Home / Latest News / Maggi now free to be on your Plate, rules Bombay High Court

Maggi now free to be on your Plate, rules Bombay High Court

August,13,2015: Ruling in favour of Nestle India, the Bombay High Court on Thursday lifted the ban on Maggi noodles by setting aside the orders of food authorities. A Division Bench of Justices V.M. Kanade and B.P. Colabawalla deemed the orders of Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) "arbitrary, unjust and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution."


Re-testing within six weeks

The Court directed re-testing of Maagi samples within six weeks in three accredited labs in Punjab, Andhra Pradesh and Jaipur. "After examining rivals contentions, we have come to the conclusion that principles of natural justice were not followed and on that ground alone the petition is allowed, particularly when the petitioner had given a press release a day before the ban that it had recalled the products," the court observed.

The Bench held that labs in which the samples were earlier tested, were not authorised to test for lead and the mandatory testing procedures were not followed.

Public health concern

The court remarked that though it was setting aside the ban order, it was " still concerned about public interest and public health." Therefore, it ordered fresh tests.

In June, Nestle India had filed petitioned to the court seeking revocation of the ban on Magginoodles and quashing of the order of FSSAI which had declared the product unsafe for consumption.

FSSAI contended that it can take action against food manufacturers on the basis of mere suspicion about the quality of their food products. Maggi products were deemed unsafe due to major violations, such as misleading labelling on MSG (monosodium glutamate), presence of lead in excess and launching of oats tastemaker without assessment. The Maharashtra government argued that the company had not followed the due procedures under the Act Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006.

Nestle India, on the other hand, sought to discredit the entire testing procedures saying that the labs testing Maggi samples were not accredited to test for lead content and there was wide variation in the results in different States.

In its petition, Nestle had said that the orders passed by the food regulators and State were illegal, arbitrary and violated the principles of natural justice. The company contested the results of excess lead in the noodles and tastemaker claiming that the testing laboratories were not accredited. The authorities, on the other hand, argued that Nestle had not followed due procedures as per the Food Safety Act.

Following the ban, Nestle started to recall Maggi products from the market. The company destroyed over 25,000 tonnes of Maggi.

Related News-

19.7.2015 – Twist in the tale- Labs that tested Maggi and led to its nation wide Ban not competent, says Nestle READ MORE…

30.6.2015- Bombay High Court allows Nestle to export Maggi noodles READ MORE…

29.6.2015- After Maggi, Top Ramen withdrawn from Indian Market under orders of FSSAI READ MORE…

5.6.2015- Law unclear if celebrities endorsing food products can be prosecutedREAD MORE…

3.6.2015- Maggi row: In a first, Centre moves National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission READ MORE…

3.6.2015- Delhi Govt. bans Maggi sales for 15 days READ MORE…

2.6.2015- Court orders FIR against Amitabh, Madhuri, Preity over Maggi rowREAD MORE…

1.6.2015- Unfolding of long story of 2 minute Maggi Noodles READ MORE…

Links to Food Laws in India at LatestLaws.in-

Facebook Comments

Check Also

Supreme Court of India

Bar Council Elections: SC mulls for elections to be conducted by Election Commission

March 24,2018: Apex Court Bench also stated that it was desirable to raise these issues before the committees constituted by the Bar Council of India and concerned State Bar Council. On Friday, SC expressed it displeasure at the manner in ...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest laws

Join our mailing list to receive the latest laws news and updates from our team.