The Delhi High Court has refused to grant bail to a husband accused of abetting the suicide of his wife, who tragically took her own life just 13 days after their marriage. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma, presiding over the case, emphasized the severe emotional toll that discovering a spouse's infidelity shortly after marriage can inflict upon an individual, potentially driving them to extreme measures like suicide.
Brief Facts:
In the case at hand, a young woman committed suicide just 13 days after her marriage. The deceased's father alleged that the husband had an extra-marital affair with another woman and that this revelation, coupled with subsequent ill-treatment, pushed his daughter to take her own life. The deceased had hanged herself using a dupatta in the intervening night of May 30-31, 2022. The father filed an FIR against the husband under Sections 498A (cruelty) and 306 (abetment to suicide) of the Indian Penal Code.
Prosecution (Deceased's Father):
The prosecution contended that the husband's extra-marital affair and the subsequent distressing treatment inflicted on the deceased had driven her to commit suicide. The father alleged that his daughter had been undergoing extreme stress and trauma due to her husband's alleged infidelity. It was further stated that the husband's affair had been disclosed to the deceased on the very first day of their marriage, leading to emotional turmoil for her.
Defendant (Husband):
The husband maintained his innocence, asserting that he had no connection with his wife's suicide. He claimed that their marital relationship had been amicable, and he was shocked by the news of her death. No suicide note was found, and the husband denied any demand for dowry. The defence argued that the deceased and the accused had a healthy relationship following their marriage and that the allegations against the husband were serious and unfounded.
Observations by the Court:
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma of the Delhi High Court made several significant observations in the case. The court noted that discovering infidelity shortly after marriage can have profound and devastating effects on a woman's mental and emotional well-being. Such revelations, especially when a woman enters a marriage with trust and hope, can shatter her emotional stability. The court recognized that the emotional trauma caused by infidelity and subsequent mistreatment by a spouse could drive a woman to the extreme step of committing suicide.
The court also considered the timing of the revelation of the husband's alleged extra-marital affair, which occurred on the first day of the marriage. This timing was noted as a factor contributing to the emotional distress experienced by the deceased.
The decision of the court:
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma denied the husband's plea seeking bail. The court based its decision on the specific allegations against the accused, which indicated that he was having an extra-marital affair and that the deceased wife was subjected to tremendous stress and emotional trauma. The court further highlighted that the husband's extra-marital relationship was revealed to the deceased on the very first day of their marriage, intensifying the emotional shock experienced by the victim.
The court concluded that, in this case, the prosecution's contention was that the suicide was a result of the husband's actions, and as the fir was registered under section 306 (abetment to suicide) and not under section 304b (dowry death), the demand for dowry was not a central issue.
Case Name: Sagar vs the State (Govt. of NCT)
Coram: Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma
Case No.: Bail Application No. 1968 of 2023
Advocates of the Petitioners: Mr. Amit Khanna, Advocate
Advocates of the Respondent: Mr. Manoj Pant, APP for State with ASI Sukhvir Singh, PS Ranjit Nagar
Read Judgment @Latestlaws.com
Picture Source :