हिंदी समाचार पढ़े
Expand
O.P. Jindal Global University
 
Home / Corporate Law News / Justice Sanjiv Khanna’s last judgment at Delhi High Court under Income Tax Act, 1961. Read Judgment.

Justice Sanjiv Khanna’s last judgment at Delhi High Court under Income Tax Act, 1961. Read Judgment.

January 28, 2019:

The Division Bench of Justices Sanjiv Khanna and Anup Jairam Bhambhani of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court on 17th January, 2019 decided a matter titled Rajan Bhatia Vs Central Board Of Direct Taxes & Anr.

Justice Sanjiv Khanna & Justice Anup Jairam Bhambhani

The petitioner in this case filed a writ petition seeking appropriate order or direction for quashing the proviso to Section 10(34) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 read along-with the provisions of Section 115BBDA of the Act.

Another prayer made in the writ petition is for staying operation of the aforesaid provisions generally and in particular in relation to the Assessment Year 2017-2018. It is submitted that the provisions under challenge are arbitrary, ultra vires and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. Section 115BBDA is a non-obstante provision that would apply and prevail over Section 10(34) of the Act.

Challenge to the constitutional validity of the aforesaid provisions is primarily on two grounds. The first ground is that Section 115BBDA of the Act does not have any ‘base’. The second ground is that the provision makes hostile discrimination between a resident assessee and a non-resident assessee, as the provision only applies to a resident assessee. It is also pointed-out that the provision excludes from its ambit any domestic company.

The Bench observed, “Pertinently, the companies have to pay dividend tax whenever they pay dividend to the shareholders. This would explain and justify the reason why companies have be en left out from the purview of Section 115BBDA. If companies were liable to pay tax under this section, it would have led to cascading effect when dividend is finally paid to the shareholders, be it, an individual, HUF or a firm i.e. the ‘specified assessee’ who are liable to pay tax under Clause (a) to Section 115BBDA of the Act.

Similarly, the argument that non-residents have been left-out is an argument of under-classification. Non-residents who invest in India contribute and help in growth of industrialization, job creation and economic progress. Non-residents have options to invest in different countries. Consequently, the Legislature/Executive as a matter of policy decide how and in what manner non-residents should be taxed.

Non-residents can be treated differently for the reason that they are residents of foreign states and not residents of India. Taxation at source principle may not be applied to non-residents. Non-residents are liable to pay tax in the country of their residence. Taxation regime applicable to non-residents need not identical to that applicable to residents.”

On the basis of above mentioned grounds, the Bench did not find any merit in the writ petition and accordingly dismissed the same.

Read Judgment @ LatestLaws.com

Rajan Bhatia Versus Central Board Of Direct Taxes & Anr(Downloadable PDF)

Facebook Comments

 
Related tags :
 

Hindu

State of Affairs Women Safety: State of Affairs             pic by mangal

TOI

Four Pillars of Democracy Four Pillars of Democracy             by Satish State of JudiciaryState of Judiciary by Sandeep Adhwaryu of TOI Auto Driver thrashed for no fault Auto Driver thrashed for no fault,                  source oneindia Demonitisation Diaries 2 Demonitisation Diaries 2  pic by sify [caption id="attachment_97477" align="alignleft" width="621"]UIDAI Leaks UIDAI Leaks[/caption]

TOI

Hindu Hindu Tax Reforms    by Hindu Tax Reforms by Hindu If India takes One Step, we will take Two by Satish If India takes One Step, we will take Two ...................by Satish [caption id="attachment_97462" align="alignleft" width="524"]Painting India Saffron Painting India Saffron[/caption] TOI

...as an eminent lawyer you ought to know that your action tantamount to, under Section B, sub-section G.VIX, read along with I.P.C. (A) XI (B), notwithstanding...                                        TOI

Demonitisation Diaries 1 Demonitisation Diaries 1                                  pic by sify   TOI Soaring of Oil Prices pic by indiaone TOI Pic by Hindu Women Empowerment and Sports Women Empowerment and Sports Belts are for Dogs Belts are for Dogs 150425_-_farmers_a_2384764f

Hindu

Hindu America First Walk Your own Talk

TOI

TOI TOI Time to straighten up Time to straighten up                pic by TOI

Hindu

TOI

Alligator vs Litigator Alligator vs Litigator [caption id="attachment_97474" align="alignleft" width="621"]Donald Trump’s immigration ban Donald Trump’s immigration ban[/caption] State of Two Nations State of Two Nations               pic by sandeep Missing the Point Missing the Point pic by english blog

pinterest

Job Hazards [caption id="attachment_97467" align="alignleft" width="621"]Humour with Latest Laws Humour with Latest Laws[/caption] Hindu

Hindu Hindu

Acheche DIn Acheche Din     pic by sify

Hindu

Demonitisation Diaries Demonitisation Diaries                                                       by sify Delivery Boy Delivery Boy                    by Satish

Hindu

TOI

IBN IBN

Hindu Let Justice Be Let Justice Be

Hindu

TOI

Hindu Hindu

TOI

Lawyers Bearing the Burden Literally Lawyers Bearing the Burden Literally pic by OMG Hindu

TOI

Hindu Hindu ALL_1_Theme_01A_24_2383617g

Hindu

Hindu Hindu

Hindu

Hindu

Hindu

Humour @ Latest Laws Achhey Din Humour @ Latest Laws: Achhey Din

TOI

Cartoon

TOI

 
 
 

Check Also

Cognizant settles Bribery case for $28 Million; US justice dept charges Coburn

February 16, 2019: In September 2016 Cognizant had first informed the US authorities that it was in violation of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act. Information technology services major Cognizant on Friday said it had settled a bribery case related to some ...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest laws

Join our mailing list to receive the Latest Laws News and updates from our team.