TH CROSS, 5TH MAIN
     ROAD, KENGERI SATELLITE TOWN
     BANGALORE - 560 060
     (SRI SIDDAGANGA COLLEGE OF ARTS,
     SCIENCE AND COMMERCE, TUMKUR)
     PPO NO.335732/RPR/UGC.

7.   T.S. SACHIDANANADA MURTHY
     66 YEARS
     S/O N. SIDDALINGAIAH
     SINDHU KUVEMPU STREET
     RAGHAVENDRANAGAR
     TUMKUR - 572 102
     (SRI SIDDAGANGA COLLEGE OF ARTS,
     SCIENCE AND COMMERCE, TUMKUR)
     PPO NO.336710/RPR/UGC.

8.   DR. H.S. NIRANJANARADHYA
     65 YEARS, S/O N. SHIVARUDRAIAH
     27, I FLOOR, 4TH CROSS
     MUNICIPAL LAYOUT
     SIDDAGANGA EXTENSION
                              3



       TUMKUR - 572 102
       (SRI SIDDAGANGA COLLEGE OF ARTS,
       SCIENCE AND COMMERCE, TUMKUR)
       PPO NO.111208990/UGC.

9.     JAYAKUMAR C.R
       65 YEARS
       S/O C.M. RUDRARADHYA SHARMA
       RUDRESHWAR, 3RD MAIN
       BASAVESHVARA BADAVANE
       KYATHASNADRA, TUMKUR - 572 104
       (SRI SIDDAGANGA COLLEGE OF ARTS,
       SCIENCE AND COMMERCE FOR WOMEN,
       TUMKUR), PPO NO.1113UGC31789.

10.    VIJAYA KUMARI M.S (1113UGC31340)
       65 YEARS
       W/O Y.V.S. KUMARI
       THARANGINI 2ND CROSS
       CHANNABASAVESHWARA NAGAR
       TUMKUR - 572 102
       (SRI SIDDAGANGA COLLEGE OF ARTS,
       SCIENCE AND COMMERCE FOR WOMEN,
       TUMKUR), PPO NO.1113UGC31340.

11.    S. RAJASHEKARAIAH (1113UGC35440)
       65 YEARS, S/O RAJASHEKARAIAH
       SIDDALINGESHWARA NILAYA
       3RD MAIN ROAD, NRUPATHUNGA EXTN
       SHETTIHALLI ROAD, TUMKUR - 572 102
       (SRI SIDDAGANGA COLLEGE OF ARTS,
       SCIENCE AND COMMERCE, TUMKUR)
       PPO NO.1113UGC35440.                 ...APPELLANTS

(BY SMT. SUMA KEDILAYA V, ADV.)

AND:

1.     THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
       TO GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA
       (HIGHER EDUCATION), EDUCATION
       DEPARTMENT, M S BUILDINGS
       AMBEDKAR VEEDHI
       BANGALORE - 560 001.
                               4



2.   STATE OF KARNATAKA
     BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRTARY
     TO GOVERNMENT, FINANCE
     DEPARTMENT, VIDHANA SOUDHA
     AMBEDKAR VEEDHI
     BANGALORE - 560 001.

3.   THE DIRECTOR OF COLLEGIATE
     EDUCATION, PALACE ROAD
     BANGALORE - 560 001.                ...RESPONDENTS

(BY S.S. MAHENDRA, AGA FOR R-1 TO R-3)

THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE ORDER PASSED ON 24.04.2015, WITH RESPECT TO EMOLUMENTS BY THE LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE OF THIS COURT IN W.P.NO.60251/2014 AND GRANT ALL THE RELIEFS CLAIMED IN THE W.P.

IN W.A.NO.5815/2017:

BETWEEN:

1. DR. M.A. JAYASHREE 66 YEARS, D/O M.A. RANGARAJAN #384, KRISHNA VILAS ROAD MYSORE - 570 024, RETD ON 30-4-2008 PPO NO.315463/RPR, D. BANUMAIAHS COLLEGE OF COMMERCE AND ARTS MYSORE.

2. SRI BALAKRISHNA H.C 65 YEARS, S/O H. CHIKKA PUTTE GOWDA #522, 8TH CROSS, VINAYA MARGA SIDDARTHA NAGAR, MYSORE - 570 011 RETD ON 31-3-2011, PPO NO.33574/RPR D. BANUMAIAHS COLLEGE OF COMMERCE AND ARTS, MYSORE.

3. SRI MAHADEVAPPA K.M S/O LATE MALLEDEVARU 68 YEARS, #218, NISARGA, 3RD MAIN

A-1 BLOCK, VIJAYNAGAR 3RD STAGE MYSORE - 570 017, RETD ON 31-5-2006 PPO NO.281661/RPR, JSS COLLEGE OF ARTS, COMMERCE AND SCIENCE, OOTY ROAD, MYSORE - 25.

4. SRI VISHWANATH K.B S/O LATE K.B. HANUMANTHAPPA AGED 68 YEARS #797, "SUSHMA", 16TH MAIN 23RD A CROSS MAIN 3RD SECTOR, HSR LAYOUT BANGALORE - 560 102 RETD ON 30-11-2006 PPO NO.287950/RPR JSS COLLEGE OF ARTS, COMMERCE AND SCIENCE, OOTY ROAD MYSORE - 25.

5. MARYAMMA A.C D/O SRI A.C. KURIAKOSE #21, MIG KHB M.G. ROAD UDAYAGIRI, MYSORE - 560 009 RETD ON 31-3-2008, PPO NO.315158/RPR ST. PHILOMENA'S COLLEGE MYSORE - 15.

6. SRI SRINIVASA SETTY S 66 YEARS, S/O P.S. SEETHARAMASETTY NO.290, IV CROSS, SUBHASA NAGAR MYSORE - 570 007, RETD ON 31-3-2008 PPO NO.315230/RPR, ST. PHILOMENAS COLLEGE, MYSORE - 15.

7. SRI SRINIVASA ADIGA K S/O KALINGA ADIGA AGED 68 YEARS CH-15, II MAIN, 6TH CROSS SARASWATHIPURAM MYSORE -570 009 RETD ON 31-8-2006.PPO NO.291714/RPR CAUVERY COLLEGE, GONIKOPAL, KODAGU.

8. DR. APPAJI GOWDA S.B SINCE DEAD REPRESENTED BY LRS

8(a) SMT. LATHA APPAJI GOWDA 63 YEARS.

8(b) S.A. CHAITRA 38 YEARS

8(c) M.A. POORNA TEJASWI AGED 35 YEARS.

8 (a) (b) AND (c) ARE RESIDING AT SIDDHAROODHARA MANE, KENGAL HANUMANTHAIAH EXTN., MADDUR - 571 428 RETD ON 31-7-2006.PPO NO.282589/RPR H.K. VEERANNA GOWDA COLLEGE MADDUR.

9. SRI NANJAIAH B S/O BORAIAH AGED 65 YEARS, CHIGARU NILAYA, RAILWAY STATION ROAD, SHIVAPURA K.S, MADDUR RETD ON 30-5-2011 PPO NO.347570/RPR H.K. VEERANA GOWDA COLLEGE MADDUR.

10. SRI SIDDARAMAIAH B S/O T. BASAPPA AGED 67 YEARS, #23, ELEVENTH BLOCK JSS LAYOUT, MYSORE - 570 029 RETD ON 30-5-2006, PPO NO.306308/RPR JSS COLLEGE OF ARTS, COMMERCE AND SCIENCE OOTY ROAD, MYSORE - 25.

11. SRI MAHADEVAIAH K S/O MADAIAH, AGED 69 YEARS #5, BLOCK NO.31 JSS LAYOUT, MYSORE - 570 011 RETD ON 30-4-2006 PPO NO.283732/RPR JSS COLLEGE, GUNDLUPET CHAMARAJANAGARA DISTRICT.

12. SRI PUTTASWAMY K AGED 66 YEARS, S/O LATE KAMAIAH DOOR NO.MIG-24 HOUSING BOARD COLONY CHAMARAJANAGARA - 571 313 RETD ON 31-3-2008, PPO NO.313642/RPR JSS COLLEGE OF ARTS AND SCIENCE CHAMARAJANAGARA DISTRICT.

13. SRI SANNANINGEGOWDA B.S S/O SHIVANNA AGED 69 YEARS NO.1108, IST CROSS, PADUVANA ROAD 4TH STAGE, T K LAYOUT,MYSORE -570 023 RETD ON 31-5-2006, PPO NO.284781/RPR JSS COLLEGE, NANJANGUD.

14. DR. CHANDRASHEKHARA BHAT AGED 70 YEARS S/O B. VENKATRAMANA BHAT MANJUSHREE, SANKAPITHILU DODDATHOTA POST VIA SULLIA - 574 240, RETD ON 30-6-2006, PPO NO.40/2006-2007 YUVARAJAS COLLEGE.

15. ZAKIA BANU D/O MAZHAR US SAMAD AGED 69 YEARS, D.NO.372, 6TH MAIN, 3RD CROSS BANNIMANTAP C LAYOUT MYSORE - 570 015, RETD ON 28-2-2006 PPO NO.281904/RPR, ST PHILOMENA COLLEGE, MYSORE - 15.

16. VATSALA C.B D/O LATE C.B. IYENGAR #20, AISHWARYA IST MAIN 4TH STAGE, T.K. LAYOUT MYSORE - 570 009, RETD ON 28-2-2011 PPO NO.340904/RPR VIDYAVARDHAKA FIRST GRADE COLLEGE MYSORE.

17. SRI CHIKKEGOWDA S/O BOREGOWDA AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS 5TH CROSS, LEELAVATHI EXTENSION BEHIND GANESH TEMPLE MADDUR TOWN, MANDYA DISTRICT - 571 428, RETD ON 31-5-2006, PPO NO.284780/RPR. . H.K. VEERANNAGOWDA COLLEGE MADDUR.

18. SRI RAMALINGAIAH AGED 69 YEARS S/O DODDAHYDIAIAH, 9TH CROSS V.V. NAGAR, MADDUR TOWN MANDYA DISTRICT - 571 428 RETD ON 29-2-2008 PPO NO.313449/RPR H.K. VEERANNAGOWDA COLLEGE MADDUR.

19. SRI AFTAB AHMED KHAN DURRANI AGED 69 YEARS S/O YAKUB ALI KHAN DVRRANI #271, NORTH EAST OF N R MOHALLA MYSORE - 570 007, RETD ON 30-6-2006 PPO NO.280019/RPR, D BANUMAIAHS COLLEGE OF COMMERCE AND ARTS MYSORE.

20. SUJAYA K.R D/O K.S. RAMASWAMY AGED 66 YEARS, A-01-15, PRITHVI ATISH LAYOUT BOGADI II STAGE, MYSORE - 570 026 RETD ON 28-2-2009, PPO NO.316875/RPR D BANUMAIAHS COLLEGE OF COMMERCE AND ARTS, MYSORE.

21. SRI KRISHNAPPA H.G S/O LATE GURULINGAPPA AGED 68 YEARS 195/S, IST B CROSS 4TH MAIN ROAD, RAMAKRISHNANAGARA IST BLOCK, MYSORE - 570 023

RETD ON 31-10-2006, PPO NO.316876/RPR D. BANUMAIAHS COLLEGE OF COMMERCE AND ARTS, MYSORE.

22. SRI CHANDRASHEKHARE GOWDA B.K S/O B.K. KEMPAIAH AGED 69 YEARS, #1274, PADUVANA ROAD 4TH CROSS, T.K. LAYOUT KUVEMPUNAGARA, MYSORE - 570 023 RETD ON 31-1-2006, PPO NO.272176/RPR D. BANUMAIAHAS COLLEGE OF COMMERCE & ARTS, MYSORE.

23. SRI SHIVAJI JOIS S S/O SRI K. GOPAL JOISH AGED 68 YEARS 166, SAMARASA KESARE II STAGE R.S. NAIDUWAGARA, MYSORE - 570 007 D. BANUMAIAHS COLLEGE OF COMMERCE AND ARTS, MYSORE RETD ON 31-1-2006, PPO NO.271494/RPR.

24. SRI RANGASWAMY N S/O NEELEGOWDA AGED 68 YEARS, 91, N BLOCK, 4TH MAIN, KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE - 570 023, D. BANUMAIAHS COLLEGE OF COMMERCE AND ARTS MYSORE, RETD ON 31-7-2006 PPO NO.286105/RPR.

25. SRI MAHADEVAIAH S/O LATE KEMPARAVALAIAH AGED 68 YEARS, #5 BLOCK NO.12, JSS NAGARA DR. RAJKUMAR ROAD, MYSORE - 570 029 RETD ON 30-4-2006, PPO NO.277552/RPR D. BANUMAIAHS COLLEGE OF COMMERCE AND ARTS, MYSORE.

26. SRI CAUVERY M.C S/O M.S. CALAPPA AGED 67 YEARS NO.9, 9TH CROSS, 3RD MAIN

SARASWATHIPURAM, MYSORE - 570 009 RETD ON 31-10-2008, PPO NO.32/2008-2009 YUVARAJAS COLLEGE, MYSORE.

27. SARVAMANGALA BAI C D/O C BHUJANGA RAO AGED 70 YEARS, NO.48, KASTHURBA, 3RD CROSS ANIKETANA ROAD(SOUTH) KUVEMPUNAGARA, MYSORE - 570 023 RETD ON 31-1-2008, PPO NO.FBS/PEN/82/2007-2008 MAHARAJAS COLLEGE, MYSORE UNIVERSITY.

28. DR. SOMASHEKARA GOWDA S/O SOMEGOWDA AGED 68 YEARS, PREETI, #2927, 21ST MAIN 3RD CROSS, POLICE STATION ROAD VIJAYANAGARA II STAGE MYSORE - 570 017 RETD ON 29-2-2008 PPO NO.9197PBS/PEN/85(2007-2008) KUVEMPU INSTITUTE OF KANNADA STUDIES, MANASAGANGOTRI, MYSORE - 6.

29. VASANTHAMMA H M D/O M MASHANABAI AGED 72 YEARS, MIG 37, HUDCO, VASANTHA MAHAL GAYATHRI LAYOUT, MYSORE - 570 009 RETD ON 30-9-2006 PPO NO.9054/RPR MAHARAJAS COLLEGE MYSORE UNIVERSITY.

30. SMT. SHOBHA M S SWAMY W/O LATE M SIDDALINGESHAPPA AGED 58 YEARS, #70, SHOPARASAI, 4TH MAIN 2ND CROSS, SAHYADRINAGAR SHIMOGA - 570 004, RETD ON 6-8-2006 PPO NO.839016/RPR, SAHYADRI ARTS AND COMMERCE COLLEGE SHIMOGA.

31. SRI H. BASAVARAJAPPA S/O LATE HANUMANTHAPPA

AGED 76 YEARS, #3624, SHREE RANGA, 8TH MAIN 5TH CROSS, MCC B BLOCK DAVANAGERE - 577 004 RETD ON 31-10-2007, PPO NO.301014/RPR SAHYADRI ARTS AND COMMERCE COLLEGE SHIMOGA.

32. SRI T.S. HOOVAIAHGOWDA AGED 71 YEARS S/O VENKATAGIRIYAPPA 81, RAILWAY PARALLEL ROAD II STAGE, VINOBANAGAR - 577 204 RETD ON 30-6-2006, PPO NO.0314779/RPR SAHYADRI SCIENCE COLLEGE, SHIMOGA.

33. SRI M. RAJANNA S/O LATE M P MALLESHAPPA AGED 73 YEARS, LAKSHMI NIVAS, VINOBANAGAR 60 ROAD, 11TH CROSS SHIMOGA - 577 204 RETD ON 31-7-2008PPO NO.315884/RPR SAHYADRI SCIENCE COLLEGE, SHIMOGA.

34. SRI JAYADEVAPPA B AGED 71 YEARS S/O LATE HALAPPA K SHREE MRITHUNJAYA, III CROSS I MAIN, VIJAYANAGARA SHIMOGA - 577 205, RETD ON 30-10-2008 HIS PPO NO. IS 0914000088/RPR/UGC SAHYADRI ARTS AND COMMERCE COLLEGE SHIMOGA.

35. DR. C.G. MATHAD S/O LATE SRI GADIGAIAH AGED 69 YEARS, NO.4, BASAVANILAYA SAHYADRI NAGAR, OPP J H PATEL BADAVANE VINOBANAGAR POST, SHIMOGA - 577 204 RETD ON 31-10-2008, PPO NO.091400038/RPR SAHYADRI SCIENCE COLLEGE SHIMOGA.

36. SMT. M.S. PUSHPALATHA W/O M GURUMURTHY AGED 68 YEARS, SUDARSHANA, #25, II CROSS VIDYANAGAR, SHIMOGA - 577 203 RETD ON 31-12-2008 PPO NO.316741/RPR SAHYADRI SCIENCE COLLEGE, SHIMOGA.

37. SRI PADMANABHAN V R S/O P P RAMA PODUVAL AGED 70 YEARS, NO.36, SWADEEP, III CROSS SAHYADRI NAGAR, VINOBANAGAR SHIMOGA - 577 204, RETD ON 31-8-2009 PPO NO.3318137/RPR, SAHYADRI SCIENCE COLLEGE, SHIMOGA.

38. SRI KRISHNAMURTHY M.S S/O M.N. SURYANARAYANA RAO AGED 70 YEARS, DOOR NO. 96, 6TH MAIN G. CHANDRASHEKARA BLOCK BEML 3RD STAGE, RAJARAJESHWARI NAGARA, BANGALORE - 560 098 RETD ON 31-8-2007, PPO NO.307404/RPR TUNGA MAHAVIDYALAYA THIRTHAHALLI SHIMOGA DISTRICT.

39. SRI G.V. GANAPATHY RAO S/O VENKATAGIRIYAPPA C-277, 9TH MAIN, VYSYA BANK COLONY AREKERE, BG ROAD, BANGALORE - 560 079 RETD ON 31-3-2006, PPO NO.287714/RPR TUNGA MAHAVIDYALAYA THIRTHAHALLI SHIMOGA DISTRICT.

40. SRI A. CHANDRASHEKHARA S/O AYADA SATYAYNARAYANAPPA AGED 66 YEARS, HAREGOPPA VILLAGE, KELADI POST, SAGAR TALUK, SHIMOGA - 577 401 RETD. ON 31/08/2011. PPO NO. IS 1113 UGC 24582, TUNGA MAHAVIDYALAY THIRTHAHALLI, SHIMOGA DISTRICT. ... APPELLANTS

(BY SMT. SUMA KEDILAYA V, ADV.)

AND:

1. THE GOVT. OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCES AND HIGHER EDUCATION NEW DELHI - 110 001.

2. THE PRINICIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA (HIGHER EDUCATION), EDUCATION DEPARTMENT, M.S. BUILDINGS AMBEDKAR VEEDHI BANGALORE - 560 001.

3. STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, FINANCE DEPARTMENT VIDHANA SOUDHA, AMBEDKAR VEEDHI BANGALORE - 560 001.

4. THE DIRECTOR OF COLLEGIATE EDUCATION, PALACE ROAD BANGALORE - 560 001.

5. THE REGISTRAR MYSORE UNIVERSITY MYSORE - 570 005.

6. THE REGISTRAR KUVEMPU UNIVERSITY SHIMOGA - 577 451. ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI S.S. MAHENDRA, AGA FOR R-1 TO R-3; SRI T.P. RAJENDRA KUMAR SUNGAY, ADV.,N FOR R-5 & R-6)

THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE ORDER PASSED ON 24.04.2015, BY THE LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE OF THIS COURT IN W.P.NO.59592-59620/2014 & W.P.NOS.59621-

631/2014(S-R) AND GRANT ALL THE RELIEFS CLAIMED IN THE W.P., EXCEPT SALARY.

IN W.A.NO.2474/2018:

BETWEEN:

1. DR. T. MANIAN 69 YEARS, S/O THANGAVELU, CHITTIRAM CRYSTAL COURT, 8/177, AMBEDKAR MAIN ROAD, SITHALAPPAKKAM, CHENNAI - 600 126. (KUVEMPU UNIVERSITY OF KANNADA STUDIES, MANASAGANGOTRI) (HE RETIRED ON 30.06.2009 AND PENSION CODE NO. IS 9277).

2. SRI R.N. PADMANABHA 70 YEARS, S/O M.R. NAGAPPA #8, 1ST CROSS, BOGADI II STAGE(SOUTH) PRASHANTH NAGAR, MYSORE - 26 (MAHARAJAS COLLEGE, MYSORE) (HE RETIRED ON 31.12.2006 AND PENSION CODE NO IS 9105).

3. DR. K. YESHODHARA S/O LATE K.T. KALACHAR, 65 YEARS, #191, 16TH MAIN, 9TH CROSS, SARASWATHIPURAM, MYSORE-570 009, (DEP OF STUDIES IN EDUCATION MANASAGANGOTRI, MYSORE) (SHE RETIRED ON 31.05.2014 AND PENSION CODE NO IS 9672).

4. DR. G.H. PARVATHAMMA /O. G. HANUMAPPA, GED 69 YEARS, SOWPURMIKA 545, C & D BLOCK, 2ND CROSS UVEMPU NAGAR, MYSORE - 23. (DEP OF STUDIES IN EDUCATION, MANASAGANGOTRI, MYSORE) (SHE RETIRED ON 07.05.2008 AND PENSION CODE NO IS 9189)

5. SRI C.B. BASAVARAJU S/O BASAPPA, 68 YEARS #11, 25TH BLOCK, JSS NAGAR MYSORE - 29, (JSS COLLEGE, OOTY ROAD, MYSORE), (HE RETIRED ON 31.12.2007 AND PPO NO IS 302911/RPR).

6. SRI B. KRISHNA 68 YEARS, S/O B. GIRIGOWDA #3038/1 D2/1, "KALPATARU" GOKULAM PARK ROAD, VV MOHALLA, MYSORE - 570 002, (ST.PHILOMENAS COLLEGE MYSORE - 15), (HE RETIRED ON 31.3.2009 AND HIS PENSION CODE NO IS 9273).

7. DR. P.K. RAJASHEKHARA S/O LATE KEMPEGOWDA 71 YEARS, NO.239, 2ND MAIN ROAD 3RD STAGE, "D" BLOCK, VIJAYANAGAR, MYSORE - 570 017, (KUVEMPU KANNADA ADYANA KENDRA, MANASAGANGOTRI, MYSORE), (HE RETIRED ON 31.10.2006. HIS PENSION CODE NO IS 9067).

8. SRI S. SIDDARAJU S/O LATE SIDDAIAH, 68 YEARS, #2118, 12TH CROSS, MARUTHI TENT ROAD, JANATHANAGAR, BHOGADI 2ND STAGE (S), MYSORE - 570 009 (MAHARAJAS COLLEGE UNIVERSITY, MYSORE), (HE RETIRED ON 31-05-2006 AND PENSION CODE NO. IS 9013).

9. SRI MAHADEVAPPA K.P S/O SRI. PUTTAPPA K, 69 YEARS #931, E/F BLOCK, AGNIHAMSA ROAD 2ND CROSS, KUVEMPUNAGARA MYSORE - 570 023, (JSS COLLEGE FOR WOMEN, SARASWATHIPURAM, MYSORE), (HE RETIRED ON 31.03.2006. HIS PPO NO IS 276840/RPR).

10. SRI C. SUBBANNA /O CHANNAPPA, 70 YEARS,

4292, "SADANANDANILAYA", 1TH CROSS, RP ROAD, NANJANGUD, ARNATAKA - 571 301. (JSS COLLEGE, OOTY ROAD, MYSORE), (HE RETIRED ON 31.01.2006, HIS PPO NO. IS 278831/RPR)

11. SRI. N. NANJUNDAIAH 70 YEARS, S/O DONDANA KENDAIAH 5174, HIGH TENSION DOUBLE ROAD VIJAYNAGARA 2ND STAGE, MYSORE - 17 (UNIVERSITY EVENING COLLEGE) (HE RETIRED ON 28.2.2007 AND PENSION CODE NO IS 9109) (NOTE:BENEFIT OF SENIOR CITIZEN NOT CLAIMED).

12. SRI. MALLUSWAMY. M S/O MAHADEVAPPA, 68 YEARS, NO.28, VIDYANAGAR, DEVARAMANHALLI, NANJANGUD - 571 118, (JSS COLLEGE, CHAMARAJANAGARA DISTRICT) (HE RETIRED ON 31.12.2007, HIS PPO NO. IS 310205/RPR/UGC-AICTE)

13. SMT. GANGAMMA, W/O H. SHEKARAPPA, AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS, VIDYA NILAYA, KHB COLONY, BIRUR, KADUR, CHICKMAGALUR DEAD BY LRS

13(A) HARSHA H.S.

S/O H. SHEKARAPPA, 40 YEARS.

VIDYA NILAYA, KHB COLONY BIRUR, KADUR, CHICKMAGALUR

13(B) SANTHOSH H.S.

S/O H.SHEKARAPPA, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS VIDYA NILAYA, KHB COLONY BIRUR, KADUR, CHICKMAGALUR

13(C) VIDYA H.S.

D/O H.SHEKARAPPA,

AGED 36 YEARS, VIDYA NILAYA, KHB COLONY BIRUR, KADUR, CHICKMAGALUR

14. SRI. CHANDRASHEKARAPPA K 69 YEARS, S/O LATE K. SHIVALINGAPPA, SWAMY MEDICAL STORES, C.B. ROAD HOLALKERE, CHITRADURGA - 577 526, (MBR COLLEGE, SIRIGERE, CHITRADURGA DISTRICT), (HE RETIRED ON 31.03.2007, HIS PPO NO. IS 302050/RPR)

15. SRI. SHEKARAPPA S/O LATE VEERABHADRAPPA, 69 YEARS, "SUPRABHA" 5TH CROSS, A BLOCK, SHARAVATHINAGAR SHIVAMOGGA, (B.P. COLLEGE OF ARTS AND COMMERCE, HOLALKERE) (HE RETIRED ON 28.02.2007, HIS PPO NO. 2970150/RPR)

16. SRI. CHIKKASIDDEGOWDA S/O LATE CHIKKASIDEGOWDA, 72 YEARS, #455, D-SIDDAIAH ROAD, CHAMARAJA MOHALLA, MYSORE-4, (MAHARAJAS COLLEGE, UNIVERSITY OF MYSORE, MYSORE - 4), (HE RETIRED ON 30.06.2006 AND PENSION CODE NO IS 9055)

17. SRI. M. SHIVANNA S/O MAYANNA, 69 YEARS, "PREETHI DEEPA", #11, 3RD MAIN MAHAJANA LAYOUT, VIJAYNAGAR II STAGE, MYSORE-570 017 NEHRU MEMORIAL COLLEGE, SULLIA, DAKSHINA KANNADA (HE RETIRED ON 31.10.2007. HIS PPO NO. IS 307646/RPR/UGC). ...APPELLANTS

(BY SMT. SUMA KEDILAYA, ADV.)

AND:

1. THE GOVT. OF INDIA, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,

MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCES AND HIGHER EDUCATION NEW DELHI - 110 001.

2. THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA (HIGHER EDUCATION) EDUCATION DEPARTMENT M.S. BUILDINGS, AMBEDKAR VEEDHI BANGALORE - 560 001.

3. STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, FINANCE DEPARTMENT VIDHANA SOUDHA, AMBEDKAR VEEDHI BANGALORE - 560 001.

4. THE DIRECTOR OF COLLEGIATE EDUCATION, PALACE ROAD BANGALORE - 560 001. ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI G.D. SRINIVAS, CGC FOR R-1; SRI S.S. MAHENDRA, AGA FOR R-3 & R-4; V/O DATED 13.11.2019 NOTICE TO R-2 H/S)

THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE ORDER PASSED ON 24.04.2015, WITH RESPECT TO "EMOLUMENTS" BY THE LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE OF THIS COURT IN W.P. NOS.7009-7023/2015 AND W.P.NOS.7024-25/2015 AND GRANT ALL THE RELIEFS CLAIMED IN THE W.P.

THESE APPEALS COMING ON FOR HEARING THIS DAY, ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

JUDGMENT

These intra court appeals have been filed against the

order dated 24.04.2015 passed by the learned Single. The

relevant extract of the order reads as under:

"4. Learned Counsel for the parties agree that the issue involved in the present writ petition is identical to the one involved in the aforesaid writ petitions. They also do not dispute that this petition can also be disposed in terms of the aforesaid judgment."

2. Thus, it is evident that the writ petitions have been

decided by the learned Single Judge on the basis of the

consent of the parties. No ground for interference in these

intra court appeals is made out to interfere with the order

passed by the learned Single Judge passed with the consent

of the parties.

3. In the result, appeals fail and are hereby dismissed.

SD/-

ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE

SD/-

JUDGE

KK